Abstract
Objective:
Platelets (PLT), which serve as the primary hemostatic indicator, can be used as a peripheral model for studying monoamine turnover in the brain. Therefore, they are attractive targets as circulatory biomarkers for the detection of psychiatric disorders. However, PLT counts have not been utilized as a peripheral biomarker of psychopathology.
Methods:
This study was a retrospective analysis of PLT counts upon admission of 108drug-naïve adolescents hospitalized in an inpatient psychiatric department. PLT counts of patients with suicidal ideation (SI) were compared with those of nonsuicidal in patients (NSI) and those of 77 healthy adolescents, serving as a control group. The patients' disorders were diagnosed and classified by one of four American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed. (DSM IV) diagnoses, that is, unipolar depression, bipolar depression, schizophrenia, and a pooled group of conduct and borderline personality disorders.
Results:
Significantly higher PLT counts were observed in SI patients, as compared with NSI patients (300,200±53.3/mL vs. 253,900±53.2/mL, respectively; p=0.0001). A significant difference in PLT counts in SI patients, relative to the control group, was also noted (300,200±53.3/mL vs. 254,000±52/mL, respectively; p=<10−26). Finally, a significant difference in PLT counts was observed between conduct/borderline personality disorders patient with and without suicidal ideation (292,000±55/mL vs. 246,000±64/mL, respectively; p=0.001).
Conclusions:
PLT counts are higher in suicidal hospitalized adolescents than in nonsuicidal inpatients, as well as than in controls.
Introduction
Suicidal ideation is defined as thoughts or wishes to be dead or to kill or harm oneself (O'Carroll et al. 1996) and is perceived not only as a major risk factor for transition to suicidal behavior (Kessler et al. 1999) but also as part of suicidal behavior (Pfeffer and Plutchik 1982). Adolescents who have severe suicidal ideation (i.e., experience active, specific ideation with an intent and/or plan to commit suicide) have an up to 60% probability of attempting suicide within 1 year of declaring or confessing these thoughts (Kessler et al. 1999). Unfortunately, juveniles rarely volunteer information concerning suicidal ideation, making it difficult to ascertain risk via psychiatric evaluation and questioners in the community (Abram et al. 2008). Therefore, the availability of a laboratory aid for the detection of suicidal ideation in adolescents may assist in suicide risk assessment and, subsequently, its prevention.
For >30 years, thrombocytes have served as targets for neuropathological research. Platelets (PLT) have been shown to represent a good cellular model for studying the uptake, storage, and release of monoamines in postsynaptic brain neurons (Sneddon 1973; Longenecker 1985; Stahl 1985; Rehavi and Weizman 1990), processes, which are altered in several psychopathologies (Briley et al. 1980; Stahl et al. 1983; Hitzemann et al. 1984; Geller et al. 1988; Hrdina et al. 1995). In hospitalized patients, PLT serotonin concentration and receptor activities have been found to be significantly higher in suicidal patients than in nonsuicidal hospitalized patients (Rao et al. 1998) and differences related to specific symptoms have been demonstrated. Specifically, aggressiveness and the impulsivity of suicidal acts were correlated with serotonin content and the number of serotonin-2-binding sites on the PLT surface (Pandey et al. 1990; Spreux-Varoquaux et al. 2001).
Several reports suggest that cellular or molecular properties of PLT change in depressed or suicidal patients. Patients with major depression were reported to have higher mean PLT volume (MPV) values than controls (Canan et al. 2012), whereas treatment with escitalopram resulted in a significant reduction in MPV of depressed patients (Ataoglu and Canan 2009). Prepubertal children with major depression and/or suicidal behavior have been reported to have lowered PLT serotonin concentrations (Pfeffer et al. 1998). Finally, elevated PLT counts have been reported to be associated with psychological stress (Van Ischoot et al. 1982). Others have reported that differences at the molecular level (e.g., receptor concentrations) might signify suicidality. However, small sample size, insufficient matching criteria of control samples, use of inadequate ligands in binding experiments, and failure to consider comorbidity have rendered these studies as suggestive, at best (Muller-Oerlinghausen et al. 2004). Moreover, differences in the standard laboratory measures of PLT have not been investigated in adolescents.
In this study, we report analysis of the differences in PLT counts between hospitalized adolescents with various psychiatric disorders and a control group of adolescents without psychiatric complaints.
