A review of Title IX and the impact of the ‘Dear Colleague’ Letter on sexual assault reporting policies: Evidence from Massachusetts

Abstract

This paper examines Title IX sexual harassment and assault reporting and investigations as a function of the release of the Dear Colleague Letter in 2011. Since then, many policies have been shaped by the letter’s contents. Yet, little empirical evidence exists of its impact. This paper offers such evidence by analyzing Campus Safety and Security reporting data from 2007–2016 for all 61 Massachusetts 4-year degree-granting colleges and universities. The years of choice capture the 5-year period before the release of the Dear Colleague Letter and the 5-year period after. The results show an increase in reporting that led to a small increase in the numbers of resulting investigations. To further analyze the reasons, this paper offers a policy typology of the three different ways in which university bureaucracies handle claims filed with their Office of Civil Rights. Discussed are the reasons for the divergence in policy design and their effectiveness.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aderholdt

W. D.

(2019). The 2011 Dear Colleague letter: A quantitative analysis of title IX’s impact on sexual violence management [ProQuest Dissertations & Theses, Montana State University]. 27663297. https://www-proquest-com-s.web.bisu.edu.cn/openview/d7060bbbd825aaabc12266874afcde66/1?cbl=51922&diss=y&pq-origsite=gscholar

Alexander v Yale University . 459 F. Supp. 1, 3 (D. Conn. 1977).

Ali

(2011, April 4). Dear colleague letter . U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights.

Archibald

R. B.

, & Feldman

D. H.

(2008). Explaining increases in higher education costs. The Journal of Higher Education, 79(3), 268–295. 10.1080/00221546.2008.11772099

Bidwell

(2015, May 5). College sexual violence complaints up 1, 000 percent in 5 years. US News. https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/data-mine/2015/05/05/college-title- ix-sexual-violence-complaints-increase-more-than-1-000-percent-in-5-years

Bingaman

(2002). Title IX of the 1972 education amendments. The Georgetown Journal of Gender and the Law, IV, 329–349. https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/grggenl4&div=21&id=&page=

Bolger

(2016, May). Gender violence costs: Schools’ financial obligations under Title IX. Yale Law Journal, 125(7), 2106–2130. http://link.galegroup.com.libproxy.umassd.edu/apps/doc/A459506350/AONE?u=mlin_s_umass&sid=AONE&xid=9f265288

Brodsky

, & Deutsch

(2015). The promise of Title IX. Dissent (00123846), 62(4), 135–144.

Brown

(2016, October 13). What a landmark finding in a title IX case means for colleges wrestling with sex assault . The Chronicle of Higher Education. Available a: http://www.chronicle.com/article/What-a-Landmark-Finding-in-a/238059

10.

Brown

(2018, August 29). DeVos’s rules on sexual misconduct, long awaited on campuses, reflect her interim policy . The Chronicle of Higher Education. https://www.chronicle.com/article/DeVos-s-Rules-on-Sexual/244394

11.

Cantalupo

N. C.

(2012). ‘Decriminalizing’ campus institutional responses to peer sexual violence. Journal of College and University Law, 38, 483–524. https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/jcolunly38&div=20&id=&page=

12.

Cantor

(2015). AAU climate survey on sexual assault and sexual misconduct . https://www.aau.edu/key-issues/aau-climate-survey-sexual-assault-and-sexual-misconduct-2015

13.

Carroll

C. M.

Dahlgren

M. G.

Grab

K. L.

Hasbun

M. E.

Hayes

M. A.

, & Muntis

S. E.

(2013). Implementing the Dear Colleague Letter: A Title IX case study for university compliance. Journal of the Student Personnel Association at Indiana University, 41, 45–63. https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/jiuspa/article/view/3673

14.

Chekwa

Thomas

Jr. Jones

V. J.

(2013). What are college students’ perceptions about campus safety? Contemporary Issues in Education Research (CIER), 6(3), 325–332. 10.19030/cier.v6i3.7903

15.

Collingsworth

T. P.

(1981). Title IX applies to employment discrimination. Duke Law Journal, 1981(3), 588–606. 10.2307/1372261

16.

