Abstract
Background:
Although exposure and personal experiences can guide breastfeeding decisions, the extant research on African American mothers is limited regarding the influence of infant feeding exposure. The persistent race-based breastfeeding disparities also underscore the lack of effective interventions to support breastfeeding among African Americans.
Objective:
To describe infant feeding exposure and personal experiences of African American mothers in the Midwestern United States with regard to decision making about breastfeeding behavior.
Materials and Methods:
Thirty individual qualitative interviews using a semistructured interview guide were conducted with African American mothers ≥18 years old with an infant 1–6 months of age. Interviews addressed participants' breastfeeding and formula feeding decisions. Data were coded line by line using thematic analysis.
Results:
Positive exposure to breastfeeding and health care providers' prenatal advice influenced nearly all participants to try breastfeeding. However, breastfeeding experiences were unexpected, they did not know how to handle challenges, and nearly half did not continue. Five central themes important to their decision-making processes were identified in the data including contact with breastfeeding mothers, guidance from health care providers, navigating the demands of breastfeeding, making the switch to formula, and my own research.
Conclusion:
Our findings support the importance of both prenatal and postnatal education, the influence of health care providers, and the impact of close social role models. Appropriate education about realistic breastfeeding information is needed to support African American mothers in their breastfeeding decision making. The high use of the Internet to access information also emphasizes the potential opportunity for breastfeeding interventions delivered through technology.
Introduction
Although ∼84
A review of published literature identified breastfeeding exposure, attitudes, knowledge of breastfeeding benefits, and complex lifestyles to be common determinants of breastfeeding behavior among African American mothers. 3 Self-determination, empowerment, and spirituality were described as key factors by mothers successful with breastfeeding. 4 However, challenges for breastfeeding mothers included structural barriers, such as returning to work early, lack of support, and problems pumping.4,5 For mothers deciding not to breastfeed their infants, pain, lack of time, and health habits were identified as main reasons for formula feeding.6,7 Limitations in this body of research specific to African American mothers include little attention to understanding the specific impact of infant feeding exposure as well as homogeneous samples. Studies have mainly focused on low income, lower educated mothers, or those who were successful breastfeeding, with formula feeding mothers commonly excluded preventing a clear understanding of how African American mothers make their infant feeding decisions. Therefore, we aimed to explore factors essential to infant feeding decisions among a diverse sample of African American mothers, including those who chose to feed formula.
The objectives were twofold: (1) describe infant feeding exposure and personal experiences and (2) describe psychosocial and cultural beliefs underlying breastfeeding and formula feeding decisions. In this article, we present our findings of the first objective.
Materials and Methods
Design and sampling
We used a descriptive qualitative design for this study allowing a low-inference naturalistic inquiry method 8 well suited to elucidating complex context-based issues to prioritize voices of participants to inform interventions. 9 Eligibility criteria were mothers ≥18 years of age and self-identified as African American (Black race, born in the United States) with an infant 1–6 months old. A purposive sampling strategy was used with flyers placed in local organizations in central Missouri serving African American mothers. Mothers contacted the principal investigator (PI) by e-mail or phone who screened participants for eligibility. Recruitment continued until data saturation occurred, then two additional participants were recruited to confirm no new information developed. The University of Missouri Health Science Institutional Review Board approved the study.
Data collection
Data were collected from February 2015 to July 2016 by individual in-depth interviews. For consistency, the PI conducted each interview and obtained written consent from participants. Demographic information regarding social, prenatal, and birth history was collected by a self-administered questionnaire.
A semistructured interview guide (Table 1) was used to elicit responses to open-ended questions. Infant feeding exposure was defined for participants as contact with media, someone who has breastfed or formula fed, or education about infant feeding. The interview guide was developed based on the theory of planned behavior that posits intentions and behavior are a function of behavioral, normative, and control beliefs that are influenced by background factors (e.g., culture, education, and past experiences). Examining the effect of specific background factors offers insight into the determinants of human behavior. 10 Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim by a trained research assistant. Data were deidentified and kept on a secure server. Participants were compensated with a $35 gift card.
