Rescaling and Responsibilising the Politics of Urban Resilience: From National Security to Local Place-Making

Abstract

Drawing on, and integrating, emerging theories and practices of urban resilience, this article charts the emergence and progression of different ‘waves’ of resilience policy in the UK. Specifically, it argues that changing practices of resilience have emerged both as a function of time, and in relation to a range of changing socio-political and economic pressures, which have re-articulated the meaning, scale, operational role of, and responsibility for, resilience. The article seeks to critique resilience policy, raising questions about the usefulness of emerging resilience as the central organising concept for depicting how urban systems respond to contemporary and future crises.

Keywords

urban resilience security counter-terrorism localism responsibilisation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adger

(2000), ‘Social and Ecological Resilience: Are They Related?’, Progress in Human Geography 24, pp. 347–364.

Beck

(1992), Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity, London: Sage.

Beck

(2002), ‘The Terrorist Threat: World Risk Society Revisited’, Theory, Culture and Society 19(4), pp. 39–55.

Benton-Short

(2007), ‘Bollards, Bunkers, and Barriers: Securing the National Mall in Washington DC’, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 25(3), pp. 424–446.

Bosher

L.S.

(ed.) (2008), Hazards and the Built Environment: Attaining Built-In Resilience, London: Taylor and Francis.

Boyle

Haggerty

(2009), ‘Spectacular Security: Mega-events and the Security Complex’, International Political Sociology 3, pp. 257–274.

Brand

Jax

(2007), ‘Focusing the Meaning(s) of Resilience: Resilience as a Descriptive Concept and a Boundary Object’, Ecology and Society 12(1), p. 23.

Briggs

(2005), Joining Forces: From National Security to Networked Security, London: Demos.

Bugliarelio

(2003), ‘Urban Security in Perspective’, Technology in Society 25(4), pp. 499–507.

10.

Burby

Deyle

Godschalk

Olhanksky

(2000), ‘Creating Hazard Resilient Communities through Land-Use Planning’, Natural Hazards Review 1(2), pp. 99–106.

11.

Cabinet Office (2003), Dealing with Disaster (rev. 3rd edn), London: Cabinet Office.

12.

Cabinet Office (2008a), National Risk Register, London: Cabinet Office.

13.

Cabinet Office (2008b), Realising Britain's Potential: Future Strategic Challenges for Britain, London: Cabinet Office.

14.

Cabinet Office (2009), Building Britain's Future, London: Cabinet Office.

15.

Cabinet Office (2011), Big Society. Available from: http://www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/big-society [Accessed 1 December 2011].

16.

Chandler

(2012), ‘Resilience and Human Security: The Post-Interventionist Paradigm’, Security Dialogue 43(3), pp. 213–229.

17.

Coaffee

(2000), ‘Fortification, Fragmentation and the Threat of Terrorism in the City of London’ in Gold

J.R.

Revill

G.E.

(eds.), Landscapes of Defence, London: Addison Wesley Longman, pp. 114–129.

18.

Coaffee

(2003), Terrorism, Risk and the City, Aldershot: Ashgate.

19.

Coaffee

(2004), ‘Rings of Steel, Rings of Concrete and Rings of Confidence: Designing out Terrorism in Central London pre and post 9/11’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 28(1), pp. 201–211.

20.

Coaffee

(2006), ‘From Counter-Terrorism to Resilience’, European Legacy: Journal of the International Society for the Study of European Ideas 11(4), pp. 389–403.

21.

Coaffee

(2010), ‘Protecting Vulnerable Cities: The UK Resilience Response to Defending Everyday Urban Infrastructure’, International Affairs 86(4), pp. 939–954.

22.

Coaffee

Bosher

(2008), ‘Integrating Counter-Terrorist Resilience into Sustainability’, Proceeding of the Institute of Civil Engineers: Urban Design and Planning 161, pp. 75–84.

23.

Coaffee

Murakami Wood

(2006), ‘Security is Coming Home: Rethinking Scale and Constructing Resilience in the Global Urban Response to Terrorist Risk’, International Relations 20(4), pp. 503–517.

24.

Coaffee

O'Hare

(2008), ‘Urban Resilience and National Security: The Role for Planners’, Proceeding of the Institute of Civil Engineers: Urban Design and Planning 161(DP4), pp. 171–182.

25.

Coaffee

Rogers

(2008), ‘Rebordering the City for New Security Challenges: From Counter Terrorism to Community Resilience’, Space and Polity 12(2), pp. 101–118.

26.

Coaffee

Murakami Wood

Rogers

(2008), The Everyday Resilience of the City: How Cities Respond to Terrorism and Disaster, London: Palgrave/Macmillan.

27.

Coaffee

O'Hare

Hawkesworth

(2009), ‘The Visibility of (In)Security: The Aesthetics of Planning Urban Defences against Terrorism’, Security Dialogue 40, pp. 489–511.

28.

Cote

Nightingale

(2012), ