Physicochemical Investigations of Homeopathic Preparations: A Systematic Review and Bibliometric Analysis

Abstract

Objectives:

The last systematic review of physicochemical research performed on homeopathic preparations was published in 2003. The aim of the study is to update and expand the current state of knowledge in the area of physicochemical properties of homeopathic preparations. In part 1 of the study, we aim to present an overview of the literature with respect to publication quality and methods used. In part 2, we aim to identify the most interesting experimental techniques. With this, we aim to be in a position to generate meaningful hypotheses regarding a possible mode of action of homeopathic preparations.

Methods:

A two-step procedure was adopted: (1) an extensive literature search, followed by a bibliometric and quality analysis on the level of publications and (2) a thorough qualitative analysis of the individual physicochemical investigations found. In this publication, we report on step (1). We searched major scientific databases to find publications reporting physicochemical investigations of homeopathy from its origin to the end of 2015. Publications were assessed using a scoring scheme, the Manuscript Information Score (MIS). Information regarding country of origin of the research and experimental techniques used was extracted.

Results:

We identified 183 publications (compared to 44 in the last review), 122 of which had an MIS ≥5. The rate of publication in the field was ∼2 per year from the 1970s until 2000. Afterward, it increased to over 5.5 publications per year. The quality of publications was seen to increase sharply from 2000 onward, whereas before 2000, only 12 (13%) publications were rated as “high quality” (MIS ≥7.5); 44 (48%) publications were rated as “high quality” from 2000 onward. Countries with most publications were Germany (n = 42, 23%), France (n = 29, 16%), India (n = 27, 15%), and Italy (n = 26, 14%). Techniques most frequently used were electrical impedance (26%), analytical methods (20%), spectroscopy (20%), and nuclear magnetic resonance (19%).

Conclusions:

Physicochemical research into homeopathic preparations is increasing both in terms of quantity and quality of the publications.

Introduction

Homeopathy is a popular complementary or alternative treatment modality in Europe¹ and India,^2,3 while less so, but with an increasing demand in the United States.⁴ Homeopathic remedies, produced by alternate sequential dilution and succussion, have been shown to be effective in plant experiments,^5
–7 animal models,⁸ as well as clinical trials involving humans.^9,10

The mode of action underlying specific effects of highly diluted homeopathic preparations could not yet be established, which strongly hampers the acceptance of homeopathy. A variety of models have been proposed. These can be categorized as local models^{11

–18} and nonlocal models.^19

–23 For recent review of the theory, the reader is referred to the reviews by Schulte and Endler²⁴ and Bellavite et al.²⁵

However, any theoretical model needs to be supported by experimental evidence. The aim of this systematic review is to compile and interpret previously published research on physicochemical investigations of homeopathically potentized preparations, to refine existing hypotheses, and generate new ones, and so direct future experiments. It is also an update of previous systematic reviews of physicochemical investigations^26,27 and a specification of a broader bibliometric evaluation of homeopathic basic research in general.²⁸

In this article, we present the literature search, quality analysis, and bibliometric description on the level of publications. In a second step, in a follow-up publication, individual investigations will be extracted from the high-quality publications and analyzed in detail, with the aims of identifying most interesting experimental techniques, identifying empirical evidence (if any) of specific physicochemical features of homeopathic preparations, determining most promising areas of research, and generating hypotheses regarding a possible mode of action of homeopathic preparations.

Methods

Protocol and registration

This review was planned and conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines.²⁹ The protocol was not registered in any database; as such databases are geared toward registering health-related systematic reviews.

We made the distinction between “publications” and “investigations”. A publication can report on results of several different investigations. On the other hand, a single investigation can be presented in several publications. To simplify the analysis, the procedure was split in two parts. This study focuses its analysis per “publications”—a deeper per “investigation” analysis will be presented in a subsequent publication.

Eligibility criteria

To be eligible for this systematic review, investigations reported in the publications needed to

• be experimental

• investigate physicochemical properties of homeopathic preparations

• investigate potency levels ≥6x or 3c

• be published before the end of 2015.

Publication types included papers in peer-reviewed and not peer-reviewed journals, theses, books, book sections, and conference proceedings. Conference abstracts were excluded, because their word limits did not allow for a detailed description of the methodology and results.

There was no language restriction (papers in English, German, French, and Russian were evaluated).

Publications were excluded, if they

• described experiments with enzymes, bacteria, cells, plants, animals, or humans

• described mathematical models or theoretical thought experiments

• were a translation of another publication in a different language.

Publications that described several experiments were included if at least one experiment fulfilled the inclusion criteria.

Information sources

The following databases were searched, from the beginning of each database until the end of 2015: HomBRex, PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, and Scopus. Personal literature collections were also included.

Search

Search terms were as follows: homeopath*, high dilutions, very dilute aqueous solutions, very high dilutions, ultrahigh aqueous dilutions, extremely diluted solutions, extremely diluted aqueous solutions, ultramolecular aqueous dilutions, and serially diluted and agitated solutions. These were combined with physicochemistry keywords.

In HomBRex, the search was by Field “Physical chemistry.”

In Web of Science, the search strategy was as follows: Keywords: Homeopath*. Restricted to Research areas: chemistry OR microscopy OR biophysics OR physics OR materials science OR science technology other topics OR instruments instrumentation OR medical lab technology. In SCOPUS and PubMed; the search terms were as follows: ([homeopath* or homoeopath* or “ultra high dilution” OR “serial* agit*”]) AND (NMR OR Spectrom* or spectrosc* or conducti* OR AFM OR Thermolumi* OR lumine* OR dielectric OR densitometry OR refractometry OR microcal* OR ultrasound OR “Surface Tension”).

The International Journal of High Dilution Research was searched by scanning the table of contents for all years available.

The personal literature collection of S.B. was searched by the following keyword: Phys*.

Further references were added from earlier reviews.^26,27

The search was performed by two authors independently (S.B. and A.T.) and then combined in EndNote.

Manuscript Information Score

Full-text papers were screened for inclusion and exclusion criteria (see above). Papers matching these criteria were then evaluated according to a Manuscript Information Score (MIS). The present MIS scoring scheme is based upon an MIS used for the rating of bioassay publications,^5
–7 which was adapted for the rating of physicochemical publications, defined at the beginning of the review. The MIS used in this review provides a score assessing the quality of reporting, with items specifically relevant for physicochemical research into homeopathic preparations.

Five assessment areas were each attributed a score between 0 and 2, providing a final maximum MIS score of 10. The categories considered were as follows: experimental procedure, materials, measuring instruments, potentization, and controls. The specifics of the scoring scheme are presented in Table 1.

Table 1.

Assessment of the Manuscript Information Content by the Manuscript Information Score

	Score	Description
Experimental procedure	2	Detailed information is given as follows: Timeline of preparations and measurements/time of measurement Randomization, blinding Number of replicates Number of measurements Treatment/handling of the samples after potentization
	1	Only some details are described or few information about the setup is given
	0	No information is given about the experimental setup
Materials	2	All materials used in the experiments are described with trade name, etc.
	1	Some materials used in the experiments are described or mentioned
	0	No information is given about the materials used
Measuring instruments	2	Measuring instruments are described in detail, operation mode, trade name, type, etc.
	1	Measuring instruments are only mentioned
	0	There is no information about measuring instruments in the paper
Potentization	2	Potentization technique, date and time of potentization, and potentization medium are described in detail
	1	Some information about potentization technique is given Ordered from company without further details—“Material 30c”
	0	No information about potentization, only the potentized test substance is mentioned
Controls	2	Detailed information (e.g. sterile distilled water from the same batch of distilled water…)
	1	Some information about the sort of control is given (e.g. water control) Or other potency levels serve as control
	0	Controls are not mentioned or done

Five assessment areas were given a score between 0 and 2, leading to a maximum of 10 points. Only studies with MIS ≥5 were included in the review.

