The 25th Bartlett Lecture: To Act or Not to Act: Perspectives on the Representation of Actions

Abstract

In this review, a description is offered of the way actions are represented, how these representations are built, and how their content can be accessed by the agent and by other agents. Such a description will appear critical for understanding how an action is attributed to its proper origin, or, in other words, how a subject can make a conscious judgement about who the agent of that action is (an agency judgement). This question is central to the problem of self-consciousness: Action is one of the main channels used for communication between individuals, so that determining the agent of an action contributes to differentiating the self from others.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

Guz

Innes

J. A.

Murphy

(1987). The early circulatory and ventilatory response to voluntary and electrically induced exercise in man. Journal of Physiology 383, 19–30.

Arbib

M. A.

(1981). Perceptual structures and distributed motor control. Handbook of physiology. Section I: The nervous system. Vol.2: Motor control. Brooks

V. B.

Baltimore, MD: Williams et Wilkins 1449–1480.

Barresi

Moore

(1996). Intentional relations and social understanding. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19, 107–154.

Bartlett

F. C.

(1926). Review of Aphasia and kindred disorders of speech, by Henry Head. Brain 49, 581–587.

Bonda

Petrides

Ostry

Evans

(1996). Specific involvement of human parietal systems and the amygdala in the perception of biological motion. Journal of Neuroscience 16, 3737–3744.

Bonnet

Decety

Requin

Jeannerod

(1997). Mental simulation of an action modulates the excitability of spinal reflex pathways in man. Cognitive Brain Research 5, 221–228.

Bridgeman

Kirch

Sperling

(1981). Segregation of cognitive and motor aspect of visual function using induced motion. Perception and Psychophysics 29, 336–342.

Carey

D. P.

Perrett

D. I.

Oram

M. W.

(1997). Recognizing, understanding and reproducing action. Handbook of neuropsychology, Vol 11: Action and Cognition. Boiler

Grafman

Jeannerod

Amsterdam: Elsevier 111–129.

Castiello

Paulignan

Jeannerod

(1991). Temporal dissociation of motor responses and subjective awareness. A study in normal subjects. Brain 114, 2639–2655.

10.

Coghill

E. G.

(1929). Anatomy and the problem of behavior London: Cambridge University Press.

11.

Crammond

D. J.

(1997). Motor imagery: Never in your wildest dream. Trends in Neurosciences 20, 54–57.

12.

Daprati

Franck

Georgieff

Proust

Pacherie

Dalery

Jeannerod

(1997). Looking for the agent. An investigation into consciousness of action and self-consciousness in schizophrenic patients. Cognition 65, 71–86.

13.

Dasser

Ulbaek

Premack

(1989). The perception of intention. Science 243, 365–367.

14.

Decety

Grezes

Costes

Perani

Jeannerod

Procyk

Grassi

Fazio

(1997). Brain activity during observation of action. Influence of action content and subject's strategy. Brain 120, 1763–1777.

15.

Decety

Jeannerod

(1996). Fitts’ law in mentally simulated movements. Behavioral Brain Research 72, 127–134.

16.

Decety

Jeannerod

Durozard

Baverel

(1993). Central activation of autonomie effectors during mental simulation of motor actions. Journal of Physiology 461, 549–563.

17.

Decety

Jeannerod

Prablanc

(1989). The timing of mentally represented actions. Behavioural Brain Research 34, 35–42.

18.

Decety

Perani

Jeannerod

Bettinardi

Tadary

Woods

Mazziotta

J. C.

Fazio

(1994). Mapping motor representations with PET. Nature 371, 600–602.

19.

Demonet

J. F.

Chollet

Ramsay

Cardebat

Nespoulous

J. L.

Wise

Rascol

Frackowiak

R. S. J.

(1992). The anatomy of phonological processing and semantic processing in normal subjects. Brain 115, 1753–1768.

20.

