Abstract
Although Staphylococcus aureus has been implicated as the main Staphylococcus species causing human food poisoning, recent studies have shown that coagulase-negative Staphylococcus could also harbor enterotoxin-encoding genes. Such organisms are often present in goat milk and are the most important mastitis-causing agents. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate the occurrence of enterotoxin-encoding genes among coagulase-positive (CoPS) and coagulase-negative (CoNS) staphylococci isolated from raw goat milk produced in the semi-arid region of Paraiba, the most important region for goat milk production in Brazil. Enterotoxin-encoding genes were screened in 74 staphylococci isolates (30 CoPS and 44 CoNS) by polymerase chain reaction targeting the genes sea, seb, sec, sed, see, seg, seh, and sei. Enterotoxin-encoding genes were found in nine (12.2%) isolates, and four different genes (sea, sec, seg, and sei) were identified amongst the isolates. The most frequent genes were seg and sei, which were often found simultaneously in 44.5% of the isolates. The gene sec was the most frequent among the classical genes, and sea was found only in one isolate. All CoPS isolates (n=7) harboring enterotoxigenic genes were identified as S. aureus. The two coagulase-negative isolates were S. haemolyticus and S. hominis subsp. hominis and they harbored sei and sec genes, respectively. A higher frequency of enterotoxin-encoding genes was observed amongst CoPS (23.3%) than CoNS (4.5%) isolates (p<0.05), reinforcing the importance of S. aureus as a potential foodborne agent. However, the potential risk posed by CoNS in goat milk should not be ignored because it has a higher occurrence in goat milk and enterotoxin-encoding genes were detected in some isolates.
Introduction
S
Besides S. aureus and other coagulase-positive staphylococci (CoPS), it is known that coagulase-negative staphylococci (CoNS) species are also capable of producing enterotoxins (Vernozy-Rozand et al., 1996; Cunha et al., 2006; Vasil, 2007; Veras et al., 2008). Moreover, staphylococcal food poisoning outbreaks attributed to CoNS have been reported (Carmo et al., 2002). Interestingly, CoNS are commonly found in goat milk and are the leading mastitis-causing agents in goats (White and Hinckley, 1999). However, information about the occurrence of enterotoxigenic CoNS in goat milk is still scarce and the public health importance of those bacteria is unknown, although some human foodborne illness outbreaks have been linked to the consumption of goat milk (Buyser et al., 2001).
The understanding of the potential hazards of staphylococcal contamination in goat milk is of major importance to the goat industry worldwide. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate the occurrence of enterotoxin-encoding genes in CoPS and CoNS Staphylococcus spp. from goat milk produced in the semi-arid Paraiba State, the main goat milk-producing region in South America.
Materials and Methods
Samplings and Staphylococcus isolation
Bulk goat milk samples were randomly collected from 55 smallholder producers in four different municipalities (A, n=18; B, n=16; C, n=12; D, n=5) located in Cariri, a semi-arid region in Paraiba State, Northeastern Brazil. Samples were processed for staphylococci isolation, according to Bennett and Lancette (2001). Briefly, milk samples (25 mL) were diluted in 225 mL of lactose broth (Acumedia, Lansing, MI) and then serially diluted (1:10) in ¼ strength Ringer's solution. Aliquots (100 μL) were spread plated over the surface of Baird-Parker agar (Acumedia) supplemented with potassium tellurite and egg yolk (Laborclin, Pinhais, Brazil). After incubation (35°C, 24–48 h), the total number of colonies on each plate was counted. At least three isolates per bacterial population were picked per dish, considering similar morphological traits. Further confirmation was performed using morphological (Gram staining) and biochemical tests (coagulase, mannitol and maltose fermentation, and hemolysis in blood agar).
Staphylococcus spp. isolates (n=74; 30 CoPS and 44 CoNS) from municipalities A (n=15), B (n=26), C (n=28), and D (n=05) were further screened for enterotoxin-encoding genes by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay as described below. Species identification of Staphylococcus-harboring enterotoxigenic genes was determined using a semi-automated system (Autoscan 4; Siemens Healthcare, Malvern, PA) by means of a biochemical panel (Combo PC33; Siemens) and software (LabPro Connect; Siemens).
Detection of enterotoxin-encoding genes by PCR
Genomic DNA was extracted using phenol/chloroform (Fritsch et al., 1989) with minor modifications. The quality and concentration of DNA were measured (Biophotometer Plus; Eppendorf, Wesseling-Berzdorf, Germany).
