Developmental Surface Dysgraphia: What is the Underlying Cognitive Impairment?

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to investigate the cognitive causes underlying spelling difficulties in a case of developmental surface dysgraphia, AW. Our results do not support a number of possibilities that could be the cause of AW's poor orthographic lexicon, including difficulties in phonological processing, phonological short-term memory, configurational visual memory, and lexical semantic memory. We have found instead that AW performs poorly in tasks that involve detection of the order of adjacent letters in a word or the order of adjacent units in strings of consonants or symbols. Finally, he performs poorly in tasks that involve reconstructing the order of a series of complex visual characters (Japanese and Hindi characters) especially when these are presented sequentially. We advance the hypothesis that AW's poor spelling and good reading skills stem from an underlying pattern of cognitive abilities where a very good visual configurational memory is coupled with a poor ability to encode serial order. This may have resulted in a holistic word-based reading strategy, which, together with the original problem of encoding order, may have had detrimental effects for the acquisition of spelling.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

M. J.

(1990). Beginning to read: Thinking and learning about print Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Baddeley

A. D.

(1979). Working memory and reading. Processing of visible language. Kolers

P. A.

Wrolstad

M. E.

Bouma

New York: Plenum.

Bakker

D. J.

(1972). Temporal order in disturbed reading Rotterdam: University Press.

Baron

(1979). Orthographic and word specific mechanisms in children's reading of words. Child Development 50, 60–72.

Bjork

E. L.

Healy

A. F.

(1974). Short-term order and item retention. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 13, 80–97.

Boder

(1973). Developmental dyslexia: A diagnostic approach based on three atypical reading spelling patterns. Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology 15, 663–687.

Breitmeyer

B. C.

(1993). The roles of sustained (P) and transient (M) channels in reading and reading disability. Facets of Dyslexia and its remediation. Wright

S. F.

Grover

Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.

Brown

G. D. A.

Preece

Hulme

(1997). Oscillator-based memory for serial order Unpublished manuscript.

Brown

G. D. A.

Vousolen

J. I.

(1998). Adaptic analysis of sequential behaviour: Oscillators as rational mechanisms. Rational models of cognition. Oaksford

Chater

Oxford: Oxford University Press.

10.

Bruck

(1993). Word recognition and component phonological processing skills of adult with childhood diagnosis of dyslexia. Developmental Review 13, 258–268.

11.

Bryant

Bradley

(1985). Children's reading problems Oxford: Basil Blackwell Ltd.

12.

Bryant

Impey

(1986). The similarities between normal readers and developmental and acquired dyslexies. Cognition 24, 121–137.

13.

Bryden

M. P.

(1972). Auditory-visual and sequential matching in relation to reading ability. Child Development 43, 824–832.

14.

Burgess

Hitch

G. J.

(1996). A connectionist model of STM for serial order. Models of short-term memory. Gathercole

S. E.

Hove: Psychology Press.

15.

Campbell

Butterworth

(1985). Phonological dyslexia and dysgraphia in a highly literate subject: A developmental case with associated deficits of phonemic processing and awareness. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 37A, 435–475.

16.

Carrol

J. B.

Davies

Richman

(1971). Word frequency book New York: American Heritage Publishing Co.

17.

Castles

Coltheart

(1996). Cognitive correlates of developmental surface dyslexia: A single case study. Cognitive Neuropsychology 13, 1 25–50.

18.

Chambers

S. M.

Forster

(1975). Evidence for lexical access in a simultaneous matching task. Memory and Cognition 3, 5 549–559.

19.

Clements

G. N.

Keyser

S. J.

(1983). CV Phonology: A generative theory of the syllable Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

20.

Coltheart

Masterson

Byng

Prior

Riddoch

(1983). Surface dyslexia. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 35A, 469–495.

21.

Conrad

(1965). Order errors in immediate recall of sequences. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 4, 161–169.

22.

Denckla

M. B.

Rudel

(1976). Rapid automatized naming (R.A.N.): Dyslexia differentiated from other learning disabilities. Neuropsychologia 14, 471–479.

23.

Di Lollo

Hansen

McIntyre

J. S.

(1983). Initial stages of visual information processing in dyslexia. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 9, 923–935.

24.

Done

D. J.

Miles

T. R.

(1978). Learning, Memory and Dyslexia. Practical aspects of memory. Gruneberg

M. M.

Morris

P. E.

Sykes

R. N.

London: Academic Press.

25.

Elliot

C. D.

Murray

D. J.

Pearson

L. S.

(1983). British Abilities Scales Windsor, UK: NFER-Nelson Publishing Company.

26.

Ellis

(1981). Information processing views of developmental dyslexia. Dyslexia Review 4, 1 and 2.

27.

Ellis

Miles

(1979). Visual information processing in dyslexic children. Practical aspects of memory. Gruneberg

M. M.

Morris

P. E.

Sykes

R. N.

London: Academic Press.

28.

Estes

W. K.

(1997). Processes of memory loss, recovery and distortion. Pyschological Review 104, 148–169.

29.

Frederiksen

J. R.

Kroll

J. F.

(1976). Spelling and sound: Approaches to the internal lexicon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 2, 3 361–379.

