Abstract
Among various public health diseases, filariasis constitutes a major public health problem in India, wherein an estimated 553.7 million people are at risk of infection. The aim of this article is to present a spatial mapping and analysis of filariasis data over a 3-year period (2004–2007) from Karimnagar, Chittoor, East and West Godavari districts of Andhra Pradesh, India. The data include epidemiological and entomological studies (i.e., infection rate, infectivity rate, mosquito per man hour, and microfilaria rate). These parameters were customized on Geographical Information System (GIS) platform and developed filaria monitoring visualization system (FMVS) for identifying the endemic/risk areas of filariasis among these four districts. GIS map for filariasis transmission from the study areas was created and stratified into different spatial entities like low, medium, and high risk zones. On the basis of the data and FMVS maps, it was demonstrated that filariasis remained unevenly distributed within the districts. Balancing the intervention coverage in different villages with overall mass drug administration and continued promotion of the proper use of control measures are necessary for further reduction of filarial cases in these districts.
Introduction
Out of 22 states, Andhra Pradesh is one of the severely affected states in which 16 districts have been reported as endemic zones for filariasis (Reddy et al. 2000) and the affected villages in all the districts were under Mass Drug Administration (MDA) program. The Government of India has initiated this program during 2004, with annual single dose of DEC tablets to all the population living in the risk zones of filariasis, but to the contrary, a high number of filariasis cases have been reported from Karimnagar, Chittoor, East Godavari, and West Godavari districts of Andhra Pradesh (Biswas et al. 1996, Mukhopadhyay et al. 2008). There is no report available on the quantification of disease load in these four districts. Hence, a pilot scale study has been carried out on epidemiological and entomological aspects of LF in these districts, which will provide valuable information to the health officials to suppress the disease load in future control programs.
The powerful tools of the spatial technology have revolutionized the way the epidemiological research on vector-borne diseases is now being carried out. Remote sensing data in Geographical Information System (GIS) have been widely used for identification, characterization, monitoring, surveillance of breeding habitats, and mapping of diseases risk zones (Clarke et al. 1996, Tanser and Le Sueur 2002, Srivastava et al. 2009). GIS maps on community-based data and output of spatial and temporal information could be enormously valuable as an operational tool for early detection and timely response to disease management. This strategy has been used in the current study to explore the impact of intervention coverage and people's adherence to the intervention on filariasis in the targeted villages in various geographic locations among four districts of Andhra Pradesh.
The prime objective of this study was to estimate the prevalence of LF in these four districts of Andhra Pradesh. The secondary objective was to develop spatial distribution maps of LF in endemic areas and to determine the parasite load at the village level. The endemic areas are classified as high, medium, and low according to their geographical location, persistence, and disease risk. Making the most from GIS technological advancement for filariasis detection, several authors have been developing GIS methodologies and models for control of various public health diseases through integrated approach. This work also aimed to contribute further to this theme, integrating system resources and geoprocessing technologies readily available, to establish disease alert levels for effective logic that identifies the real degree of danger. Thus, proper disease control actions can be established faster and further spreading of the disease can be prevented.
Methods
Study site
This study was undertaken covering 120 villages from four districts (Table 1) of Andhra Pradesh (30 villages from Karimnagar and Chittoor district, 45 villages from East Godavari district, and 15 villages from West Godavari district) during 2004 to 2007. The villages in these districts are populated predominantly by paddy farmers. The climate of these four districts is characterized by summer (46°C–20°C), winter (32°C–11°C), and monsoon (June–December). The South West monsoon and North East monsoon are responsible for the total rainfall in Andhra Pradesh.
Study design
For this study, 120 villages were selected from the four districts in consultation with the Department of Health, Government of Andhra Pradesh. Before investigations, the local authorities and the residents of the study villages were informed about the proposed study for their authorization. Individuals from all households involved were offered filarial treatment during the period of the study. Before collecting blood samples, all individuals who participated were interviewed, using a structured questionnaire, and data regarding the socioeconomic status and their knowledge, attitude, and behavior in relation to filariasis were collected. The households for survey were selected by the stratified random sampling methodology. During the study period, a large volume of data (epidemiology, entomology, and socioeconomic data) has been collected, and in the current study, the summarized data pertaining to only four parameters (i.e., infection rate, infectivity rate, mosquito per man hour [PMH], and microfilaria [MF] rate) have been focused for spatial mapping.
Blood sample collection
A total of 23,624 blood smears (5794 from Karimnagar, 5830 from Chittoor, 9000 from East Godavari, and 3000 from West Godavari) were collected from 120 villages of four districts during the study period (2004–2007) from different age groups and genders. From each village nearly 200 blood smears (from 45 households) have been collected to assess the MF rate. The blood sample details are summarized in Table 2. Each selected household was considered a sampling unit, and all individuals present at the time of survey were registered for screening of microfilaraemia of W. bancrofti species, and the disease was assessed through house-to-house visit. From each respondent, about 20 μL of blood was collected between 20:00 and 23.00 h by finger prick method, smears were prepared on clean prenumbered glass slides, and the presence of MF was examined and counted under light microscopy (Sasa 1976).
p>0.05.
Entomological survey
Indoor-resting mosquitoes were collected with the help of mechanical aspirators (Hausherr's machine Works) during 06:00 to 09:00 h from the study areas during the study period (2004–2007). Only female Culex quinquefasciatus mosquitoes, the principal vectors of bancroftian filariasis were identified by using the key developed by Reuben et al. (1994) and subjected for dissection. The vector abundance was expressed as the number of female C. quinquefasciatus mosquitoes collected per man per hour. To assess the transmission levels of the disease, C. quinquefasciatus mosquitoes were dissected to identify the stage of the MF, using the key developed by Nelson (1959) and Yen et al. (1982), and the infection rate was calculated by the presence of any stage (L1, L2, and L3) of MF. Infectivity rates were recorded based on the presence of third stage (L3) of MF only.
PMH=No. of female mosquitoes collected/the time spent
Infection rate (%)=No. positive for L1, L2, L3/no. of mosquitoes dissected×100
Infectivity rate (%)=No. of mosquitoes positive for infective stage (L3)/no. of mosquitoes dissected×100
MF rate (%)=The number MF positive cases/total number of persons examined×100
Ethics statement
The study received ethical clearance from the ethics committee that was constituted in our institute (Indian Institute of Chemical Technology) affiliated to Ministry of Science and Technology, Government of India. This ethics committee has approved to carry out the research work. The subjects who provided the blood sample were interviewed individually before the commencement of epidemiological survey. The consent was verbally conveyed, and oral approval was obtained from the respondents of the study area. The verbal consent was obtained because most of the respondents of the study area are illiterate and do not know to read or write. During the study, from each respondent, socioeconomic details were obtained using a structured questionnaire. During the entomological survey, mosquitoes were collected from the private residences after obtaining oral consent in consultation with the concerned family members. In addition to this, the consent of the village head and the concerned health officials pertaining to the village was obtained well in advance to carry out the study. To document verbal consent, the name of each individual who provided verbal consent was recorded, along with the test results for their samples. The verbal consent obtained from the subjects of the study was approved by the ethics committee of our institute.
Spatial data preparation
Global Positioning System (GPS) is a system of 24 satellites that allows the co-ordinates of any point on or near the earth's surface to be measured with extremely high precision (Boulos et al. 2001). GPS 12, a product of Garmin (
Development of GIS application
GPS data were downloaded from the GPS handheld receiver for GIS mapping and analysis; MapSource software was used to upload and download maps data, points of interest, waypoints, tracks, and routes to and from the GPS unit. Customization of GIS application is the process of leveraging the available functionalities in a desired manner from software development kits. ArcGIS Engine-9.2 is one such kit of GIS functionalities that can be accessed through programming language such as C++, VB, .Net, and Java. For the current application, .Net was used to incorporate various functionalities such as data accessing, data visualization, and thematic representation based on attributes.
In this application the data are stored in Environmental Systems Research Institute personal Geodatabase format, which contains spatial layers such as village boundaries and GPS locations of each of four districts. The data-accessing module is called application and is invoked to display in map window(s) the selected district data, and, subsequently, the user can choose the data through the combo box provided in the interface.