De Vries

J. I. P.

Visser

G. H. A.

Prechtl

H. F. R.

(1982). The emergence of fetal behavior. I Quantitative aspects. Early Human Development 7, 301–322.

21.

di Pellegrino

Fadiga

Fogassi

Gallese

Rizzolatti

(1992). Understanding motor events: A neurophysiological study. Experimental Brain Research 91, 176–180.

22.

Dominey

Decety

Broussolle

Chazot

Jeannerod

(1995). Motor imagery of a lateralized sequential task is assymetrically slowed in hemi-Parkinson patients. Neuropsychologia 33, 727–741.

23.

Dominey

P. F.

Georgieff

(1997). Schizophrenics learn surface but not abstract structure in a serial reaction time task. NeuroReport 8, 2877–2882.

24.

DriskeII

J. E.

Cooper

Moran

(1994). Does mental practice enhance performance?. Journal of Applied Psychology 79, 481–492.

25.

Fadiga

Fogassi

Pavesi

Rizzolatti

(1995). Motor facilitation during action observation. A magnetic stimulation study. Journal of Neurophysiology 73, 2608–2611.

26.

Faillenot

Toni

Decety

Gregoire

M. C.

Jeannerod

(1997). Visual pathways for object oriented action and object recognition: Functional anatomy with PET. Cerebral Cortex 7, 77–85.

27.

Feinberg

(1978). Efference copy and corollary discharge. Implications for thinking and its disorders. Schizophrenia Bulletin 4, 636–640.

28.

Feltz

D. L.

Landers

D. M.

(1983). The effects of mental practice on motor skill learning and performance: A meta-analysis. Journal of Sport Psychology 5, 25–57.

29.

Fourneret

Jeannerod

(1998). Limited conscious monitoring of motor performance in normal subjects. Neuropsychologia 36.

30.

Frith

C. D.

(1987). The positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia reflect impairments in the perception and initiation of action. Psychological Medicine 17, 631–648.

31.

Frith

C. D.

(1992). The cognitive neuropsychology of schizophrenia Hove: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Ltd.

32.

Frith

C. D.

(1995). Consciousness is for other people. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 18, 682–683.

33.

Frith

C. D.

(1996). The role of the prefrontal cortex in self-consciousness: the case of auditory hallucinations. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, London B 351, 1505–1512.

34.

Frith

C. D.

Done

D. J.

(1989). Experiences of alien control in schizophrenia reflect a disorder in the central monitoring of action. Psychological Medicine 19, 359–363.

35.

Frith

C. D.

Friston

Liddle

P. F.

Frackowiak

R. S. J.

(1991). Willed action and the prefrontal cortex in man: A study with PET. Proceedings of the Royal Society 244, 241–246.

36.

Gandevia

S. C.

Killian

McKenzie

O. K.

Crawford

Allen

G. M.

Gorman

R. B.

Hales

J. P.

(1993). Respiratory sensations, cardiovascular control, kinesthesia and transcranial stimulation during paralysis in humans. Journal of Physiology 470, 85–107.

37.

Georgopoulos

A. P.

Lurito

J. T.

Petrides

Schwartz

A. B.

Massey

J. T.

(1989). Mental rotation of the neuronal population vector. Science 243, 234–236.

38.

Goodale

M. A.

Pélisson

Prablanc

(1986). Large adjustments in visually guided reaching do not depend on vision of the hand or perception of target displacement. Nature 320, 748–750.

39.

Grafton

S. T.

Arbib

M. A.

Fadiga

Rizzolatti

(1996). Localization of grasp representations in humans by positron emission tomography. 2. Observation compared with imagination. Experimental Brain Research 112, 103–111.

40.

Gray

J. A.

Feldon

J. N.

Rawlins

J. N. P.

Hemsley

D. R.

Smith

A. D.

(1991). The neuropsychology of schizophrenia. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 14, 1–84.

41.

Harris

C. S.

(1963). Adaptation to displaced vision: Visual, motor or proprioceptive change?. Science 140, 812–813.