Davis v. Monroe County Bd . Of Ed., 526 U.S. 629 (1999).

17.

DeMatteo

Galloway

Arnold

, & Patel

(2015). Sexual assault on college campuses: A 50-state survey of criminal sexual assault statutes and their relevance to campus sexual assault. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 21(3), 227–238. 10.1037/law0000055

18.

Dudley

S. F.

(2016). Paved with good intentions: Title IX campus sexual assault proceedings and the creation of admissible victim statements. Golden Gate University Law Review, 46(2), 117–151.

19.

Ellman-Golan

(2017). Saving title IX: Designing more equitable and efficient investigation procedures. Michigan Law Review, 116(116.1), 155–186. 10.36644/mlr.116.1.saving

20.

Fisher

B. S.

Hartman

J. L.

Cullen

F. T.

, & Turner

M. G.

(2002). Making campuses safer for students: The Clery Act as a symbolic legal reform. Stetson Law Review, 32, 61–89. https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/stet32&div=10&id=&page=

21.

Gillespie-Porter

(2016). Title IX of the education amendments of 1972: Does its application parallel the original intent of congress? Illinois State University Pro & Quest Dissertations & Theses, 10163985. https://ir.library.illinoisstate.edu/etd/569/

22.

Gravois

J. D.

(2020). Show’em a Good time. a case study on title IX and its flawed implementation in universities. Tennessee Journal of Race, Gender, & Social Justice, 9(1), 24–41.

23.

Henry

Scott Lewis

Morris

L. K.

Schuster

S. K.

Sokolow

B. A.

Swinton

D. C.

, & Van Brunt

(2016). The deadly sins of title IX investigations. Association of title IX administrators, King of Prussia, PA . https://www.atixa.org/resources/atixa-2016-whitepaper-the-7-deadly-sins-of-title-ix-investigations/

24.

Jaquette

, & Parra

E. E.

(2014). Using IPEDS for panel analyses: Core concepts, data challenges, and empirical applications. In Paulsen

(Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (Vol. 29, pp. 467–533). Springer. 10.1007/978-94-017-8005-6_11

25.

Jeanne Clery disclosure of campus Security policy and campus crime statistics Act of 1990, 20 U.S.C. §1092(f).

26.

Jessup-Anger

Lopez

, & Koss

M. P.

(2018). History of sexual violence in higher Education. New Directions for Student Services, 2018(161), 9–19. 10.1002/ss.20249

27.

Johnson

L. S.

(2015). Gender discrimination and title IX implementation: Lessons from the office for civil rights resolution letters 1997-2011 [Theses and Dissertations-Educational Policy Studies and Evaluation 32, University of Kentucky]. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/epe_etds/32

28.

Jordan

C. E.

(2014). The safety of women and college campuses: Implications of evolving paradigms in postsecondary education. Trauma, Violence, and Abuse, 1, 1–6. 10.1177/1524838014520635

29.

Jozkowski

K. N.

, & Wiersma-Mosley

(2017). The Greek system: How gender inequality and class privilege perpetuate rape culture. Family Relations, 66(1), 89–103. 10.1111/fare.12229

30.

Karjane

H. M.

Fisher

B. S.

, & Cullen

F. T.

(1999). Campus sexual assault: How America’s institutions of higher education respond . Final Report. Office of Justice Programs. https://www.ojp.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/196676.pdf

31.

Karjane

H. M.

Fisher

B. S.

, & Cullen

F. T.

(2002). Campus sexual assault: How America’s institutions of higher education respond . Final Report, NIJ Grant # 1999-wa-VX-008. Education Development Center, Inc. https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/196676.pdf.

32.

Karjane

H. M.

Fisher

B. S.

, & Cullen

F. T.

(2005). Sexual assault on campus: What colleges and universities are doing about it. National Institute of Justice. https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/205521.pdf

33.

Kelly

C. R.

(2019). Navigating complexity: The challenging role of Title IX coordinators in campus sexual assault [ProQuest Dissertations & Theses 13811366, Boston College]. https://www-proquest-com-s.web.bisu.edu.cn/openview/376f4824c37674614b29238eb567aa3e/1?cbl=18750&diss=y&pq-origsite=gscholar

34.