MIS, Manuscript Information Score.

Scoring was performed by two reviewers independently. Differences in MIS scores greater than one were resolved by discussion between the reviewers. No reviewer scored his own publications. Authors of the publications were not contacted for obtaining additional (missing) data.

Data items

The following data were extracted from each publication:

• Publication type (Peer-reviewed journal, Not peer-reviewed journal, Journal peer review unknown, Conference proceedings, Book or book section, Thesis)

• Publication year

• Techniques used, categorized in 11 groups: Electrical impedance, Analytical methods, Spectroscopy, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR), Imaging methods, Calorimetry, Electrochemistry, Luminescence, Chromatography, Raman spectroscopy, Various physical

• Country of origin (the country of the corresponding author was selected when authors were from several countries)

• MIS (see above).

Results

Three hundred and three references were identified through searching databases and personal libraries. For 14 references, no full text was available (some books could not be found in the libraries accessible to us, and some PhD theses could not be obtained in full text), such that only 289 could be retrieved in full text. Out of these 289 publications, 106 were excluded for various reasons (Fig. 1). Finally, 183 publications were included in this bibliometric evaluation^{11,12,16,30

–209} (Fig. 1). The full list of included publications along with their associated MIS score, Country, Publications Type, and Methods used is provided as Supplementary Data (Supplementary Data are available online at www.liebertpub.com/acm).

FIG. 1.

PRISMA flow diagram of paper inclusion.

Publication type and journals

Most papers appeared in peer-reviewed journals, with 68% of all publication peer reviewed. Seventy-three percent of the publications with an MIS ≥5 were peer reviewed (Table 2). Table 3 presents the journals having published more than five publications. We see that the journal Homeopathy (formerly British Homeopathic Journal) has published the most with 24 publications in the field and has carried on publishing in recent years (17 publications from 2000 onward). Interestingly, the Journal of the American Institute of Homeopathy, which published 11 papers in this field, has stopped publishing physicochemical research in recent years. Similarly, the Annales Homéopathiques Françaises has stopped publishing in this field (six publications before 2000). On the other hand, journals like the International Journal of High Dilution Research, the Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, and the Journal of Molecular Liquids have been publishing in this field from 2000 onward (seven publications from 2000 onward each).

Table 2.

Breakdown of Publications According to Type of Publication

Publication type	MIS <5	MIS ≥5	Total
Peer-reviewed journal	36	89	125
Not peer-reviewed journal	2	2	4
Journal peer review unknown	14	10	24
Conference proceedings	5	5	10
Book or book section	4	10	14
Thesis	0	6	6

MIS, Manuscript Information Score.

Table 3.

Journals Publishing More Than Five Physicochemical Investigations of Homeopathic Preparations—Before 2000 and from 2000 Onwards

Journal	Before 2000	2000 Onward	Total
Homeopathy	7	17	24
Journal of the American Institute of Homeopathy	11	0	11
Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry	0	11	11
International Journal of High Dilution Research	0	7	7
Journal of Molecular Liquids	0	7	7
Annales Homéopathiques Françaises	6	0	6

Development over time

Figure 2 presents the number of publications over time. The number of publications has been increasing markedly around 2000 from ∼2 publications per year to over 5.5 publications per year from 2000 onward (see insert in Fig. 2). The first publication we found dates back to 1842 and was performed by a German author, Carl Mayrhofer, who studied the grinding of metals through solid trituration by microscopic investigation.¹⁵⁸ The following publication was a French study, which appeared in 1935,²⁰⁶ followed in 1936 by the first British publication.⁵²

FIG. 2.

Publications of physicochemical studies of homeopathic preparations per time period. MIS, Manuscript Information Score.

Reporting quality

The rate of agreement in the MIS—defined as one or less point difference between the two reviewers scoring the papers—was greater than 85%. One hundred and twenty-two of the 183 publications (67%) were scored with an MIS ≥5 and rated as publication with “acceptable reporting quality.” Fifty-six of the 183 publications (31%) were scored with an MIS ≥7.5 and rated as publication with “high reporting quality.”

The quality of the papers, as determined by MIS ≥5, has also risen sharply in recent years, with only 35% of publication in the 80s having an MIS ≥5 compared to 82% in the current decade (Fig. 2). Looking at the distribution of MIS scores over the years, we see that the average MIS score has increased significantly since 1990 from 4.2 to 6.9 (data not shown). Considering that 50% of publications were published in 2000 or after, it makes sense to look more closely at recent years. Before 2000, only 12 (13%) publications had an MIS ≥7.5 (defined as “high-quality”), with most publications having MIS scores around 4 (Fig. 3). The picture is considerably different from 2000 onward, where 44 (48%) publications had an MIS ≥7.5. On average, over the whole time range, 30% of publications had an MIS ≥7.5.

FIG. 3.

Distribution of Manuscript Information Scores (MIS) (average of two scorings from two reviewers) for the publications before 2000 and from 2000 onward.

Geographic distribution

Figure 4 presents the breakdown of publications by country (more specifically, the country of the corresponding author). Most publications came from Germany with 42 publications (23% of all publications), France with 29 publications (16%), India with 27 publications (15%), and Italy with 26 publications (14%). Germany and Italy have been publishing the most publications with MIS ≥5 (25 each, i.e., 20%). From 2000 onward, the breakdown per country is somewhat different with Italy (26% of publications), India (22%), and Germany (14%) appearing most active in the field in recent years (Fig. 5).

FIG. 4.

Number of publications per country for all 183 publications. MIS, Manuscript Information Score.

FIG. 5.

Number of publications per country from 2000 onward. MIS, Manuscript Information Score.

Techniques

A variety of experimental techniques have been used to investigate homeopathic dilutions. The experimental techniques were categorized in 11 categories: Electrical impedance (which included dielectric constant, dielectric relaxation, resistance, capacity, and impedance), Analytical methods (Inductively Coupled Plasma-Mass Spectrometry, Atomic Absorptions, radioactive tracers, and neutron activation), Spectroscopy (Ultra-Violet, Visible, Infra-Red, and Fourier-Transform Infra-Red), NMR (NMR spectroscopy and NMR relaxation times), Imaging methods (Kirlian photography, X-rays, photography, microscopy, crystallization, Transmission electron microscopy, Calorimetry, Electrochemistry (including pH measurements), Luminescence (fluorescence and thermoluminescence), Chromatography (including thin layer chromatography), Raman spectroscopy, Various physical (any other technique that did not fit another category).

The breakdown of the number of publications per investigation technique used is shown in Figure 6. One paper may present experiments using several techniques. Techniques most commonly used were electrical impedance with 48 publications using this technique (26% of publications), analytical methods (37 publications—20%), spectroscopy (37 publications—20%), and NMR (34 publications—19%).

FIG. 6.

Breakdown of publications in terms of investigative technique used (see text for more detailed description of what each category included). One publication can report on more than one technique. MIS, Manuscript Information Score.

The picture, which emerges in terms of techniques used from 2000 onward, is very similar (data not shown). If one looks more closely at the geographical breakdown of investigative techniques from 2000 onward (data not shown), we observe that certain countries weigh heavily in certain techniques. Italy accounts for 100% of calorimetry experiments, 69% of electrical impedance experiments, and 57% of use of analytical techniques, whereas most spectroscopy experiments were performed in India (35%) and Switzerland (24%). Finally most NMR experiments were performed in France (33%) and India (27%). This shows the “hotspots” in physicochemical homeopathic research from 2000 onward.