30.

Frith

(1980). Unexpected spelling problems. Cognitive processes in spelling. Frith

London: Academic Press.

31.

Frith

(1985). Beneath the surface of developmental dyslexia. Surface Dyslexia. Patterson

Marshall

Coltheart

Hove, UK: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Ltd.

32.

Funnel

Davison

(1989). Lexical capture: A developmental disorder of reading and spelling. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 41A, 3 471–487.

33.

Gascon

Goodglass

(1970). Reading retardation and the information content of stimuli in paired associate learning. Cortex 6, 417–429.

34.

Goldsmith

(1990). Autosegmental phonology New York: Garland Press.

35.

Goodman

Caramazza

(1985). The Johns Hopkins Dysgraphia Battery Baltimore, Maryland: The Johns Hopkins University.

36.

Goodman

Caramazza

(1986). The Johns Hopkins Dyslexia Battery Baltimore, Maryland: The Johns Hopkins University.

37.

Goulandris

N. K.

Snowling

(1991). Visual memory deficits: A plausible cause of developmental dyslexia?, Evidence from a single case study. Cognitive Neuropsychology 8, 2 127–154.

38.

Goyen

J. D.

LyIe

J. G.

(1971). Effects of incentives upon retarded and normal readers on a visual associative learning task. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 11, 274.

39.

Hanley

J. R.

Gard

(1995). A dissociation between developmental surface and phonological dyslexia in two undergraduate students. Neuropsychologia 33, 7 909–914.

40.

Hanley

J. R.

Hastie

Kay

(1992). Developmental surface dyslexia and dysgraphia: An orthographic processing impairment. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 2, 285–319.

41.

Hanna

R. R.

Hanna

J. S.

Hodges

R. E.

Rudolf

E. H.

(1966). Phoneme-grapheme correspondences as cues to spelling improvement Washington, DC: US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Education.

42.

Healy

(1974). Separating item from order information in short-term memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 13, 644–655.

43.

Hicks

(1980). The ITPA visual sequential memory task: An alternative interpretation and its implication for good and poor readers. British Journal of Educational Psychology 50, 18–25.

44.

Holmes

D. R.

McKeever

W. F.

(1979). Material specific serial memory deficit in adolescent dyslexia. Cortex 15, 51–62.

45.

Holmes

J. M.

(1973). Dyslexia: A neurolinguistic study of traumatic and developmental disorders of reading University of Edinburgh Unpublished Ph.D thesis.

46.

Holmes

V. M.

(1993). Word specific knowledge, word recognition strategies and spelling ability. Journal of Memory and Language 32, 230–257.

47.

Houghton

Glasspool

D. W.

Shallice

(1994). Spelling and serial recall: Insights from a competitive queueing model. Handbook of spelling: Theory, process and intervention. Brown

G. D. A.

Ellis

N. C.

John Wiley & Sons.

48.

Jastak

Bijon

S. W.

Jastak

(1978). The Wide Range Achievement Test Delaware: Jastak Associates.

49.

Jorm

A. F.

(1979). The cognitive and neurological basis of developmental dyslexia: A theoretical framework and review. Cognition 7, 19–33.

50.

Kay

Lesser

Coltheart

(1992). PALPA: Psycholinguistic assessments of language processing in aphasia Hove: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Ltd.

51.

Kirk

S. A.

McCarthy

J. J.

Kirk

W. W.

(1968). Illinois Test of Psycholinguistic Abilities Chicago, IL: University of Illinois.

52.

Lee

C. L.

Estes

W. K.

(1981). Item and order information in short-term memory: Evidence for multilevel perturbation processes. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 7, 3 149–169.

53.

Lewandowsky

Murdock

B. B.

(1989). Memory for serial order. Psychological Review 96, 25–57.

54.

Lovegrove

Martin

Slaghuis

(1986). A theoretical and experimental case for a visual deficit in specific reading disability. Cognitive Neuropsychology 3, 225–267.

55.

Mason

(1980). Reading ability and the encoding of item and location information. Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance 6, 89–98.

56.

Mason

Katz

Wicklund

D. A.

(1975). Immediate spatial order memory and item memory in sixth-grade children as a function of reader ability. Journal of Educational Psychology 67, 610–616.

57.

Mason

Pilkington

Brandau

(1981). From print to sound. Reading ability and order information. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 7, 580–591.

58.

McCann

R. S.

Besner

(1987). Reading pseudohomophones: Implications for models of pronunciation assembly and the locus of word frequency effects in naming. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 13, 1 14–24.

59.

McClelland

J. L.

Rumelhart

D. E.

(1981). An interactive activation model of context effects in letter perception: Part 1. An account of basic findings. Psychological Review 88, 375–407.

60.

Miles

T. R.

(1983). Dyslexia: The pattern of difficulties London: Granada.

61.

Mitterer

J. O.

(1982). There are at least two kinds of poor readers: whole words poor readers and receding poor readers. Canadian Journal of Psychology 36, 445–461.

62.

Murdock

B. B.

von Saal

(1967). Transposition in short-term memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology 74, 137–143.

