Constitution or Competence? the SNP's Re-Election in 2011

Abstract

The Scottish National Party's outright win in the Scottish Parliament election on 5 May 2011 confounded pre-election polls and commentaries as well as a (broadly) proportional electoral system which was held to minimise the risk of a Nationalist majority moving Scotland to independence. But an extraordinary result in historical context looks much more ordinary when we explore voters' attitudes and choices. According to data from the ESRC-funded Scottish Election Study 2011, the SNP won its majority for that most mundane of electoral reasons: most voters thought that the party would do a better job in office than its rivals, including its chief rival, the Labour Party.

Keywords

Scottish Parliament elections valence Scottish National Party Labour Party

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

(2011) ‘A Better Nation?’, Andrew John Williamson Memorial Lecture, Stirling University, 13 October.

Available from: http://politics.caledonianmercury.com/2011/10/13/a-better-nation-%E2%80%93-a-speech-by-douglas-alexander-mp/ [Accessed 17 November 2011].

Anderson

C. J.

(2000) ‘Economic Voting and Political Context: A Comparative Perspective’, Electoral Studies, 19 (2/3), 151–70.

BBC News (2011) ‘Scottish Election: Iain Gray Targeted by Protesters’, Scotland, 7 April. Available from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-12998918 [Accessed 6 November 2011].

Bennie

Brand

Mitchell

(1997) How Scotland Votes. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Brown

McCrone

Paterson

Surridge

(1999) The Scottish Electorate. Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Butler

Stokes

(1969) Political Change in Britain. London: Macmillan.

Campbell

Converse

P. E.

Miller

W. E.

Stokes

D. E.

(1960) The American Voter. New York: Wiley.

Clarke

McCutcheon

(2009) ‘The Dynamics of Party Identification Reconsidered’, Public Opinion Quarterly, 73 (4), 704–28.

10.

Clarke

Sanders

Stewart

Whiteley

(2004) Political Choice in Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

11.

Clarke

Sanders

Stewart

Whiteley

(2009) Performance Politics and the British Voter. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

12.

Clarke

Sanders

Stewart

Whiteley

(2011) ‘Valence Politics and Electoral Choice in Britain, 2010’, Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties, 21 (2), 237–53.

13.

Crewe

(1988) ‘Partisan Alignment Ten Years On’, in Berrington

(ed.), Change in British Politics, second Edition. London: Frank Cass, pp. 183–215.

14.

Crewe

Thomson

(1999) ‘Party Loyalties: Dealignment or Realignment?’, in Evans

Norris

(eds), Critical Elections. London: Sage, pp. 64–86.

15.

Curtice

(2006) ‘Is Holyrood Accountable and Representative?’, in Bromley

Curtice

Hinds

Park

(eds), Has Devolution Delivered? Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 90–108.

16.

Curtice

McCrone

McEwen

Marsh

Ormston

(2009) Revolution or Evolution? The 2007 Scottish Elections. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

17.

Denver

Johns

(2010) ‘Scottish Parliament Elections: “British Not Scottish” or “More Scottish than British”?’, Scottish Affairs, 70 (1), 9–28.

18.

Evans

Andersen

(2006) ‘The Political Conditioning of Economic Perceptions’, Journal of Politics, 68 (1), 194–207.

19.

Fiorina

(1981) Retrospective Voting in American National Elections. New Haven CT: Yale University Press.

20.

Foley

(2000) The British Presidency. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

21.

Green

(2007) ‘When Voters and Parties Agree: Valence Issues and Party Competition’, Political Studies, 55 (3), 629–55.

22.

Johns

Carman

(2008) ‘Coping with Coalitions? Scottish Voters under a Proportional System’, Representation, 44 (4), 301–15.

23.

Johns

Denver

Mitchell

Pattie

(2009) ‘Valence Politics in Scotland: Towards an Explanation of the 2007 Election’, Political Studies, 57 (1), 207–33.

24.

Johns

Denver

Mitchell

Pattie

(2010) Voting for a Scottish Government: The Scottish Parliament Elections of 2007. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

25.

Key

V. O.

(1966) The Responsible Electorate. Cambridge MA: Belknap.

26.

Livingstone

(2011) ‘Running up a Dead End?’, STV News, Election 2011, 7 April. Available from: http://stv.jamielivingstone.com/stv/iain-gray-running-up-a-dead-end/ [Accessed 7 January 2013].

27.

Miller

(1981) The End of British Politics? Oxford: Clarendon.

28.

Park

McCrone

(2006) ‘The Devolution Conundrum?’, in Bromley

Curtice

Hinds

Park

(eds), Has Devolution Delivered? Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 15–28.

29.

Paterson

(2006) ‘Sources of Support for the SNP’, in Bromley

Curtice

Hinds

Park

(eds), Has Devolution Delivered? Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 46–70.

30.

Paterson

Brown

Curtice

Hinds

McCrone

Park

Sproston

Surridge

(2001) New Scotland, New Politics? Edinburgh: Polygon.

31.

Pattie

Denver

Johns

Mitchell

(2011) ‘Raising the Tone? The Impact of “Positive” and “Negative” Campaigning on Voting in the 2007 Scottish Parliament Election’, Electoral Studies, 30 (2), 333–43.

32.

Powell

G. B.

Whitten

(1993) ‘A Cross-National Analysis of Economic Voting: Taking Account of Political Context’, American Journal of Political Science, 37 (2), 391–414.

33.

Quinn

(2008) ‘The Conservative Party and the “Centre Ground” of British Politics’, Journal of Elections, Public Opinion & Parties, 18 (2), 179–99.

34.

Reif

K.-H.

Schmitt

(1980) ‘Nine Second-Order National Elections: A Conceptual Framework for the Analysis of European Election Results’, European Journal of Political Research, 8 (1), 3–44.

35.

The Scotsman (2011) ‘From Station to Subway: The Flight of Iain Gray’, News, 7 April. Available from: http://www.scotsman.com/news/from_station_to_subway_the_flight_of_iain_gray_1_1573538 [Accessed 6 November 2011].

36.

Stevens

Karp

Hodgson

(2011) ‘Party Leaders as Movers and Shakers in British Campaigns? Results from the 2010 Election’, Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties, 21 (2), 125–45.

37.

Surridge

(2006) ‘A Better Union?’, in Bromley

Curtice

Hinds

Park

(eds), Has Devolution Delivered? Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, pp. 29–45.

38.

Swaddle

Heath

(1989) ‘Official and Reported Turnout in the British General Election of 1987’, British Journal of Political Science, 19 (4), 537–51.

39.

Wheatley

Carman

Mendez

Mitchell

(2011) ‘The Dimensionality of the Scottish Political Space: Results from an Experiment on the 2011 Holyrood Elections’. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Elections, Public Opinion and Parties Specialist Group of the Political Studies Association, Exeter, 9–11 September.