Discussion

Overview

Our investigation identified 183 publications in physicochemical research of homeopathic preparations, starting with a first German publication in 1842.¹⁵⁸ Of these 183 publications, 122 (66%) had an MIS ≥5 reflecting acceptable reporting quality. The number of publication per year has risen over time with a marked increase around 2000, leading to 50% of publications appearing from 2000 onward. Over 63% of publications were peer reviewed (73% for publications with MIS ≥5).

Previous reviews and search strategy

Becker-Witt et al. published a previous review in 2003, which focused on the quality of physical research in homeopathy.²⁷ They included investigations using measurements of dielectric strength, NMR, and spectroscopy (UV, Vis and IR), and explicitly excluded techniques such as refractometry, microcalorimetry, surface tension, conductivity, densitometry, and many others. They consulted MEDLINE, EMBASE, Current Contents, and the Karl and Veronica Carstens Foundation. Their search strategy yielded 44 publications with only 6 publications (14%) being considered of high quality (Score for Assessment of Physical Experiments on Homeopathy [SAPEH] score >7). Our search strategy was wider, including areas that had been excluded from the Becker-Witt study. For comparison, we found 95 publications before 2000, 12 of which (13%) have an MIS ≥7.5 (equivalent to “high quality”). One further explanation for the higher number of publications in our review could also be our use of the specialized HomBRex database of basic research in homeopathy, which was not available at the time of the Becker-Witt literature search.²¹⁰

Indeed, many of the old publications are not referenced in modern databases (e.g., Web of Science); so we had to rely on specialized databases such as the HomBRex database.²¹⁰ Because of this lack of referencing of older publications, it is possible we missed some older references. In principle, this could only be resolved by manual scanning of older journals, which was beyond the scope of this review. Nonpublished investigations were also out of scope for this review.

Quality assessment

Becker-Witt et al. introduced the so-called SAPEH score in their 2003 review.²⁷ This score is based on three fundamental quality constructs: methodology, experiment standardization, and presentation. The SAPEH score was designed to assess overall study quality.

In our review, we decided to restrict the quality assessment to “reporting quality” in five fields of particular interest for physicochemical investigations of homeopathic preparations: experimental procedure, materials, measuring instruments, potentization procedure, and controls (Table 1). The idea of this procedure is to include only publications in a more detailed qualitative evaluation that reported enough experimental details for the reviewers to understand what was actually done in the study presented. Any judgment whether the study design used was meaningful, whether the controls used were adequate, and whether any conclusions were justified compared to the data presented was postponed to the detailed qualitative evaluation.

The MIS design was also inspired by the prepublication checklist put together by Stock-Schröer in 2015 in the Reporting Experiments in Homeopathic Basic Research (REHBaR) scheme.²¹¹ However, the REHBaR scheme is a publication guideline for proper presentation of the work and not a tool to evaluate quality or methodological aspects.

A 2015 review by Schulte and Endler carried on the work of Becker-Witt, investigating the quality of publications using experimental methods in ultra-high dilutions, 2004–2014.²⁴ They analyzed nine publications published in the journal Homeopathy. Overall quality of the nine papers analyzed was low (one publication with SAPEH = 5). Our analysis did not include any restriction on the journal where the findings were published. We found, in contrast, 66 publications over the same period, 2004–2014, 59 of which had an MIS ≥5. A quick look at these publications reveals that the majority were indeed not published in the journal Homeopathy. Accordingly, our conclusions are somewhat different than Schulte's: where Schulte reports that studies in the field have been appearing at a steady rate, we find a marked increase from 2000 onward, the majority of which was not published in the journal Homeopathy and hence was not analyzed by Schulte. Also, the rather low incidence of high-quality publications reported is not reflected in our findings where we see a significant increase in quality from 2000 onward, with 44 (48%) publications having an MIS ≥7.5, corresponding to “high reporting quality”.”

Geographic distribution

With its long history in homeopathy, Europe currently dominates, in terms of number of publications, with 115 publications (63%), with Germany leading with 42 publications (23%) followed by France with 29 publications (16%), and Italy with 26 publications (14%). Coming in second place overall, we have India with 27 publications (15%).

This European dominance has decreased slightly in recent years with 53 publications (58%) from 2000 onward (Fig. 5). This can be attributed mostly to the strong appearance of Indian research over the last few years with 20 publications (22%) from 2000 onward versus 7 (8%) before 2000. Similarly, we notice that most of Italy's publications appeared in the last few years with 24 publications (26%) appearing from 2000 onward versus 2 (2%) before 2000.

The 2014 review by Clausen et al.,²⁸ which also included in vitro and in vivo experiments, reported on 1,383 publications. They found the main countries publishing in this field to be France with 267 publications (14%), Germany with 246 publications (13%), and India with 237 publications (13%).

Conclusions

We found 183 publications reporting physicochemical experiments investigating homeopathic dilutions. The rate of publication in the field has increased from ∼2 per year from the 1970s until 2000 to over 5.5 publications per year since then. The reporting quality of the studies has increased over the years with a significant increase from 13% of publications rated as “high reporting quality” before 2000 compared to 48% since then. Europe is leading in terms of total number of publications, Germany (23% of publications) leading in front of France (16%) and Italy (14%). India has been making steady progress in the field in recent years (15%). The most frequently used techniques were electrical impedance (used in 26% of publications), analytical methods, spectroscopy, and NMR techniques (∼20% each).

Footnotes

Acknowledgments

We thank the Karl and Veronica Carstens Foundation and DHU library for providing us full-text references.

Author Disclosure Statement

S.W. is an employee of Hevert-Arzneimittel, Germany; however, none of the publications included in this review used Hevert products.

References

Frass

, Strassl

, Friehs

, et al. Use and acceptance of complementary and alternative medicine among the general population and medical personnel: A systematic review. Ochsner J, 2012; 12:45–56.

Ghosh

. A short history of the development of homeopathy in India. Homeopathy, 2010; 99:130–136.

Srinivasan

, Sugumar

. Spread of traditional medicines in India: Results of national sample survey organization's perception survey on use of Ayush. J Evid Based Complementary Altern Med, 2015;pii:2156587215607673.

Dossett

, Davis

, Kaptchuk

, Yeh

. Homeopathy use by US adults: Results of a national survey. Am J Public Health, 2016; 106:743–745.

Jäger

, Scherr

, Shah

, et al. Use of homeopathic preparations in experimental studies with abiotically stressed plants. Homeopathy, 2011; 100:275–287.

Betti

, Trebbi

, Majewsky

, et al. Use of homeopathic preparations in phytopathological models and in field trials: A critical review. Homeopathy, 2009; 98:244–266.

Majewsky

, Arlt

, Shah

, et al. Use of homeopathic preparations in experimental studies with healthy plants. Homeopathy, 2009; 98:228–243.

Bonamin

, Cardoso

, de Carvalho

, Amaral

. The use of animal models in homeopathic research—a review of 2010–2014 PubMed indexed papers. Homeopathy, 2015; 104:283–291.

Mathie

, Lloyd

, Legg

, et al. Randomised placebo-controlled trials of individualised homeopathic treatment: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Syst Rev, 2014; 3:142.

10.

Mathie

, Ramparsad

, Legg

, et al. Randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials of non-individualised homeopathic treatment: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Syst Rev, 2017; 6:63.

11.

Chikramane

, Suresh

, Bellare

, Kane

. Extreme homeopathic dilutions retain starting materials: A nanoparticulate perspective. Homeopathy, 2010; 99:231–242.

12.

Chikramane

, Kalita

, Suresh

, et al. Why extreme dilutions reach non-zero asymptotes: A nanoparticulate hypothesis based on froth flotation. Langmuir, 2012; 28:15864–15875.

13.

