Abstract
Differentiating between illness caused by community-acquired respiratory pathogens versus infection by biothreat agents is a challenge. This review highlights respiratory and clinical features of category A and B potential biothreat agents that have respiratory features as their primary presenting signs and symptoms. Recent world events make such a reminder that the possibility of rare diseases and unlikely events can occur timely for clinicians, policymakers, and public health authorities. Despite some distinguishing features, nothing can replace good clinical acumen and a strong index of suspicion in the diagnosis of uncommon infectious diseases.
Differentiating between illness caused by community-acquired respiratory pathogens versus infection by biothreat agents is a challenge. This review highlights respiratory and clinical features of category A and B potential biothreat agents that have respiratory features as their primary presenting signs and symptoms. Recent world events make such a reminder that the possibility of rare diseases and unlikely events can occur timely for clinicians, policymakers, and public health authorities.
D
Twenty-sixty percent of patients with community-acquired pneumonia are hospitalized, with 10% to 20% requiring admission to the intensive care unit. 1 With US treatment guidelines for community-acquired pneumonia requiring early empirical treatment, there has been a decreased emphasis on determining the microbial cause; a specific pathogen was identified in only 38% of patients hospitalized with community-acquired pneumonia 2 and 50% of patients with severe community-acquired pneumonia. 1 In addition to influenza, other common causes of community-acquired pneumonia include Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae, Mycoplasma pneumoniae, and rhinovirus. Rapid multiplex diagnostics may provide presumptive diagnoses, but clinicians should remain vigilant with broad differential diagnoses. A routine patient with presumed community-acquired pneumonia could be the index patient in a biothreat attack but might be missed without a larger cluster of patients.
Recent world events, including the use of chemical agents in Syria and an attack in the United Kingdom with a Novichok nerve agent, demonstrate the ongoing potential use of weapons of mass destruction on civilian populations. Countries that have developed chemical weapons often also included biological weapons in their arsenals. A 2017 report by Harvard's Belfer Center on North Korea's bioweapon activities provides a case in point. 3 Using unclassified reports, defector testimonies, and interviews with subject matter experts, the report's authors argue that preparation for the threat is “urgent and necessary.” Moreover, North Korea is presumed to have assassinated Kim Jong-Un's half-brother with the nerve agent VX.
Therefore, we believe a reminder of potential biological weapons threats is timely. In 2002, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) assigned potential bioweapons threats to 3 categories, A, B, and C, with category A having the greatest potential to cause disruption and for which countermeasures were most needed. We focused our review on the agents in categories A and B that are known to cause respiratory manifestations as their primary means of presentation. 4 Other category A and B agents that may have respiratory manifestations, but in which these symptoms generally occur as later disease complications rather than as their primary presenting features, are listed in a separate section with more succinct descriptions. Both sections list the agents in alphabetical order.
Agents that Present Primarily with Respiratory Manifestations
Anthrax
Anthrax is a zoonosis of herbivores worldwide, caused by Bacillus anthracis, a Gram-positive spore-forming bacillus. Humans are infected by inoculation, ingestion, or inhalation of spores from infected animals or animal products. The 2001 outbreak of inhalational and cutaneous anthrax arising from mailed letters containing B. anthracis spores highlighted the risk of B. anthracis as a terrorist weapon.
Pulmonary Manifestations
Inhalational anthrax occurs after spores are inhaled. As the spores germinate in the tracheobronchial and mediastinal lymph nodes, they secrete edema toxin and lethal toxin, which interfere with host innate immune response and impair lymphocyte, neutrophil, and macrophage function. Patients develop fever, chills, fatigue, malaise, nonproductive cough, and gastrointestinal symptoms (nausea, vomiting). As the organisms proliferate, they cause a hemorrhagic lymphadenitis of the subcarinal, hilar, and paratracheal lymph nodes, yielding the characteristic “widened mediastinum” on chest x-ray or chest computed tomography (CT). 5 Although pulmonary infiltrates can occur, extensive consolidation is absent. Large pleural effusions may require thoracentesis. Prompt recognition and treatment is critical to prevent death, because organisms can cause bacteremia and systemic toxemia, in addition to hemorrhagic meningitis once the meninges are seeded.