Methods
Subjects
The patient population consisted of 821 adolescents hospitalized between November 1, 1995 and October 31, 2004 in the inpatient psychiatric ward at the Beer Sheva Mental Health Center. Patient data were extracted from the medical records. Records were screened for the diagnosis made at admission and at the time of discharge, as well as for laboratory test results. Inclusion criteria consisted of age (12.5–18 years) and a psychiatric diagnosis of depression, schizophrenia, borderline personality disorder, or conduct disorder. A patient's data were excluded if any of the following exclusion criteria were met: 1) Use of alcohol (self-reported or reported by parents, social workers, and/or teachers) or drugs (either psychoactive, nonpsychoactive, or recreational) during the month prior to blood examination; 2) Evidence of infection upon admission or a white blood cell count of >12,000 cells/mL; 3) Evidence of hormonal disorders, diabetes, thyroid dysfunction, heart disease, trauma, blood disease, or any infection diagnosed upon or during hospitalization; and 4) Evidence of any neurological disorder, except for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). A total of 108 patients met all these criteria and were considered in subsequent analyses. Control subjects (n=79) were randomly selected from the medical records of the Soroka University Medical Center, using the pre-operational blood tests of otherwise healthy patients designated to undergo elective surgery, mostly plastic surgery. Inclusion criterion for the control group was age (12.5–18 years). The exclusion criteria were: 1) A record of neurological or infectious diseases or 2) A record of drug use or abuse. Approval to analyze the data of patients and controls was obtained from the internal review board of the appropriate medical institutions.
Psychiatric classification and background variables
Patients were categorized into two major groups, suicidal and nonsuicidal patients, based on the presence of suicidal ideation at any point during the week prior to the psychiatric examination using questions 6 and 8 from the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale for Children and Adolescents. The assessment was conducted by raters blinded to the blood test results and psychiatric diagnoses (Overall and Pfefferbaum 1982). Control individuals were all assumed to be nonsuicidal. In addition, patients were classified into four groups according to their major diagnosis (Table 1) as defined in the axis-I American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed., Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) criteria (American Psychiatric Association 2000): 1) Schizophrenia, including schizophreniform and schizoaffective disorders; 2) major depression; 3) bipolar disorder; and 4) others, including conduct and borderline personality disorder, as the main diagnoses. Age, gender, smoking habits, and PLT count were assessed for each individual. Smoking habits were not recorded for control individuals. All PLT count measurements were generated in computerized hematology laboratories at the Beer-Sheva Mental Health Center or the Soroka Medical Center.
The number of patients with each disorder according to DSM axis-I are shown, as well as the number of patients with or without suicidal thoughts for each disorder. Bipolar patients in the depressed state were grouped with patients suffering from major depression.
Institutional review board approval
The study was approved by the Hospital Beer-Sheva Mental Health Center Review Board and the Israeli Ministry of Health. The need for informed consent was waived because of the naturalistic retrospective nature of the study.
Statistical methods
Data were analyzed using the t-test for two independent samples, assuming equal variance, and one-way ANOVA to compare several groups. In addition, the equivalent nonparametric Wilcox test and Chi squared test were also used as appropriate. Statistical analysis was carried out using the R programming language (version 2.10.1). In all statistical tests, a significant cutoff of 5% (p=0.05) was used.
Results
We reviewed the records of 821 adolescents hospitalized between November 1, 1995 and October 31, 2004 at the Beer Sheva Mental Health Center. PLT counts of 108 drug-free patients with no evidence of relevant hematological, endocrine, infectious, or neurological disorder upon admission were identified. A single patient with a recent and significant suicidal act (i.e., low-height jump without any indication of trauma), and five patients with superficial cuts in the wrists were not excluded from the study group. For controls, as mentioned in the Methods section, data on PLT counts of 79 individuals were collected from records in the Soroka Medical Center (see Methods section for detailed description of the inclusion/exclusion criteria).
The background variables of the different subgroups revealed few significant differences (Table 2). The average age of suicidal patients was slightly lower than that of the control group (14.7±1.5 years, as compared with15.5±1.6 years; p=0.005, Student's t-test) and of the nonsuicidal patients group (14.7±1.5years, as compared to 15.5±1.6 years; p=0.01, Student's t-test). These differences are not likely to introduce significant differences in PLT levels among these groups, as no significant correlation was observed between PLT and age when the entire population was considered (p=0.9, Pearson's test). However, to further reduce the possibility that age differences contribute to differences in PLT counts, the groups were balanced in terms of patients' ages. This process only marginally changed the results, such that all of the differences detected without age balancing were also found to be significant with such balancing and vice versa.
The background variables are compared for different groups of subjects. The number of subjects included in each group (N), the mean and standard deviation of their ages (Age±SD), the % females and the number of smokers is given for the two groups (arbitrarily denoted as I or II). Statistically significant differences (p<0.05, Student's t-test) are marked in bold. For comparison, where a significant difference in patients' age was found, the analysis was repeated with age correction by resampling one of the groups to reduce the age difference. The group that was resampled is marked with an asterisk (*).
n.a.=not applicable; n.d.=not determined.
No significant differences were found in the number of smokers in those groups for which smoking status was known (i.e., suicidal and nonsuicidal patients) or in the fraction of females in the different groups.