Temgire

, Suresh

, Kane

, Bellare

. Establishing the interfacial nano-structure and elemental composition of homeopathic medicines based on inorganic salts: A scientific approach. Homeopathy, 2016; 105:160–172.

14.

Anick

. The octave potencies convention: A mathematical model of dilution and succussion. Homeopathy, 2007; 96:202–208.

15.

Anick

, Ives

. The silica hypothesis for homeopathy: Physical chemistry. Homeopathy, 2007; 96:189–195.

16.

Demangeat

J-L

. NMR relaxation evidence for solute-induced nanosized superstructures in ultramolecular aqueous dilutions of silica-lactose. J Mol Liquids, 2010; 155:71–79.

17.

Kratky

. [Homeopathy and structure of water: A physical model]. Forschende Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd, 2004; 11:24–32. (Article in German).

18.

Bell

, Schwartz

. Enhancement of adaptive biological effects by nanotechnology preparation methods in homeopathic medicines. Homeopathy, 2015; 104:123–138.

19.

Waisse

, Bonamin

. Explanatory models for homeopathy: From the vital force to the current paradigm. Homeopathy, 2016; 105:280–285.

20.

Walach

. [Entanglement model of homeopathy as an example of generalized entanglement predicted by weak quantum theory]. Forschende Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd, 2003; 10:192–200 (Article in German).

21.

Weingärtner

. The homeopathic mechanism from the viewpoint of a quantum mechanical paradoxon. J Altern Complement Med, 2005; 11:773–774.

22.

Beauvais

. Memory of water and blinding. Homeopathy, 2008; 97:41–42.

23.

Milgrom

. A new geometrical description of entanglement and the curative homeopathic process. J Altern Complement Med, 2008; 14:329–339.

24.

Schulte

, Endler

. Update on preliminary elements of a theory of ultra high dilutions. Homeopathy, 2015; 104:337–342.

25.

Bellavite

, Marzotto

, Olioso

, et al. High-dilution effects revisited. 1. Physicochemical aspects. Homeopathy, 2014; 103:4–21.

26.

Schulte

, Endler

. Outline of experimental physical methods to investigate specific structures of ultra highly diluted solvents. In: Endler

, Schulte

, eds. Ultra High Dilution. Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Springer Netherlands, 1994:99–104. https://link-springer-com-443.web.bisu.edu.cn/book/10.1007/978-94-015-8342-8#about

27.

Becker-Witt

, Weisshuhn

TER

, Lüdtke

, Willich

. Quality assessment of physical research in homeopathy. J Altern Complement Med, 2003; 9:113–132.

28.

Clausen

, van Wijk

, Albrecht

. Geographical and temporal distribution of basic research experiments in homeopathy. Homeopathy, 2014; 103:193–197.

29.

PRISMA. Online document at: http://prisma-statement.org.Accessed April 3, 2017 .

30.

Aabel

, Fossheim

, Rise

. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies of homeopathic solutions. Br Homeopath J, 2001; 90:14–20.

31.

Anagnostatos

, Pisses

, Viras

, Provata

. Physico-chemical study of homeopathic dilutions. In: Bornoroni

, ed. Omeomed 92. First International Congress, 1992. Urbino, Italy: Compositori.

32.

Anagnostatos

, Pissis

, Viras

. Possible water cluster formation by dilution and succussions. In: Anagnostatos

, von Oertzen

, eds. Atomic and Nuclear Clusters. Berlin, Germany: Springer, 1995:215–217.

33.

Anagnostatos

, Pissis

, Viras

, Soutzidou

. Theory and experiments on high dilutions. In: Ernst

, Hahn

, eds. Homoeopathy—A Critical Appraisal. Oxford, United Kingdom: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1998:153–166.

34.

Anick

. High sensitivity 1H-NMR spectroscopy of homeopathic remedies made in water. BMC Complement Altern Med, 2004; 4:15.

35.

Assumpcao

. Electrical impedance and HV plasma images of high dilutions of sodium chloride. Homeopathy, 2008; 97:129–133.

36.

Bardet

, Luu

. Etude des dilutions homéopathiques par effet Raman-Laser. Travaux de la Société de Pharmacie de Montpellier, 1975; 35:361–372.

37.

Baumgartner

, Wolf

, Skrabal

, et al. High-field ¹H T₁ and T₂ NMR relaxation time measurements of H₂O in homeopathic preparations of quartz, sulfur, and copper sulfate. Naturwissenschaften, 2009; 96:1079–1089.

38.

Beier

. Über physikalische Wirkungen oder Eigenschaften echter homöopathischer Hochpotenzen. Leipzig, Germany: Universität Leipzig, Med. Fakultät, 1953.

39.

Bell

, Lewis

, Brooks

, et al. Gas discharge visualization evaluation of ultramolecular doses of homeopathic medicines under blinded, controlled conditions. J Altern Complement Med, 2003; 9:25–38.

40.

Bell

, Muralidharan

, Schwartz

. Nanoparticle characterization of traditional homeopathically-manufactured Gelsemium sempervirens medicines and placebo controls. Nanomed Biotherapeut Discov, 2015; 5:136.

41.

Bell

, Muralidharan

, Schwartz

. Nanoparticle characterization of traditional homeopathically-manufactured silver (argentum metallicum) medicines and placebo controls. Nanomed Nanotechnol, 2015; 6:311.

42.

Belon

, Elia

, et al. Conductometric and calorimetric studies of the serially diluted and agitated solutions—on the combined anomalous effect of time and volume parameters. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2008; 93:459–469.

43.

Betti

, Elia

, Napoli

, et al. Biological effects and physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions as a function of aging-time. Front Life Sci, 2011; 5:117–126.

44.

Bhattacharyya

, Mandal

, Biswas

, et al. In vitro studies demonstrate anticancer activity of an alkaloid of the plant Gelsemium sempervirens . Exp Biol Med, 2008; 233:1591–1601.

45.

Boericke

, Smith

. Modern aspects of homeopathic research. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1963; 56:363–366.

46.

Boericke

, Smith

. Modern aspects of homeopathic research (continued). J Am Inst Homeopath, 1965; 58:158–167.

47.

Boiron

. Kontrolle der homöopathischen Kügelchen mit Hilfe markierter Präparationen. ZKH, 1963; 7:241–248.

48.

Boiron

. Nouvellle technique de préparation des dilutions korsakowiennes. Ann Homéopathiques Françaises, 1965; 7:586–594.

49.

Boiron

, Vinh

CLD

. Contribution to the study of the physical structure of homoeopathic dilutions by Raman laser effect. In: Intérêt d'adhérer à la LMHI, ed. 31e Congres de la Ligue Médicale Homéopathique Internationale Athens, Greece, 17.05.1976–22.05.1976. Athens, Greece: Eigenverlag, 1976:459–474.

50.

Bonet-Maury

, Deysine

, Vogeli

L-M

. Etude de dilutions homéopathiques par les radio-isotopes. Ann Pharm Franc, 1954; 12:654–663.

51.

Botha

, Ross

AHA

. A nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy comparison of 3C trituration derived and 4C trituration derived remedies. Homeopathy, 2008; 97:196–201.

52.

Boyd

. Research on the Low Potencies of Homoeopathy, an Account of Some Physical Properties Indicating Activity. London, United Kingdom: Heinemann, 1936.

53.

Brucato

, Stephenson

. The photometric determination of the concentration of homoeopathic dilutions of mercuric sulfide (HgS). J Am Inst Homeopath, 1957; 50:242–243, 253.

54.

Brucato

, Stephenson

. Dielectric strength testing of homeopathic dilutions of HgCl₂ . J Am Inst Homeopath, 1966; 59:281–286.

55.

