Abstract
The humanized bone marrow-liver-thymus (BLT) mouse model harbors a nearly complete human immune system, therefore providing a powerful tool to study human immunology and immunotherapy. However, its application is greatly limited by the restricted supply of human CD34+ hematopoietic stem cells and fetal thymus tissues that are needed to generate these mice. The restriction is especially significant for the study of human immune systems with special genetic traits, such as certain human leukocyte antigen (HLA) haplotypes or monogene deficiencies. To circumvent this critical limitation, we have developed a method to quickly propagate established BLT mice. Through secondary transfer of bone marrow cells and human thymus implants from BLT mice into NSG (NOD/SCID/IL-2Rγ−/−) recipient mice, we were able to expand one primary BLT mouse into a colony of 4–5 proBLT (propagated BLT) mice in 6–8 weeks. These proBLT mice reconstituted human immune cells, including T cells, at levels comparable to those of their primary BLT donor mouse. They also faithfully inherited the human immune cell genetic traits from their donor BLT mouse, such as the HLA-A2 haplotype that is of special interest for studying HLA-A2-restricted human T cell immunotherapies. Moreover, an EGFP reporter gene engineered into the human immune system was stably passed from BLT to proBLT mice, making proBLT mice suitable for studying human immune cell gene therapy. This method provides an opportunity to overcome a critical hurdle to utilizing the BLT humanized mouse model and enables its more widespread use as a valuable preclinical research tool.
Introduction
S
Because it supports the development and maintenance of a nearly complete and functional human immune system, the humanized BLT mouse model is a promising tool to study human hematopoiesis and immune cell activities under healthy and disease conditions [1,2]. It is particularly useful for studies of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection because of the high frequencies of human T cells in the lymphoid and mucosal tissues of BLT mice, as well as because of the proper maturation status and lineage differentiation of these human T cells [14 –16]. To date, studies using BLT mice have generated valuable knowledge in many aspects of HIV infection, including prevention, mucosal transmission, HIV-specific innate and adaptive immunity, viral latency, and novel anti-retroviral and immune-based therapies for suppression and reservoir eradication [14 –17]. The humanized BLT mouse model is also ideal for the study of hematopoietic stem cell (HSC)- and T cell-based immunotherapies, because of the long-term engraftment of human HSCs and T cells in BLT mice [10,11]. We and others have utilized BLT mice for the preclinical development of gene-modified HSC-based immunotherapies for treating cancer and HIV [18,19]. Despite its potential as a valuable research tool, the application of BLT mice is greatly limited by the restricted supply of human CD34+ cells and human fetal liver and thymus tissues that are required to generate these mice. The restriction is especially problematic for the study of human immune systems with special genetic traits, such as certain human leukocyte antigen (HLA) haplotypes or immune monogene deficiencies [19 –22].
To circumvent this critical limitation, we have developed a method to quickly propagate established BLT mice without the need of additional human tissues. We hypothesized that human CD34+ cells engrafted into the bone marrow of a primary BLT mouse retained their HSC potential and could repopulate a human immune system in multiple naïve NSG mice through secondary bone marrow transfer; meanwhile, the human thymus organoid established in a primary BLT mouse maintained a human thymus structure and could be split and transplanted into the secondary recipient NSG mice to provide a human thymus microenvironment supporting proper human T cell development. In the present article, we demonstrated the feasibility of this new method to expand a single primary BLT mouse into a colony of 4–5 proBLT (propagated BLT) mice in 6–8 weeks, and we provided evidence to support the potential research value of these proBLT mice.
Materials and Methods
Mice and materials
NOD.Cg-PrkdcSCIDIl2rgtm1Wjl/SzJ (NOD/SCID/IL-2Rγ−/−, NSG) mice were purchased from the Jackson Laboratory and maintained in the animal facilities at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA). Six- to 10-week-old females were used for all experiments, unless otherwise indicated. All animal experiments were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of UCLA.