Detection of the enterotoxigenic genes was performed by individual PCR reactions targeting the genes sea, seb, sec, sed, see, seg, seh, and sei (Blaiotta et al., 2004). Reactions were performed in 25-μL reactions containing 0.4 mM of each primer, 200 mM of each dNTP, 2 mM of MgCl2, 100 ng of genomic DNA, and 1U of Taq DNA polymerase (Invitrogen, São Paulo, Brazil). Primer details are provided in Table 1.
Amplification was performed in a thermal cycler (TC-5000; Techne, Stone, Staffordshire, UK) according to the following conditions: initial denaturation step (95°C, 3 min), 30 amplification cycles (95°C, 30 sec; 55°C, 75 sec; 72°C, 30 sec), and final extension step (72°C, 5 min). Products were analyzed by electrophoresis in 2% agarose gel (LGC Biotechnology, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil) stained with GelRed (Biotium, Hayward, CA). The presence or absence of bands was analyzed visually under ultraviolet light. Positive controls used in the reactions included S. aureus American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) 13565 (sea), S. aureus ATCC 14458 (seb), S. aureus ATCC 19095 (sec, seh, and sei), S. aureus ATCC 23235 (sed and seg), and S. aureus ATCC 27664 (see) (Fig. 1).

Agarose gel containing polymerase chain reaction–amplified products of enterotoxin-encoding genes in Staphylococcus spp. used as positive controls. M, 100-bp DNA ladder; 1, sea (120pb); 2, seb (478pb); 3, sec (257pb); 4, sed (317pb); 5, see (482pb); 6, seg (642pb); 7, seh (376pb); 8, sei (577pb); 9, femA (132pb).
Statistical analysis
Data was analyzed using SPSS 17.0 (SPSS, Chicago, IL) to generate descriptive analyses, chi-square tests, and Fisher's exact test when appropriate. Mean counts of Staphylococcus were transferred into log format for data normalization and compared between municipalities. Possible associations between the occurrence of enterotoxin-encoding genes and the production of coagulase by the isolates were determined.
Results and Discussion
Staphylococci counts ranged from 2×102 to 3×107 CFU/mL, with a mean value of 2.08×106 CFU/mL. Mean staphylococci counts were significantly lower (p<0.05) in municipality A (1.2×105 CFU/mL) compared to B (2.2×106 CFU/mL), C (5.8×106 CFU/mL), and D (2×105 CFU/mL), suggesting the existence of factors associated with the staphylococcal contamination in raw milk produced in the region. Most important, however, considering that staphylococcal food poisoning is associated with staphylococci levels in food, is the fact that staphylococci contamination was high. It is assumed that S. aureus levels of 105 CFU/g of food may produce enough enterotoxin to cause illness (Seo and Bohach, 2007). Counts exceeding 105 CFU/mL were observed in 41.7% (5/11) of the milk samples collected in municipality A, 61.1% (11/18) in B, 55% (11/20) in C, and 20% (1/5) in D (Table 2).
Out of the 74 isolates, 44 (59.4%) were coagulase-negative staphylococci (CoNS), and all coagulase-positive (CoPS) isolates (n=7) harboring enterotoxigenic genes were identified as S. aureus. The frequency of CoNS in goat milk was similar to that previously reported (Ndegwa et al., 2002). The two CoNS isolates harboring enterotoxigenic genes were S. hominis and S. haemolyticus, which usually are present in low numbers in milk from healthy goats and sheep (Vasil, 2007; Onni et al., 2012). However, the occurrence of S. haemolyticus was reported in milk from goats and cows with mastitis (Virdis et al., 2010; Fessler et al., 2010).
In the present study, enterotoxin-encoding genes were found in nine (12.2%) isolates, from which seven were CoPS and two were CoNS. A higher frequency (p<0.05) of enterotoxin-encoding genes was observed in CoPS (23.3%) compared with CoNS (4.5%), which corroborates a previous report (Valle et al., 1990). Amongst the positive isolates, four (44.5%) were positive for one gene, three (33.4%) harbored two genes, and one (11.2%) was positive for three genes.
Higher frequencies of enterotoxin-encoding genes in CoPS compared to CoNS were previously described in other cases such as food handlers (Bartels et al., 2009) and sheep's milk (Vasil, 2007). However, a previous report in Brazil indicated a higher enterotoxigenic potential for CoNS than CoPS in milk from goat and other species (Lamaita et al., 2005). Additionally, the genes sea and sec have been reported in CoNS staphylococci from different types of foods in Brazil (Cunha et al., 2006).
The frequency of isolates harboring staphylococcal enterotoxigenic genes in the present study was lower than frequencies reported in samples of bovine milk (Rall et al., 2008) and sheep milk (Maslankova et al., 2009). Although the low number of isolates harboring staphylococcal enterotoxigenic genes in the present study was very similar to that reported for bovine milk produced by smallholders in Norway (Jorgensen et al., 2005), frequencies higher than 50% were reported in samples of different animal species and products elsewhere (Cremonesi et al., 2006; Morandi et al., 2007; Mork et al., 2010).
The sei gene was detected in isolates originating from all four municipalities. The gene seg was detected in municipalities A–C. However, sea was identified in municipality A only, while sec was identified only in staphylococci from municipalities C and D. The genes seb, sed, see, and seh were not detected in the present study.
Amongst the classic enterotoxin-encoding genes, sec was detected in 55.6% of the isolates. The gene sea was observed in one isolate and only in combination with other genes. This gene is described as one of the most common gene found in staphylococci from bovine milk (Rall et al., 2008) and from human samples (Rall et al., 2010). Although there are investigations on the occurrence of enterotoxin-encoding genes in staphylococci goat milk and most of them are restricted to the classic genes, the present study corroborates previous findings (Scherrer et al., 2004; Loncarevic et al., 2005) that reported sec as the gene with higher frequency amongst the classic genes in staphylococci from goat milk, reaching up to 71% (Mork et al., 2010) and 86% (Silva et al., 2005) in staphylococci from healthy and mastitic animals, respectively. The gene sec was detected almost exclusively in staphylococci from goat origin (Cremonesi et al., 2006), and it was also reported as the most frequent (24.1%) in S. aureus from sheep milk and dairy products (Maslankova et al., 2009). A comparative study of staphylococci from goats and cows from the same region (Cremonesi et al., 2006) showed that sed (65.5%) and sea (51.7%) were the most common classical enterotoxin-encoding genes in bovine staphylococci, while goat staphylococci harbored mainly sec (97.3%).
The present study corroborates the majority of reports worldwide indicating a higher frequency of novel as compared to classic enterotoxigenic genes in staphylococci (Jorgensen et al., 2005; Loncarenvic et al., 2005; Rall et al., 2008; Zouharova and Rysanek, 2008; Karahan et al., 2009). The results were similar to those reported by Scherrer et al. (2004) in Switzerland, who detected the genes seg (10.6%), sej (8.9%), and sei (8.2%) in staphylococci from goat milk.
The most common combination of enterotoxin-encoding genes was seg and sei, found in 44.5% of isolates. This finding has been previously reported in Brazil (Rall et al., 2008, 2010; Vasconcelos et al., 2011).
There is a lack of information about the occurrence of enterotoxin-encoding genes in staphylococci from goat milk in Brazil. Although the present study showed that the majority of isolates harboring enterotoxigenic genes were identified as S. aureus, the high numbers of CoNS in goat milk and the detection of enterotoxigenic genes in CoNS reinforce the need to establish regulatory standards for total Staphylococcus spp. counts in goat milk, and not only for CoPS as recommended in the current legislation.
The detection of enterotoxin-encoding genes in goat milk highlights the need for improvements in surveillance programs in order to estimate the real impact of goat milk and dairy products on public health. While one could argue that the frequency of enterotoxin-encoding genes was low in the present study, the cultural habit of consumption of raw milk by rural populations raises special concern, since it potentiates the probability of acquiring zoonotic infections. Public health risks associated with the consumption of bovine raw milk is well documented (Oliver et al., 2009) and should be further investigated for goat milk. Studies to raise knowledge about the host specificity of staphylococci harboring enterotoxin-encoding genes are warranted.
Finally, the results of the present investigation indicate the need to improve veterinary assistance and extension programs targeting education in rural communities in order to decrease microbial contamination in raw milk and warrant market competitiveness for smallholders.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
We thank CNPq for grants (Proc. 557593/2009-3) and a scholarship to D.L. (Proc. 554302/2010-1).
Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