Cacace

, Elia

, et al. Conductometric and pH metric titrations of extremely diluted solutions using HCl solutions as titrant A molecular model. J Mol Liquids, 2009; 146:122–126.

56.

Cartwright

. Solvatochromic dyes detect the presence of homeopathic potencies. Homeopathy, 2016; 105:55–65.

57.

Chakraborty

, Datta

, Sukul

, et al. Variation in free and bound water molecules in different homeopathic potencies as revealed by their fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). Int J High Dilution Res, 2014; 13:189–196.

58.

Chibici-Revneanu

. UV-spektroskopische und dielektrische Untersuchungen von Wasser und hoch verdünnten homöopathischen Arzneistofflösungen. Leipzig, Germany: Universität Leipzig, Fakultät f. Biowissenschaften, Pharmazie und Psychologie (Institut für Pharmazie), 2005.

59.

Ciavatta

, Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted solutions. Electromotive force measurements of galvanic cells sensible to the activity of NaCl at 25°C. J Solution Chem, 2008; 37:1037–1049.

60.

Conte

, Berliocchi

, Lasne

, Vernot

. Theory of High Dilutions and Experimental Aspects. Paris, France: Polytechnica, 1996.

61.

Datta

, Bose

, Ghosh

. Spectrophotometric estimation of elemental sulphur in homoeopathic sulphur mother tincture and 4 × dilution. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1972; 65:53–55.

62.

Daudel

, Robilliart

. Étude des dilutions homéopathiques a l'aide de la méthode des indicateurs radio-actifs. Cahiers d'homéopathie et de thérapeutique comparée, 1946; 12:153–157.

63.

de Alvarenga

, de Oliveira

APM

, da Silva

RTB

, Casali

VWD

. Effect of magnesium phosphoricum 12C on sodium dodecylsulphate by 13C nuclear magnetic resonance. Int J High Dilution Res, 2009; 8:3–8.

64.

Demangeat

J-L

. NMR water proton relaxation in unheated and heated ultrahigh aqueous dilutions of histamine: Evidence for an air-dependent supramolecular organization of water. J Mol Liquids, 2009; 144:32–39.

65.

Demangeat

J-L

. Nanosized solvent superstructures in ultramolecular aqueous dilutions: Twenty years' research using water proton NMR relaxation. Homeopathy, 2013; 102:87–105.

66.

Demangeat

. Gas nanobubbles and aqueous nanostructures: The crucial role of dynamization. Homeopathy, 2015; 104:101–115.

67.

Demangeat

, Demangeat

, Gries

, et al. Modifications des temps de relaxation RMN à 4 MHz des protons du solvant dans les très hautes dilution salines de silice/lactose. J Méd Nucl Biophys, 1992; 16:135–145.

68.

Demangeat

, Gries

, Poitevin

. Modification of 4 MHz NMR water proton relaxation times in highly diluted aqueous solutions. Br Homeopath J, 1995; 84:169–170.

69.

Demangeat

, Gries

, Poitevin

. Modification of 4 MHz N.M.R. water proton relaxation times in very high diluted aqueous solutions. In: Bastide

, ed. Signals and Images. Dordrecht, Netherland: Kluwer Academic, 1997:95–110.

70.

Demangeat

, Gries

, Poitevin

, et al. Low-field NMR water proton longitudinal relaxation in ultrahighly diluted aqueous solutions of silica-lactose prepared in glass material for pharmaceutical use. Appl Magn Reson, 2004; 26:465–481.

71.

Dragan

. Some consideration of coherency in topoenergetic terms, I. High-resolution mixing calorimetry (HRMC) experiments on aqueous solutions. J Therm Anal, 1992; 38:1497–1508.

72.

Ducassou

. Expérimentations en cours sur l'appareil à dynamisations korsakoviennes. Ann Hom Franc, 1973; 15:129–140.

73.

Elia

, Ausanio

, Gentile

, et al. Experimental evidence of stable water nanostructures in extremely dilute solutions, at standard pressure and temperature. Homeopathy, 2014; 103:44–50.

74.

Elia

, Baiano

, Duro

, et al. Permanent physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions of homeopathic medicines. Homeopathy, 2004; 93:144–150.

75.

Elia

, Elia

, Cacace

, et al. ‘Extremely diluted solutions’ as multi-variable systems—a study of calorimetric and conductometric behaviour as a function of the parameter time. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2006; 84:317–323.

76.

Elia

, Elia

, Marchese

, et al. Interaction of “extremely diluted solutions” with aqueous solutions of hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide—a calorimetric study at 298 K. J Mol Liquids, 2007; 130:15–20.

77.

Elia

, Elia

, Marchettini

, et al. Physico-chemical properties of aqueous extremely diluted solutions in relation to ageing. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2008; 93:1003–1011.

78.

Elia

, Elia

, Montanino

, et al. Conductometric studies of the serially diluted and agitated solutions on an anomalous effect that depends on the dilution process. J Mol Liquids, 2007; 135:158–165.

79.

Elia

, Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. Conductometric and calorimetric studies of serially diluted and agitated solutions: The dependence of intensive parameters on volume. Int J Ecodyn, 2006; 1:361–372.

80.

Elia

, Marchese

, Montanino

, et al. Hydrohysteretic phenomena of “extremely diluted solutions” induced by mechanical treatments: A calorimetric and conductometric study at 25°C. J Solution Chem, 2005; 34:947–960.

81.

Elia

, Marchettini

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. The role of ethanol in extremely diluted solutions. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2014; 116:477–483.

82.

Elia

, Marrari

, Napoli

. Aqueous nanostructures in water induced by electromagnetic fields emitted by EDS: A conductometric study of fullerene and carbon nanotube EDS. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2012; 107:843–851.

83.

Elia

, Napoli

. Dissipative structures in extremely diluted solutions of homeopathic medicines: A molecular model based on physico-chemical and gravimetric evidences. Int J Des Nat Ecodyn, 2010; 5:39–48.

84.

Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. On the stability of extremely diluted aqueous solutions at high ionic strength—a calorimetric study at 298 K. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2008; 92:643–648.

85.

Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. A molecular model of interaction between extremely diluted solutions and NaOH solutions used as titrant. Conductometric and pHmetric titrations. J Mol Liquids, 2009; 148:45–50.

86.

Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. Thermodynamic parameters for the binding process of the OH-ion with the dissipative structures. Calorimetric and conductometric titrations. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2010; 102:1111–1118.

87.

Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

. On the stability of extremely diluted solutions to temperature. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2013; 113:963–970.

88.

Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

, et al. New physico-chemical properties of extremely dilute solutions. A conductivity study at 25°C in relation to ageing. J Solution Chem, 2008; 37:85–96.

89.

Elia

, Napoli

, Niccoli

, et al. New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solution—a calorimetric and conductivity study at 25°C. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2004; 78:331–342.

90.

Elia

, Niccoli

. Thermodynamics of extremely diluted aqueous solutions. Ann N Y Acad Sci, 1999; 827:241–248.

91.

Elia

, Niccoli

. New physico-chemical properties of water induced by mechanical treatments. A calorimetric study at 25°C. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2000; 61:527–537.

92.

Elia

, Niccoli

. New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions. J Therm Anal Calorim, 2004; 75:815–836.

93.

Frisse

. Adsorptionsuntersuchung und Neutronenaktivierungsanalyse homöopathischer Dilutionen. Bonn, Germany: Hohe Mathematisch-Naturwissenschaftliche Fakultät, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität;. 1981.

94.

Gangar

. Management and control of genetic processes in cotton plants through homoeopathy. Ind J Res Hom, 2007; 1:1–5.

95.

Gautam

, Tewari

, Roper

, Mishra

. Spectrophotometric analysis of potentisation of Euphrasia officinalis . Hahnemann Gleanings, 1977; 44:1–5.

