Abstract
Background:
Women with opioid use disorder (OUD) are encouraged to breastfeed, but have lower breastfeeding rates than the general population.
Objective:
We examined self-reported barriers and motivators for breastfeeding in women with OUD and the relationship between maternal/postnatal factors and breastfeeding noninitiation/discontinuation.
Materials and Methods:
A cross-sectional design was used; 40 women with OUD who were eligible to breastfeed were included. Information about breastfeeding initiation, duration, barriers/motivators, demographic characteristics, and self-efficacy was obtained through semi-structured interviews at 4–8 weeks postpartum. Wilcoxon rank sum or Fisher's exact test was used to examine the relationship between maternal/postnatal factors and never-initiated/discontinued breastfeeding.
Results:
Respondents were 29.3 ± 5.3 years old; most were prescribed buprenorphine (77.5%); and 36.8% of infants were treated for neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome with methadone or morphine. Most (75.0%) participants initiated breastfeeding; 50.0% continued breastfeeding at 4–8 weeks. The most common motivators included infant health (100%) and bonding (45.0%). On average, women reported discontinuing breastfeeding at 3.3 ± 1.1 weeks postpartum. The most common barriers were concerns regarding transfer of medications or other substances to the infant (50.0%) and concerns about breast milk supply (35.0%). Mean self-efficacy scores were similar among those who continued versus never-initiated/discontinued breastfeeding (33.5 versus 33.0; p = 0.388). Neonatal intensive care unit admission was associated with never-initiated/discontinued breastfeeding (p = 0.047).
Conclusion:
Women with OUD share many similar motivators and barriers to breastfeeding with the general population. Unique concerns include infant exposure to medications or substances, even in those who are eligible to breastfeed, which should be addressed by targeted education for patients and providers.
Introduction
Opioid use in pregnancy increased 333% from 1999 to 2014. 1 For the past several decades, New Mexico drug and alcohol overdose rates have been among the highest in the nation, with some counties having rates four times the national average. 2 This alarming statistic affects all segments of the New Mexico population. In 2014, 14.8 per 1,000 infants in the state had prenatal exposure to opioids. 1 Medications to treat opioid use disorder (MOUD), such as methadone and buprenorphine, decrease the risk of overdose, criminal involvement, relapse, and the transmission of diseases associated with intravenous drug injection; they are also associated with increased prenatal care. 3
Although small amounts of methadone and buprenorphine are transferred into human milk, the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine (ABM), American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) recommend breastfeeding for women on MOUD, unless contraindications exist, such as continued substance use or HIV infection.4–7 In addition to the well-established medical and neurodevelopmental advantages of breastfeeding, it also decreases the severity of neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome (NOWS) and the need for pharmacologic treatment of NOWS.8–10 Breastfeeding may also be particularly important for women with OUD and their infants to attenuate risks of reduced parent-child bonding.10–13
Striking disparities exist in the initiation and duration of breastfeeding in women on MOUD compared to the general population. Nationally, 83% of women initiate breastfeeding and 57% are still breastfeeding at 6 months postpartum. 14 In a review of breastfeeding literature among women on MOUD, seven out of nine evaluated studies reported breastfeeding initiation rates at least 10% lower than the U.S. national average. 15 Despite these health disparities, there is limited research on breastfeeding barriers and motivators among women with MOUD, whose social milieu often differs from the general population. 16
The primary objectives of this cross-sectional study were to (1) identify key barriers and motivators of breastfeeding in women with MOUD; (2) examine the relationship between perceived self-efficacy and reported breastfeeding at 4–8 weeks; and (3) examine the relationship between maternal and postnatal factors and failure to initiate or early discontinuation of breastfeeding. We hypothesized that (1) infant health benefits would be the most important motivator for breastfeeding and (2) low self-efficacy, low socioeconomic status or education level, and concerns about transfer of medications and substance use would be key barriers to breastfeeding among women on MOUD.
Materials and Methods
Study design, setting, and sample
This was a cross-sectional study of postpartum women on MOUD at the University of New Mexico (UNM). The UNM Human Research Review Committee approved the study; all participants provided written informed consent. Study participants were recruited in 2017–2018 from the UNM Milagro program, which provides prenatal and postnatal care for women with substance use disorders. Approximately 200 women receive care through Milagro each year (∼85% with OUD) and about 170 deliver children while in the program. The majority give birth at UNM Hospital (UNMH)—a designated Baby-Friendly hospital. UNMH utilizes guidelines adopted from the ABM Clinical Protocol, which encourages women on MOUD without recent relapse to opioids or other illicit drugs to breastfeed.4,17 Breastfeeding information is typically discussed with Milagro patients throughout their pregnancy, and an infant feeding plan is recorded in the electronic medical record.