PLT counts were found to be significantly higher in the group of suicidal patients (Table 3). The mean PLT count in this group was 298±55 cells/mL×1000. In comparison, the mean PLT count of healthy controls was 262±47 cells/mL×1000 (p=0.0005, Student's t-test), and 260±60 for inpatients without suicidal tendencies (p=0.0004, Student's t-test).
The PLT values in specific sub-groups of hospitalized adolescents were compared. The statistical significance of each comparison is provided (p-value and Student's t test statistics). For comparison, where a significant difference in patients' age was found, the analysis was repeated with age correction by resampling one of the groups to reduce the age difference. The group that was resampled is marked with an asterisk (*).
A large fraction of the patients with suicidal tendencies in this study had major depression (25 of the 51 patients considered; see Table 1). This raises the possibility that the observed differences in PLT levels are associated with the depression, rather than with the suicidal thoughts. To test this hypothesis, we compared the PLT levels of nondepressed suicidal patients with nondepressed, nonsuicidal patients and with healthy controls. Significantly higher PLT counts were observed in the nondepressed suicidal patients than in either control group (Table 3).
The differences between PLT levels in suicidal patients, nonsuicidal patients, and healthy controls reported previously were also detected when the three groups were compared using the ANOVA test (p=0.0001).
Discussion
In this retrospective study, we compared the platelet counts of patients with suicidal thoughts, patients without such thoughts, and nonsuicidal, healthy controls. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to compare PLT counts among adolescents admitted with or without suicidal ideation. Suicidal patients were found to have significantly higher PLT than did nonsuicidal patients or healthy controls. No statistically significant differences were found among the groups with respect to the number of smokers or gender distribution. The stress associated with psychiatric hospitalization (Beattie et al. 2009), which could affect PLT levels (Van Ischoot et al. 1982), might also be a confounder. Therefore, we compared subjects with different psychopathologies, as well as healthy adolescents, a comparison that may have emphasized differences within the population of the hospitalized patients. Both groups of patients, that is, suicidal and nonsuicidal, are expected to experience similar stress. We therefore propose that the design presented here, namely, comparing inpatients with different complaints and diagnosis, may be more sensitive and robust in identifying markers that differ among diseases than would comparing patients with healthy nonhospitalized controls.
Another possible confounder is the large overlap between suicidality and depression. One cannot ignore the possibility that the elevation in PLT is mainly caused by the state of depression. This hypothesis was, however, rejected by showing differences in PLT counts between non depressed patients with and without suicidal ideation. As such, it is possible that depression contributes to the elevation of PLT, even if it does not explain it. Follow-up studies with larger populations are required to evaluate the independent contribution of depression to PLT levels. Finally, age could be a confounder. A small but significant difference was observed between the age of patients with or without suicidal thoughts (Table 2). However, controlling for these differences by resampling did not eliminate the difference in PLT counts.
These findings suggest a possible association between suicidal thoughts and elevated PLT counts. In addition, they suggest that depressed suicidal adolescents constitute a specific group of adolescents. Alternatively, this difference might reflect depression in progression that was misdiagnosed at this stage of the disorder as conduct or borderline personality disorder (Valevski et al. 2001; Farbstein et al. 2002) leading to the mis-assignment of such patients to the borderline personality/conduct disorder group. Further investigation is required to clarify these points.
This work is a pilot study and subsequent studies conducted with larger samples in multiple centers are needed to substantiate our findings. Different age groups, the effects of medication and drugs, and other laboratory measures, as well as other symptoms should be investigated in patients having suicidal thoughts. Moreover, searching for additional PLT-related biomarkers may enable the discrimination between suicidal and nonsuicidal adolescents and eventually lead to the identification of the mechanism(s) underlying suicidal ideation/behavior.
Can elevated PLT counts serve as diagnostic aid? Obviously, as the differences we report are within the normal range, the discriminative power of PLT counting is limited. However, understanding the mechanism underlying the observed differences may point to new markers that could assist in diagnosis.
Conclusions
Hospitalized adolescents with suicidal thoughts are reported to have elevated PLT counts within the normal range.
Clinical Significance
Our findings suggest a possible association between suicidal thoughts and elevated PLT counts. Although the discriminative power of PLT counting is limited, understanding the mechanism underlying the observed differences may point to new markers that could assist in the diagnosis of suicidality.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
We thank Hagit Cohen for her assistance in analyzing the results, Asher Moser and Dr. Hadas Ner Gaon for their assistance in manuscript preparation, and Yael Djorno for helping in data acquisition. Finally we thank our anonymous reviewers for their helpful suggestions.
Disclosures
No competing financial interests exist. This work was partially funded by the National Institute for Biotechnology in the Negev through a scholarship to Eitan Rubin.
