Within the context of the devolution process in England, Cornwall and the North-East stand out in contrasting comparison. The North-East was given the opportunity to vote for a regional assembly, which it rejected in 2004, while the strong popular movement for an assembly in Cornwall was ignored by central government. This is reflected in the literature on the English question and regionalism in the UK, which focuses on the example of the North-East, and largely overlooks the grassroots support in Cornwall and the opportunities for understanding regionalism that this could provide. In this article, we explore why this might be the case, developing a comparison between the two areas in the context of the campaigns for setting up directly elected assemblies. We look at the territorial status of the two areas, how the respective campaigns were organised, the types of group involved, the motives that were driving activists, and each region's political significance to Labour. We find central control of the political agenda to be a key issue behind the failure of English regionalism.
AugheyA. (2007) The Politics of Englishness. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
4.
BondR.McCroneD. (2004) ‘The Growth of English Regionalism? Institutions and Identity’, Regional and Federal Studies, 14 (1), 1–25.
5.
BondR.McCroneR.BrownA. (2003) ‘National Identity and Economic Development: Reiteration, Recapture, Reinterpretation and Repoliticisation’, Nations and Nationalism, 9 (3), 371–91.
6.
BurchM.GomezR. (2002) ‘The English Regions and the European Union’, Regional Studies, 36 (7), 767–78.
7.
CollsR. (2000) ‘Our Friends in the South: Bad Day in Newcastle’, Political Quarterly, 71 (4), 463–8.
8.
CollsR.LancasterB. (1998) Geordies: The Roots of Regionalism. Newcastle: Northumbria University Press.
9.
Cornish Constitutional Convention (CCC) (2003) Your Region, Your Choice: The Case for Cornwall, Cornwall's Response to the Government's Devolution White Paper. Truro: Cornish Constitional Convention. Available from: http://www.cornishassembly.org/publications.htm [Accessed 20 August 2011].
10.
Cornish Constitutional Convention (CCC) (2009) Cornish Assembly: The Next Push. Truro: Cornish Constitutional Convention. Available from: http://www.cornishassembly.org/publications.htm [Accessed 20 August 2011].
Cornwall Industrial Development Association (CIDA) (1976) The Economy of Cornwall: A Discussion Document Prepared with Particular Reference to the Cornwall Structure Plan. Redruth: Cornwall Studies Library.
14.
Cornwall Social and Economic Research Group (COSERG) (1988) Cornwall at the Crossroad. Redruth: Eagles Press.
15.
DaviesR. (1999) Devolution: A Process Not an Event. Cardiff: Institute of Welsh Affairs.
16.
DeaconB. (2004) ‘Under Construction: Culture and Regional Formation in South West England’, European Urban and Regional Studies, 11 (3), 213–25.
FenwickJ.McMillanJ.ElcockH. (2009) ‘Local Government and the Problem of English Governance’, Local Government Studies, 35 (1), 5–20.
22.
HaleA. (1997) ‘Rethinking Celtic Cornwall: An Ethnographic Approach’, in PaytonP. (ed.), Cornish Studies Five. Exeter: University of Exeter Press, pp. 85–99.
23.
HarrisonJ. (2006) ‘The Political Economy of Blair's “New Regional Policy”’, Geoforum, 37, 932–43.
24.
HarrisonJ. (2008) ‘Stating the Production of Scales: Centrally Orchestrated Regionalism, Regionally Orchestrated Centrism’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 32 (4), 922–41.
25.
HazellR. (2006) The English Question. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
26.
HechterM. (1975) Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development. London: Routledge.
27.
House of Commons (2001) General Election 1997. House of Commons Library: Research Paper 01/38, 29 March.
28.
House of Commons (2005) General Election 2005. House of Commons Library: Research Paper 05/33, 17 May.
29.
HutchinsonJ. (2005) Nations as Zones of Conflict.London: Sage.
30.
JewellH. M. (1994) The North—South Divide: The Origins of Northern Consciousness in England. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
31.
JonesM.MacLeodG. (1999) ‘Towards a Regional Renaissance? Reconfiguring and Rescaling England's Economic Governance’, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 24 (3), 295–313.
32.