After birth, infants typically room-in with their mother, while NOWS observation is performed for 96 hours, unless another medical problem requires their admission to the level II nursery or neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). All infants at risk for NOWS receive supportive non-pharmacologic treatment, while rooming-in with their mother (at the mother-baby unit or another rooming-in unit at UNMH) and, if needed, pharmacologic treatment. Infants may also be transferred to the level II nursery for NOWS treatment if the mother is unable to stay in the hospital for the full 96 hours of infant observation.
The target population for this study was women on MOUD who were attending a 4–8 week postpartum visit at the Milagro program. Inclusion criteria for participation were as follows: (1) at least 18 years of age; (2) able to give informed consent in English; (3) receiving MOUD (either methadone or buprenorphine) prenatally; and (4) met institutional eligibility criteria for breastfeeding, including abstinence from illicit drugs. Women were excluded if they were advised not to breastfeed by a Milagro provider.
Data collection
Patients were approached at a postpartum visit by a research assistant in a private room, either before or after their clinic visit, to determine eligibility and ascertain interest in participation. If eligible and interested, written informed consent was obtained. Participants completed a semi-structured interview with questions about breastfeeding initiation, current breastfeeding status, key barriers and motivators to breastfeeding, self-efficacy, demographic information, and participation in social services, such as the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC). Questions were adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) Infant Feeding Practices Study II Infant Month 2 Questionnaire. 18
Participants who reported breastfeeding at the time of the interview were asked to identify all motivators for breastfeeding (multiple responses allowed), and to choose the most important factor that contributed to their continued breastfeeding. Participants who reported discontinued breastfeeding were asked the age of their infant at the time of discontinuation (in days or weeks); they were also asked to identify all of the reasons and the most important reason for discontinuing or never initiating breastfeeding. The research assistant coded participants' verbal responses by selecting from a predetermined list of options. Responses that did not fit within one of the listed categories were coded as “other” and further specified with a written description.
A validated eight-item self-efficacy questionnaire, the New General Self-Efficacy (NGSE) scale, was administered as part of the interview. 19 The NGSE scale has a high reliability and assesses the degree to which participants believe they can overcome obstacles and achieve goals. 19 Finally, participants were asked a series of demographic questions regarding age, marital status, race/ethnicity, education level, employment outside the home, enrollment in WIC, breastfeeding education during pregnancy, and social support for breastfeeding. The research assistant also abstracted information from the electronic medical record on medical characteristics, such as mode of delivery, hospital unit where the family stayed after birth, hepatitis C virus (HCV) status, and whether an infant had NOWS requiring pharmacological treatment. Study data were collected and managed using REDCap. 20
Data analysis
Data were analyzed using SAS, version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, NC). Descriptive statistics (frequencies and means) were used to summarize demographic characteristics, breastfeeding barriers and motivators, and self-efficacy scores. A two-sided Wilcoxon rank sum test or Fisher's exact test was used, as appropriate, to identify relationships of never-initiated or discontinued breastfeeding with demographic variables, gestational age at birth, mode of delivery, duration of hospital stay, self-efficacy score, maternal MOUD type, infant NOWS treatment, employment, WIC enrollment, hospital unit after delivery, and social support.
Results
The study population included 40 women on MOUD (22.5% on methadone and 77.5% on buprenorphine), interviewed on average at 5.3 ± 1.3 weeks postpartum (Table 1). Most participants identified as white (90.0%) and Hispanic/Latina (77.5%), had an education level of a high school degree or lower (60.0%), and were either single or separated/divorced (52.5%). The majority (80%) were enrolled in WIC. More than one-third (36.8%) of study infants received pharmacologic treatment for NOWS. Only 7.9% of infants were discharged at the same time as their mother. More than one-third of infants were admitted to either a level II nursery (32.5%) or the NICU (35.0%) at some point during hospitalization (note: categories are not mutually exclusive).
Participant Characteristics (n = 40)
Neonatal outcome variables were missing in two subjects who delivered outside of UNMH system.
Median (IQR) duration of hospital stay: 5.5 (5, 20) days.
Women were allowed to choose more than one race.
Categories are not mutually exclusive due to transfer between hospital units.
GED, General Education Diploma; IQR, interquartile range; NICU, neonatal intensive care unit; NOWS, neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome; OUD, opioid use disorder; SD, standard deviation; UNMH, University of New Mexico Hospital; WIC program, Woman, Infant, Child program.
At the time of the interview, 50.0% of participants were breastfeeding or giving expressed human milk. The remaining 25.0% never initiated breastfeeding, and another 25.0% initiated breastfeeding, but discontinued before the interview at the postpartum visit. On average, women reported discontinuing breastfeeding at 3.3 ± 1.1 weeks postpartum. Mean self-efficacy scores were similar among those who continued versus never-initiated or discontinued breastfeeding (33.5 versus 33.0; p = 0.388). Among those who reported continued breastfeeding, the most common motivators were infant health benefits (100.0%), bonding with the infant (45.0%), perceived convenience over formula feeding (30.0%), and encouragement from a health care provider (15.0%; Table 2). The most important reasons for continuation included infant health benefits (90.0%), encouragement from a health care provider (5.0%), and bonding with the infant (5.0%).
