Abstract
The Tanpopo mission has two objectives: (1) test the panspermia hypothesis and (2) test whether organic compounds may have been transferred to Earth before the origin of life. We developed an exposure panel (EP) designed to expose microbes and organic compounds to the space environment and a capture panel designed to capture high-velocity particles on the International Space Station (ISS) using aerogel contained in an aluminum container. The panels returned after 1 year of exposure at the Exposure Facility of the Japan Experimental Module, ISS. In this communication, we report the measurements of temperature, radiation dosimeter and vacuum ultraviolet dosimeter in the EP, and survival data of Deinococcus aetherius. The environmental data are consistent with survival data of microbes and organic compounds, which will be presented elsewhere in detail.
1. Introduction
T
The Tanpopo mission consists of six subthemes as follows: capture of microbes in space (subtheme 1), exposure of microbes in space (subtheme 2), analysis of organic compounds in interplanetary dust (subtheme 3), exposure of organic compounds in space (subtheme 4), measurement of space debris at the ISS orbit (subtheme 5), and evaluation of ultralow-density aerogel developed for the Tanpopo mission (subtheme 6). The panspermia hypothesis will be addressed in subthemes (1) and (2). The possible space origin of organic compounds before the origin of terrestrial life will be addressed in subthemes (3) and (4). Ultralow-density silica aerogel specifically designed for the Tanpopo mission (Tabata et al., 2015) will be evaluated in subtheme (6).
Silica aerogel comprises dried amorphous porous SiO2, and this low-density aerogel can reduce the damage caused upon impact. The function of aerogel will be analyzed by evaluating the performance of aerogel in subthemes (1), (3), and (5). The amount of space debris smaller than 1 mm in diameter in low Earth orbit (LEO) has increased (Higashide et al., 2012). To obtain the latest data on the distribution of space debris at LEO, we will capture and count the number of metal particles in the aerogel in subtheme (5). Because survival of microbes (subtheme 2) and organic compounds (subtheme 4) depends on environmental factors, we have analyzed and report here the measurements of temperature, the radiation dosimeter, and the vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) dosimeter in the exposure panel (EP).
2. Tanpopo Mission Apparatus
We developed two types of apparatus for the Tanpopo mission: capture panels (CPs) with aerogel to capture microparticles (Supplementary Fig. S1; Supplementary Data are available online at

The exposure panel for the Tanpopo mission. The exposure panel (100 × 100 × 20 mm) consists of 20 exposure units (25 × 20 × 11.5 mm). Each exposure unit with a window in the front contains either a bacterial (A–C) or organic sample (D, E) or an alanine VUV dosimeter (F, G). The unit without a window contains radio dosimeters (H). VUV, vacuum ultraviolet.
3. Tanpopo Mission Timeline
Three EPs and 36 CPs were launched by the space carrier Space-X CRS-6 in April 2015 (Supplementary Fig. S2). The 3 EPs and 12 CPs were placed on the Exposed Experiment Handrail Attachment Mechanism (ExHAM) in the ISS for the first year of operation (Kawaguchi et al., 2016). The ExHAM was exposed in the depressurized air lock for about 2 weeks. On May 26, 2015, the ExHAM with panels was placed on the EF of JEM-ISS through the air lock of JEM-ISS using robotic arms.
On June 13, 2016, after about 1 year of exposure, the ExHAM was transferred to a pressurized area through the air lock. The first set of CPs was removed from the ExHAM, stored in the pressurized area of the ISS, and a new set of CPs was attached to the ExHAM for the next exposure operation. One of the three EPs used for the first-year exposure experiment was removed from the ExHAM to be returned to the ground, while the other two were left on the ExHAM for the next two exposure operations. The retrieved EP and CPs were returned to the ground in the space capsule. In October 2016, the EP was separated into exposure units, each harboring either microbe or organic compounds, and was handed over to the scientist in charge of the respective microbe or organic compound. Some units were dedicated to UV or radiation dose measurement. CPs were initially inspected for high-velocity impact, and these data will be published elsewhere.