42.

Haxby

J. V.

Horwitz

Ungerleider

L. G.

Maisog

J. M.

Pietrini

Grady

C. L.

(1994). The functional organization of human extrastriate cortex. A PET-rCBF study of selective attention to faces and locations. Journal of Neurosciences 14, 6336–6353.

43.

Ingvar

Philipsson

(1977). Distribution of the cerebral blood flow in the dominant hemisphere during motor ideation and motor performance. Annals of Neurology 2, 230–237.

44.

Jacob

(1996). What minds can do Cambridge: Cambrige University Press 1996.

45.

Jacobson

(1930). Electrical measurements of neuro-muscular states during mental activities. III. Visual imagination and recollection. American Journal of Physiology 95, 694–702.

46.

Jeannerod

(1993). A theory of representation-driven actions. The perceived self. Ecological and interpersonal sources of self-knowledge. Neisser

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 68–88.

47.

Jeannerod

(1994). The representing brain. Neural correlates of motor intention and imagery. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 17, 187–245.

48.

Jeannerod

(1995). Mental imagery in the motor context. Neuropsychologia 33, 1419–1432.

49.

Jeannerod

(1997). The cognitive neuroscience of action Oxford: Blackwell.

50.

Jeannerod

(1998). Representations for actions. Advances in psychological science. Vol 2, Biological and cognitive aspects. Sabourin

Craik

Robert

Hove, U.K.: Psychology Press 337–353.

51.

Jeannerod

Decety

(1995). Mental motor imagery: A window into the representational stages of action. Current Opinion in Neurohbiology 5, 727–732.

52.

Johansson

(1977). Studies on visual perception of locomotion. Perception 6, 365–376.

53.

Kirn

S.-G.

Jennings

J. E.

Strupp

J. P.

Andersen

Ugurbil

(1995). Functional MRI of human motor cortices during overt and imagined finger movements. International Journal of Imaging Systems and Technology 6, 271–279.

54.

Leonardo

Feldman

Sadato

Campbell

Ibanez

Cohen

Deiber

M.-P.

Jezzard

Pons

Turner

Le Bihan

Hallen

(1995). A functional magnetic resonance imaging study of cortical regions associated with motor task execution and motor ideation in humans. Human Brain Mapping 3, 83–92.

55.

Leslie

A. M.

(1987). Pretense and representation: The origins of “theory of mind”. Psychological Review 94, 412–426.

56.

Liberman

A. M.

Mattingly

I. G.

(1985). The motor theory of perception of speech revisited. Cognition 21, 1–36.

57.

Libet

(1985). Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of conscious will in voluntary action. Behavioral Brain Science 6, 529–566.

58.

Libet

Gleason

C. A.

Wright

E. W.

Perl

D. K.

(1983). Time of conscious intention to act in relation to cerebral activities (readiness potential). The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act. Brain 102, 193–224.

59.

Mahoney

M. J.

Avener

(1987). Psychology of the elite athlete. An explorative study. Cognitive Therapy and Research 1, 135–141.

60.

Malenka

R. C.

Angel

R. W.

Hampton

Berger

P. A.

(1982). Impaired central error-correcting behavior in schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry 39, 101–107.

61.

Martin

Haxby

J. V.

Lalonde

P. M.

Wiggs

C. L.

Ungerleider

L. G.

(1995). Discrete cortical regions associated with knowledge of color and knowledge of action. Science 270, 102–105.

62.

Martin

Wiggs

C. L.

Ungerleider

L. G.

Haxby

J. V.

(1996). Neural correlates of category-specific knowledge. Nature 379, 649–652.

63.

Massey

J. T.

Lurito

J. T.

Pellizzer

Georgopoulos

A. P.

(1992). Three-dimensional drawings in isometric conditions. Relations between geometry and kinematics. Experimental Brain Research 88, 685–690.

64.