A review of presenting symptoms from the 2001 outbreak 6 showed that the majority of patients had dyspnea, drenching sweats, and pleuritic chest pain; half had myalgias and headache; only 20% (2/10) had pharyngitis; and only 1 had rhinorrhea. The absence of those latter symptoms might help to distinguish anthrax from respiratory viruses, especially during cold and influenza season. An analytic approach for distinguishing influenzalike illness from anthrax was published, 7 in addition to an algorithm to discriminate anthrax from community-acquired pneumonia in cases and controls. 8 Using the presence or absence of mediastinal widening, altered mental status, and an elevated hematocrit, the authors discriminated inhalational anthrax from community-acquired pneumonia with high sensitivity and specificity.
Without an approved rapid diagnostic for inhalational anthrax, diagnosis requires a high index of suspicion. The preferred treatment for inhalational anthrax is ciprofloxacin plus a protein synthesis inhibitor like clindamycin or linezolid, along with antitoxin therapy (raxibacumab, obiltoxaximab, or anthrax immunoglobulin).
Glanders
Glanders, an exceedingly rare disease in humans, is caused by Burkholderia mallei, a nonmotile, facultative intracellular Gram-negative bacillus. The last naturally acquired case of glanders in the United States was reported in 1934, so any contemporary case should prompt consideration of an intentional release, a laboratory accident, 9 or close contact with an equine host in foreign enzootic locales. Given the significant mortality of the disease occurring in animal aerosol challenge studies, stability in aerosol, and infection by the respiratory route, it is regarded as a potential biothreat. Glanders occurs as an acute or chronic disease. The chronic form (“farcy” in humans) typically manifests as generalized lymphadenopathy, with multiple ulcerating, draining skin nodules and induration, thickening, and regional lymphatic nodularity.
Pulmonary Manifestations
Pulmonary involvement occurs after direct inhalation or via hematogenous spread. Infected individuals typically present with fever, rigors, myalgia, profound malaise, adenopathy, mucopurulent rhinitis with copious sputum, and pleuritic chest pain. Radiographic findings include segmental or lobar consolidation or nodular opacities. 10 Glanders can cause pulmonary cavitation, similar to tuberculosis, or abscesses in other organs, such as the liver and spleen. Systemic dissemination and septicemic glanders can occur regardless of entry portal and can be rapidly progressive, with additional manifestations of jaundice, diarrhea, and granulomatous and necrotizing lesions in any organ, especially the liver, spleen, and lungs. Its high mortality (up to 40% treated and 90% in untreated) requires prompt diagnosis. 10 Given that human cases are rare, there is a limited amount of data with respect to antibiotic treatment in humans. Sulfadiazine has been shown to be effective in animal studies and human cases. Proposed treatment of glanders consists of ceftazidime or meropenem for initial parenteral therapy, followed by oral therapy with trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole or doxycycline.
Melioidosis
Melioidosis is caused by the motile, facultative intracellular Gram-negative bacillus Burkholderia pseudomallei; which is endemic to Southeast Asia and northern Australia. In northeastern Thailand, B. pseudomallei causes 20% of community-acquired septicemia cases. 11 Individuals are usually infected by inhaling aerosols from contaminated soil, water, or mud or through percutaneous inoculation. Individuals with diseases that impair neutrophil function, such as diabetics and alcoholics, are at risk of severe manifestations. The potential ease of access to the organism, environmental stability, potential for antimicrobial resistance, direct infection by the respiratory route, and the significant morbidity associated with pulmonary infection make meliodosis a significant threat as a bioweapon.
Pulmonary Manifestations
Pneumonia is the most common clinical manifestation, with over 50% of patients presenting with primary pneumonia and a substantial proportion developing secondary pneumonia. 12 The pneumonia generally occurs acutely and is accompanied by septicemia and high mortality. Upper and lower lobes are affected with similar frequency, and multi-lobar involvement occurs in 30% of cases. 12 Chronic melioidosis pneumonia can mimic tuberculosis, with a predilection for the upper lobes or reactivation from a latent focus. 12 Similar to glanders, melioidosis can produce cavities in the lungs or other major organs. Bloody sputum occurs commonly in melioidosis and may help distinguish it from influenza or community-acquired pneumonia. First-line treatment of melioidosis consists of ceftazidime or meropenem for initial parenteral therapy, followed by eradication therapy with trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole or doxycycline.