KeatingM. (1989) ‘Regionalism, Devolution and the State’, in GarsideP. L.HebbertM. (eds), British Regionalism 1900–2000.London: Mansell, pp. 158–72.
33.
KeatingM. (1998) The New Regionalism in Western Europe: Territorial Restructuring and Political Change. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
34.
KeatingM. (2008a) ‘A Quarter of a Century of the Europe of the Regions’, Regional and Federal Studies, 18 (5), 629–35.
35.
KeatingM. (2008b) ‘Thirty Years of Territorial Politics’, West European Politics, 31 (1), 60–81.
36.
LowennaS. (2004) ‘Jenner, Dunscombe Jewel and Their Milieu’, in PaytonP. (ed.), Cornish Studies Twelve. Exeter: Exeter University Press, pp. 61–87.
37.
MatherJ. (2000) ‘Labour and the English Regions: Centralised Devolution?’, Contemporary British History, 14 (3), 10–38.
38.
MorganK. (2002) ‘The English Question: Regional Perspectives on a Fractured Nation’, Regional Studies, 36 (7), 797–810.
39.
NairnT. (1977) The Break-Up of Britain. London: New Left Books.
40.
North East Constitutional Convention (NECC) (1999) Time for a Change. Newcastle: North East Constitutional Convention.
41.
ODPM (2002) Your Region, Your Choice: Revitalising the English Regions. London: HMSO.
PaytonP. (1991) ‘Understanding Cornwall: Centre and Periphery in the Multi National State’. UK Politics Working Group Annual Conference, Politics Association.
45.
PaytonP. (1993) ‘Territory and Identity’, in PaytonP. (ed.), The Making of Modern Cornwall: Cornwall since the War. Redruth: Institute of Cornish Studies, pp. 224–53.
46.
RawnsleyS. (2000) ‘Constructing “the North”: Space and a Sense of Place’, in KirkN. (ed.), Northern Identities. Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 3–22.
47.
Rodriguez-PoseA.GillN. (2005) ‘On the “Economic Dividend” of Devolution’, Regional Studies, 39 (4), 405–20.
48.
RokkanS.UrwinD. (1982) The Politics of Territorial Identity: Studies in European Regionalism. London: Sage.
49.
SandfordM. (2002) The Cornish Question: Devolution in the South West Region. London: The Constitution Unit, University College London.
50.
SandfordM. (2006) ‘English Regionalism through the Looking Glass: Perspectives on the English Question from the North East and Cornwall’, National Identities, 8 (1), 77–93.
51.
ShieldsR. (1991) Places on the Margin: Alternative Geographies of Modernity. London: Routledge.
52.
StoyleM. (2002) West Britons. Exeter: Exeter University Press.
53.
TieboutC. (1956) ‘A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures’, Journal of Political Economy, 64 (5), 416–24.
54.
TomaneyJ. (2000) ‘End of the Empire State? New Labour and Devolution in the United Kingdom’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 24 (3), 675–88.
55.
TomaneyJ. (2006) ‘The Idea of English Regionalism’, in HazellR. (ed.), The English Question. Manchester: Manchester University Press, pp. 158–73.
56.
TomaneyJ.PikeA. (2006) ‘Deepening Democracy and Engaging Civil Society? Economic and Social Partners and Devolved Governance in the UK’, Regional and Federal Studies, 16 (2), 129–35.
57.
TregidgaG. (1997) ‘The Politics of the Celto-Cornish Revival, 1886–1939’, in PaytonP. (ed.), Cornish Studies Five. Exeter: Exeter University Press, pp. 125–50.
58.
TregidgaG. (2000) The Liberal Party in South West Britain since 1918: Political Decline, Dormancy and Rebirth. Exeter: University of Exeter Press.
59.
TregidgaG. (2006) Killerton, Camborne and Westminster: The Political Correspondence of Sir Francis and Lady Acland 1910–1912. Exeter: Short Run Press.
WardN.LoweP. (2007) ‘Blairite Modernisation and Countryside Policy’, Political Quarterly, 78 (3), 412–21.
62.
WillettJ. (2008) ‘Cornish Identity, Vague Notion or Social Fact?’, in PaytonP. (ed.), Cornish Studies Sixteen. Exeter: Exeter University Press, pp. 183–205.
