Abstract
The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine is a worldwide organization of physicians dedicated to the promotion, protection and support of breastfeeding and human lactation. Our mission is to unite into one association members of the various medical specialties with this common purpose.
Introduction
Background
The benefits of breastfeeding have been well documented. Medical doctors worldwide play a key role in advocating for breastfeeding, and they interact with women and children throughout the lifespan. To advocate for breastfeeding, educate families about breastfeeding, and provide optimal clinical management of breastfeeding, these medical doctors must also be educated about and skilled in breastfeeding preventive maintenance, diagnosis, and treatment.1–5 Lack of sufficient education and preparation for breastfeeding support and guidance by physicians has been well documented in the medical literature.6,7
The 1989 World Health Organization (WHO)/UNICEF “Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding” calls for all healthcare staff to be trained in skills necessary to support breastfeeding; this call has been reiterated in multiple subsequent WHO/UNICEF statements. 8
The Innocenti Declaration of 1990 9 sets four tenets: national committees for oversight, the Ten Steps mentioned above (which include education for health professionals), the Code of Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes, and maternity protection. Where these national committees exist, many have as an objective to educate all healthcare providers regarding appropriate breastfeeding and lactation support (e.g., the Australian National Breastfeeding Strategy, 10 the German Breastfeeding Committee, 11 Breastfeeding Promotion Network of India, 12 Kenya's National Infant and Young Child Feeding Committee, the United States Breastfeeding Committee,13,14 etc.). The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine (ABM) was founded in 1995 to promote physician education and has as its central goal to develop and disseminate the standard for physician education about breastfeeding and human lactation. 15 Guidance for the integration of breastfeeding medicine throughout the undergraduate, graduate, and postgraduate medical education of physicians is provided in this statement. (ABM recognizes that terminology used to describe levels of medical education in various medical education systems around the globe differs. In this statement, the term “undergraduate medical education” is used to describe education received prior to obtaining a medical doctor degree, “graduate medical education” refers to clinical education received after the medical degree has been conferred and prior to the independent practice of medicine [i.e., doctors in training, typically during internship and/or residency], and “postgraduate education” refers to continuing medical education received, for continued professional development and/or as a requirement to maintain licensure/registration.
Guidelines
Undergraduate medical education
a. All physicians, regardless of discipline, should have basic knowledge and skills in breastfeeding preventive maintenance, diagnosis, and treatment. 16 Therefore, the theory and practice of breastfeeding should be incorporated routinely into medical school curricula.
Medical students should learn basic anatomy of the breast, the physiology of lactation (including milk production), hormonal impact on mother and child, fertility changes, and the biochemical and immunological properties of human milk. Students should be able to explain the biological, sociological, and cultural aspects of supporting breastfeeding. They should have opportunities to take a maternal history, obtain a feeding history of a newborn or child, and observe breastfeeding mothers and children in a variety of clinical settings. Students need to recognize the value of breastfeeding and human milk feeding, as well as the risks of less than optimal breastfeeding. Ideally, this education should be incorporated into block rotations, systems-based curriculum, or case-based learning in the preclinical education and be reinforced during maternal–child health clinical rotations, including obstetrics and gynecology, pediatrics, and family medicine. 17 All students, regardless of specialty choice, should receive this basic education.
All applicable examinations, whether standardized subject matter, specific written examinations, oral examinations, observed structured clinical examinations, or national certification board examinations, should assess knowledge base and clinical decision-making skills in breastfeeding. At a basic level, all medical students, and therefore all physicians, should understand the scientific evidence for breastfeeding as the gold standard of infant feeding, understand evidence-based clinical management of normal mothers and newborns, and understand the societal context of lactation to provide health care that supports breastfeeding initiation and maintenance and avoids creating barriers.
18
An internet-based resource is freely available for medical student education.