96.

Gay

. Présence d'un facteur physique dans les dilutions homéopathiques. Lyon, France: Editions des Laboratoires P.H.R., 1951.

97.

Gebhardt

. FTIR-spektroskopische Untersuchungen an wässrigen und ethanolischen homöopathischen Arzneimitteln. Leipzig, Germany: Fakultät für Biowissenschaften, Pharmazie und Psychologie, 2002.

98.

Gorlowska

, Gorlowska

, Skibinski

, Komsta

. Chemometrics meets homeopathy—an exploratory analysis of infrared spectra of homeopathic granules. J Pharmaceut Biomed Anal, 2015; 115:36–38.

99.

Güldenstern

. Fluoreszenzmessungen des Präparates Aesculus Cortex und des Wirkstoffes Aesculinum. Der Merkurstab, 2001; 54:307–312.

100.

Hadley

. An experiment showing an increase with dilution in a physical parameter. Br Hom J, 1981; 70:129–135.

101.

Hartmann

, Farenkopf

. Über eine neue Möglichkeit, Hochpotenzen physikalisch-meßtechnisch zu erfassen. AHZ, 1952; 197:127–129.

102.

Hartmann

, Götz

, Langer

. Kann ein homöopathisches Präparat elektrophysikalisch meßbare Veränderungen an destilliertem Wasser erzielen?. EHK, 1992; 41:559–564.

103.

Heintz

. Physikalische Wirkungen hochverdünnter potenzierter Substanzen. Die Naturwissenschaften, 1941; 48:713–725.

104.

Heintz

. Bemerkungen zu meinem Artikel: Physikalische Wirkungen hochverdünnter, potenzierter Substanzen. Naturwiss, 1942; 30:642.

105.

Heintz

. Eine neuartige Anordnung zum Messen physikalisch-chemischer Wirkungen von Potenzen: Das D-Element. Elemente der Naturwissenschaft, 1971; 15:33–44.

106.

Heintz

. [New experiences of the mode of action of serial dilutions]. Ann Hom Franc, 1971; 13:515–530 (Article in French).

107.

Heintz

. [Measurement of the action of serial dilutions by means of electric elements]. Ann Hom Franc, 1972; 14:275–284 (Article in French).

108.

Holandino

, Harduim

, da Veiga

, et al. Modeling physical-chemical properties of high dilutions. An electrical conductivity study. Int J High Dilution Res, 2008; 7:165–173.

109.

Holandino

, Leal

, de Olivereira Barcellos

, et al. Chapter 3: Mechanical versus handmade succussions, a physical chemistry comparison. In: Bonamin

, ed. Signals and Images. Contributions and Contradictions About High Dilution Research. New York: Springer, 2008:37–48.

110.

Hsu

Y-C

, Liang

Y-S

, Cheng

P-Y

. A study of water crystal growing based on dilution and succussion theory of homeopathy. In: Wei

, ed. Machine Design and Manufacturing Engineering III, 2014:61–64.

111.

Hüttenrauch

, Fricke

. Molekulargalenische Bewertung der konventionellen Feststoffverarbeitung in der Homöopathie. Pharmazie, 1985; 40:129–130.

112.

Ives

. Relative permittivity as a measure of homoeopathic potency effect, negative results on repeating previous work. Midlands Hom Res Group Commun, 1980; 3:15–16.

113.

Jerman

, Berden

, Škarja

. Instrumental measurements of different homeopathic dilutions of potassium iodide in water. Acupunct Electrother Res, 1999; 24:29–44.

114.

Jussal

. A brief report from the research directorate. Homoeopathician, 1978; 2:78–82.

115.

Jussal

, Meera

, Dua

, Mishra

. Physical effects on the suspending mediums by compounds in asymptomically infinite dilutions. Hahnemann Glean, 1982; 94:114–120.

116.

Jussal

, Mishra

, Dua

. Dielectric dispersion of weak alkoholic solutions of some drugs at high frequencies using time domain spectroscopy. Hahnemann Glean, 1983; 50:358–366.

117.

Kar

, Bandyopadhyay

, Chakraborty

, et al. Derivation of an empirical relation between the size of the nanoparticle and the potency of homeopathic medicines. Int J High Dilution Res, 2015; 14:2–7.

118.

Khan

. Comparison between preparation of aconite napellus potencies made by two different homeopathic chemists by means of spectroscopic method. Proceedings of the International Homeopathic Medical Organization (OMHI) Congress. Mexico, 1980.

119.

Khan

, Mriphh

MCS

, Akber

. Determination of plumbum in the low and high homoeopathic potencies by means of eel atomic absorption spectrophotometer. In: LMHI, ed. 32nd International Homeopathic Medical Congress of the International Homoeopathic Medical League, New Delhi, India, October 5–11, 1977:126–129.

120.

Khan

, Saify

. Estimation of low and higher homoeopathic potencies by means of biochemical and pharmacological methods, second research report. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1975; 68:97–104.

121.

Kirn. Experimentelle Versuche über die physikalischen Eigenschaften homöopathischer Potenzen. AHZ, 1911; 159:15–25.

122.

Klein

, Sandig

, Baumgartner

, Wolf

. Differences in median ultraviolet light transmissions of serial homeopathic dilutions of copper sulfate, Hypericum perforatum, and sulfur. Evid Based Complement Altern Med, 2013;Article ID: 370609, 2013.

123.

Klein

, Wolf

. Investigating homeopathic verum and placebo globules with UV spectroscopy. Forsch Komplementarmed, 2013; 20:295–297.

124.

Knapp

. Die Sichtbarmachung von Energiemustern bei homöopathischen Potenzen. In: Weingärtner

, ed. Forschung zum Nachweis von Wirkung und Wirksamkeit homöopathischer Arzneimittel. Heidelberg, Germany: Haug, 1984:62–102.

125.

Knapp

. Die bioenergetische Strahlung und homöopathische Medikamente. Erfahrungsheilkunde, 1985; 2:74–82.

126.

Knauer

. Nachweis der Wirkung potenzierter Lösungen auf chemisch-physikalischem Wege. Acta Hom, 1969; 13:157–164.

127.

Knauer

. Beiträge zur Potenzforschung Pforzheim, 1970.

128.

Knauer

. Beiträge zur Potenzforschung, Versuche zur Potenzierung nach der Ein- und Mehrgefäßmethode; Über die Haltbarkeit potenzierter Lösungen. Acta Hom, 1971; 15:143–148.

129.

Kolisko

. Physiologischer und physikalischer Nachweis der Wirksamkeit kleinster Entitäten. Stuttgart, Germany: Der Kommende Tag AG, 1923.

130.

Kolisko

. Physiologischer und physikalischer Nachweis der Wirksamkeit kleinster Entitäten (1923–1959). Stuttgart, Germany: Arbeitsgemeinschaft anthroposophischer Ärzte, 1959.

131.

Kracmar

. Biophysik der homöopathischen Arzneiwirkung. AHZ, 1966; 211:481–500.

132.

Kumar

, Jussal

. A hypothesis on the nature of homoeopathic potencies. Br Hom J, 1979; 68:197–204.

133.

Lasne

. Proprietés des solutions “homéopathiques”, Mesure de la relaxation magnétiques T2. Lyon, France: Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, U.E.R. Faculté de Pharmacie, 1986.

134.

Lasne

, Duplan

, Fenet

, Guerin

. Contribution à l'approche scientifique de la doctrine homéopathique. De Natura Rerum, 1989; 3:38–43.

135.