Interview Guide
Data analysis
Data collection and analysis occurred concurrently using Dedoose software. 11 Thematic analysis occurred in six phases. 12 The first phase involved data immersion, reading, and rereading narratives noting perceptions. In the second phase, the first and third authors coded data independently line by line using an inductive approach, a process of coding that is data driven to generate a list of initial codes reflecting meaningful information. 12 Next, we met regularly to compare and sort codes in phase 3 searching for potential themes. Themes were then refined for coherent patterns exploring the relationship between concepts (phase 4) and named to reflect the underlying significance of broad meaning (phase 5) categorizing the story it tells with subthemes identified. 12
As we worked systematically through the data, reflexive writing was conducted to examine how ideas evolved and a paper trail of analysis was maintained. In the final phase, the second author reviewed the paper trail for consistency, confirming agreement with results and relevant participant quotes were selected. 12
Results
Thirty individual interviews were conducted with African American mothers (mean age = 26 years). Participant demographics are displayed in Table 2. Five central themes emerged with seven subthemes (Tables 3–5). Themes illustrating infant feeding exposure included contact with breastfeeding mothers and guidance from health care providers. Themes depicting personal experiences with infant feeding were navigating the demands of breastfeeding and making the switch to formula. The theme my own research overlapped both exposure and personal experience narratives.
Demographic Characteristics (N = 30)
Infant Feeding Personal Experiences Themes, Subthemes, and Participant Quotes
BF, breastfeeding participant; CF, combination feeding participant; FF, formula feeding participant; WIC, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children.
Infant Feeding Exposure Themes, Subthemes, and Participant Quotes
BF, breastfeeding participant; CF, combination feeding participant; FF, formula feeding participant; WIC, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children.
My Own Research Subtheme and Participant Quotes
BF, breastfeeding participant; WIC, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children.
Contact with breastfeeding mothers
Most participants had personal frequent contact with a breastfeeding mother (family, friends, or church member) who made them feel breastfeeding was the right thing to do. Those still breastfeeding consistently spoke about having someone close to call for help with breastfeeding concerns. Participants also mentioned white coworkers who openly talked about breastfeeding that helped them choose breastfeeding as a feasible option. Formula feeding mothers reported formula was the normal feeding choice for their family and generally identified breastfeeding exposure by more distant people they had limited contact with (mentors or health care providers).
Some participants identified their first breastfeeding exposure was during pregnancy, whereas others grew up in breastfeeding families and viewed formula feeding as an unacceptable option. Many participants, but not all, had positive breastfeeding exposures. Some participants reported hearing breastfeeding was painful, it was hard to produce enough milk, or were advised to give formula instead. Most participants disregarded negative exposures, but reported it created “some doubt” about their ability to be successful breastfeeding.
Guidance from health care providers
Health care providers, lactation consultants, and the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) had substantial influence on mothers' infant feeding intentions. Participants talked about receiving recommendations to breastfeed and specific information about breastfeeding benefits from health care providers as well as attending WIC education classes. Breastfeeding education was provided during prenatal visits by reading materials that participants reported gave the impression breastfeeding would be easy. Nonetheless, some participants described detailed breastfeeding conversations they had with their doctor while many stated they were simply asked their plans for infant feeding “and that was it” with no attempt to “sway me one way or another.”
Participants appreciated a relaxed positive approach to discussing infant feeding. This led them to feel more comfortable and motivated to try breastfeeding without a sense of pressure. Most participants were knowledgeable about the benefits of breastfeeding for infants and viewed it as the optimal infant feeding choice. However, none recalled learning specific breastfeeding techniques.
Navigating the demands of breastfeeding
Navigating breastfeeding demands illustrates the postpartum “learning curve.” Several participants described being overwhelmed and unprepared with the first few weeks of breastfeeding labeled as “rough” and “not easy” as expected. Some reported they did not know how many questions they had until after they began breastfeeding. They identified feeling apprehensive about needing to record the details of each breastfeeding to report to the nurse. In addition, multiple questions from nurses regarding infant feeding at the breast often left them feeling they were doing something wrong or the infant may not be eating enough. As a result, some participants spent more time expressing milk and supplementing with formula to physically see how much their infant was eating. Consequently, these participants also reported latch issues after discharge.
Overwhelmingly, the most difficult aspect of breastfeeding was reported as infant fussiness and hunger signs requiring “back to back” feedings, further giving the impression that their infant was not “getting enough.” For participants returning to work, issues with pumping and infants only wanting to eat directly at the breast were major challenges. Although all participants described breastfeeding as difficult, those still breastfeeding at the time of the interview were undeterred by challenges seeking professional lactation support and advice from close role models. One participant was surprised by the “in-depth and thorough help” she received from the community lactation consultant. Participants still breastfeeding reported they were able to “push past” the challenges to reach their goals, whereas formula feeding participants sometimes stated they felt they “gave up easy.”
Making the switch to formula
Some participants decided to switch to formula because “it was the easiest thing to do,” but others perceived it a necessity. One mother found it easy to make the switch after she exclusively breastfed the first week at home and her infant was readmitted to the hospital with severe dehydration. The switch for others was driven by the need for their infant “not to eat continuously.” However, this was a very difficult decision for one participant who reported a postpartum nurse at the hospital told her “it [formula] could give him brain damage.” She did not fully switch to formula until after discharge from the hospital, stating she felt “stressed out” about whether to breastfeed or formula feed her infant. As a result, she gave him bottles of water to counteract the possibility of brain damage from formula.
Some participants reported strong desires to continue breastfeeding but had factors beyond their control that impacted milk supply, such as being told their “medications were incompatible with breastfeeding.” Four participants had infants who were in the neonatal intensive care unit after birth. It was important to these participants to “strictly breastfeed,” but challenging to keep up milk supply and simultaneously deal with their own health issues. Some described feeling relieved after their decision to switch to formula, whereas others depicted feeling guilty due to knowledge of breast milk benefits for their infant. Nearly all had a difficult time finding a formula their infant could tolerate. Some infants on formula were fussy, constipated, and vomiting and their mothers also expressed remorse wishing they could have “stuck with breastfeeding.”
My own research
In this final theme, participants described the importance of easy access to information. Receiving pamphlets about the benefits of breastfeeding from health care providers prompted participants to do more research on breastfeeding, particularly through the Internet. Smartphones provided convenience to access resources quickly. Participants were aware not everything online “is true” and tried searching for reliable information. As mothers searched for more detailed information, some also read parenting magazines and books. Others joined social media groups, such as “Black Women Do Breastfeed” on Facebook.
Access to information online allowed participants to do their own research during pregnancy and focus on specific topics of interest. Before giving birth, they read mainly about the benefits of breastfeeding compared with formula that led most participants to decide that “breastfeeding was the way to go.” However, after discharge from the hospital, only participants who were still breastfeeding at the time of the interview used the Internet to search for information when needing help with breastfeeding. Easy access to the Internet helped these mothers overcome challenges and continue breastfeeding. Using the Internet to connect with other breastfeeding mothers on social media sites also helped breastfeeding participants not “feel alienated” and know other mothers share the same experience.
Discussion
African American mothers in our study identified breastfeeding as most beneficial for infants. Breastfeeding exposure from family, friends, coworkers, health care providers, and the Internet influenced nearly all of them to initiate breastfeeding. However, many had little practical information about how to breastfeed or navigate challenges and had a hard time adjusting to breastfeeding demands in early postpartum. This caused nearly half of participants to switch to formula feeding that was accompanied by feelings of guilt. Nonetheless, most participants continued to exclusively breastfeed, relying on social media, lactation consultants, and personal support to overcome challenges. These findings highlight that although African American mothers in this study were clearly receiving the message that “breast is best” and wanted to do what they believed was best for their infants, the barriers to continue breastfeeding were substantial for some mothers.
Although formula feeding was more common in families of many mothers in our study, this did not deter them from initiating breastfeeding. Exposure to other mothers normalized breastfeeding, and participants identified breastfeeding mothers in their personal circle as important influencers for infant feeding decisions as other research has found.5,7,13,14
Lutenbacher et al. 5 found African American mothers reported both the influence of distant and close role models as important to their breastfeeding decisions. However, for our participants, only close role models appeared to have substantial influence. These close role models allowed mothers access to people they had contact with in their everyday life and trusted to call after discharge from the hospital to get individual advice about breastfeeding. Some participants who were still breastfeeding also accessed professional lactation support. Conversely, formula feeding participants were only exposed to breastfeeding by distant people in their lives, such as health care providers. This highlights the need to connect African American mothers with other successful breastfeeding mothers before birth to establish the close personal relationships that facilitates breastfeeding initiation and duration.
Receiving information from health care providers about the benefits of breastfeeding was highly influential in participants' infant feeding intentions. Research indicates that African American mothers report varied experiences with prenatal care providers that range from encouraging and educational to nonexistent.4,5,12–15 Many participants in our study (most of whom delivered at baby-friendly hospitals) reported their providers simply asked about their infant feeding preferences, whereas others discussed breastfeeding benefits and made recommendations for breastfeeding over formula. This approach to infant feeding education appeared generally beneficial in that participants reported feeling comfortable about trying breastfeeding but not unduly pressured to breastfeed and the majority initiated breastfeeding.
Many participants did not receive practical information about how to actually breastfeed, did not anticipate that it would be difficult, and they struggled to adjust to the demands of breastfeeding. This challenging period occurred in the early weeks postpartum, which Lutenbacher et al. 5 also found to be a critical time for breastfeeding support. Although participants had help with breastfeeding in the hospital, they were unprepared to meet expectations.