Facilitators to Breastfeeding (n = 20)
Participants were allowed to choose multiple responses; thus, categories are not mutually exclusive.
n is limited to participants who continued to breastfeed/pump at the time of the interview.
Among participants who never initiated or discontinued breastfeeding before the interview, the most common barriers cited were the use of medications/substances that might be transferred to the infant through breast milk (50.0%), not having enough breast milk (35.0%), discouragement by a health care professional (15.0%), and feeling that breastfeeding was too tiring and inconvenient (15.0%; Table 3). The most important barriers for discontinuation were concerns about infant exposure to medication/substances (35.0%), not having enough breast milk (30.0%), and having HCV (10.0%). Among patients who had Cesarean section delivery, 71.4% did not initiate or discontinued breastfeeding before the interview compared to 45.5% among women with vaginal deliveries; however, differences did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.408; Table 4). Admission in the NICU was the only significant predictor associated with never-initiated/discontinued breastfeeding (p = 0.047).
Barriers to Breastfeeding (n = 20)
Sample size is limited to those who discontinued breastfeeding/pumping or never initiated breastfeeding.
HCV, hepatitis C virus; ICU, intensive care unit.
The Association Between Sociodemographic and Medical Factors and Breastfeeding Status at 4–8 Weeks Postpartum (n = 40)
p-Value in bold indicates the only p-value which was significant (<0.05).
Neonatal outcome variables were missing in two subjects who delivered outside of UNMH system.
Categories are not mutually exclusive.
Wilcoxon rank sum test.
Fisher's exact test.
Row percentages.
GED, General Education Diploma; IQR, interquartile range; MOUD, medications for opioid use disorder; NICU, neonatal intensive care unit; NOWS, neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome; UNMH, University of New Mexico Hospital; WIC program, Woman, Infant, Child program.
Discussion
Breastfeeding for women on MOUD without contraindications is strongly supported by the ABM, ACOG, and AAP. In our study, 75% of eligible women on MOUD initiated breastfeeding, similar to the 72% and 80% initiation rates in two other recent studies of women with MOUD,21,22 and slightly below the estimated national rate of 83% in the general population.23,24 With respect to the continuation rates, two of the studies included in a recent systematic review reported that only 50–66% of women on MOUD continued breastfeeding at 6–8 weeks postpartum,25,26 and the mean duration of breastfeeding was 5.9 ± 6.5 days.15,27 The mean duration of breastfeeding was longer in our study (3.3 ± 1.1 weeks) compared to these earlier estimates.
Similar to our findings, prior qualitative studies of women on MOUD identified infant health benefits, bonding, and financial reasons as important motivators for breastfeeding.21,22,28,29 One of the benefits reported in earlier studies was alleviation of NOWS symptoms.21,22 In our study, 15.0% of participants who continued to breastfeed stated that their primary reason was to ease withdrawal symptoms for their infant.
The most important reason for never initiating or early discontinuation of breastfeeding was concern about neonatal exposure to medications or substances, consistent with other studies.21,22,28,29 Although the safety of breastfeeding while on MOUD is emphasized by physicians and staff during prenatal care, it is possible that women are receiving conflicting information on the safety of breastfeeding, while on MOUD, from family members or some medical staff.
In our study, all participants met the hospital eligibility requirements for breastfeeding, yet three subjects reported that they did not breastfeed because they were discouraged by a health care professional. It is unclear if this response was influenced by “social desirability” bias, or confounded by concerns about transfer of MOUD, alcohol, or illicit substances into breast milk. Other studies cited maternal concerns about an infant becoming “addicted” to methadone or “getting high” as barriers.28,29 Since the greatest barrier to breastfeeding in multiple studies was a concern about the transfer of medications, future efforts are needed to educate health care providers and pregnant and postpartum women on MOUD, and the general public on the safety of breastfeeding with MOUD.
Concern about breast milk supply is consistent with research in both women on MOUD and the general population.29,30 However, women on MOUD may require additional breastfeeding support related to infant latch and suck, milk transfer, and breast milk fortification or supplementation because of infant health issues associated with NOWS. NOWS may cause oral motor dysregulation, leading to poor feeding and poor milk transfer, which could eventually cause a lower milk supply. 31 In addition, NOWS may cause infant weight loss, leading to the need for breast milk fortification or supplementation. 32 Howard et al. found that mothers felt disappointed in themselves when supplementation was necessary. 21 It is important to help breastfeeding women on MOUD to understand that the need for fortification or supplementation is not related to poor milk supply or breastfeeding skills, but is instead attributable to physiological complications related to NOWS. 21 Efficient and accurate patient-provider communication from the entire medical support team is crucial in reassuring the patient that supplementation might be necessary, without inducing a sense of guilt or inadequacy in maternal skill.