Plague
Plague, caused by the Gram-negative organism Yersinia pestis, remains endemic around the world, including in the United States, where a handful of cases occur every year. A large epidemic of plague, including pneumonic cases, recently occurred in Madagascar, which provides a reminder of this disease's epidemic potential. Infection usually occurs via an infected flea bite, which typically leads to bubonic plague. Symptoms include acute onset of fever, malaise, chills, headache, nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain. Within 24 hours, an extremely painful, swollen lymph node (a bubo) develops proximal to the flea bite. Lymph nodes involved include femoral, inguinal, axillary, and cervical, in descending order of frequency. Some patients present with a tender palpable liver and/or spleen or an acute abdomen.13,14
Most individuals develop bacteremia, which can be self-limited or lead to septicemic plague and subsequent spread to the meninges (causing plague meningitis) or the lungs (causing pneumonic plague). 15
Pulmonary Manifestations
Pneumonic plague can occur “secondary” to bacteremia or primarily from person-to-person spread via respiratory droplets or by intentionally released aerosol. Patients may develop chest pain, cough with tachypnea, dyspnea, and hypoxia. Initial purulent sputum may become blood-tinged or grossly hemorrhagic; 14 the presence of hemoptysis helps differentiate plague from other more common causes of pneumonia.
Chest x-ray findings in plague are variable, with patchy consolidated bronchopneumonia, frequently bilateral, and cavities or confluent consolidation and may appear more concerning than the exam might indicate initially. 5 Gentamicin or streptomycin is used for the treatment of pneumonic plague. Doxycycline or ciprofloxacin are used for postexposure prophylaxis.
Psittacosis
Psittacosis is a zoonotic disease caused by the bacterium Chlamydia psittaci. Numerous species of domesticated and wild birds are susceptible to the disease. Individuals at highest risk include those with direct contact with birds: bird owners, pet store and aviary employees, poultry workers, and veterinarians. 16 Psittacosis was introduced to the United States secondary to a pandemic in 1929. Fewer than 10 cases of the disease have been reported per year since 2010, mostly in the western United States; however, experts believe the disease is potentially underdiagnosed and underreported. 17 Outbreaks of the disease have been identified among workers on poultry farms. The United States studied psittacosis as a potential biological weapon in the offensive biological warfare program that existed until it was closed in 1969.
Pulmonary Manifestations
Clinical symptoms develop within 5 to 14 days and include fever, chills, headache, muscle aches, and productive cough. In the majority of cases, respiratory manifestations of psittacosis are limited to cough; consequently, it is most likely a disease that is underdiagnosed, as people with milder cases may not seek medical attention. A minority of patients develop pneumonia or, alternatively, respiratory failure secondary to pulmonary edema. Despite variability in patient presentation, approximately 80% of cases will require hospital admission. Chest x-ray findings are initially normal and remain normal in approximately a third of patients; in more severe cases, air space consolidation and ground-glass attenuation of the lung is denoted bilaterally on chest x-ray. 18 In patients with abnormal chest x-rays, their imaging will return to normal baseline after a mean of 7.2 weeks. Prompt antibiotic therapy is key to mitigating disease morbidity and mortality: Tetracycline and doxycycline are the antibiotics of choice. Treating patients for 2 to 3 weeks prevents relapse.