Koss

M. P.

, & Gidycz

C. A.

(1985). Sexual experiences survey: Reliability and validity. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 35(3), 422–423. 10.1037/0022-006X.53.3.422

35.

Krebs

C. P.

Lindquist

C. H.

Warner

T. D.

Fisher

B. S.

, & Martin

S. L.

(2007). The campus sexual assault (CSA) study . Final report: January 2005 through December 2007.

36.

Lee

Y. J.

, & Won

(2016). Applying representative bureaucracy theory to academia: Representation of women in faculty and administration and title IX compliance in intercollegiate athletics. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 9(4), 323–338. 10.1037/a0039727

37.

Leslie

L. L.

, & Rhoades

(1995). Rising administrative costs: Seeking explanations. The Journal of Higher Education, 66(2), 187–212. 10.1080/00221546.1995.11774772

38.

Lindo

J. M.

Siminski

, & Swensen

I. D.

(2018). College party culture and sexual assault. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 10(1), 236–265. 10.1257/app.20160031

39.

Melear

K. B.

(2006). Title IX and retaliation: The impact of Jackson v. Birmingham board of education on higher education. Journal of Personnel Evaluation in Education, 19(3–4), 91–103. 10.1007/s11092-007-9040-9

40.

Mertz

N. T.

(2006). The promise of title IX: Longitudinal study of gender in urban school administration & comma; 1972 to 2002. Urban Education, 41(6), 544–559. 10.1177/0042085906292511

41.

National Federation of State High School Associations . (2010-11). High school athletics participation survey . National Institute of Health, https://www.nfhs.org/media/1020199/2011-12_hs_participation_survey.pdf

42.

Nobles

M. R.

Fox

K. A.

Khey

D. N.

, & Lizotte

A. J.

(2012). Community and campus crime: A geospatial examination of the Clery Act. Crime and Delinquency, 59(8), 1131–1156. 10.1177/0011128710372188

43.

Office for Civil Rights | U.S. Department of Education . (2017, November 17). https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/index.html

44.

Opportunity Insights . (2016). Longitudinal statistics by College tier, parent income and cohort . https://opportunityinsights.org/data/?geographic_level=100&topic=0&paper_id=0#resource-listing

45.

Palmer

J. E.

, & Alda

(2016). Examining the impact of federal grants to reduce violent crimes against women on campus. Review of Higher Education, 40(1), 63–89. 10.1353/rhe.2016.0038

46.

Palmer

J. E.

, & Perrotti

(2016). Measuring self-reported sexual victimization experiences at one university: A comparison of methods. Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice, 53(4), 403–415. 10.1080/19496591.2016.1202119

47.

Paul

(2016). Navigating title IX and gender-based campus violence: An analysis of the roles and experiences of title IX coordinators [Electronic Theses and Dissertations, UCLA]. 10125206. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/422513r6

48.

Paule-Koba

(2012). Pressure is a privilege: Billie Jean King, title IX, and gender equity. Reviews in American History, 40(4), 711–715. 10.1353/rah.2012.0094

49.

Peterson

, & Ortiz

(2016). A better balance: Providing survivors of sexual violence with “effective protection” against sex discrimination through title IX complaints. Yale Law Journal, 125(7), 2132–2155.

50.

Poole

K. M.

(2014). University response to the dear colleague letter on sexual violence: A case study [ProQuest Dissertations & Theses, Clemson University]. 3636846. https://www-proquest-com-s.web.bisu.edu.cn/openview/b4e0f09488c4ad0884100eac9ec38922/1?cbl=18750&pq-origsite=gscholar

51.

Ramirez

C. A.

(2009). FERPA clear and simple: The College Professional’s Guide to compliance. John Wiley & Sons.

52.

Richards

T. N.

(2019). No evidence of “weaponized title IX” here: An empirical assessment of sexual misconduct reporting, case processing, and outcomes. Law and Human Behavior, 43(2), 180–192. 10.1037/lhb0000316

53.

Richards

T. N.

Branch

K. A.

Fleury-Steiner

, & Kafonek

(2017). A feminist analysis of campus sexual assault policies: Results from a national sample. Family Relations, 66(1), 104–115. 10.1111/fare.12236

54.