The potential of HCV transmission was similarly noted as a barrier to breastfeeding in our and other studies.21,29 At UNMH, the CDC's recommendation for breastfeeding with HCV is reviewed during prenatal care, stating that it is generally considered safe to breastfeed with HCV, but that if nipples are cracked or bleeding, it is recommended that the patient gives expressed milk only until her nipples are healed. 33 It is possible that women in our study stopped breastfeeding because they developed cracked nipples and were concerned about transmission, or that not all of the health care providers in the hospital were aware of the CDC recommendations.
NICU admission was the only significant factor associated with noninitiation or early discontinuation of breastfeeding. This may be due to infants in the NICU having an overall more complex health status and therefore increased difficulties establishing or maintaining breastfeeding. Alternatively, it could be because infants in the NICU are more likely to be separated from their mothers for at least part of the day. At UNMH, there are chairs for a mother to sit next to her infant, but there are no beds, and parents are required to leave the unit during shift changes. Rooming-in has been found to be one of the most effective interventions to promote breastfeeding 34 ; however, this is often logistically challenging for intensive care nurseries.
Other studies of women on MOUD also recognized these challenges, including difficulties with transportation to and from the hospital after discharge. 22 The finding that only 7.9% of infants were discharged at the same time as their mothers in our study was not surprising, given the required 96-hour observation period for NOWS, and much longer hospitalization of infants requiring pharmacological treatment for NOWS. Most women are discharged 2 days after a vaginal birth and 4 days after a Cesarean section. Similar to our study, the majority of infants (73.0%) in the study by Hicks et al. remained hospitalized at the time of maternal discharge. 22 Some women may be able to room in with their infant after discharge, but women on methadone need to travel to a methadone clinic daily for dosing after their hospital discharge.
In this study, there was no significant association between self-efficacy and breastfeeding. A relatively small sample size might have contributed to the observed lack of association. In addition, a prior research study demonstrated a strong association between breastfeeding self-efficacy and social support, 35 while in our study, about one-third of participants did not receive social support from a person who has breastfed. Prior research also identified negative impact of internal and external stigma on maternal self-efficacy. 21 The role of breastfeeding and general self-efficacy, maternal mental health, social support, stigmatization and discrimination, and socioeconomic environment on breastfeeding outcomes should be examined in future studies.
Hospitals that serve women with OUD should consider including content specific to the concerns of this population in required provider trainings, breastfeeding education classes, and peer support models. Specific content that should be addressed includes the safety of breastfeeding with MOUD, special considerations of breastfeeding an infant with NOWS, and breastfeeding with HCV. Working on interventions to prevent the need for NICU admission or changing the NICU environment to support breastfeeding by allowing rooming-in may also positively impact breastfeeding for women with MOUD. Future studies should examine health care provider knowledge, attitudes, and practices, as well as educational outreach and training programs for hospital staff on substance use disorders, HCV, and MOUD, and address the potential for unconscious bias to provide more supportive environments for breastfeeding in this population.
Limitations
First, our results may not be representative of or generalizable to all women with MOUD. The majority of patients in this study were Hispanic, which we view as a strength, given the underrepresentation of this group in research. Second, given the sensitive nature of some questions, we acknowledge a potential for recall or social desirability bias. However, interviews were conducted in a non-judgmental manner by a research assistant who was not a part of the medical team. Third, questions regarding maternal concerns about the transfer of illicit substances into breast milk were worded generally as concerns about medication and other substance transfer; thus, we cannot differentiate concerns for infant exposure to MOUD and other medications versus illicit drugs. A broader question was chosen by design, however, to minimize discomfort level of the interview questions and associated reporting bias, as well as potential legal implications.
Conclusions
While some breastfeeding concerns are shared with the general population of postpartum women, such as low milk supply, women on MOUD have unique concerns regarding medication transfer. In addition, patients on MOUD might receive mixed messages from their health care team about breastfeeding. Future studies should develop and test the effectiveness of interventions to promote breastfeeding, as well as provide education and support tailored to the needs of women on MOUD. Effective breastfeeding support for women with OUD is needed to address health disparities in this field, given the multiple health benefits of breastfeeding for both mother and infant.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to acknowledge Sandra Cano, MA, for assistance with coordination of research activities and Laura Garrison, MA, for editorial assistance. We are also in debt to the Milagro program staff and patients.
Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
Funding Information
This project was supported by a grant from the University of New Mexico College of Pharmacy (PI: Bakhireva).