Q Fever
Q (for Query) fever is caused by the rickettsialike, Gram-negative organism Coxiella burnetii. Q fever occurs worldwide, except in New Zealand. Unlike brucellosis, there is an extensive wildlife reservoir, although the primary reservoirs are sheep, cattle, and goats. Cats, dogs, and rabbits can also become infected. Ticks can serve as both reservoirs and vectors, but they are primarily involved in transmission among animal species.19,20
Infected animals are usually asymptomatic, but Coxiella localizes in the uterus and mammary glands and is known for causing spontaneous abortion. Massive amounts of organisms (up to 109 guinea pig infective doses per gram of tissue) in placental tissues put animal handlers at risk. 19 Others who work closely with animals or animal carcasses are at occupational risk, including abattoir workers, veterinarians, and farmers. Vehicles kicking up dust on roads around farms have been known to spread organisms.21,22 Rarer modes of infection include skinning of infected animals, ingestion of raw milk, and inhalational lab exposure.23-25
Like Bacillus anthracis, Coxiella burnetii has a hardy, spore-like stage. Unlike anthrax, it has a very low infective dose of approximately 1 to 10 organisms, which makes Coxiella a potential bioweapon agent. The incubation period can range from a few days to several weeks, with the severity of infection varying related to the infectious dose. 26
Acute Coxiella infection can present as pneumonia, hepatitis, bradycardia, osteomyelitis, meningoencephalitis, Guillain-Barré syndrome, mononeuropathy, optic neuritis, pericarditis, myocarditis, anemia, bone marrow necrosis, thrombocytosis, thrombocytopenia, splenic rupture, or erythema nodosum. Approximately 1% to 2% of untreated individuals can progress over months to years to chronic Q fever disease, with endocarditis as the most common long-term complication. Because of the difficulty in growing this organism, these cases often present as “culture-negative” endocarditis. Having preexisting valvular abnormalities is a risk factor. Osteomyelitis may also occur, especially with preexisting bone disease or prosthetic hardware. Pregnancy can be complicated by fetal death, prematurity, or low birth weight if infection occurs during the first or second trimester.19,20
Pulmonary Manifestations
Q fever pneumonia typically presents with high fever lasting 1 to 2 weeks, chills, sweats, headache, myalgias, shortness of breath, cough (productive and nonproductive), and chest pain. Occasionally, respiratory symptoms are accompanied by GI symptoms: anorexia, abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea. Physical findings may include hypoxemia, bradycardia, tachypnea, decreased breath sounds, crackles, and/or rhonchi. Chest imaging either by x-ray or CT is most often nonspecific and may reveal unilateral or bilateral lobar, segmental, or patchy infiltrates. Hilar lymphadenopathy and pleural effusions also can be seen. “Round pneumonia” infiltrates (5-10 cm) in the lower lobes have been associated with Q fever in outbreak settings.19,20,27,28 Generally, 2% to 5% of acute Q fever cases result in disease severe enough to require hospitalization, although that increased to 21% in a recent large outbreak in the Netherlands (2007-2009). Of those hospitalized, 29% were characterized as having severe Q fever pneumonia. Median duration of hospitalization for the Q fever pneumonia cohort was 5 days (IQR 3-7), while direct mortality related to Q fever pneumonia was 1.1%; all-cause 2-year mortality related to Q fever was 6%. 29 Q fever pneumonia is treated with doxycycline. Moxifloxacin, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, and clarithromycin or azithromycin are alternative agents.
Ricin
Ricin is a potent cellular toxin derived from the castor bean.30,31 In fact, the “waste mash” resulting from the production of castor oil contains 3% to 5% ricin by weight. This fact, combined with the worldwide availability of castor beans and the low degree of technological sophistication necessary to extract the toxin, has led to the inclusion of ricin among the CDC's category B agents of bioterrorism. A potent inhibitor of protein synthesis, the bi-chain ricin molecule is toxic via multiple routes of exposure, including inhalation.
Pulmonary Manifestations
The pulmonary effects of inhalational ricin exposure are dose-dependent. Data derived from accidental sublethal exposures in humans document the development, within 4 to 8 hours, of fever, nausea, cough, dyspnea, chest tightness, and arthralgia. Based on experimental animal data, exposure to higher doses is likely to result in the necrosis of respiratory epithelium, with resultant tracheitis, bronchitis, interstitial pneumonia, perivascular edema, and alveolar flooding. Death in these animals typically occurred within 36 to 72 hours after exposure. Chest radiographs would likely demonstrate the nonspecific findings associated with bilateral pneumonitis and severe pulmonary edema. 32 Diagnosis depends on a high index of suspicion in the proper epidemiologic context. Lack of mediastinal involvement may help differentiate ricin intoxication from anthrax, and a failure to respond to antibiotics further supports a nonbacterial etiology. Ricin intoxication acquired via ingestion or percutaneous exposure is not likely to produce significant pulmonary symptoms. There is no specific antitoxin for ricin, and treatment is largely supportive.
