Influence of the Selection of the Suture Material on the Mechanical Behavior of a Biomaterial to be Employed in the Construction of Implants. Part 2: Porcine Pericardium

Abstract

Using a hydraulic stress simulator, the mechanical behavior of the porcine pericardium used in the construction of cardiac valve leaflets was characterized following the same procedure employed with calf pericardium in Part 1 of this study. One hundred fifty pairs of tissue samples were subjected to tensile testing to rupture. One of the two samples from each of 120 pairs (four series of 30 pairs each) was saturated with commercially available threads made of nylon, silk, Prolene or Gore-Tex, while the other sample in each of these pairs was left unsewn. The remaining 30 pairs were employed as controls in which neither of the two samples was subjected to suturing. The sutured tissue samples showed a significant decrease in tensile strength at rupture (range: 11.61 to 21.22 MPa) when compared with unsutured samples (range: 50.80 to 89.45 MPa; p < 0.01). When these results were compared with their equivalent in calf pericardium, no significant differences were observed (the mean values at rupture in calf pericardium ranged between 211.61 MPa and 26.04 MPa). Again, the application of morphological and mechanical selection criteria to ensure the homogeneity of the samples provided excellent fit with respect to the stress/strain curves.

The interaction of the different suture materials with the pericardial tissue was also assessed by comparing the mechanical behavior of the sutured samples with that of the control samples. At the working stress of a cardiac valve leaflet, 0.250 MPa, samples sewn with Gore-Tex were found to show the least difference in behavior with respect to the controls, indicating that this material presented the lowest degree of interaction with the pericardium. In conclusion, the suture clearly has deleterious effects on the resistance of both calf and porcine pericardium, which showed no statistically significant differences in terms of resistance to rupture when their respective sutured or unsutured samples were compared, except in the case of porcine pericardium sewn with silk, which presented lower resistance to rupture in all the zones studied. These findings suggest that the hypothesis that porcine pericardium is less resistant is erroneous.

The Gore-Tex suture also presented a lower degree of interaction with the porcine pericardium, with values similar to the working stress of a cardiac valve leaflet.

This methodology and the results should be evaluated in dynamic studies, such as fatigue testing, that not only confirm the resistance of the material but establish the durability of the samples being assayed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Vongpatanasin, W. , Hillis, L.D. and Lange, R.A. , “Medical progress: prosthetic heart valves”, N. Engl. J. Med., 335, 407–416 (1996).

2. Guerra, F. , Bortolotti, U. , Thiene, G. , Milano, A. , Mazzucco, A. , Talenti, E. , Stellin, G. and Gallucci, V. , “Long-term performance of the Hancock porcine bioprosthesis in the tricuspid position. A review of forty-five patients with fourteen-year follow-up”, J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., 99, 838–845 (1990).

3. Grunkemeier, G.L. , Jamieson, W.R.E. , Miller, D.C. and Starr, A. , “Actuarial versus actual risk of porcine structural valve deterioration”, J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., 108, 709–718 (1994).

4. Kent, P.D. , Tazelaar, H.D. , Edwards, W.D. and Orszulak, T.A. , “Temporal changes in the surgical pathology of prosthetic aortic valves: a study of 157 cases spanning 26 years (1970–1995)”, Cardiovasc. Pathol., 17, 9–23 (1998).

5. Munro, A.I. , Jamieson, W.R.E. , Burr, L.H. , Ling, H. , Miyagishima, R.T. and Germann, E. , “Comparison of porcine bioprostheses and mechanical prostheses in multiple valve replacement operations”, Ann. Thorac. Surg., 60, S459–S463 (1995).

6. Tyers, G.F.O. , Jamieson, W.R.E. , Munro, I.A. , Germann, E. , Burr, L.H. , Miyagishima, R.T. and Ling, L. , “Reoperation in biological and mechanical valve populations: fate of the reoperative patient”, Ann. Thorac. Surg., 60, S464–S469 (1995).

7. Munro, A.I. , Jamieson, W.R.E. , Tyers, G.F.O. and Germann, E. , “Tricuspid valve replacement: porcine bioprostheses and mechanical prostheses”, Ann. Thorac. Surg., 59, S470–S474 (1995).

8. Cannegieter, S.C. , Rosendaal, F.R. and Beiet, E. , “Thromboembolic and bleeding complications in patients with mechanical heart valve prostheses”, Circulation, 89, 635–641 (1994).

9. Hariza, F. , Papouin, G. , Barratt-Boyes, B. , Christia, G. and Whitlock, R. , “Tear in bioprosthetic heart valve leaflets without calcific degeneration”, J. Heart Valve. Dis., 5, 35–39 (1996).