Lasne

, Duplan

, Mallet

. Mise en évidence de signaux physiques émanant de solutions dilutees-dynamisées ou “homéopathiques”. Bull du M.TS (Medical Telematic System). 2. 1985 Lacenas, France:Centre Européen d'Informatique et d'Automation (CEIA). 2ème bulletin du MTS (Medical Telematic System).

136.

Lechuga

VRL

, Martinez

RER

, Lopez

LOM

, Barajas

NYG

. Résultats des recherches de l'étude fluorométrique des médicaments homéopathiques. Homéopathie Francaise, 1991; 79:22–25.

137.

Leeser

, Janner

. Untersuchungen über die Potenzierung in der Homöopathie mit Hilfe von radioaktivem Phosphor. Arch Hom, 1953; 1:9–17.

138.

Lefebvre

, Aubin

, Ferret-Bouin

, Vrignaud

. Etude de dilutions homéopathiques hahnémanniennes à l'aide du glucose marqué au carbone 14. Ann Hom Franc, 1978; 20:227–235.

139.

Lenger

. Homeopathic potencies identified by a new magnetic resonance method: Homeopathy—an energetic medicine. Subtle Energ Energ Med, 2004; 15:225–243.

140.

Lenger

, Bajpai

, Drexel

. Delayed luminescence of high homeopathic potencies on sugar globuli. Homeopathy, 2008; 97:134–140.

141.

Lenger

, Bajpai

, Spielmann

. Identification of unknown homeopathic remedies by delayed luminescence. Cell Biochem Biophys, 2014; 68:321–334.

142.

Lobyshev

. Water is a sensor to weak forces including electromagnetic fields of low intensity. Electromagn Biol Med, 2005; 24:449–461.

143.

Lobyshev

, Tomkevich

, Petrushanko

. Experimental study of potentiated aqueous solutions. Biophysics, 2005; 50:416–420.

144.

Lobyshev

, Tomkevitch

. Luminescence study of homeopathic remedies. In: Priezzhev

, Cote

(eds). Optical Diagnostics and Sensing of Biological Fluids and Glucose and Cholesterol Monitoring, Proceedings of the SPIE, Vol 4263. Russia: MAIK Navka/Interperiodica, 2001, pp 1605–7422.

145.

Ludwig

. Physikalische Grundlagenforschung in Bezug auf Informationsspeicherung in lebenden Systemen und homöopathischen Medikamenten, Strukturierung von Wasser und Alkohol. EHK, 1991; 40:293–295.

146.

Ludwig

. Spektroskopische Messungen an Resonanzhomöopathika. EHK, 1998; 47:335–338.

147.

Ludwig

. Wissenschaftliche Grundlagen zur Wirkung homöopathischer Mittel. In: Würthle

, ed. Homöopathie für Garten- und Zimmerpflanzen. München, Germany: BLV Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, 2002:105–122.

148.

Luu-d-Vinh

. Les dilutions homéopathiques, Contrôle et étude par spectrographie Raman-laser. Montpellier, France: Université de Montpellier, Faculté de Pharmacie et Institut Européen des Sciences Pharmaceutiques Industrielles, 1974.

149.

Luu-d-Vinh

. Etude des dilutions homéopathique par effet Raman-Laser. Ann Homeopath Franc, 1975; 17:433–444.

150.

Maag

. Untersuchung der Potenzen von Silbernitrat D1–D12 und D1–D33. Dt Z Hom, 1932; 49:277–285.

151.

Maag

. Untersuchungen über die Schüttelzeiten von Metallpotenzen. Dt Z Hom, 1933; 49:281–286.

152.

Maag

. Zusammenhang von Potenzreihen mit den Vorgängen am Sternenhimmel, Untersuchung von Silbernitrat D1 bis D33 zu den Zeiten der 4 Mondphasen. ZKH, 1965; 9:166–173.

153.

Mahata

. Dielectric dispersion studies of some potentised homeopathic medicines reveal structured vehicle. Homeopathy, 2013; 102:262–267.

154.

Maier

. Spektroskopische Untersuchungen an potenzierten Proben des Präparates Aesculus Cortex. Der Merkurstab, 2001; 54:303–306.

155.

Maity

, Ghosh

, Mahata

. Effect of dielectric dispersion on potentised homeopathic medicines. Homeopathy, 2010; 99:99–103.

156.

Marschner

. Bioelektronische Studien zum Verständnis des Wirkungsmechanismus homöopathischer Potenzen. Erfahrungsheilkunde, 1985; 2:83–91.

157.

Marschollek

, Nelle

, Wolf

, et al. Effects of exposure to physical factors on homeopathic preparations as determined by ultraviolet light spectroscopy. ScientificWorldJournal, 2010; 10:49–61.

158.

Mayrhofer

. Mikroskopische Untersuchungen der homöop. Metallpräparate, Durch Zeichnungen erläutert. Hygea, 1842; 16:17–35.

159.

Mayrhofer

. Mikroskopische Untersuchungen der homöopathischen Metallpräparate, (Schluss vom vor. Hefte). Hygea, 1842; 16:97–106.

160.

Mendez

. Changes in physico-chemical parameters of homeopathic remedies ferrum metallicum CH6 and ferrum metallicum CH30 after exposure to high frequency electromagnetic radiation of low intensity. Radiats Biol Radioekol, 2005; 45:212–213 (Article in Russian).

161.

Milgrom

, King

, Lee

, Pinkus

. On the investigation of homeopathic potencies using low resolution NMR T2 relaxation times: An experimental and critical survey of the work of Roland Conte et al. Br Homeopath J, 2001; 90:5–13.

162.

Morozov

. Avogadro's number and homeopathy. Hom Links, 2003; 16:97–100.

163.

Munshi

. Identification of homoeopathic inorganic drugs by T.L.C. Hahnemann Glean, 1983; 50:450–451.

164.

Nain

, Droliya

, Manchanda

, et al. Physicochemical studies of extremely diluted solutions (homoeopathic formulations) of sulphur in ethanol by using volumetric, acoustic, viscometric and refractive index measurements at different temperatures. J Mol Liquids, 2015; 211:1082–1094.

165.

Pillai

, Kumar

, Sharma

, Bhasin

. LC-MS based workflows for qualitative and quantitative analysis for homeopathic preparation of Hydrastis canadensis . Chromatographia, 2014; 77:119–131.

166.

Rajendran

. An evaluation of Avogadro's number in the light of HRTEM and EDS studies of high dilutions of Ferrum metallicum 6, 30, 200, 1 M, 10 M and 50Mc. Int J High Dilution Res, 2015; 14:3–9.

167.

de Miranda

. Water and High Dilutions Phenomenology: Physical Characterization. In: Bonamin

(eds). Signals and Images. Dordrecht: Springer, 2008 Presented at 20th Symposium of GIRI, São Paolo, 2006.

168.

Rao

, Roy

, Bell

. Characterization of the structure of ultra dilute sols with remarkable biological properties. Mater Lett, 2008; 62:1487–1490.

169.

Rao

, Roy

, Bell

, Hoover

. The defining role of structure (including epitaxy) in the plausibility of homeopathy. Homeopathy, 2007; 96:175–182.

170.

Resch

, Gutmann

, Schauer

. “The shaking effect” on the conductivities of liquids. J Ind Chem Soc, 1982; 59:130–132.

171.

Rey

. Thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride. Phys A, 2003; 323:67–74.

172.

Rey

. Can low-temperature thermoluminescence cast light on the nature of ultra-high dilutions?. Homeopathy, 2007; 96:170–174.

173.

Roder

, Frisse

. On the stability of homeopathic dilutions in glass and plastic containers. Pharmazie, 1981; 36:615–619 (Article in German).

174.

Röder

, Pütz

, Frisse

. Bestimmung von Au, Fe, Zn und Hg in homöopathischen Dilutionen durch zerstörungsfreie Neutronenaktivierungsanalyse. Fresenius Zeitschrift Anal Chem, 1981; 307:120–126.