Staphylococcal Enterotoxin B
The bacteria Staphylococcus aureus produces several toxins, one of which is staphylococcal enterotoxin type B (SEB). The toxin is referred to as an enterotoxin because of its primary effect on the intestine. This toxin is one of several that causes food poisoning in humans who ingest foods that have been stored or handled improperly. Alternatively, this agent can be aerosolized, which produces minimal mortality at low doses but can cause severe incapacitation. During the US offensive biological weapons program, SEB was studied extensively as an incapacitating weapon by the inhalational route. The incapacitating dose in 50% of humans was determined to be 0.0004 ug/kg, and the estimated lethal dose in 50% (LD50) was at 0.02 uk/kg. 33 Latent period depends on route of exposure: 3 to 12 hours for inhalation versus 4 to 12 hours for ingestion. An increased index of clinical suspicion in conjunction with a correlating epidemiologic history is necessary for diagnosis. 34
Pulmonary Manifestations
Cases exposed to inhaled toxin present with fever, chills, headache, myalgia, and cough. Inhalational exposure to SEB results in persistent fever (103°F to 106°F), which can last up to 5 days, along with accompanying prodromal symptoms. Cough may persist for up to 4 weeks. Most cases are self-limited, so chest x-ray is usually unremarkable; however, in patients with more severe illness, atelectasis or corresponding increase in lung markings may be present. A limited number of cases progress to pulmonary edema or acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Antibiotics have not shown efficacy in the treatment of SEB; supportive care is the mainstay of clinical treatment. 35
Tularemia
Tularemia is caused by the pleomorphic, Gram-negative coccobacillus Francisella tularensis. 36 The low infectious dose and the organism's hardiness in the environment justify concerns for its use as a potential bioweapon.
The disease primarily occurs in the northern hemisphere, and approximately 100 to 200 cases are reported in the United States each year. 37 Infection occurs after direct contact with infected animals, inhalation or ingestion of the organism, arthropod bites, or laboratory exposure. There is no human-to-human transmission. Clinical presentations include localized (ulceroglandular) and systemic (typhoidal and pneumonic) forms. Symptoms include fever, headache, myalgias (typhoidal), lymphadenopathy and skin lesions (glandular and ulceroglandular), conjunctivitis (oculoglandular), cough and dyspnea (pneumonic), and nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and abdominal pain (oropharyngeal/gastrointestinal). 38
Pulmonary Manifestations
Pneumonic tularemia typically occurs after inhalational exposure, but it can occur secondarily via hematogenous dissemination after gastrointestinal or cutaneous inoculation. With pneumonia, initial symptoms are followed by the development of cough, dyspnea, hemoptysis, and chest pain. Chest x-ray findings are nonspecific and may range from normal to patchy bilateral or unilateral infiltrates that may cavitate, hilar lymphadenopathy, pleural effusions, and granulomas. 39 Early recognition is important, as reported case fatality rates in untreated patients are as high as 60% for pneumonic and other severe forms of the disease, but drop to 2% with treatment in the United States. 40 The drugs of choice for tularemia are streptomycin or gentamicin, although the former is difficult to obtain and the latter is used with less and less frequency in the United States. Patients with mild to moderate disease may be treated with oral agents, including ciprofloxacin or doxycycline.
Agents with Limited Respiratory Manifestations or Other Distinguishing Features
Botulism
Eight serotypes of Clostridium botulinum produce neurotoxins that cause botulism, which usually occurs after foodborne toxin ingestion. Serotypes A, B, and E (rarely F) cause naturally occurring disease in humans. Botulism does not cause cough or sputum production, and victims are generally afebrile. Pulmonary symptoms would be related to the paralytic manifestations, including difficulty maintaining an open airway, and potentially progressing to respiratory failure from diaphragmatic paralysis. Antitoxin therapy is the main treatment option for botulism.