McGuire

P. K.

Silbersweig

D. A.

Murray

R. M.

David

A. S.

Frackowiak

R. S. J.

Frith

C. D.

(1996). Functional anatomy of inner speech and auditory verbal imagery. Psychological Medicine 26, 29–38.

65.

Meltzoff

A. N.

(1995). Understanding the intentions of others. Re-enactment of intended acts by 18-month-old children. Development Psychology 31, 838–850.

66.

Millar

Ittyerah

(1991). Movement imagery in young and congenitally blind children. Mental practice without visuospatial information. International Journal of Behavioral Development 15, 125–146.

67.

Neisser

(1976). Cognition and reality San Francisco: Freeman.

68.

Neisser

(1993). The self perceived. The perceived self. Ecological and interpersonal sources of self-knowledge. Neisser

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 3–21.

69.

Nielsen

T. I.

(1963). Volition: A new experimental approach. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 4, 225–230.

70.

Pacherie

(1997). Motor images, self-consciousness, and autism. Autism as an executive disorder. Russell

Oxford: Oxford University Press 215–255.

71.

Paivio

(1986). Mental representations. A dual coding approach Oxford: Clarendon Press.

72.

Parsons

L. M.

(1987). Imagined spatial transformations of one's hands and feet. Cognitive Psychology 19, 178–241.

73.

Parsons

L. M.

(1994). Temporal and kinematic properties of motor behavior reflected in mentally simulated action. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance 20, 709–730.

74.

Parsons

L. M.

Fox

P. T.

Downs

J. H.

Glass

Hirsch

T. B.

Martin

C. C.

Jerabek

P. A.

Lancaster

J. L.

(1995). Use of implicit motor imagery for visual shape discrimination as revealed by PET. Nature 375, 54–58.

75.

Pascual-Leone

Dang

Cohen

L. G.

Brasil-Neto

Cammarota

Hallett

(1995). Modulation of motor responses evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation during the acquisition of new fine motor skills. Journal of Neurophyriology 74, 1037–1045.

76.

Perani

Cappa

S. F.

Bettinardi

Bressi

Gorno-Tempini

Matarrese

Fazio

(1995). Different neural systems for the recognition of animals and man-made tools. NeuroReport 6, 1637–1641.

77.

Perrett

D. I.

Harris

M. H.

Bevan

Thomas

Benson

P. J.

Mistlin

A. J.

Citty

A. J.

Hietanen

J. K.

Ortega

J. E.

(1989). Framework of analysis for the neural representation of animate objects and actions. Journal of Experimental Biology 146, 87–113.

78.

Pitblado

Schapiro

Petrides

(1980). Adaptation to prismatic displacement by schizophrenics and normals. Neuropsychobiology 6, 201–207.

79.

Premack

Woodruff

(1978). Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4, 515–526.

80.

Requin

Brener

Ring

(1991). Preparation for action. Handbook of cognitive psychophysiology. Central and autonomie nervous system approaches. Jennings

J. R.

Coles

M. G. H.

New York: John Wiley.

81.

Rizzolatti

Arbib

M. A.

(1998). Language within our grasp. Trends in Neurosciences 21, 188–194.

82.

Rizzolatti

Fadiga

Gallese

Fogassi

(1996). Premotor cortex and the recognition of motor actions. Cognitive Brain Research 3, 131–141.

83.

Rizzolatti

Fadiga

Matelli

Bettinardi

Paulesu

Perani

Fazio

(1996). Localization of grasp representations in humans by PET. 1. Observation versus execution. Experimental Brain Research 111, 246–252.

84.

Roland

P. E.

Skinhoj

Lassen

N. A.

Larsen

(1980). Different cortical areas in man in organization of voluntary movements in extrapersonal space. Journal of Neurophysiology 43, 137–150.

85.

Roth

Decety

Raybaudi

Massarelli

Delon-Martin

Segebarth

Morand

Gemignani

Décorps

Jeannerod

(1996). Possible involvement of primary motor cortex in mentally simulated movement. A functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Neuroreport 7, 1280–1284.