175.

Sacks

. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of homeopathic remedies. J Holist Med, 1983; 5:172–177.

176.

Sarkar

, Konar

, Sukul

, et al. Free water molecules and hydrogen bonding form the basis of variation in homeopathic potencies as revealed by vibrational spectroscopy. Int J High Dilution Res, 2015; 14:8–15.

177.

Schilling

. Versuche zum Nachweis der physikalischen Kräfte der homöopathischen Arzneiform. In: LHI, ed. X. Kongress der Liga Homoeopathica Internationalis, Budapest. Budapest, Hungary; 1935:374–385.

178.

Sharma

, Purkait

. Identification of medicinally active ingredient in ultradiluted Digitalis purpurea: Fluorescence spectroscopic and cyclic-voltammetric study. J Anal Methods Chem, 2012; 2012:109058.

179.

Silvio

, Arnaldo

. Ultrasonic study of homoeopathic solutions. Br Hom J, 1990; 79:212–216.

180.

Smith

Jr ., Boericke

. Modern instrumentation for the evaluation of homeopathic drug structure. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1966; 59:263–280.

181.

Smith

, Boericke

. Continued research with modern instrumentation for the evaluation of homeopathic drug structure. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1967; 60:259–272.

182.

Smith

, Boericke

. Changes caused by succussion on N.M.R. patterns and bioassay of bradykinin triacetate (BKTA) succussions and dilutions. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1968; 61:197–212.

183.

Stephenson

, Brucato

. The effect of succussed macro- and micro-dilutions of sodium thiosulfate (Na₂S₂O₃) on supersaturated solutions of sodium thiosulfate. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1960; 53:94–95.

184.

Sukul

, Sarkar

, Sinhababu

, Sukul

. Altered solution structure of alcoholic medium of potentized Nux vomica underlies its antialcoholic effect. Br Homeopath J, 2000; 89:73–77.

185.

Sukul

, Datta

, Sinhababu

. Conformational changes of bovine serum albumin in 4 M urea and ultra high dilutions of different drugs. Sci Cult, 2007; 73:173–175.

186.

Sukul

, De

, Dutta

, et al. Nux vomica 30 prepared with and without succussion shows antialcoholic effect on toads and distinctive molecular association. Br Homeopath J, 2001; 90:79–85.

187.

Sukul

, Ghosh

, Sinha Babu

, Sukul

. Strychnos nux-vomica extract and its ultra-high dilution reduce voluntary ethanol intake in rats. J Altern Complement Med, 2001; 7:187–193.

188.

Sukul

, Ghosh

, Sukul

, Sinhababu

. Variation in fourier transform infrared spectra of some homeopathic potencies and their diluent media. J Altern Complement Med, 2005; 11:807–812.

189.

Sukul

, Sinhababu

, Datta

, et al. Nematotoxic effect of Acacia auriculiformis and Artemisia nilagerica against root-knot nematodes. Allelopathy J, 2001; 8:65–72.

190.

Süss

. Struktur und Dynamik von homöopathischen Hochpotenzen–Resonanz-/Dämpfungs-/Entdämpfungs-Messungen (REDEM). In: Süss

, ed. Homöopathische Arzneimittel–wissenschaftliche Grundlagen für die Herstellung, Qualität und Anwendung. Stuttgart, Germany: Deutscher Apotheker Verlag; 2004:49–63.

191.

Taufiq Khan

. Physical aspects related to the problems in potentised drugs. In: Seitschek

, ed. XXVIII. Internationaler Kongress für homöopathische Medizin. Vol Wien, May 28–June 2, 1973: Österreichische Gesellschaft für Homöopathische Medizin; 1973:473–479.

192.

Tiezzi

, Catalucci

, Marchettini

. The supramolecular structure of water: NMR studies. Int J Des Nat Ecodyn, 2010; 5:10–20.

193.

Upadhyay

, Nayak

. Homeopathy emerging as nanomedicine. Int J High Dilution Res, 2011; 10:299–310.

194.

van Wijk

, Bosman

, van Wijk

EPA

. Thermoluminescence in ultra-high dilution research. J Altern Complement Med, 2006; 12:437–443.

195.

Veith

. Dynamik bewegter Flüssigkeiten. BM, 1976; 5:123–125.

196.

Walach

, van Asseldonk

, Bourkas

, et al. Electric measurement of ultra-high dilutions–a blinded controlled experiment. Br Homoeopath J, 1998; 87:3–12.

197.

Weingärtner

. Homöopathie verstehen. Versuch eines naturwissenschaftlichen Zuganges. Therapeutikon, 1988; 5(Mai):310–320.

198.

Weingärtner

. NMR-Spektren von Sulfur-Potenzen. Therapeutikon, 1989; 3:438–442.

199.

Weingärtner

. NMR-features that relate to homoeopathic sulphur-potencies. Berlin J Res Homeopath, 1990; 1:61–68.

200.

Weingärtner

. Homöopathische Potenzen. Wunsch und Wirklichkeit bei der Suche nach der therapeutisch wirksamen Komponente. Berlin, Germany: Springer Verlag, 1992.

201.

Witt

. Versuch der Messung einer nichtstofflichen Information. In: Albrecht

, Frühwald

, eds. Jahrbuch Karl und Veronica Carstens-Stiftung. Vol 2. Stuttgart, Germany: Hippokrates, 1995:153–165.

202.

Witt

. Physikalische Untersuchung homöopathischer Hochpotenzen. Essen, Germany: KVC Verlag, 2000.

203.

Witt

, Ludtke

, Weisshuhn

, Willich

. High homeopathic potencies are different from potentized solvent when investigated with the REDEM technology. Forsch Komplement, 2005; 12:6–13.

204.

Witt

, Ludtke

, Weisshuhn

TER

, et al. The role of trace elements in homeopathic preparations and the influence of container material, storage duration, and potentisation. Forsch Komplement, 2006; 13:15–21.

205.

Wolf

, Wolf

, Heusser

, et al. Homeopathic preparations of quartz, sulfur and copper sulfate assessed by UV-spectroscopy. Evid Based Complement Altern Med, 2011; 2011:Article ID 692798.

206.

Wurmser

, Loch

. Recherches expérimentales sur les dilutions homoeopathiques. In: LHI, ed. X. Kongress der Liga Homoeopathica Internationalis Budapest 1935. Budapest, Germany. 1935:359–373.

207.

Young

. Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of succussed solutions. J Am Inst Homeopath, 1975; 68:8–16.

208.

Zacharias

. Implications of contaminants to scientific research in homoeopathy. Br Homeopath J, 1995; 84:3–5.

209.

Zacharias

. Contaminants in commercial homoeopathic medicines. Br Homeopath J, 1995; 84:71–74.

210.

Albrecht

, van Wijk

, Dittloff

. A new database on basic research in homeopathy. Homeopathy, 2002; 91:162–165.

211.

Stock-Schröer

. Reporting experiments in homeopathic basic research (REHBaR). Homeopathy, 2015; 104:333–336.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.05 MB

Physicochemical Investigations of Homeopathic Preparations: A Systematic Review and Bibliometric Analysis—Part 1

Abstract

Objectives:

Methods:

Results:

Conclusions:

Introduction

Methods

Protocol and registration

Eligibility criteria

Information sources

Search

Manuscript Information Score

Data items

Results

Publication type and journals

Development over time

Reporting quality

Geographic distribution

Techniques

Discussion

Overview

Previous reviews and search strategy

Quality assessment

Geographic distribution

Conclusions

Footnotes

Acknowledgments

Author Disclosure Statement

References

Supplementary Material