4. Mechanical Space Thermometer
In the Tanpopo mission, the maximum temperature of the exposed panel needed to be below 80°C for microbe survival. We developed a mechanical thermometer that did not depend on electric power supply to monitor this requirement. Based on the thermal model calculation, the temperature range on the ISS orbit of the exposed panel was expected to be between −115.0°C and 32.8°C and therefore the range of the thermometer was designed to be −140°C to 80°C with 5°C accuracy.
The mechanical space thermometer (MST) consists of an indicator and a temperature sensor (Fig. 2). The indicator (110 × 70 × 8.5 mm) comprises an aluminum alloy body and a stainless steel panel with a U-shaped window to view the pointer. The temperature sensor is a heat-treated, bimetallic strip coil in a stainless steel pipe (6 mm diameter × 100 mm). The pointer is connected to a shaft that rotates with temperature change.

The mechanical space thermometer. The mechanical space thermometer consists of an indicator and a temperature sensor and its mass is 159 g.
The MST was attached to one of the Tanpopo EPs. The indicator was video-imaged by an extravehicular video camera attached to the Kibo-EF and controlled from the ground. The temperature was estimated from six metal EVA (extravehicular activity) labels attached to the display board and the pointer angle. Five measurements with different sun beta angles, including the angle where the maximum temperature was expected from the model calculation, high positive beta and low beta, were conducted in ∼1 month during the first-year operation. Each measurement took about 6 h to monitor four revolutions of the ISS around Earth.
Table 1 shows data obtained from five measurements of the first-year experiment; the maximum and minimum temperatures were 24°C ± 5°C and −21°C ± 5°C, respectively (Hashimoto et al., 2016). The high temperature resulting from the higher sun incident angle was expected in the orbit with the low beta angle. However, there are many objects interfering with sunlight, including other instruments, the ISS, solar panels, and heat radiation boards near and/or above the Tanpopo apparatus. Heat conduction, heat radiation, and shade from them affect the temperature of the Tanpopo apparatus depending on the solar beta angle. Since all their positions were not included in the model calculation, the maximum temperature and minimum temperature estimated from the measurement were different from those obtained in the model calculation. However, the maximal temperature was recorded during the orbit with low beta angle as expected from the high sunlight incident angle.
EF, Exposure Facility.
5. Radiation Dosimetry
5.1. Radiation dosimetry system
Aluminum oxide (Al2O3)-based optically stimulated luminescence dosimeters (OSLDs) (Yukihara and Mckeever, 2011) and silver-activated phosphate glass-based radiophotoluminescence dosimeters (RPLDs) (Miyamoto et al., 2011) were used for radiation dosimetry outside and inside the ISS. These dosimeters have previously been used for space radiation dosimetry (Sihver et al., 2016) in addition to conventional thermoluminescence dosimeters (NCRP, 2002; Berger et al., 2016). We have employed the two types of luminescence dosimeters (LDs) to cross-check the dose data. Space radiation dosimetry is usually carried out with a combination of LDs and plastic nuclear track detectors (PNTDs) (Doke et al., 1995). The latter are used to monitor charged particles with various linear energy transfer (LET) values. The typical PNTD, CR-39, is sensitive only to high LET particles ≥10 keV/μm in water, covering a high LET region, while LD is less sensitive to high LET particles, covering low LET particles <10 keV/μm consisting mainly of protons and He ions. However, the CR-39 PNTD is not active in vacuum conditions (Kodaira et al., 2009). Because the Tanpopo experiment is operated in vacuum conditions, only LDs have been employed for radiation dosimetry. According to previous space radiation data (Kodaira et al., 2014), the total absorbed dose obtained without using the CR-39 PNTD may have underestimated the dose by 5%, which corresponds to the dose of high LET particles.
The OSLD (7.2 mm diameter 0.5-mm thick; Nagase Landauer, Inc., Japan) was analyzed with a Microstar reader system (Landauer, Inc., IL), illuminating and stimulating with 525 nm LED, while the RPLD (8.5 × 8.5 × 1.5-mm thick; Chiyoda Technol Corporation, Japan) was analyzed by the standard processing protocol, including annealing and readout luminescence excited with 355 nm YAG laser, and quality controlled by Chiyoda Technol Corporation for personal dosimetry. These dosimeters were calibrated by means of a standard 137Cs γ-ray source and heavy ion beams from HIMAC (Heavy Ion Medical Accelerator in Chiba). Different materials were placed on top of the dosimeter to test the space radiation shield effect (Table 2).
The corresponding material thickness was achieved by placing the shield inside a holder made of 2 mm Al.
OSLDs, optically stimulated luminescence dosimeters; RPLDs, radiophotoluminescence dosimeters.
5.2. Radiation dosimetry results
The mean absorbed dose with the thinnest cover (0.55 g/cm2) was 272 mGy outside and 100 mGy inside the Kibo module for the duration of the flight (Table 2). The radiation dose outside was about three times higher than the dose inside because of the well-shielded environment inside the Kibo module. As illustrated in Fig. 1, samples are shielded with a window made of SiO2 (0.53 g/cm2) or MgF2 (0.63 g/cm2). The dose follows the exponential function as shown in Supplementary Fig. S3A so that the actual dose received by samples could be estimated by fitting data with the exponential function. The mean dose (D
r [mGy]) of OSLD and RPLD as a function of material thickness (x [g/cm2]) is expressed as
Although the dose outside decreased from 0.55 to 2.95 g/cm2 following the exponential function, the dose remained almost constant inside (Supplementary Fig. S5A). This indicates that low-energy protons with energies less than about 50 MeV trapped in the South Atlantic Anomaly would be attenuated in materials with 3 g/cm2. The measured dose reduction outside the Kibo module strongly supports previous results (Supplementary Fig. S3B).
6. Alanine VUV Dosimeter
Since VUV radiation is the major source of chemical and biological effects at LEO, the VUV dose was estimated. In EXPOSE-E (Rabbow et al., 2009) and EXPOSE-R (Rabbow et al., 2015) experiments, the VUV dose was monitored by electronic UV sensors, and data were obtained every 10 s and transmitted to the ground by telemetry (Rabbow et al., 2009, 2015). Because of partial loss of data (Rabbow et al., 2009, 2015), the total UV flux was estimated from interpolation of transmitted data (Rabbow et al., 2009). We developed an integrating type of VUV sensor using an alanine film coated on a quartz window in the Tanpopo experiment.
The alanine film absorbs VUV wavelengths shorter than 190 nm and is dissociated by the absorbed VUV light (Izumi and Nakagawa, 2011). The dissociation quantum efficiency of the alanine film with a 172-nm photon was determined to be 0.1 using a 172-nm Xe2* excimer lamp (Izumi and Nakagawa, 2011).
Schematic diagrams of alanine dosimeters are shown in Supplementary Fig. S4. Alanine films with a diameter of 14 mm were applied to the windows using a vacuum evaporation technique. Windows were set on a rotating disk during the evaporation procedure to obtain an even thickness of alanine. Film thickness was 584 ± 8 nm as measured by the infrared absorption spectrum with an FT-IR spectrometer (Spectrum One; PerkinElmer Japan, Tokyo) and chromatography analysis with an HPLC system (SPD-10AVP; Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan). A standard curve was obtained with a 172-nm Xe2* excimer lamp (SUS03; Ushio, Tokyo, Japan), and irradiation was carried out in a vacuum chamber (about 10−3 Pa) in a laboratory. Flux of 172-nm photons was determined by a calibrated photodiode (S1227-1010BQ; Hamamatsu Photonics, Hamamatsu) to be about 1016 photons/m2 (corresponding to 115 W/m2).
Using a quartz window with 160-nm cutoff wavelength, we can limit the wavelength region of the alanine dosimeter to be at 160 < λ < 190 nm. We estimated the solar radiation at 160 < λ < 190 nm from the standard curve of the 172-nm dissociation experiment in the laboratory.
Irradiation doses of returned dosimeters after about 1 year of exposure on the ISS orbit were studied. Deviation of the film thickness was between −2.5% and +2.5% along the x-axis and was less along the y-axis (Supplementary Fig. S5), which was similar to the dark control dosimeter, suggesting no detectable nonhomogeneous solar radiation distribution. Remaining alanine content was estimated, and radiation doses were determined from the standard curve to be 4.29 ± 0.08 kJ/m2 at 172 nm irradiation. The accumulated solar irradiation dose, D, at 160 < λ < 190 nm after a 382-day exposure on the ISS orbit was 7.09 ± 0.13 kJ/m2 based on the detection efficiency 0.605, while solar irradiance at the LEO was estimated from data reported by Lean (1991) and was 48.1 mW/m2 for 160 < λ < 190 nm for 382 days, corresponding to the accumulated solar irradiance D 0 1.59 MJ/m2.
Total dose D of the alanine dosimeter in the Tanpopo experiment can be
It is important to note that
7. Survival Analysis of Deinococcus aetherius
The D. aetherius strain ST0316 was cultured at 30°C on mTGE agar plates supplemented with 1% glycerol for about 10 days. D. aetherius cells were collected from the agar plate with a sterilized platinum loop and washed with 10 mM phosphate buffer three times. Aluminum plates containing cylindrical wells (2.0 mm diameter, 2 mm or 100-μm depth) with a flat floor were used as sample folders (Kawaguchi et al., 2016). Cell suspensions were dropped into wells and dried under 3.3 × 10−2 atm in a desiccator (SPD–WVGS300; SANYO, Tokyo, Japan) on a clean bench. These steps were repeated 20 to 30 times and concluded with the final drying process for more than 16 h under 3.3 × 10−2 atm in a desiccator. The wells were filled with a different amount of D. aetherius cells corresponding to about 100, 500, and 1000 μm cell layers. The sample in the upper aluminum plate was exposed to the space vacuum and UV irradiated through an MgF2 window for 382 days.
After exposure and the samples' return to the laboratory, dehydrated cells were recovered from wells of aluminum plates by resuspending the cell pellet with 10 mM phosphate buffer. Aliquots of Deinococcus cells were serially diluted in sterile phosphate buffer and dropped on mTGE medium plates. Colonies were counted after incubation at 30°C for 4 weeks. The surviving fractions were determined from the quotient N/N 0, where N is the number of colony-forming units of space samples and N 0 is those at the time of sample preparation.
Surviving fractions of cell aggregate of D. aetherius ST exposed to space for about a year were 0, (6.7 ± 4.9) × 10−4, and (7.8 ± 2.7) × 10−4 (n = 3 or 2) for 100, 500, and 1000 μm cell layers, respectively. Although the cell layer with 100-μm thickness is not sufficient, 500 μm is sufficient to survive in space for a year. Provably, dead cells in the surface portion shielded the cells beneath from UV radiation. Space-exposed, dried D. aetherius samples with 500 μmt (μmt: abbreviates μm thickness) or thicker that were illuminated with UV radiation survived, which supports the panspermia hypothesis. Samples with 100 μmt were dead.
8. Conclusion
From the measurement of the first-year experiment, the maximum and minimum temperatures were 24°C ± 5°C and −21°C ± 5°C, respectively. The mean absorbed dose at the thinnest cover (0.55 g/m2) was 272 mGy outside and 100 mGy inside the Kibo module for the duration of the flight. These data are compatible with survival of microbes and organic compounds, which will be reported elsewhere. The accumulated solar irradiation dose at 160 < λ < 190 nm after 1 year of exposure in the ISS orbit was 7.09 ± 0.13 kJ/(m2·y), corresponding to 35 ESDs. These data will be compared with survival of microbes and organic compounds in the upper sample plates of the exposure units. Space-exposed, dried D. aetherius samples with 500 μmt or thicker that were illuminated with UV radiation survived, which supports the panspermia hypothesis, while samples with 100 μmt were dead.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to the ISS program supporting members. This work is partly supported by JSPS KAKENHI (Grant Number JP16H04823) and the Astrobiology Center Program of National Institutes of Natural Sciences (Grant Number AB282002).
Author Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
Associate Editor: Gerda Horneck
Abbreviations Used
References
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
