“There Is Nothing to Do About It”: Nonbinary Individuals' Experience of Gender Dysphoria

Abstract

Purpose:

Clinical definitions of gender dysphoria have primarily centered on a binary conceptualization of gender. This study aimed to understand nonbinary transindividuals' experiences of gender dysphoria.

Methods:

Data were collected online from a nonclinical sample comprised of 205 nonbinary and agender participants. Analysis focused on answers to a single open-ended question prompting participants to describe their gender dysphoria as it relates to their body and/or appearance.

Results:

First, content analysis was used to document 11 contextual elements in which participants described their dysphoria with regard to three overarching categories, including no gender dysphoria (no issues with body, no dysphoria), aspects of gender/sex (naming gender identity, naming assigned sex, gender role, or expression), and aspects of body (body shape, genitals, chest, secondary sex characteristics, hormones, reproductive capability). Second, thematic analysis revealed six central themes describing the unique way gender dysphoria is experienced by nonbinary individuals: (1) Androgyny or Fluidity, (2) Feminine and Masculine Traits, (3) Dysphoria vs. Expression or Appearance, (4) Varying or Shifting Dysphoria, (5) No Solution, and (6) Trade-off/Loss.

Conclusion:

Results of this study suggest that nonbinary transindividuals experience gender dysphoria in unique ways. These findings highlight the need to develop clinical assessments of gender dysphoria that reflect nonbinary experience, and to outline explicit medical protocols for interventions tailored to achieve a desired outcome of physical androgyny.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Galupo

, Davis

, Grynkiewicz

, Mitchell

. Conceptualization of sexual orientation identity among sexual minorities: patterns across sexual and gender identity. J Bisex. 2014; 14:433–456.

Tate

, Youssef

, Bettergarcia

. Integrating the study of transgender spectrum and cisgender experiences of self-categorization from a personality perspective. Rev Gen Psychol. 2014; 18:302–312.

Beemyn

. Making campuses more inclusive of transgender students. J Gay Lesbian Issues Educ. 2008; 3:77–89.

Galupo

, Pulice-Farrow

, Ramirez

. “Like a constantly flowing river”: gender identity flexibility among non-binary transgender individuals. In: Identity Flexibility During Adulthood: Perspectives in Adult Development. (Sinnott JD; ed). New York City: Springer, 2017, pp. 163–177.

Harrison

, Grant

, Herman

. A gender not listed here: genderqueers, gender revels, and otherwise in the National Transgender Discrimination Survey. LGBTQ Policy J Harvard Kennedy. 2012; 2:13–24.

Factor

, Rothblum

. Exploring gender identity and community among three groups of transgender individuals in the United States: MTFs, FTMs, and genderqueers. Health Sociol Rev. 2008; 17:235–253.

Richards

, Bouman

, Seal

, et al. Non-binary or genderqueer genders. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2015; 28:95–102.

Matsuno

, Budge

. Non-binary/genderqueer identities: a critical review of the literature. Curr Sex Health Rep. 2017; 9:116–120.

Butler

. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. New York, NY: Routledge, 2012.

10.

Levitt

, Ippolito

. Being transgender: navigating minority stressors and developing authentic self-presentation. Psychol Women Q. 2014; 38:46–64.

11.

Galupo

, Pulice-Farrow

. Subjective ratings of gender dysphoria scales by transgender individuals. Arch Sex Behav. 2020; 49:479–488.

12.

Motmans

, Nieder

, Bouman

. Transforming the paradigm of nonbinary transgender health: a field in transition. Int J Transgend. 2019; 20:119–225.

13.

American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th ed. DSM-5 ed. Arlington, VA, 2013.

14.

Coleman

, Bockting

, Botzer

, et al. Standards of care for the health of transsexual, transgender, and gender-nonconforming people, Version 7. Int J Transgend. 2012; 13:165–232.

15.

Byne

, Karasic

, Coleman

, et al. Gender dysphoria in adults: an overview and primer for psychiatrists. Transgend Health. 2018; 3:57–73.

16.

Chen

, Hidalgo

, Leibowitz

, et al. Multidisciplinary care for gender-diverse youth: a narrative review and unique model of gender-affirming care. Transgend Health. 2016; 1:117–123.

17.

Olson

, Schrager

, Belzer

, et al. Baseline physiologic and psychosocial characteristics of transgender youth seeking care for gender dysphoria. J Adolesc Health. 2015; 57:374–380.

18.

White Hughto

, Rose

, Pachankis

, Reisner

. Barriers to gender transition-related healthcare: identifying underserved transgender adults in Massachusetts. Transgend Health. 2017; 2:107–118.

19.

Ashley

. The misuse of gender dysphoria: toward greater conceptual clarity in transgender health. Perspect Psychol Sci. 2020 [Epub ahead of print]; DOI: 10.1177/1745691619872987.

20.

Lev

. Gender dysphoria: two steps forward, one step back. Clin Soc Work Forum. 2013; 41:288–296.

21.

Vance Jr. SR, Cohen-Kettenis PT, Drescher J, et al. Opinions about the DSM gender identity disorder diagnosis: results from an international survey administered to organizations concerned with the welfare of transgender people. Int J Transgend. 2010; 12:1–14.

22.

Zucker

, Duschinsky

. Dilemmas encountered by the sexual and gender identities disorder work group for DSM-5: an interview with Kenneth J. Zucker. Psychol Sex. 2015; 7:23–33.

23.

Zucker

, Lawrence

, Kreukels

BPC

. Gender dysphoria in adults. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 2016; 12:217–247.

24.

Drescher

, Cohen-Kettenis

, Winter

. Minding the body: situating gender identity diagnoses in the ICD-11. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2012; 24:568–577.

25.

