Abstract
Undiagnosed cases of HIV infection in developed countries are estimated at 20–30% of individuals living with HIV. Web-based strategies may represent a new approach to easier, wider, and unrestricted access to early testing. The Abruzzo Region, Italy, developed a Web-based tool to recruit persons at high risk of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections (STIs). At the Website
Introduction
D
To increase HIV screening among high-risk groups, the Abruzzo Region (Central Italy) developed a Web-based tool, to the best of our knowledge the first in Italy with a region-wide deployment, aimed to recruit persons at high risk of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections (STIs). In this report, we present the preliminary results of the 15-month deployment of this strategy.
Methods
At the Website (
All blood samples were processed in the reference microbiology laboratory, the Virology Unit of Pescara General Hospital. Results are made available within 1 week after sampling. Blood samples are collected according to standard procedures. 15 HIV Abs assays were performed with LIAISON® XL murex HIV assay (Diasorin, Saluggia, Italy), HBsAg with LIAISON XL murex hepatitis B virus (HBV) assay (Diasorin), hepatitis B virus (HCV) Abs with LIAISON XL murex HCV Ab assay (Diasorin), and Treponema Pallidum (TP) antibodies with LIAISON Treponema Screen (Diasorin). HIV Abs positive results were confirmed by Western blot assays (Fujirebio Diagnostics, Pomezia, Italy); TP screening was confirmed by Treponema Pallidum Hemagglutination Assay (TPHA) (Biosystems, Barcellona, Spain).
The local Health and Ethics Administrative Board in Chieti-Pescara reviewed in detail the program plan, set up by the Infectious Diseases Staff in Pescara General Hospital, in collaboration with staff members in the other five participating Infectious Diseases Units. After completing the process of funding and administrative and ethical authorization, on February 1, 2014, the Web-based HIV Testing and Counseling program was made available for the whole regional population through the Website (
Results
Between February 1, 2014, and May 31, 2015, about 6000 users visited the Website; a few more than 5000 went through the “risk calculator” section and nearly 3500 booked their testing using the site. Among them, 3046 individuals presented for their testing: 1183 in Pescara, 513 in Chieti, 552 in Avezzano, 307 in Teramo, 272 in Vasto, and 219 in L'Aquila. Among the 3046 blood samples collected, we found 28 (0.92%) positive for HIV. All HIV-positive tests were confirmed by Western blot assays; none of the positive subjects reported a previous diagnosis of HIV. Two of them, however, failed to collect the results of testing. The remaining 26 (92.8%) were successfully linked to care and all of them were put on antiretrovirals by attending physicians at the sites of diagnosis, in accordance with current guidelines, as all of them had indications to antiretroviral treatment (Table 1). Among HIV infections, we found two patients coinfected with HCV, HBV, and syphilis; two coinfected with HCV; and one coinfected with HBV. Thanks to the special funding of the present program, the same blood samples collected were tested for HCV, HBV, and syphilis. We, therefore, found 58 (1.90%) tests positive for HCV, 56 (1.84%) for HBsAg, and 90 (2.95%) for TP antibodies. All patients were suggested immediate linkage to care; we do not have follow-up data, however, for most of them at present. Clinical and demographic characteristics, as well as CD4 T cell counts of newly diagnosed HIV patients, are reported in Table 1. Risk factors for HIV transmission were homosexual intercourse in 12 (46.0%), heterosexual intercourse in 11 (42.0%), and intravenous drug addiction in 3 (12.0%) cases. Mean CD4 T cell counts were 416 ± 206 cell/mm3, nine (37.5%) patients had CD4 T cell counts ≤350 cell/mm3, and four had (16.7%) ≤200 cell/mm3. Among these, two patients had preclinical opportunistic infections at the time of their first visit and were diagnosed as AIDS cases. Median viral load was 21,025 cp/mL (interquartile range 3644–123,300), and six (21.4%) patients had a viral load ≥100,000 cp/mL. As of CDC stage at time of diagnosis, 60.7% were in CDC class A, 10.7% in B, and 7.1% in C. Positive results for the four screened infections were evenly distributed across the study period and no suggestion of clustering in time and space emerged.
SD, standard deviation; IDU, injection drug user.