86.

Schnitzler

Salenius

Salmelin

Jousmäki

Hari

(1997). Involvement of primary motor cortex in motor imagery: A neuromagnetic study. Neuroimage 6, 201–208.

87.

Shallice

(1988). From neuropsychology to mental structure Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

88.

Sirigu

Cohen

Duhamel

J.-R.

Pillon

Dubois

Agid

Pierrot-Deseiligny

(1995). Congruent unilateral impairments for real and imagined hand movements. NeuroReport 6, 997–1001.

89.

Sirigu

Duhamel

J.-R.

Cohen

Pillon

Dubois

Agid

(1996). The mental representation of hand movements after parietal cortex damage. Science 273, 1564–1569.

90.

Spelke

E. S.

Breinlinger

Macornber

Jacobson

(1992). Origins of knowledge. Psychological Reviews 99, 605–632.

91.

Spence

S. A.

Brooks

D. J.

Hirsch

S. R.

Liddle

P. F.

Meehan

Grasby

P. M.

(1997). A PET study of voluntary movements in schizophrenic patients experiencing passivity phenomena (delusions of alien control). Brain 120, 1997–2011.

92.

Sperry

R. W.

(1950). Neural basis of the spontaneous optokinetic response produced by visual inversion. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 43, 482–489.

93.

Stephan

K. M.

Fink

G. R.

Passingham

R. E.

Silbersweig

Ceballos-Baumann

A. O.

Frith

C. D.

Frackowiak

R. S. J.

(1995). Functional anatomy of the mental representation of upper extremity movements in healthy subjects. Journal of Neurophysiology 73, 373–386.

94.

Trevarthen

(1993). The self born in intersubjectivity: The psychology of an infant communicating. The perceived self. Ecological and interpersonal sources of self-knowledge. Neisser

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 121–173.

95.

Tyszka

J. M.

Grafton

S. T.

Chew

Woods

R. P.

Colletti

P. M.

(1994). Parceling of mesial frontal motor areas during ideation and movement using functional magnetic resonance imaging at 1.5 Tesla. Annals of Neurology 35, 746–749.

96.

Viviani

Stucchi

(1992). Biological movements look uniform. Evidence of motor-perceptual interactions. Journal of Experimental Psychology, Human Perception and Performance 18, 603–623.

97.

Vogt

(1995). On relations between perceiving, imagining, and performing in the learning of cyclical movement sequences. British Journal of Psychology 86, 191–216.

98.

von Holst

(1954). Relations between the central nervous system and the peripheral organs. British Journal of Animal Behavior 2, 89–94.

99.

Wann

J. P.

Ibrahim

S. F.

(1992). Does limb proprioception drift?. Experimental Brain Research 91, 162–166.

100.

Warburton

Wise

R. J. S.

Price

Weiller

Hadar

Ramsay

Frackowiak

R. S. J.

(1996). Noun and verb retrieval by normal subjects: Studies with PET. Brain 119, 159–179.

101.

Wehner

Vogt

Stadier

(1984). Task-specific EMG characteristics during mental training. Psychological research 46, 389–401.

102.

Weiss

Paulignan

Jeannerod

Freund

H. J.

The temporal organization of complex movements.

Experimental Brain Research. in press.

103.

Wise

Chollet

Hadar

Fristen

Hoffner

Frackowiak

R. S. J.

(1991). Distribution of cortical neural networks involved in word comprehension and word retrieval. Brain 114, 1803–1817.

104.

Wittgenstein

(1953). Philosophical investigations Oxford: Blackwell.

105.

Wolpert

D. M.

Ghahramani

Jordan

M. I.

(1995). An internal model for sensorimotor integration. Science 269, 1880–1882.

106.

Yue

Cole

K. J.

(1992). Strength increases from the motor program. Comparison of training with maximal voluntary and imagined muscle contractions. Journal of Neurophysiology 67, 1114–1123.