Brucellosis
Although inhalation of contaminated aerosols is the primary route of exposure for brucellosis in laboratory or abattoir workers, frank pulmonary signs and symptoms or pneumonia occur rarely.41-43 Bacteremia may seed the lungs following exposure via other routes.41,44 Pulmonary brucellosis, accounting for 0.6% to 7% of cases, may manifest solely as a chest x-ray abnormality or as part of a syndromic illness.41,43,45 Pulmonary manifestations include lymphadenopathy (hilar and paratracheal), granuloma, pleural effusion, empyema, bronchopneumonia, and lung abscess.41,43,46-48 Most cases of pulmonary brucellosis are not life threatening and respond rapidly to treatment. 45
Multiple imaging modalities may be used to assess for abscesses or granulomas, including chest x-ray, plain films of areas of concern, CT/MRI, ultrasound, or technetium/gallium scans. Brucellosis is treated with doxycycline plus streptomycin or gentamicin, or with doxycycline plus rifampin.
Smallpox
Smallpox presents with a high fever, headache, backache, and other systemic complaints. After a few days, patients develop a synchronous pustular rash that is more prominent on the face and extremities than the trunk. Although patients may develop pneumonia as a complication, the major manifestations are due to the exanthem and enanthem in the respiratory and gastrointestinal systems, respectively. Smallpox virus is stable in the environment and highly infectious via the aerosol route. Smallpox (Variola) virus was eradicated by the World Health Organization's global eradication campaign, which ended in 1980. 49 Minimal use of vaccination for decades has left a significant portion of the global population immunologically naïve and highly vulnerable, which creates the potential for significant devastation and risk of spread from a bioweapon attack.
Viral Hemorrhagic Fevers
Four families of single-stranded RNA viruses—arenaviruses, bunyaviruses, flaviviruses, and filoviruses—cause viral hemorrhagic fever. Among these, the arenaviruses (Lassa, new world arenaviruses) and filoviruses (Ebola, Marburg) are considered potential bioweapons threats. Patients present with fever, myalgias, maculopapular rash, and conjunctival injection, followed by gastrointestinal manifestations. As the illness progresses, patients may develop multi-organ failure, vascular leak, or bleeding manifestations. Pulmonary manifestations may occur but usually from pulmonary edema during volume resuscitation. Hantavirus pulmonary syndrome, caused by new world hantaviruses, has characteristic pulmonary features, but these viruses are generally not considered viable bioweapon threats because of the difficulty of growing these agents in large concentrations.
Diagnostics
Although some of the diseases discussed in this review have potential distinguishing features, the nonspecific nature of many, especially early in the illness, makes the use of optimal diagnostic tools imperative. Rapid diagnostic assays for influenza (rapid influenza diagnostic tests, or RIDTs) are important for distinguishing this common cause of respiratory illness from other diseases discussed in this review, and these continue to evolve, but their sensitivity and specificity remain suboptimal. The type of sample collected and time from illness onset dramatically affect test accuracy. Moreover, some rapid influenza diagnostic tests are specific for influenza A or B, but not both. However, their rapidity (often as short as 20 minutes) compared with viral culture (which often requires 3 to 10 days) makes rapid influenza diagnostic tests appealing.
Diagnostics for the other infectious agents listed in this review usually include blood culture, Gram stain or other special stains, and PCR of blood, sputum, or specific lesions. With some exceptions, these approaches are useful only while the pathogen is present in the bodily fluid or tissue; therefore, the diagnostic window is short for some infections. Additionally, PCR-based diagnostics are pathogen-specific, requiring a reasonable pretest hypothesis.
Newer exploratory diagnostic assays focus on pathogen-agnostic—or at least multiplex—approaches to identifying infecting pathogens. Multiple platforms using multiplex PCR aim to enable pathogen identification in the absence of a clear presumptive diagnosis,50-52 and the potential applications of CRISPR-based diagnostics might enable development of a new class of nucleic acid–based diagnostics that combine diagnosis with treatment. 53 The only truly pathogen-agnostic approach to pathogen identification and potentially to pathogen discovery, however, is next-generation sequencing (NGS)–based approaches. Advances in portable sequencing technology are raising the possibility of one day enabling sequencing-based diagnostics in the field, as well as in outer space.54-56 However, the technology supporting that end is still in development, and issues with both front-end sample processing and back-end data analysis need to be considered.57-59 A thorough review of culture-independent approaches has recently been published. 60 As with influenza diagnostics, however, negative diagnostic results are often inconclusive.