Discussion
An overall 7% of unaware STIs, including 0.92% of HIV infections, were found among the 3046 participating people. The rate of tests positive for HIV among recruited persons was definitely higher than 2/1000, the threshold deemed cost-effective when offering routine HIV testing. 16,17 Indeed, here we report on a much higher proportion of positive HIV tests, very close to the yields of screening programs deployed for high-prevalence areas. 18 The remarkably high proportion of new HIV cases (8.8/1000 tests) sounds particularly high when compared with most recent programs in Italy and Europe, including those based on mobile testing for MSM, injection drug user (IDU), or female sex workers. 19 –24 Further, although our testing technology requested patients to come back to collect results, the proportion of people linked to care was very high (>90%). 18,22
As in many other developed countries, HIV infection is not highly prevalent in our area, and systematic screening of the general population would not be cost-effective. 18,22 Similarly, HIV testing performed in rehabilitation centers for drug addiction and STI clinics detected a low proportion of asymptomatic diagnoses in recent years, both in our country and in many other developed areas; 18,22,25 further, other screening programs at public health European institutions fell below target, likely because many undiagnosed asymptomatic HIV infected persons may have limited contact with healthcare facilities. 26,27 Screening programs targeted to high-risk groups are the most suitable, but in many international settings they proved rather inefficacious because of several limitations for the access of at-risk subjects, including low perception of risk and reluctance to participate because of fears about confidentiality. 18,19,28,29 To the best of our knowledge, our report describes the first Web-based screening program performed in Italy, at least with such a large regional design and direct Web-based booking of testing. Since people all around Europe and the United States are increasingly searching for health information on the Internet, 30 this may be an innovative way to propose HIV and, in general, STI testing. So far, several health projects were implemented around the word for Internet-based HIV testing of at-risk individuals. 24,31 –34 Internet-based HIV testing programs differ in eHealth (using information and communication technologies for health) mode of recruitment, counseling, and testing. Some programs implement Websites, others interactive Web pages, e-mail invitations, banners, Web chats, or Web 2.0, allowing users to interact and collaborate through social media platforms as cocreators of user-generated content. 24,31,32,35,36 Web-based platforms in the United States, 33 EU, 24 and China 31 were mainly directed toward MSM, and aimed to increasing HIV testing, linkage to care, and adherence to antiretrovirals. Some included access to HIV risk self-assessment systems. 31 Ruutel et al., for instance, implemented a Facebook page to invite MSM individuals to HIV, Hepatitis, and other STI testing. They made available a questionnaire with 144 sociodemographic items and offered participants to visit laboratories for testing procedures. 24 None of these platforms, however, provided the users with the possibility of choosing site of testing, by direct Web-based booking. The program delivered by Cheng et al. 31 in China, at variance, provided similar Internet-based STI/HIV testing tools as ours. It was targeted to MSMs, using a scenario-based application, simulating real-life HIV risk scenarios and an online risk self-assessments system. Clients were linked to an online appointment system for HIV testing in one of the three facilities in the area. 31 Our platform is open to all at-risk populations able to browse the Web, linking the visitor to the direct booking of test, and proved effective in collecting HIV-infected subjects from all at-risk groups.
We found a surprisingly high overall STI rate of about 7%. Prevalence of syphilis in Italy is high, with 582 yearly cases recently reported per 100,000 inhabitants. 1 Data on screening for syphilis are scanty in developed countries; when syphilis was tested in venues frequented by MSM, 1–2% of new cases were found. 37,38 In our area, no data were published on the prevalence of syphilis so far; so, our program provided for the first time direct evidence that many asymptomatic persons, unaware of syphilis, are present among those engaging in behaviors at risk for HIV transmission. 39 Similarly, we found a high prevalence of both HBsAg antigen and HCV-Ab-positive subjects. Evidence from European programs of screening for HCV revealed rates of prevalence ranging between 0.3% and 2.0%. 40,41 A recent epidemiological survey from Abruzzo, however, reported higher prevalence of HCV antibodies, peaking to >5% in males aged 30–49 years and more than 70 years, in a large sample of patients undergoing opt-out presurgical screening, as well as a peak prevalence of 1.7% for HBsAg. 42 Our program, therefore, provided results in line with these recent estimates. 42 Overall, our data suggest that whenever a screening program for HIV is run, additional screenings for other STIs are likely to be cost-effective.
This study has several relevant limitations. First, the Web system failed to record HIV risk calculator results until recently, so we cannot know, at present, the proportion of people at high risk for HIV among those passing the self-evaluation step. Moreover, we have no data to perform any comparison between site users who did and those who did not book a visit. On the same line, we lack a control group including people attending routine testing in the same area of Abruzzo in the same time span, that is people accessing laboratory testing in parallel to our Web-based recruitment system; similarly, we had no way, until now, to resume data on new parallel diagnoses of HCV, HBV, and syphilis in our region.
In conclusion, our Web-based recruitment for free testing for HIV and other STIs helped to diagnose more than 7% of either HIV, HBV, HCV, or syphilis-unaware subjects from several at-risk groups. Newly diagnosed HIV cases were linked to care in a very high proportion. The long-term cost-effectiveness of this Web-based screening program may definitely be worth further and larger scale evaluation.
Footnotes
Authors Contributions
E.P., G.P., C.D., V.C., A.G., D.D.G., M.P.S., J.V., and M.P. conceived and designed the program. P.D.S., A.S., P.F., T.U., F.S., and L.P. contributed to the development of the project. E.P., G.P., and E.R. analyzed the data. E.P., G.P., and E.R. wrote the article draft.
Acknowledgments
We are greatly indebted to all physicians and nurses involved in testing and counseling activities in the sites of the six Infectious Disease Units of the Abruzzo Region. We are also indebted to the staff of the “Fondazione Camillo de Lellis per l'Innovazione e la Ricerca in Medicina” for the invaluable support to the program and for contributing to inform the local population on this innovative way of testing, contacting local newspapers, radios, and televisions for advertising programs and campaigns, and distributing leaflets to all pharmacies in the area, high schools, body-building centers, and some of the local industrial plants. P.D.S. was funded by an educational grant from the “Fondazione Camillo de Lellis per l'Innovazione e la Ricerca in Medicina” Pescara, Italy. Written informed consent was obtained from each patients for publication of data.
Author Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interest exist.