19
Additional resources may also be helpful in developing a breastfeeding curriculum.17,18,20,21
b. Preclinical medical school training in breastfeeding should address the following objectives:5,16,17,22 List the health risks of not breastfeeding for children, mothers, families, and society. Diagram anatomy of the mammary gland and supportive breast structures and identify normal and abnormal histology. Describe the physiology of milk production and secretion. Describe the hormones of lactation and their multiple effects in mother and child. Explain the biochemical and immunologic properties of human milk. Describe the physiology of lactation-related fertility suppression. Appreciate the biological, sociological, psychological, and cultural aspects of supporting breastfeeding. Identify the demographic associations of ethnicity, maternal education, and socioeconomic status on breastfeeding initiation and duration. Identify national and/or international goals for breastfeeding rates and goals for breastfeeding practices, as appropriate. Compare latch (attachment) and suckling dynamics of breastfeeding to bottle-feeding mechanics. Counsel a breastfeeding mother about basic nutritional needs for herself and her child. Describe recommended evidence-based practices for maternity care providers that have been shown to result in increased initiation and duration of breastfeeding. c. Clinical training in medical school should address objectives related to clinical management of breastfeeding, as follows:5,16–18,22 Identify factors that contribute to parental decision-making about breastfeeding. Obtain a detailed breastfeeding history and perform a breastfeeding-related breast examination. Recognize the effects of labor and delivery interventions on initiation of breastfeeding. Describe the impact of intrapartum and immediate postpartum procedures and medications on lactation. Be able to facilitate and assist with the first feeding immediately after delivery. Recognize correct attachment and effective suckling at the breast. Counsel mothers about establishing and maintaining milk supply during separation due to illness or return to study or employment. Provide anticipatory guidance for breastfeeding mothers and children. Recommend medications and treatment options that are compatible with lactation. Discuss appropriate family planning options for the lactating woman. Discuss causes, prevention, and management of common breastfeeding problems (e.g., sore nipples, low milk supply, poor weight gain, and jaundice). Describe appropriate timing, introduction, and selection of complementary foods. Recognize that most infants, even those with special healthcare needs, can breastfeed. Understand normal growth patterns for breastfed babies. Coordinate services with, and provide appropriate referral to, other professionals, lay persons, and community groups. Support policies and procedures across all specialties and practices that promote breastfeeding.
Graduate medical education
a. Residents in obstetrics and gynecology, pediatric, family medicine, and preventive medicine residency training programs report a lack of education in breastfeeding, lack of experience in breastfeeding skills, and lack of competence or confidence in providing breastfeeding support to patients.23–25 Resident physicians report a need for more direct patient interaction in regard to breastfeeding and experience in counseling and problem-solving skills during residency. 26 Residents have demonstrated deficits in interpreting growth patterns of breastfed babies. 27 Residency training program directors also report that training programs do not provide adequate training or experience in breastfeeding. 28
b. Several specific activities to achieve resident competency in breastfeeding management have resulted in an increase in knowledge of residents and improved breastfeeding management and behaviors. Examples include:29–31
Didactic presentations and small group discussion about breastfeeding recommendations, benefits, resources, and maternal medication use
Role playing and video on breastfeeding initiation, assessing position and latch-on, and adequacy of breastfeeding
Management of maternal problems and maintenance of breastfeeding after return to work, as well as use of hand expression or breast pumps
Panel discussion with breastfeeding mothers and support services
Observation of breastfeeding consults
Attendance at peer counselor meetings (e.g., La Leche League International) or at peer support provided at other volunteer or government-sponsored programs (e.g., Australian Breastfeeding Association, National Childbirth Trust [United Kingdom], or Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children [WIC] [United States], hospital-based groups, etc.)