Ridolfi-Starr

(2016). Transformation requires transparency: Critical policy reforms to advance campus sexual violence response. Yale Law Journal, 125(7), 2156–2181.

55.

Rose

A. M.

(2020). Two approaches to analyzing institutions’ spending responses to campus sexual assault [Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports, West Virginia University]. 7658. 10.33915/etd.7658

56.

Sable

M. R.

Danis

Mauzy

D. L.

, & Gallagher

S. K.

(2006). Barriers to reporting sexual assault for women and men: Perspectives of college students. Journal of American College Health, 55(3), 157–162. 10.3200/JACH.55.3.157-162

57.

Safko

E. D.

(2016). Are campus sexual assault tribunals fair?: The need for judicial review and additional due process protections in light of new case law. Fordham Law Review, 84, 2289–2332. 10.2139/ssrn.2743013

58.

Sharp

E. A.

Weaver

S. E.

, & Zvonkovic

(2017). Introduction to the special issue: Feminist framings of sexual violence on college campuses. Family Relations, 66(1), 7–16. 10.1111/fare.12242

59.

Sharrow

E. A.

(2020). “Female athlete” politic: Title IX and the naturalization of sex difference in public policy. In Brown

N. E.

& Gershon

S. A.

(Eds.), Body politics (pp. 46–66). Routledge.

60.

Sieben

(2011). Education dept. issues new guidance for sexual assault investigations. The Chronicle of Higher Education, 57(32), 20–21.

61.

Smith

(2015). Title ix and sexual violence on college campuses: The need for uniform on-campus reporting, investigation, and disciplinary procedures. Saint Louis University Public Law Review, 35(1), 157–178.

62.

Smith

(2017). The old college trial: Evaluating the investigative model for adjudicating claims of sexual misconduct. Columbia Law Review, 117(4), 953–989. 10.2139/ssrn.2866099

63.

Smith

(2011). On sexual harassment and title IX. Real clear politics . https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2011/08/30/on_sexual_harassment_and_title_ix_111065.html

64.

Subotnik

(2017). Assaulting the facts. Academic Questions, 30(2), 225–231. 10.1007/s12129-017-9633-9

65.

Tani

K. M.

(2016). An administrative right to be free from sexual violence: Title IX enforcement in historical and institutional perspective. Duke Law Journal, 66, 1847–1904. https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/duklr66&div=58&id=&page=

66.

U. S. Constitution , Amendment XIV, §1. https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-14/

67.

U.S. Department of Education . (2011). Dear Colleague Letter . U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights.

68.

U.S. Department of Education . (2017). All data combined for calendar years 2007-16 (version 1) . [Excel file]. https://ope.ed.gov/campussafety/#/

69.

Whissemore

(2016). Clery act changes the landscape of campus safety. Community College Journal, 86(3), 4–5.

70.

White House Task Force to Protect Students From Sexual Assault . (2014). Not alone: The first report of the White House task force to protect students from sexual assault . White House Task Force to Protect students from Sexual Assault. https://www.nsvrc.org/publications/reports/not-alone-first-report-white-house-task-force-protect-students-sexual-assault

71.

White Kress

V. E.

Trippany

L. R.

, & Nolan

J. M.

(2003). Responding to sexual assault victims: Considerations for college counselors. Journal of College Counseling, 6(2), 124–133. 10.1002/j.2161-1882.2003.tb00233.x

72.

Wiersma-Mosley

J. D.

Willis

Jozkowski

K. N.

, & Cleveland

M. J.

(2020). Do party schools report higher rates of violence against women in their Clery data? A latent class analysis. Violence Against Women, 26(6–7), 636–658. 10.1177/1077801219840436

73.

Wilkie

(2014). Complying with Clery. International Educator, 23(6), 2–4, 6, 8–10.

74.

Wolitzky-Taylor

Resnick

H. S.

Amstadter

A. B.

Mccauley

L. J.

Ruggiero

J. K.

, & Kilpatrick

D. G.

(2011). Reporting rape in a national sample of college women. Journal of American College Health, 59(7), 582–587. 10.1080/07448481.2010.515634