Statistical analysis
SPSS version 15.0 was used for statistical analysis. Risk estimates (odds ratio [OR]) were calculated using bivariate logistic regression. Level of significance was considered as 0.05.
Results
Prevalence of W. bancrofti infection
The overall MF was present in 744 (31.49%) of the 23,624 samples across the 120 villages of the four districts ranging 8.91% (Chittoor), 21.40% (Karimnagar), 45.33% (East Godavari), and 53.33% (West Godavari; Table 2). In our study it was noticed that there was not much difference observed between male and female (χ 2=2.516, p=0.113) filarial cases. In Karimnagar district, out of 5794 blood smears, 124 (71 males and 53 females) were found to be positive; in Chittoor, out of 5830 respondents, 52 (28 males and 24 females) were positive for MF. In East Godavari, 408 samples (male 208 and female 200) were found to be positive from 9000 samples; similarly, in West Godavari, out of 3000 smears collected, 160 (male 85 and female 75) were recorded positive for MF (Table 2). In the study, it was also observed that the MF infection has steadily increased along with the age groups (p=0.001), and the maximum prevalence was found in 20–40-year and >60-year age groups. In bi-variate analysis, Karimnagar district was considered as a reference, and the analysis reveals that Chittoor (OR=2.4, 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.75–3.37), East Godavari (OR=0.46, 95% CI=0.37–0.56), and West Godavari (OR=0.38, 95% CI=0.30–0.49) had significantly lower risk for filariasis. Data collected on various entomological and epidemiological parameters from all the 120 villages of four districts are presented in Tables 3 –6. These tables infer that the intensity of disease rates largely varied among the villages from all these four districts of Andhra Pradesh.
NA, not available.
Chronic clinical filariasis
The chronic condition of LF, namely, elephantiasis (lymphoedema), was prevalent in the study population. Chronic conditions of elephantiasis alone were recorded in 89 (1.5%) people from Karimnagar, 27 (0.46%) from Chittoor, 152 (1.69%) from East Godavari, and 69 (2.3%) from West Godavari districts. Most of the infected individuals (males and females) had swelling in the right, left, or both in upper and lower limbs. Although these figures are an indication of a substantial disease burden in the communities examined, they do not accurately reflect the level of burden in the study areas on a random survey basis.
The collected data on disease rates and GPS data of each village were customized to derive the filarial endemicity among the surveyed 120 villages. On the basis of the relative contribution of each parameter (i.e., MF rate, PMH, infection, and infectivity rates), a filariasis-monitoring model has been developed and maps were generated on a GIS platform. This decision support system has been built up with user interface facilities for browsing thematic maps of the surveyed villages of the four districts (Figs. 1 –4). This visualization model allows integration of data from any database software or worksheet. The tool is designed as a model for filariasis, and this can be put into function for country-wide LF control operations, with all the desired data.

Spatial map showing the village-level prevalence of filariasis (infectivity, infection, MF rate, and PMH) in Chittoor District of Andhra Pradesh. MF, microfilaria; PMH, per man hour. Color images available online at

Spatial map showing the village-level prevalence of filariasis (infectivity, infection, MF rate, and PMH) in Karimnagar District of Andhra Pradesh. Color images available online at

Spatial map showing the village-level prevalence of filariasis (infectivity, infection, MF rate, and PMH) in East Godavari District of Andhra Pradesh. Color images available online at

Spatial map showing the village-level prevalence of filariasis (infectivity, infection, MF rate, and PMH) in West Godavari District of Andhra Pradesh. Color images available online at
Filaria monitoring visualization system: a GIS-based application
Filaria monitoring visualization system (FMVS) a GIS-based application was developed and classified all the study villages into three groups based on the intensity of the disease—high (red), medium (yellow), and low risk (blue)—by considering the four parameters (i.e., infection rate, infectivity rate, PMH, and MF rate). To represent these intensities, value rendering functionality was used to represent in different colors by reading the corresponding attribute of each village. A unique feature of this application is having four geometrically synchronized map windows, which are used to present each parameter in different window of the same study area. A location map is also provided to display the study area location in the state map. A dropdown box is provided to choose any one of the district, which will be reflected in both map windows and location map areas. The spatial distribution of the sampled villages/districts with their filariasis prevalence is shown in the Figures 1 to 4 on GIS platform. The present study has shown that the areas with risk of filariasis can be identified at the macro level using the FMVS in four districts of Andhra Pradesh.
Discussion
In India, three states (Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Andhra Pradesh) alone account for 52% of the endemic population and 62% of the infected population (Das et al. 2001). National Health Policy 2002 aims at elimination of transmission and the prevention of disability due to LF by the year 2015, through MDA program with annual single dose of DEC. Sixteen out of the 23 districts of Andhra Pradesh are under the grip of filariasis, and 54 million people of the state are under MDA program with annual single dose of DEC tablets once a year (Directorate of National Vector Borne Disease Control Programme 2004). Chittoor, Karimnagar, and East and West Godavari are the worst affected districts in Andhra Pradesh. In an attempt to control LF in East Godavari, from 1999 to 2005, a total of six rounds of MDA programs were organized covering five million people (Government of Andhra Pradesh 2005). Our data demonstrate that these four districts of Andhra Pradesh represent filariasis-endemic districts. Among the sampled population, the overall MF prevalence was recorded as 31.49%. It was observed that the lowest MF prevalence recorded among the four districts was 8.91, and the percentage of MF varied in other districts (Table 2). Despite concentrated efforts of the MDA program, it has been found that the disease is still prevalent as it is an endemic area; our study depicts that the endemicity is due to autochthonous transmission occurring in the community.
C. quinquefasciatus is the major vector of filariasis. It is well adapted to both urban and rural areas, especially those with high population densities with low socioeconomic and poor living conditions, etc. These conditions are favorable for proliferation of vectors (Mott et al. 1990, Albuquerque 1993). The mean value of PMH density recorded in Chittoor was 30.84, Karimnagar 34.40, East Godavari 39.43, and West Godavari 35.62. The high vector density (>40) was recorded in most of the villages of East Godavari district and in few villages in rest of the districts where the study was done.
The risk factors for infection and disease due to W. bancrofti have been difficult to characterize because of the complex life cycle of this mosquito-borne helminths and because of the broad range of clinical signs and symptoms attributable to this nematode. The mean prevalence rate of microfilaraemia in Chittoor was 0.883%, Karimnagar 2.067%, East Godavari 10.982%, and West Godavari 22.713%. From the WHO classification, most of the villages from East and West Godavari districts were seen to be hyperendemic (>10%). Similarly, low (<5%) and medium (<10%) endemicity was reported from both Karimnagar and Chittoor districts of Andhra Pradesh. The microfilaraemia rates varied among the different age groups; higher MF was noticed among adults and older persons. The prevalence of microfilaraemia usually increased with age (Rajagopalan et al. 1989).
The FMVS was developed on a GIS platform and has been used to identify filariasis risk areas. The disease transmission is largely influenced by various variables (environmental and socioeconomic factors), which help identify the disease transmission zones at micro- and macro-scale (Galvez Tan 2003, Sherchand et al. 2003). Similarly, the prevalence of filariasis in human population is directly related to the parameters such as vector abundance, vector infection, infectivity, and biting rate of infective vector population.
In summary, the data on epidemiological and entomological aspects were subjected for spatial mapping of filariasis infection zones in the four districts of Andhra Pradesh during 2004–2007. These results demonstrate that microfilaraemia is still prevailing with various levels of intensity even after the implementation of MDA programs. The application of FMVS will help the end user to quickly assess the intensity of the disease based on the input information provided by the visualization system. The observed prevalence (MF rate and vector density) rates in our study are found to be above the threshold level. Hence, this application will certainly be helpful for the health official to implement the integrated control measures to suppress the filarial load in the community.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to Director, IICT, for his encouragement and support. The authors thank Ministry of Communication and Information Technology for sponsoring the project, and the Government of Andhra Pradesh for supporting the Project. The authors also acknowledge the District Medical and Health Services, Hyderabad, for their support during the study.
Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