Participation on postpartum rounds with a physician with expertise in breastfeeding support and/or with a board-certified lactation consultant/specialist
Supervised assessment of latch and breastfeeding technique with mother–infant dyads
Participation in outpatient breastfeeding or lactation consultant/specialist clinics
c. For primary care disciplines, resident competencies in breastfeeding build upon those established for medical students. The residency competencies are classified below according to the competency domains of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME).5,7,16–18,22,24,32,33 The ACGME is the organization responsible for the accreditation of post–medical degree medical training programs within the United States, although the competencies are relevant worldwide.
Medical Knowledge
Identify risks of not breastfeeding for infants, mothers, and society.
Identify anatomic structures of the breast.
Describe physiology of milk production and removal.
Describe the physiology of lactational infertility.
Describe the hormones of lactation and their multiple effects in mother and child.
Explain the biochemical and immunologic properties of human milk.
Describe differences in the rates of breastfeeding initiation and duration based upon factors such as ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and maternal education.
Describe suckling and compare breastfeeding and bottle-feeding mechanics.
Recognize the impact of intrapartum and postpartum medications and procedures on lactation.
Describe signs of adequate milk intake by the infant.
Describe the normal growth pattern of breastfed infants.
List absolute contraindications to breastfeeding.
Describe the lactational amenorrhea method of family planning.
Identify indications for maternal milk expression.
Recognize the need to maintain breastfeeding during separation.
List the specific benefits of human milk for premature infants.
Recognize the late preterm infant as being at higher risk of complications and breastfeeding failure compared with the term infant.
Understand the interactions among jaundice, breastfeeding, and breastmilk and appropriate diagnostic and management strategies.
Recognize the role of human milk banking and the appropriate indications and utilization of donor human milk.
Patient Care
Obtain a relevant past medical history of breastfeeding mothers and babies.
Perform a maternal breast assessment, including nipple configuration and assessment for scars.
Perform infant oral assessment and general health assessment.
Evaluate positioning, latch, and attachment for the breastfeeding mother and infant.
Evaluate effective nutritive suckling pattern.
Counsel mothers about maternal nutrition during lactation.
Develop a differential diagnosis for neonatal hypoglycemia and manage newborn blood sugars in a manner that supports breastfeeding.
Evaluate and manage infants with neonatal jaundice in a manner that supports breastfeeding.
Develop a differential diagnosis for sore nipples or breast pain.
Evaluate and manage sore nipples.
Evaluate infants with ankyloglossia.
Recognize common causes and prevention of engorgement.
Evaluate and manage maternal nipple or infant oral candidiasis.
Counsel mothers about the perception of inadequate milk.
Measure, plot, monitor, and interpret infant growth patterns.
Evaluate and manage infants with poor weight gain.
Be able to counsel mothers on hand expression.
Diagnose and treat plugged/blocked ducts, mastitis, and abscess.
Evaluate risk of transmission of infectious diseases during breastfeeding.
Evaluate maternal infections and potential risk of transmission to the breastfed infant.
Counsel families about vaccination practices during breastfeeding.
Counsel mothers about family planning and the potential impact on breastfeeding.
Counsel mothers about maintaining breastfeeding during separation from the infant.
Counsel mothers specifically about milk storage and use and continuing breastfeeding when returning to work or school.
Evaluate medication risk during lactation.
Support breastfeeding in special circumstances, such as prematurity, infant congenital anomalies, cleft lip/palate, congenital heart disease, trisomy 21, maternal diabetes, and delayed lactogenesis II.
Provide gestational age appropriate introduction and progression of breastfeedings for premature infants.
Counsel mothers about introduction of complementary feedings.
Counsel mothers about weaning.
Communication and Interpersonal Skills
Counsel mothers and families about optimal infant feeding decisions for health outcomes, child spacing, and nutrition.
Demonstrate sensitivity to cultural and ethnic differences and practices related to breastfeeding and infant care.
Demonstrate sensitivity to different family structures and the impact upon lactation.
Systems-Based Practice
Identify hospital policies that support breastfeeding for maternity care facilities (e.g., the Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding 8 ).
Identify barriers to successful breastfeeding and suggest strategies to overcome them.