Bouman

, Bauer

, Richards

, Coleman

. World professional association for transgender health consensus statement on considerations of the role of distress (Criterion D) in the DSM diagnosis of Gender Identity Disorder. Int J Transgend. 2010; 12:100–106.

26.

Galupo

, Pulice-Farrow

, Lindley

. “Every time I get gendered male, I feel a pain in my chest”: understanding the social context for gender dysphoria. Stigma Health. 2020; 5:199–208.

27.

Riggs

, Ansara

, Treharne

. An evidence-based model for understanding the mental health experiences of transgender Australians. Aust Psychol. 2015; 5:32–39.

28.

Pulice-Farrow

, Cusack

, Galupo

. “Certain parts of my body don't belong to me”: trans individuals' descriptions of body-specific gender dysphoria. Sex Res Social Policy. 2019 [Epub ahead of print]; DOI: 10.1007/s13178-019-00423-y.

29.

Meyerowitz

. How Sex Changed: A History of Transsexuality in the United States. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2002.

30.

Serano

. The case against autogynephilia. Int J Transgend. 2010; 12:176–187.

31.

Benjamin

. The Transsexual Phenomenon. New York: Julian Press, 1966.

32.

Blanchard

. The concept of autogynephilia and the typology of male gender dysphoria. J Nerv Ment Dis. 1989; 177:616–623.

33.

Blanchard

. The classification and labeling of nonhomosexual gender dysphorias. Arch Sex Behav. 1989; 18:315–324.

34.

Cohen-Kettenis

, van Goozen

SHM

. Sex reassignment of adolescent trannsexuals: a follow up study. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1997; 36:263–271.

35.

Deogracias

, Johnson

, Meyer-Bahlburg

HFL

, et al. The gender identity/gender dysphoria questionnaire for adolescents and adults. J Sex Res. 2007; 44:370–379.

36.

American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed., text revision. DSM-IV-TR ed. Washington, DC, 2000.

37.

James

, Herman

, Rankin

, et al. The Report of the 2015 US Transgender Survey. Washington, DC: National Center for Transgender Equality, 2016.

38.

Mayring

Qualitative content analysis. In: A Companion to Qualitative Research. (Flick U, von Kardoff E, Steinke I; eds). Berlin, Germany: Sage Publications, 2004, pp. 266–269.

39.

Braun

, Clarke

. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol. 2006; 3:77–101.

40.

Braun

, Clarke

. Successful Qualitative Research: A Practical Guide for Beginners. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2013.

41.

Nowell

, Norris

, White

, Moules

. Thematic analysis: striving to meet the trustworthiness criteria. Int J Qual Methods. 2017; 16:1–13.

42.

Sandelowski

. Real qualitative researchers do not count: the use of numbers in qualitative research. Res Nurs Health. 2001; 24:230–240.

43.

Tufford

, Newman

. Bracketing in qualitative research. Qual Soc Work. 2012; 11:80–96.

44.

Frank

. Queering menstruation: trans and non-binary identity and body politics. Soc Inquiry. 2020; 90:371–404.

45.

Bradford

, Rider

, Spencer

. Hair removal and psychological well-being in transfeminine adults: associations with gender dysphoria and gender euphoria. J Dermatolog Treat. 2019 [Epub ahead of print]; DOI: 10.1080/09546634.2019.1687823.

46.

Peterson

, Matthews

, Copps-Smith

, Conard

. Suicidality, self-harm, and body dissatisfaction in transgender adolescents and emerging adults with gender dysphoria. Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2017; 47:475–482.

47.

Turan Ş, Poyraz

, Sağlam

NGU

, et al. Alterations in body uneasiness, eating attitudes, and psychopathology before and after cross-sex hormonal treatment in patients with female-to-male gender dysphoria. Arch Sex Behav. 2018; 47:1–13.

48.

Jones

, Bouman

, Haycraft

, Arcelus

. Gender congruence and body satisfaction in nonbinary transgender people: a case control study. Int J Transgend. 2019; 20:263–475.

49.

Jones

, Bouman

, Haycraft

, Arcelus

. The gender congruence and life satisfaction scale (GCLS): development and validation of a scale to measure outcome from trandsgender health services. Int J Transgend. 2019; 20:63–80.

50.

van Anders

. Beyond sexual orientation: integrating gender/sex and diverse sexualities via sexual configurations theory. Arch Sex Behav. 2015; 44:1177–1213.

51.

Tate

CC.

Gender identity as a personality process. In Gender Identity: Disorders, Developmental Perspectives, and Social Implications. (Miller BL; ed). Hauppauge, NY: Nova Science Publishers, 2014, pp. 1–22.

52.

Nieder

, Eyssel

, Kohler

. Being trans without medical transition: exploring characteristics of trans individuals from Germany not seeking gender-affirmative medical interventions. Arch Sex Behav. 2019 [Epub ahead of print]; DOI: 10.1007/s10508-019-01559-z.

53.

Riggle

EDB

, Rostosky

, Reedy

. Online surveys for BGLT research: issues and techniques. J Homosex. 2005; 48:1–21.

54.

Christian

, Dillman

, Smyth

. The effects of mode and format on answers to scalar questions in telephone and web surveys. In: Advances in Telephone Survey Methodology (Lepkowski JM, Tucker C, Brick JM, de Leeuw ED, Japec L, Lavrakas PJ, Link MW, Sangster RL; eds). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons, 2008, pp. 250–275.

55.

Shulman

, Holt

, Hope

, et al. A review of contemporary assessment tools for use with transgender and gender nonconfirming adults. Psychol Sex Orientat Gend Divers. 2017; 4:304–313.

56.

Koehler

, Eyssel

, Nieder

. Genders and individual treatment progress in (non-) binary trans individuals. J Sex Med. 2018; 15:102–113.