Normal aspects of breastfeeding, such as tracking feeding patterns and frequent feedings, made participants feel breastfeeding was more demanding and their infant was not getting enough milk. This led some mothers to express milk and bottle feed or supplement with formula that caused latch difficulties. Participants did not understand the connection between tracking breastfeeding activity and infant output as a strategy to show adequate infant intake and support breastfeeding success. Previous research also identified that the main reason for introducing formula or discontinuing breastfeeding was due to a concern of insufficient milk intake. 6
Although participants in our study did not express a need for more support, like Hinson et al., 13 we found a need for specific prenatal education about what to expect after birth and how to breastfeed. Although participants indicated they received plenty of information on the benefits of breastfeeding for infants, they were not aware of benefits for mothers. Simply knowing the benefits for infants was not enough to influence breastfeeding duration or maintain milk supply when returning to work. This finding echoed a previous study, 6 but participants in our study who were still breastfeeding at the time of the interview demonstrated a strong commitment to breastfeeding as they were able to push past difficulties by seeking help from close family or friends, searching the Internet for information, and professional support from lactation consultants. Past studies also report successful breastfeeding mothers expressed a strong desire to breastfeed and were self-determined to meet their goals despite negative support and challenges.4,5 Nonetheless, all African American mothers should receive specific information about how to breastfeed.
Health care providers may vary in their approach to educating patients, offering multiple strategies during the prenatal and postpartum period. Future research should identify education strategies and assess knowledge to find the best way to teach African American mothers about maternal and infant benefits, realistic views of the breastfeeding experience, and a clear understanding about breast milk production. Having specific knowledge about how to handle common breastfeeding challenges may help mothers breastfeed for longer durations.
Most formula feeding participants in our study expressed intentions to breastfeed, but barriers led to short durations of breastfeeding. In line with research conducted by Cottrell and Detman, 6 our study found that the level of dedication to breastfeeding was reflected in participants quick decision to switch to formula and lack of use of breastfeeding resources. Breastfeeding triggered stress for many participants and formula feeding seemed to provide relief. Consistent with previous research, 14 feelings of guilt arose due to the emphasis placed on breastfeeding. Mothers in our study also expressed remorse regarding trouble finding a formula that did not cause gastrointestinal discomfort for their infant.
Health care providers should educate mothers that discontinuing breastfeeding before reaching their goal is not a failure. In addition, receiving incorrect information, such as formula causes brain damage, increased maternal stress and led to inappropriate infant feeding practices. More research is needed on how to best support African American breastfeeding mothers in the early postpartum period. Future research could identify what drives some mothers to have a strong commitment to breastfeeding while others give up easy.
Strengths and limitations
This study was designed to enhance trustworthiness of the findings. Reliability was fostered by consistency in data collection across participants with the same African American researcher conducting the interviews using a semistructured guide. Fidelity was also ensured with close monitoring of data collection by the coinvestigator providing feedback to the PI allowing opportunity for revisions and reducing bias. 9 There are some limitations to consider. African American mothers self-selected to participate in the study and their experiences may differ from mothers not likely to take part in the research. Views expressed are from a small sample of 30 mothers living in an urban community in the Midwestern United States. Our findings are also limited to mothers' perceptions of education received as we did not assess the quality of educational materials provided. Given these limitations, the findings from our study are not broadly generalizable.
Conclusions
This study focused on infant feeding exposure and experiences of African American mothers that allowed insight regarding processes for breastfeeding decisions. Our findings add to the existing qualitative research that centers the experiences of African American mothers from various regions of the United States, indicating shared experiences that provide a cultural perspective for breastfeeding decisions, particularly the influence of infant feeding exposure. This evidence highlights the impact of exposure to close social relationships with other breastfeeding mothers in overcoming challenges and the need to identify effective education strategies for African American mothers. Breastfeeding education should include specific practical information on how to breastfeed and be presented to mothers in a way that avoids giving the impression that it will be easy. Breastfeeding is natural but not effortless.
For mothers deciding not to breastfeed because of personal choice or health issues, donor human milk is the first alternative that many African American mothers may not have access to leaving commercially prepared iron-fortified formula as their only infant feeding option. Therefore, mothers need to receive appropriate education about formula feeding. Placing emphasis only on breastfeeding may contribute to anxiety or feelings of guilt. Using a scare tactic approach regarding formula creates additional stress that can lead to inappropriate practices in a population already at greatest risk for poor outcomes.
Understanding the infant feeding perspectives of African American mothers can help develop effective interventions to address the racial disparity in breastfeeding. There is a need for culturally congruent breastfeeding interventions that allow convenient access to support focused on addressing challenges and monitoring by health care providers to permit early intervention that may reduce rehospitalizations. The high use of the Internet to access information emphasizes the potential opportunity for using technology to support breastfeeding.
Footnotes
Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
Funding Information
This study was funded by the University of Missouri Research Council, Grant No. URC-15-057.