Identify cultural and psychosocial factors that impact breastfeeding rates.
List ways in which the community can support breastfeeding.
Identify community resources to assist breastfeeding mothers, including mother-to-mother support as well as breastfeeding-friendly practitioners.
Refer breastfeeding mothers and babies for more expert assistance as needed.
Understand the role of board-certified lactation consultants and other members of the healthcare team in caring for mothers and babies.
Understand current local laws protecting breastfeeding mothers regarding maternity leave, breastfeeding, or pumping/expressing breastmilk at work, and breastfeeding in public.
Advocate for improved legislative policies to support and protect breastfeeding.
Facilitate follow-up visits for breastfeeding mothers and babies.
Practice-Based Learning and Improvement
Locate resources for continuing education.
Perform evidence-based review of breastfeeding educational topics or clinical issues.
Investigate local breastfeeding initiation and duration rates.
d. Lactation education should be integrated longitudinally throughout the curriculum and should occur in a variety of clinical settings: outpatient continuity clinic and practices; inpatient setting, such as labor and delivery, newborn nursery, mother/baby units or postpartum units, neonatal intensive care units, inpatient general pediatric, and gynecology wards; and community settings, such as public health department clinics or government funded community health centers. 29 In addition, the breastfeeding information should be presented through a variety of teaching modalities, to include didactics, case presentations and discussions, daily teaching rounds, and journal “clubs” in which peer-reviewed journal articles are critically reviewed. Residents may attend live discussions, review CDs or DVDs, read breastfeeding textbooks or periodicals, such as Breastfeeding Medicine, the Journal of Human Lactation, or specialty-specific literature, and complete web-based training modules. In the United States, a multidisciplinary, competency-based curriculum in breastfeeding education that provides multiple activities for integration throughout the residency program is available from the American Academy of Pediatrics website. 34 In each country, resident participation in public clinics would be an important exposure to common breastfeeding problems.
e. The knowledge, skills, and attitudes of residents are important in supporting breastfeeding in patients and the general population. It is equally important that residents in training are supported themselves when they are breastfeeding parents. Some residents report lack of support from their supervisory staff and colleagues about breastfeeding and the need to express milk after return to work. 35 Residency directors and faculty need to advocate for program policies that support breastfeeding among residents, as well as medical students, faculty, and staff.
f. The need for physician leadership in residency training to provide interest, knowledge, and skills to make the human lactation curriculum an ongoing sustainable component of medical education has been noted. 17 Physician administrators (e.g., department chairs and residency program directors) need to identify and support or develop this expertise within the local institution or hospital.
g. Lactation electives in the form of block rotations devoted to breastfeeding, occurring in a variety of clinical settings, have been described in family medicine and pediatric residency training programs.29,36 These electives may include more advanced topics, such as relactation, induced lactation, or Raynaud's phenomenon, and should stimulate more advanced clinical problem-solving skills and/or provide an experience in clinical research or advocacy. Faculty oversight by individuals with a high degree of knowledge and skills in breastfeeding and human lactation is essential. The ABM has a peer-reviewed process for review of the credentials and background of physicians in breastfeeding through the Fellow of the ABM (FABM) award. 37 Fellowship in the ABM is one, but not the only means, of identifying those individuals with a high degree of specialization in breastfeeding medicine. The emergence of breastfeeding medicine practices provides an additional opportunity for education of residents in an intensive setting and should assist in encouraging participating residents to make the practice of breastfeeding medicine an integral part of their professional practice. 38
h. Subspecialty training programs (e.g., fellowship programs in subspecialty disciplines, such as maternal–fetal medicine and neonatology) require additional structured didactic and experiential education, as well as research opportunities, to further the science and advance the understanding of the role and importance of human milk.