X-VIVO-15 cell culture medium was purchased from Lonza. Recombinant human Flt3 ligand, stem cell factor (SCF), thrombopoietin (TPO), IL-3, and Fixable Viability Dye eFluor506 were purchased from affymetrix eBioscience. Retronectin® was purchased from Clontech.
Antibodies and flow cytometry
Fluorochrome-conjugated antibodies that were specific for human CD45, TCRαβ, CD11b, CD11c, CD14, CD19, CD56, and HLA-A2 were purchased from BioLegend; those specific for human CD34 were purchased from BD Biosciences. Human Fc Receptor Blocking Solution (TruStain FcX™) was purchased from BioLegend, whereas mouse Fc Block (anti-mouse CD16/32) was purchased from BD Biosciences. Cells were stained as previously described and analyzed by using an MACSQuant Analyzer 10 flow cytometer (Miltenyi Biotec) [23]. FlowJo software was used to analyze the data.
Tissue processing for flow cytometry analysis
For flow cytometry analysis, all tissues were processed into mononuclear cells (MNCs) and lysed of red blood cells (RBCs). Blood and bone marrow samples were directly lysed with Tris-buffered ammonium chloride (TAC) buffer, following a standard protocol (Cold Spring Harbor Protocols). Spleens were smashed against a 70 μm cell strainer (Corning) to prepare single cells and then lysed with TAC. Livers were cut into small pieces by using a pair of scissors, smashed against a 70 μm cell strainer to prepare single cells, and passed through a 33% Percoll gradient isolation (Sigma) to remove hepatocytes, followed by TAC lysis.
Human CD34+ cells and thymus tissues
Human fetal liver CD34+ HSPCs, as well as fetal thymus tissues, were obtained from the CFAR Gene and Cellular Therapy Core Laboratory at UCLA, without identification information under federal and state regulations. CD34+ cells were sorted from fetal liver cells through magnetic-activated cell sorting by using a Direct CD34 Progenitor Cell Isolation Kit (Miltenyi Biotec) following the manufacturer's instructions [18]. The purity of CD34+ cells was more than 97%, as evaluated by flow cytometry.
pMND-EGFP lentiviruses
pMND-EGFP lentiviral vector was constructed by inserting an EGFP reporter gene into the lentivector that contains the MND retroviral LTR U2 region as an internal promoter [24]. VsVg-pseudotyped pMND-EGFP lentiviruses were produced by using HEK293.T cells, following a standard calcium precipitation protocol and an ultracentrifugation concentration protocol as previously described [25].
Generation of humanized BLT Mice
Humanized BLT mice were generated as previously described, with certain modifications [10,11]. In brief, human CD34+ cells were cultured for no more than 48 h in X-VIVO-15 cell culture medium containing recombinant human Flt3 ligand (50 ng/mL), SCF (50 ng/mL), TPO (50 ng/mL), and IL-3 (20 ng/mL) in nontissue culture-treated plates coated with Retronectin. Viral transduction, when applicable, was performed at 24 h by adding concentrated pMND-EGFP lentiviruses directly to the culture medium. At around 48 h, CD34+ cells were collected and i.v. injected into NSG recipient mice (∼0.5–1 × 106 CD34+ cells per recipient) that had received 270 rads of total body irradiation. Then, 1–2 fragments of human fetal thymus (∼1 mm3), as well as donor-matched fetal liver CD34− cells, when available (∼4.5 × 106), were implanted under the kidney capsule of each recipient NSG mouse. The mice were maintained on trimethoprim/sulfmethoxazole (TMS) chow in a sterile environment for 8–12 weeks until analysis or use for further experiments.
Generation of humanized proBLT Mice
Humanized proBLT (propagated BLT) mice were generated through adoptive transfer of bone marrow cells and human thymus organoid implant fragments from BLT mice into secondary recipient NSG mice that had received 270 rads of total body irradiation. On the day of transfer, one primary BLT mouse was dissected. Total bone marrow cells harvested from the femur and tibia of the BLT mouse were split equally and i.v. injected into 4–5 recipient NSG mice. On average, about 40–50 × 106 total bone marrow cells were harvested from each primary BLT donor mouse, whereas about 10 × 106 total BLT bone marrow cells were given to each NSG recipient mouse. Meanwhile, human thymus organoid was dissected out from the kidney capsule of a BLT mouse, cut into pieces of ∼1 mm3, and surgically implanted under the kidney capsule of the secondary recipient NSG mice (1–2 human thymus organoid pieces per recipient). The mice were maintained on TMS chow in a sterile environment for 8–12 weeks until analysis or use for further experiments.
Immunohistology
Primary human fetal thymus tissue or human thymus organoid implants dissected out from the experimental BLT or proBLT mice were fixed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin and embedded in paraffin for sectioning (4 μm thickness), followed by hematoxylin and eosin (H/E) staining or antibody staining (for human CD45 or CD3) by using standard procedures (UCLA Translational Pathology Core Laboratory). The sections were imaged by using an Olympus BX51 upright microscope equipped with an Optronics Macrofire CCD camera (AU Optronics) at 40 × , 100 × , and 400 × magnifications. The images were analyzed by using Optronics PictureFrame software (AU Optronics).
Statistical analysis
Student's two-tailed t test was used for paired comparisons. Data are presented as mean ± SEM, unless otherwise indicated. P < 0.05 was considered significant.
Results
Generation of BLT mice
We generated humanized BLT mice by following previously established procedures, with certain modifications (Materials and Methods section; Fig. 1A). In brief, cryopreserved human fetal liver CD34+ cells were thawed and cultured for no more than 48 h in X-VIVO-15 medium containing recombinant human Flt3 ligand, SCF, TPO, and IL-3. Viral transduction, when applicable, was performed at 24 h by adding concentrated lentiviral vectors directly to the culture medium. At around 48 h, CD34+ cells were collected and i.v. injected into NOD/SCID/IL-2Rγc−/− (NSG) recipient mice (∼0.5–1 × 106 CD34+ cells per recipient) that had received 270 rads of total body irradiation. On the same day, 1–2 fragments of human fetal thymus (∼1 mm3), as well as donor-matched fetal liver CD34− cells, when available (∼4.5 × 106), were implanted under the kidney capsule of each recipient NSG mouse. The resulting BLT mice were allowed to reconstitute a human immune system, whereas periodic bleedings were performed to monitor the presence of human immune cells (gated as hCD45+, Fig. 1B, D). We started to detect human immune cells in BLT mice at 4 weeks post human tissue transplantation. The levels of human immune cells gradually increased over time and then peaked and stabilized at around week 12 (Fig. 1B). In our experiments, we routinely obtained ∼30–80% human immune cell reconstitution in the blood of BLT mice. Data from a representative experiment showing ∼40% human immune cell reconstitution are presented (Fig. 1B, D). In our studies, we found that transfer of fetal liver (either tissue fragments or CD34− cells) was optional for making BLT mice. We also found that human CD34+ cells and human fetal thymus used for making BLT mice did not need to be donor matched, making it flexible to use CD34+ cells isolated from fetal liver, cord blood, adult bone marrow, or G-CSF-mobilized adult peripheral blood. The reconstitution efficiency was ranked as the following: fetal liver CD34+ cells > cord blood CD34+ > adult CD34+ cells (data not shown). In this article, data from BLT mice made with fetal liver CD34+ cells (either donor matched or -unmatched with fetal thymus tissue) are presented. Notably, when nondonor matched CD34+ cells and fetal thymus are used to produce BLT mice, such BLT mice can still be valuable tools to study human immune cell development, but certain precautions need to be taken when using these mice to study human T cell immunity. In these BLT mice, T cell function may be affected by the HLA mismatch between human T cells developed in these mice (selected on fetal thymus HLAs) and human APCs generated in these mice (derived from CD34+ cells and, therefore, carrying their HLAs). For certain research, a partial HLA match (e.g., HLA-A2+) may still allow for the study of defined types of T cell responses (e.g., HLA-A2-restricted T cell response).

Generation of proBLT mice through secondary transfer of bone marrow cells and human thymus implants from primary BLT mice to naïve NSG mice. The experiments were repeated over six times. Representative results are presented.
Generation of propagated BLT mice
Humanized propagated BLT (proBLT) mice were generated through secondary transfer of bone marrow cells and human thymus organoid fragments harvested from BLT mice into naïve recipient NSG mice that had received 270 rads of total body irradiation (Fig. 1A). Primary BLT mice at 12 weeks post primary human tissue transplant were used as donor mice. Total bone marrow cells harvested from one BLT mouse (∼40–50 × 106 cells) were split equally and i.v. injected into 4–5 recipient NSG mice (∼10 × 106 cells per recipient). Meanwhile, human thymus organoid dissected out from the BLT mouse was cut into pieces of ∼1 mm3, and it was then surgically implanted under the kidney capsule of the recipient NSG mice (1–2 human thymus organoid pieces per recipient). The resulting proBLT mice were allowed to reconstitute a human immune system, whereas periodic bleedings were performed to monitor the generation of human immune cells (gated as hCD45+; Fig. 1C, D). Interestingly, human immune cells were reconstituted more quickly in proBLT mice compared with those in BLT mice, peaking and stabilizing at around week 6 (Fig. 1C). The faster human immune cell reconstitution in proBLT mice was likely due to their inheritance of both early and intermediate human hematopoietic progenitor cells, as well as mature human immune cells, from the bone marrow of donor BLT mice. Notably, because the bone marrow cells and human thymus organoid implant harvested from a single BLT mouse could be used to generate 4–5 proBLT mice, these proBLT mice contain a human immune system including a human T cell educational microenvironment genetically identical to that of their donor BLT mouse and, thus, can be considered “clonal” (Fig. 1A). Post stabilization, the human immune cell reconstitution levels are consistent among individual “clonal” proBLT mice and similar to those of the primary BLT donor mouse (Fig. 1C, D). Therefore, the proBLT approach allows the expansion of established BLT mice to a large homogeneous colony in a short period of time, while also maintaining the “clonal” nature of the engrafted human immune system. These features are especially attractive for studies that are large scale and require specific genetic traits of human immune cells such as MHC haplotypes or immune monogene deficiencies [19 –22].
Reconstitution of multilineage human immune cells in proBLT mice
To study the human immune cell reconstitution in proBLT mice, we performed a systemic analysis of these mice in comparison with their “parental” BLT mouse. Data from a representative analysis are presented in Fig. 2. High percentages of human immune cells were detected in all immune-homing tissues of proBLT mice, including peripheral blood (∼80%), central lymphoid organs such as bone marrow (∼80%) and spleen (∼80%), and immune regulatory organs such as liver (>90%), at levels similar to those of their primary donor BLT mouse (Fig. 2A). Lineage analysis revealed the reconstitution of a nearly complete human immune system in these proBLT mice, including adaptive immune cells such as TCRαβ+ T cells and CD19+ B cells, as well as innate immune cells such as CD56+ natural killer (NK) cells, CD11b+ myeloid cells, CD11c+ dendritic cells, and CD14+ monocytes/macrophages, with a composition similar to that of the primary BLT mouse (Fig. 2B–D). Notably, in the primary BLT mice, we detected high numbers of human CD34+ HSPCs (gated as hCD45+Lin−hCD34+) that were enriched in the bone marrow (comprising ∼10% of total hCD45+ cells) but not in other tissues such as liver and spleen (comprising <0.4% of total hCD45+ cells) (Fig. 2B). This observation suggests that the initial transplants of human fetal liver CD34+ HSPCs were able to home to the proper HSC niche in the recipient NSG mice and expand, while still maintaining their characteristic longevity and multi-potential to repopulate a nearly complete human immune system. Encouragingly, a similarly high percentage of human CD34+ HSPCs (∼10%) were detected in the bone marrow of proBLT mice, indicating the ability of these human CD34+ HSPCs to survive the secondary bone marrow transfer and to repopulate the secondary NSG recipient mice, which was key to the success of the proBLT method (Fig. 2C).

Reconstitution of multilineage human immune cells in proBLT mice. The experiments were repeated at least three times. Representative results are presented from BLT and proBLT mice at 8–12 weeks post the primary human tissue or secondary BLT tissue transfer (n = 4–5 per experimental group). All tissues were processed into mononuclear cells and lysed of red blood cells for flow cytometry analysis (Materials and Methods section).
Reconstitution of human thymus and human T cells in proBLT mice
The most attractive feature of the BLT model is its capacity to support long-term systemic reconstitution of properly matured human T cells, which benefits from the presence of an authentic human thymus component [10,11]. Post insertion under the kidney capsule of NSG recipient mice, the implanted human fetal thymus fragments (∼1 mm3 in size; 1–2 pieces per implantation site) grow into human thymus organoids that support human T cell development [10,11]. In our experiments, these human thymus organoids could grow to a size of ∼20–200 mm3. The image of a representative organoid is presented in Fig. 3A. When generating proBLT mice, such an organoid was cut into ∼1 mm3 fragments and 1–2 pieces of these fragments were implanted under the kidney capsule of each secondary NSG recipient mouse (Materials and Methods section). In proBLT mice, secondary human thymus organoids were observed and grown to a size similar to that of the primary BLT mice. An immunohistology study revealed that both the BLT and proBLT human thymus organoids displayed a typical human thymus structure similar to that of the primary human fetal thymus, comprising a cortex region that could support the positive selection of human thymocytes for HLA recognition, and a medulla region that could support the negative selection of thymocytes for autoreactive T cell depletion (Fig. 3B, C). These human thymus organoids were populated with developing human thymocytes that had undergone T cell receptor (TCR) selection, evidenced by the positive immunochemical staining for human CD45 and CD3 markers (Fig. 3B). Interestingly, in the medulla of these human thymus organoids, we also observed abundant numbers of Hassall's corpuscles (HCs), structures that are unique to human thymus and have been implicated in regulating the development of human FoxP3+ regulatory T cells (Fig. 3C) [26]. These results indicate the reconstitution of a proper human thymus microenvironment in both BLT and proBLT mice.

Reconstitution of human thymus and human T cells in proBLT mice. The experiments were repeated at least three times. Representative results are presented from BLT and proBLT mice at 8–12 weeks post the primary human tissue or secondary BLT tissue transfer (n = 4–5 per experimental group).
Next, we analyzed the development and reconstitution of human T cells in proBLT mice. Similar to that in the human thymus organoid of BLT mice, human thymocytes (gated as hCD45+) in the human thymus organoid of proBLT mice expressed rearranged human αβ TCR receptors (stained as hTCRαβ+), and they seemed to follow a classical human T cell developmental path from DP (gated as CD4+CD8+) to CD4 or CD8 SP (gated as CD4+CD8− or CD4−CD8+, respectively) stages (Fig. 3D) [27]. Large numbers of mature human T cells (gated as hCD45+hTCRαβ+) were detected in various peripheral tissues of proBLT mice, including blood, spleen, bone marrow, and liver (Figs. 2 and 3). These T cells comprised both CD4+ helper and CD8+ cytotoxic T cell subsets, at a ratio similar to that observed in the primary BLT mice (Fig. 3E, G, H). Therefore, proBLT mice are able to support the proper development and systemic reconstitution of human T cells, at levels comparable to those of the primary BLT mice.
Inheritance of human immune cell genetic traits from BLT to proBLT mice
Certain genetic traits, such as HLA haplotypes that play important roles in regulating the development and functionality of human T cells, are critical for the study of human immunity [28]. For example, our knowledge of antigen-specific human T cell responses to viral infections and cancers are largely based on the studies of HLA-A2-restricted T cell reactions [29]. Humanized BLT mice that harbor a human immune system of HLA-A2 haplotype (denoted as BLTA2+) are valuable tools for studying HLA-A2-restricted T cell responses and developing T cell-based immunotherapies. However, the supply of human CD34+ cells and fetal thymus tissues of HLA-A2 haplotype needed to produce such BLTA2+ mice are especially limiting. We proposed to overcome this hurdle by maximizing the utilization of the limited supply of HLA-A2+ human tissues, through expanding a small number of established BLTA2+ mice into a large colony of proBLTA2+ mice without the need for additional primary human tissues. As shown in Fig. 4, the resulting proBLTA2+ mice faithfully inherited the HLA-A2 haplotype genetic trait and reconstituted a human immune system, including the human T cell compartment that expressed HLA-A2.

Inheritance of human immune cell genetic traits from BLT to proBLT mice. HLA-A2+ human fetal liver CD34+ cells and matching fetal thymus were used to generate the primary BLT mice (denoted as BLTA2+), which were then utilized to generate the secondary proBLT mice (denoted as proBLTA2+). The experiments were repeated at least three times. Representative results are presented from BLT and proBLT mice at 8–12 weeks post the primary human tissue or secondary BLT tissue transfer (n = 4–5 per experimental group).
Persistence of human immune cell gene modifications from BLT to proBLT mice
Humanized BLT mice are potent tools that are used to study gene-modified human immune cell therapies, especially gene-modified HSC therapies for treating diseases such as cancer, HIV, or primary immune deficiencies [30 –34]. To evaluate whether the proBLT approach may be useful for such applications, we transduced human CD34+ cells with a lentivector pMND-EGFP encoding an enhanced green fluorescence (EGFP) reporter gene, and we then used these genetically modified CD34+ cells to generate BLT mice (Fig. 5A). In the resulting BLT mice (denoted as BLTEGFP), we observed high expression of the EGFP transgene in a high portion of human immune cells (gated as hCD45+EGFP+ comprising ∼60% of total hCD45+ cells; Fig. 5B). proBLT mice generated from these BLTEGFP mice, denoted as proBLTEGFP, repopulated a human immune system that persistently expressed high levels of EGFP transgene with the appearance of hCD45+ cells starting from 4 weeks post secondary bone marrow transfer (Fig. 5B, C). Transgene expression was detected in multilineages of human immune cells, including CD4+ helper and CD8+ cytotoxic human T cells (gated as hCD45+hTCRαβ+CD4+ or hCD45+hTCRαβ+CD8+, respectively; Fig. 5D). Moreover, the levels of human immune cell gene modifications were very consistent among individual proBLT mice and were similar to those of the primary BLTEGFP mice (∼60% of total hCD45+ cells; Fig. 5C). Therefore, proBLT mice are suitable to support large-scale studies of gene-modified human immune cell therapies.

Persistence of human immune cell gene modifications from BLT to proBLT mice. Human CD34+ cells transduced with pMND-EGFP lentiviruses were used to generate the primary BLT mice modified with the EGFP reporter gene (denoted as BLTEGFP), which were then utilized to generate the secondary proBLT mice (denoted as proBLTEGFP). The experiments were repeated at least three times. Representative results are presented (n = 4–5 per experimental group).
Discussion
In this article, we describe a new method for propagating humanized BLT mice for the study of human immunology and immunotherapy. Through secondary transfer of bone marrow cells and human thymus implants from BLT mice into naïve NSG recipient mice, we were able to expand one primary BLT mouse into a colony of 4–5 proBLT mice in 6–8 weeks (Fig. 1). These proBLT mice reconstituted human immune cells, including T cells, at levels comparable to those of their primary BLT donor mice (Figs. 2 and 3). They also faithfully inherited the human immune genetic traits from their donor BLT mice, such as the HLA-A2 haplotype that is of special interest for studying antigen-specific T cell activities and T cell-based immunotherapies (Fig. 4). Moreover, an EGFP reporter gene engineered into the human immune system was stably passed from BLT to proBLT mice, making them suitable for studying gene-modified human immune cell gene therapies, especially gene-modified HSC therapies (Fig. 5). Therefore, these proBLT mice can be considered expanded “clones” of the established primary BLT mice. Through bypassing the need for additional human CD34+ cells and fetal thymus tissues, the proBLT approach provides an opportunity to overcome a critical hurdle to utilizing the BLT humanized mouse model and enables its more widespread use as a valuable preclinical research tool.
There are two key factors that make the proBLT approach successful. One is the persistence of human CD34+ HSPCs through secondary bone marrow transfer in NSG recipient mice; the other is the regeneration of a functional human thymus structure in the secondary NSG recipient mice through implanting the human thymus organoids harvested from the primary BLT mice. Despite their original sources (e.g., fetal liver, cord blood, adult bone marrow, or adult G-CSF-mobilized peripheral blood), human CD34+ cells post adoptive transfer always preferentially homed to the bone marrow of NSG mice, likely because NSG mouse bone marrow provides a nurturing environment that supports the engraftment and long-term maintenance of these cells (Fig. 2B) [4]. The ability of BLT bone marrow-experienced human CD34+ HSPCs to survive the secondary bone marrow transfer, while maintaining their longevity and multi-potential, validates the supporting function of the NSG mouse bone marrow niche. Meanwhile, the ability of the human thymus organoids generated in BLT mice to develop into a functional human thymus structure in the proBLT mice is intriguing (Fig. 3). A human thymus graft is critical for the proper development, functional maturation, and systemic reconstitution of human T cells in humanized mice [9]. In addition to thymocytes that are derived from HSPCs, a functional human thymus comprises thymic epithelial/dendritic cells that mediate the positive and negative selections of human T cells, as well as the programming of special human T cell sublineages such as CD4+CD25+FoxP3+ regulatory T cells (Tregs) [27]. In our experiments, we observed a typical cortex/medulla structure in human thymus organoids harvested from both BLT and proBLT mice, suggesting that human thymocytes and thymic epithelial/dendritic cells were present and organized properly in these organoids (Fig. 3B). In particular, we observed abundant numbers of HCs in the medulla of these human thymus organoids (Fig. 3C). HCs are structures unique to human thymus, formed from eosinophilic type VI epithelial reticular cells arranged concentrically, and have been implicated in the development of human Tregs [26]. Thymic stromal lymphopoietin expressed by thymic epithelial cells within the HCs has been indicated to activate thymic CD11+ dendritic cells that then mediate the secondary positive selection of human Tregs [26]. Taken together, these observations verified the presence of an authentic human thymus environment in proBLT mice that is responsible for the functional reconstitution of human T cells in these mice.
Based on the success of generating proBLT mice, it is intriguing to propose that the tertiary transfer of bone marrow cells and human thymus organoid harvested from the proBLT mice into NSG mice may further expand the BLT colony size by another four- to five-fold, allowing the propagation of a single primary BLT mouse to ∼5 pro-BLT mice in 6–8 weeks and then to ∼25 pro-proBLT mice in 3–4 months. Unfortunately, our initial attempts to generate pro-proBLT mice did not yield satisfactory results. Reconstitution of human immune cells in the pro-proBLT mice was low and variable. It seemed that the human CD34+ cells had exhausted their long-term potential post the tertiary bone marrow transfer, a phenomenon similar to but more severe than that has been observed for mouse HSCs post series bone marrow transfers in the mouse model. It has been well recognized in the mouse model that series of bone marrow transfers induce stress and impair the longevity of HSCs. Furthermore, in the BLT humanized mouse model, the mouse bone marrow environment does not provide the optimal support for the long-term maintenance of human HSCs. Supplementing the primary BLT mice and proBLT mice with human cytokines that are important for human HSC maintenance, such as Flt3 ligand, SCF, TPO, and IL-3, may improve the longevity of engrafted human CD34+ cells and allow for the further propagation of proBLT mice. If possible, such a preclinical animal model will allow the continuous “passage” of human immune cells in living animals for an extended period of time, therefore maximizing the research value of a limited supply of primary human immune cells and tissues.
proBLT mice are particularly valuable for the study of human immune systems with special genetic traits. These genetic traits often pose particular restrictions on the supply of human tissues that can be used. One example is the HLA haplotype. For instance, the study of HLA-A2-restricted T cell responses is of special interest for cancer immunotherapy research, whereas the study of HLA-B57-restricted T cell responses is of special interest for HIV latency research [35,36]. Generation of BLT mice for such studies requires HLA-A2+ or HLA-B57+ human CD34+ HSPCs as well as HLA haplotype-matched fetal thymus tissues. Another example is monogene deficiencies of the human hematopoietic system. For instance, adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency is of interest for studying human ADA-deficient severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID), whereas β-globin deficiency is of interest for studying human sickle cell disease [20 –22]. Over the past decades, gene-corrected autologous HSC transfer has become a promising therapy for these monogene deficiency-induced diseases and inspires further investigations [32]. Humanized animal models are valuable tools for the preclinical development of these therapies, but their application is greatly limited by the small number of CD34+ cells that can be collected from patients, which are often too few to engraft enough animals for meaningful studies [20 –22]. By expanding established BLT mice and reducing the need for additional primary human tissues, the proBLT approach provides an attractive solution to overcome this critical hurdle and makes the humanized BLT mouse model suitable for the preclinical study of such hematopietic stem cell-based gene therapies.
Despite its valuable research potential, the BLT model still has its own limitations and can be improved further to make it more representative of the human immune system in terms of the composition of various lineages of immune cells and their functions. These next-generation humanized mouse models utilize recipient mice such as NSG or BRG that are further genetically modified to allow for enhanced human immune cell reconstitution. Such modifications include the deficiency of murine c-Kit gene that supports improved human CD34+ HSPC engraftment [37,38], the addition of human transgenes such as SIRPα to improve overall human hematopoietic cell engraftment [39], or knock-in of human immune regulatory genes such as TPO, IL-3, GM-CSF (granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor), and M-CSF (macrophage colony-stimulating factor) that promote the development and function of human monocytes, macrophages, and NK cells [40]. The proBLT approach should also be applicable to expand BLT mice that are produced with these advanced recipient mice and support the studies of a human immune system that more closely resembles the human situation.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to the University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) animal facility for providing animal support, the UCLA Translational Pathology Core Laboratory (TPCL) for providing immunohistology support, and Dr. Gay Crooks for providing flow cytometry reagents. They also thank Dr. Rachel Steward and the FPA Women's Health, and the UCLA AIDS Institute/CFAR Virology Core/Gene and Cell Therapy Core/Humanized Mouse Core for providing human cells/tissues and humanized mice services. D.J.S. is a predoctoral fellow supported by the UCLA Tumor Immunology Training Grant (T32 CA009056). This work was supported by an UCLA Center for AIDS Research Grant (NIH/NIAID AI028697, to J.Z.), a National Institutes of Health (NIH) Director's New Innovator Award (DP2 CA196335, to L.Y.), a STOP CANCER Research Career Development Award (to L.Y.), a GTSN Challenge Award for Lethal Prostate Cancer (to L.Y.), and a CIRM 2.0 Partnering Opportunity for Translational Research Projects Award (TRAN1-08533, to L.Y.).
Author Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
