As France is traditionally opposed to electronic voting, especially when used in general elections or national referenda, electoral interference could take the form of false information disseminated online. Indeed, misinformation may affect the honesty of electoral debates and influence voting behavior. This article first studies the electoral interference that occurred in France, during the 2017 presidential campaign, and that targeted more particularly the future president of the republic, Emmanuel Macron. It shows that the laws that existed at the time could only imperfectly counter disinformation spread in an online environment. This article then analyzes the new laws on the fight against the manipulation of information, adopted in reaction to the 2017 electoral interference with the support of the president of the republic. It studies how those laws aim to react to manipulation of digital information before general elections and national referenda. A new judge sitting for urgent matters may order the suspension or suppression of limited digital false information. The French regulatory broadcasting agency may suspend, interrupt, or refuse broadcasting of false information by audiovisual media controlled or influenced by a foreign state. Its powers are, however, restrained for legal and political reasons. This article then studies how the new laws aim to prevent manipulation of digital information. They give users of online platforms more means to critically assess digital information and be less influenced by it. Thus, online platforms must be more transparent about the information they host, especially during electoral campaigns. Furthermore, information and media literacy are strengthened. Finally, this article concludes that the scope of the new legislation against the manipulation of information, constrained by the freedom of expression, remains modest. It argues that facilitating the detection of false information by platforms' users is the way forward to diminish the impact of that information on electoral debates.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BancaudDelphine. 2019. “Why Is Media Literacy Still Lagging Behind in France?” [in French]. 20 Minutes. February 21.
CNCCEP. 2017b. Report Prepared by the National Commission for the Control of the Election Campaign for the Presidential Election (ballots of April 23 and May 7, 2017) [in French]. <http://www.cnccep.fr/communiques/Rapport_fin_mission_2017.pdf>.
6.
Constitutional Council. 1971. Decision no. 71-44 DC of 16 July 1971.
7.
Constitutional Council.. 2004. Decision no. 2004-496 DC, 10 June 2004.
8.
Constitutional Council.. 2012. Decision no. 2012-4589 AN, 7 December 2012.
9.
Constitutional Council.. 2018. Decision no. 2018-773 DC, 20 December 2018.
10.
Constitutional Council.. 2018. Decision no. 2018-774 DC, 20 December 2018.
11.
Couderc and Hachette Filipacchi Associés v. France.. 2015. App. no. 40454/07. ECHR November 10.
12.
Court of Cassation, Correctional Chamber. 2015. Ruling no. 14-82587, 20 October 2015.
13.
Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen. 1789. August 26.
14.
Decree no. 2019-53 of 30 January 2019, Designating the “Tribunal of Big Instance” and the Court of Appeal of Paris Competent to Hear Actions Based on Art. L. 163-2 of the Electoral Code.
15.
Decree no. 2019-297 of 10 April 2019, Relating to Information Obligations of Online Platform Operators Promoting Information Content Related to a General Interest Debate.
16.
DreyerEmmanuel. 2019. “False Good News: The Law of December 22, 2018 on the Manipulation of Information Is Published.” [in French]. Légipresse, 367(January): 19–33.
17.
En Marche! 2017. “En Marche Was the Victim of a Massive and Coordinated Hacking Action.” [in French]. Press release. May 5. <https://en-marche.fr/articles/communiques/communique-presse-piratage>.
European Convention on Human Rights. 1950. November 4.
20.
Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill on the Fight Against the Manipulation of Information, Registered at the Presidency of the National Assembly the 21st of March 2018.
21.
FrassaChristophe-André. 2018. Opinion No. 667 Made on Behalf of the Commission for Constitutional Laws, Legislation, Universal Suffrage, Regulation and General Administration on the Private Member's Bill Adopted by the Assembly General After Initiating the Accelerated Procedure, on the Fight Against the Manipulation of Information. [in French]. <https://www.senat.fr/rap/a17-667/a17-6670.html>.