10.

10. Bloomfield, P. , Wheatley, D.J. , Prescott, R.J. and Miller, H.C. , “Twelve-year comparison of a Bjork-Shiley mechanical heart valve with porcine bioprostheses”, N. Engl. J. Med., 324, 573–579 (1991).

11.

11. Jorge-Herro, E. , Fernandez, P. , Gutierrez, M. and Castillo-Olivares, J.L. , “Study of the calcification of bovine pericardium: analysis of the implication of lipids and proteoglycans”, Biomaterials, 12, 683–689 (1991).

12.

12. Talman, E.A. and Boughner, D.R. , “Internal shear properties of fresh porcine aortic valve cusps: implications for normal valve function”, J. Heart Valve Dis., 152–159 (1996).

13.

13. Sacks, M.S. , Chuong, C.J. and More, R. , “Collagen fiber architecture of bovine pericardium”, ASAIO J., 40, M632–M637 (1994).

14.

14. Garcia Páez, J.M. , Carrera, A. , Garcia Sestafe, J.V. , Jorge, E. , Millán, I. , Candela, I. and Castillo-Olivares, J.L. , “Is cutting stress responsible for the limited durability of heart valve bioprostheses?” J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., 100, 580–586 (1990).

15.

16. Garcia Páez, J.M. , Carrera, A. , Jorge Herrero, E. , Millán, I. , Navidad, R. , Candela, I. , Garcia Sestafe , and Castillo-Olivares, J.L. , “Effect of suture on the durability of bovine pericardium used in cardiac bioprostheses”, Biomaterials, 5, 172–176 (1994).

16.

17. Garcia Páez, J.M. , Carrera, A. , Garcia Sestafe, J.V. , Jorge Herrero, E. , Millán, I. , Navidad, R. , Cordon, A. and Castillo-Olivares, J.L. , “Resistance and elasticity of suture thread employed in cardiac bioprostheses”, Biomaterials, 15, 981–984 (1994).

17.

18. Gould, P.L. , Cataloguin, A. , Dhatt, P.S. , Chattopadhyay, A. and Clark, R. , “Stress analysis of the human aortic valve”, In: Computer and structures. London: Pergamon Press, vol. 3, pp. 377–384 (1973).

18.

19. Simionescu, D. , Simionescu, A. and Deac, R. , “Mapping of glutaraldehyde treated bovine pericardium and tissue selection for bioprosthetic heart valves”, J. Biomed. mater. Res., 27, 697–704 (1993).

19.

20. Braile, D.M. , Soares, M.J. , Souza, D.R. , Ramirez, D.A. , Suzigan, S. and Godoy, M.F. , “Mapping of bovine pericardium: physical and histopathologic test”, J. Heart Valve Dis., 7, 202–206 (1998).

20.

21. Hiester, E.D. and Sacks, M.S. , “Optimal bovine pericardial tissue selection sites. I: Fiber architecture and tissue thickness measurements”, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 39, 207–214 (1998).

21.

22. Hiester, E.D. and Sacks, M.S. , “Optimal bovine pericardial tissue selection sites. II: Cardiographic analysis”, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 39, 215–221 (1998).

22.

23. Garcia Páez, J.M. , Carrera, A. , Garcia Sestafe, J.V. , Jorge Herrero, E. , Navidad, R. , Cordon, A. and Castillo-Olivares, J.L. , “Elastic behaviour of sutured calf pericardium: influence of the suture threads”, Biomaterials, 17, 1677–1683 (1996).

23.

24. Carrera, A. , Garcia Páez, J.M. , Garcia Sestafe, J.V. , Jorge Herrero, E. , Salvador, J. , Cordon, A. and Castillo-Olivares, J.L. , “Selection and interaction of biomaterials used in the construction of cardiac bioprostheses”, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 39, 568–574 (1998).

24.

25. von Fraunhofer, J.A. and Sichina, W.J. , “Characterization of surgical suture materials using dynamic mechanical analysis”, Biomaterials, 13, 715–720 (1992).

25.

26. Smith, D.B. , Sacks, M.S. , Pattany, P.M. and Schroeder, R. , “High-resolution magnetic resonance imaging to characterize the geometry of fatigued porcine bioprosthetic heart valves”, J. Heart Valve Dis., 6, 424–432 (1997).

26.

27. Kunzelman, K. , Cochran, R.P. and Verrier, E. , “Finite element of mitral valve pathology, long-term effects”, J. Med. Impl., 3, 161–179 (1993).