Postgraduate/in-service/continuing medical education
a. Practicing physicians, especially those in the disciplines of obstetrics and gynecology, pediatrics, and family medicine, require ongoing continuing medical education regarding breastfeeding to maintain and enhance their clinical skills and expertise. Key components of ongoing education should encompass the importance of breastfeeding and, especially, the risks of not breastfeeding, lactation management, and counseling skills. 39 Practicing physicians acknowledge that they do not understand clearly the health outcomes related to breastfeeding. 40 Patients have reported not receiving routine prenatal or postpartum counseling about breastfeeding by their physicians. 41 Physician attitudes, while counseling mothers, have been shown to be a significant factor in the mother's infant feeding decisions. However, in other studies, physicians' lack of knowledge has led patients to seek guidance elsewhere. Some physicians are not proactive about supporting breastfeeding, are neutral, or may not provide appropriate advice.42,43 Mothers who report receiving encouragement from their physicians are more likely to continue breastfeeding. 44 The role of the physician in encouraging breastfeeding has been shown to be especially important in those patient populations less likely to initiate breastfeeding. 45 In the United States, surveys of practicing pediatricians indicate that many of them are either not aware of the American Academy of Pediatrics policy statements on breastfeeding or are not following these policies when counseling patients.3,46 Requirements to renew or maintain certification should incorporate breastfeeding-related materials into every activity required for ongoing certification.
b. Practicing physicians have the following areas of need in terms of continuing medical education regarding breastfeeding:
Clinical management and problem-solving skills in breastfeeding 47
Awareness of maternal concerns, such as weight loss, birth control during lactation, and maternal medications
Knowledge of common maternal complications, such as mastitis and engorgement 48
Training in evaluating positioning, latch, and attachment 49
Skills in teaching breastfeeding techniques
Evaluating problems with nipple or breast pain
Dealing with maternal perception of insufficient breastmilk 50
Advising mothers about returning to work and continued breastfeeding
Availability of referral services for breastfeeding support 50
Need for more practical training and self-study materials 51
Understanding the role of family support 53
Importance of avoiding routine provision of infant formula, infant formula samples, or educational materials that bear the infant formula logos or product information 54
c. The ABM course, “What Every Physician Needs to Know About Breastfeeding,” provides continuing medical education at an introductory level for physicians and other healthcare practitioners. The ABM also has an annual international conference that provides education for physicians on current state of the art breastfeeding knowledge and research. 55 Many national organizations also offer continuing medical education in breastfeeding medicine for practicing physicians. A growing number of sources, from local to international, are available that provide breastfeeding continuing education for physicians, including internet resources and web-based seminars.
d. The competencies for resident physicians are equally applicable to practicing physicians. Many practicing physicians are in positions of authority and may be able to affect health policy, so additional educational objectives for continuing medical education relate to breastfeeding advocacy:3,5
Promote hospital policies and procedures that facilitate breastfeeding.
Create the hospital policies indicated in the “Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding.”
Collaborate with other primary care providers and with dental health professionals to ensure optimal outcomes.
Provide space for breastfeeding or milk expression/private lactation areas for all breastfeeding mothers, both patients and staff, in hospital and office settings.
Develop office practices that promote and support breastfeeding.
Advocate for reimbursement for physician and lactation consultant breastfeeding services from insurance and managed care companies.
Promote governmental policies and legislation that support breastfeeding mothers and children and increase breastfeeding rates.
Increase availability of lactation consultants and other skilled breastfeeding support personnel.
Achieve a positive image of breastfeeding as normative behavior in the media.
Encourage support of breastfeeding and the use of expressed milk in child care settings.
Implement evidence-based protocols addressing breastfeeding policy and management, such as those available from the ABM.
Summary
Implementation of high-quality breastfeeding education throughout the continuum of medical education is critical to ensuring that practicing physicians maintain their skills and that physicians-in-training develop the knowledge, skills, and attitudes to ensure that virtually every child realizes the right to be breastfed. The medical community plays a critical role in promoting, protecting, and supporting breastfeeding for optimal health outcomes for all children and families.