63.

Murphy

L. A.

Pollatsek

Well

A. D.

(1988). Developmental dyslexia and word retrieval. Brain and Language 35, 1–23.

64.

Noelker

R. W.

Schumsky

D. A.

(1973). Memory for sequence, form and position as related to the identification of reading retardates. Journal of Educational Psychology 64, 22–25.

65.

Perin

(1983). Phonemic segmentation in spelling. British Journal of Psychology 74, 129–144.

66.

Plaut

D. C.

Shallice

(1993). Deep dyslexia: A case study of connectionist neuropsychology. Cognitive Neuropsychology 10, 377–500.

67.

Romani

Martin

R. C.

A deficit in the short-term retention of lexical-semantic information: Forgetting words, but remembering a story.

Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. in press.

68.

Romani

Stringer

(1994). Developmental dyslexia: A problem acquiring orthographic/ phonological information in the face of good visual memory and good short-term memory. Brain and Language 57, 3 482–485.

69.

Rust

Golombok

Trickey

(1993). Wechsler Objective Reading Dimension Scale Sidcup (Kent): The Psychological Corporation.

70.

Seidenberg

M. S.

Waters

G. S.

Barnes

M. A.

Tanenhaus

(1984). When does irregular spelling or pronunciation influence word recognition?. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 23, 383–404.

71.

Seymour

P. H. K.

(1986). Cognitive analysis of dyslexia London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

72.

Seymour

P. H. K.

Evans

H. M.

(1993). The visual orthographic processor and developmental dyslexia. Visual processes in reading and reading disabilities. Willows

D. M.

Kruk

R. S.

Corcos

Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

73.

Seymour

P. H. K.

MacGregor

C. J.

(1984). Developmental dyslexia: A cognitive experimental analysis of phonological, morphemic, and visual impairments. Cognitive Neuropsychology 1, 43–82.

74.

Shankweiler

Liberman

I. Y.

Mark

L. S.

Fower

C. A.

Fisher

F. W.

(1979). The speech code and learning to read. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 5, 531–545.

75.

Snowling

(1980). The development of grapheme-phoneme correspondence in normal and dyslexic children. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 29, 2–294.

76.

Snowling

(1987). Dyslexia: A cognitive developmental perspective Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

77.

Snowling

Stackhouse

Rack

(1986). Phonological dyslexia and dysgraphia-a developmental analysis. Cognitive Neuropsychology 3, 3 309–339.

78.

Sperling

(1960). The information available in brief visual presentations. Psychological Monographs 74, Whole No. 498.

79.

Stanley

Hall

(1973). Short-term visual information processing in dyslexies. Child Development 44, 841–844.

80.

Stanovich

K. E.

(1988). The right and wrong place to look for the cognitive locus of reading disability. Annals of Dyslexia 38, 154–177.

81.

Temple

(1985). Developmental surface dysgraphia: A case report. Applied Psycholinguistics 6, 391–406.

82.

Temple

C. M.

(1986). Developmental dysgraphias. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 38A, 77–110.

83.

Temple

C. M.

Marshall

J. C.

(1983). A case study of developmental phonological dyslexia. British Journal of Psychology 74, 517–533.

84.

Thomson

M. E.

Wilsher

(1979). Some aspects of memory in dyslexic children and controls. Practical aspects of memory. Gruneberg London: Academic Press.

85.

Treiman

(1984). Individual differences among children in reading spelling styles. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 37, 463–477.

86.

Vellutino

F. R.

Steger

J. A.

Pruzek

R. M.

(1973). Inter vs. intra-sensory deficit in paired associate learning in poor and normal readers. Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science 5, 111–123.

87.

Vellutino

F. R.

Harding

C. J.

Phillips

Steger

J. A.

(1975). Differential transfer in poor and normal readers. Journal of Genetic Psychology 126, 3–18.

88.

Vellutino

F. R.

Steger

J. A.

Harding

C. J.

Phillips

(1975). Verbal vs. non-verbal paired associates learning in poor and normal readers. Neuropsychologia 13, 75–82.

89.

Vellutino

F. R.

Steger

J. A.

Desetto

Phillips

(1975). Immediate and delayed recognition of visual stimuli in poor and normal readers. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 19, 223–232.

90.

Wagner

Torgesen

(1987). The nature of phonological processing and its causal role in the acquisition of reading skills. Psychological Bulletin 101, 192–212.

91.

Wechsler

(1987). Wechsler memory scale - revised New York: The Psychological Corporation, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Inc.

92.

Wickelgren

W. A.

(1967). Acoustic similarity and intrusion errors in short-term memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology 70, 102–108.

93.

Wilding

(1989). Developmental dyslexies do not fit in boxes: Evidence from the case studies. European Journal of Cognitive Psychology 1, 2 105–127.

94.

Wilding

(1990). Developmental dyslexies do not fit in boxes: Evidence from six new case studies. European Journal of Cognitive Psychology 2, 97–131.

95.

Wolf

(1984). Naming, reading and the dyslexias: A longitudinal overview. Annals of Dyslexia 34, 87–115.