GuillaumeMarine. 2019. “Combating the Manipulation of Information—a French Case.” Strategic Analysis. 1–8. February.
24.
Human Rights Council. 2018. Report of the Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression. UN Doc. A/HRC/38/35.
25.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. 1966. December 16.
Law no. 2018-1202 of 22 December 2018 on the Fight Against the Manipulation of Information.
31.
Law no. 2004-575 of 21 June 2004 for Confidence in the Digital Economy.
32.
Law no. 2013-1028 of 15 November 2013 on the Independence of the Public Audiovisual.
33.
Le CainBlandine, PiquetCaroline, and Boudisseau.Julien. 2017. “What Are the Risks of Those Who Spread False Information in the Run-Up to the Election?” [in French]. Le Figaro. May 6.
34.
LeloupDamien and Martin Untersinger. 2017. “Why Was the Electronic Vote of French Citizens Living Abroad for Legislative Elections Cancelled?” [in French]. Le Monde. March 9.
35.
LeloupDamien and Martin Untersinger. 2019. “Behind the scenes of the MacronLeaks.’” [in French]. Le Monde. June 15.
36.
LeloupDamien and Tual Morgane. 2017. “Le Monde and the ‘MacronLeaks’ Documents.” [in French]. Le Monde. May 6.
Morin-DesaillyCatherine. 2018. Report No. 677 Made on Behalf of the Commission for Culture, Education and Communication. [in French]. Senate. July 18. <https://www.senat.fr/rap/l17-677/l17-677.html>.
MoutchouNaïma. 2018. General Discussion. Report Made on Behalf of the Commission for Cultural Affairs and Education on the Private Member's Bill. [in French]. National Assembly. No. 990. May 30. <http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/15/rapports/r0990.asp>.
42.
PilletFrançois and Thani Mohamed Soilihi. 2016. Information Report No. 767 (2015–2016) Made on Behalf of the Law Commission. [in French]. Senate. July 6. <https://www.senat.fr/rap/r15-767/r15-767.html>.
State Council.. 2018. Ruling no. 394641-394642, Opinion Relating to the Bills on the Fight Against the Manipulation of Information. April 19.
49.
StuderBruno. 30 May 2018. General Discussion. Report Made on Behalf of the Commission for Cultural Affairs and Education on the Private Member's Bill. [in French]. National Assembly. No. 990. <http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/15/rapports/r0990.asp>.
50.
Superior Audiovisual Council. 2018. Report on Electoral Campaigns. [in French]. April. Paris.
51.
Superior Audiovisual Council.. 2018. Decision no. 2018-493 Putting RT Company on Notice, 27 June 2018. Official Journal of the French Republic [in French]. no. 0148. June 29.
52.
Superior Audiovisual Council.. 2019. Recommendation no. 2019-13 of 15 May 2019 of the Superior Audiovisual Council to Online Platform Operators in the Context of the Duty to Cooperate to Fight the Dissemination of False Information.
53.
Superior Audiovisual Council. 2020. ”Fight against the dissemination of false information on online platforms.” [in French]. July. Paris.
54.
ThierryGabriel. 2017. “MacronLeaks: The Information Technology Fraud Investigation Unit, Actor ‘Essential’ of Computer Investigations.” [in French]. Dalloz. Actualité. May 12.
United Nations (UN) Group of Governmental Experts. 2015. Developments in the Field of Information and Telecommunications in the Context of International Security. Report 2015 UN Doc. A/70/174.
VilmerJean-Baptiste Jeangène, AlexandreEscorcia, Janaina.Guillaume Marine and Herrera. 2018. Information Manipulation: A Challenge for Our Democracies. Report by the Policy Planning Staff of the Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs and the Institute for Strategic Research of the Ministry for the Armed Forces. Paris. <https://www.rcmediafreedom.eu/Publications/Reports/Information-Manipulation-A-Challenge-for-Our-Democracies>.