Serologic assays are available for most agents discussed in this review, but they are beneficial only weeks after acute infection. Laboratory diagnostics to consider are listed in Table 1. If not available locally, diagnostics for biothreat agents can be accessed through local or state health departments, through the laboratory response network, or through the CDC.
Laboratory Diagnostic Testing for Biothreat Agents
Note: CSF = cerebrospinal fluid; LRN = Laboratory Response Network.
Discussion
Recent world events prompt the need for a reminder to clinicians and public health practitioners of the potential for bioterrorism events and other unexpected disease activity. We elected to focus this review on potential biothreat agents that present primarily with respiratory features and on differentiating them from community-acquired pneumonia, a step critical to the selection of proper therapy. Often-recommended empiric outpatient treatment regimens for community-acquired pneumonia in adults without co-morbidities include azithromycin and clarithromycin, which have little efficacy against the majority of category A and B threat agents. Conversely, doxycycline, also recommended for empiric therapy of adult community-acquired pneumonia, does have efficacy against anthrax, plague, tularemia, glanders, melioidosis, psittacosis, and Q fever, although it would likely prove inadequate when given alone. In adults with community-acquired pneumonia and co-morbid conditions, fluoroquinolones are often recommended. Again, these have efficacy against anthrax, plague, and tularemia but not against other agents. Moreover, they, too, are often inadequate in many cases when given as monotherapy. Therefore, following current guidelines for treating community-acquired pneumonia, if either a quinolone or doxycycline is selected, there may be partial coverage by chance of anthrax, plague, and tularemia.
In children, the situation is even more problematic. Amoxicillin, Augmentin, and azithromycin, all used frequently for community-acquired pneumonia, are likely to prove inadequate when used alone against any category A or B threat agent.
The threats covered in this review may present initially as nonspecific febrile illnesses (Table 2). Later in the illness, without adequate treatment, some may develop characteristic features that could help distinguish them from community-acquired pneumonia (Table 3). In some cases, chest imaging may help (Table 4). Anthrax causes a widened mediastinum on chest x-ray. Pneumonic plague presents with bloody sputum and severe sepsis. Glanders and melioidosis can present with bloody sputum and multiple cavitary lesions in the lungs, as well as in other major organs. The more difficult infections to distinguish include Q fever, which may have minimal pulmonary findings or a chest x-ray more concerning than the clinical illness; tularemia; SEB exposure; and psittacosis, which may not have any specific distinguishing features.
Hallmark Clinical Symptoms of Category A/B Biothreat Agents, Early Clinical Symptoms that May Occur on Presentation for Care
Hallmark Clinical Symptoms of Category A/B Biothreat Agents, Late Clinical Signs/Symptoms Without Adequate Treatment
Chest Imaging for Specific Biothreat Agents
The absence of rhinorrhea or pharyngitis may aid in defining an appropriate differential diagnosis. These 2 features were not widely seen during the 2001 anthrax attacks, although some of the diseases mentioned here can also have upper respiratory findings. For example, oropharyngeal anthrax can cause tonsillar exudates and cervical adenopathy. Pharyngeal plague carriers can have asymptomatic colonization with organisms grown from the pharynx. Tularemia pharyngitis can occur in both ulceroglandular and typhoidal tularemia. Overall, 25% of cases present with acute exudative pharyngitis or tonsillitis, with or without mucosal ulceration or cervical adenopathy. Although not associated with pharyngitis, melioidosis is known for causing acute parotitis. Varieties of oronasal glanders also can occur.
Identifying any of these diseases first requires a thorough history and physical exam, as well as a basic knowledge about the natural epidemiology of the diseases, so that a more detailed exposure history can be obtained. Armed with this information, the frontline clinician needs to be a trained observer and be willing to consider the rare “zebra” when they hear hoof beats, because with all these diseases, nothing can replace a healthy index of suspicion for the unusual and the knowledge of how to obtain the appropriate diagnostics.
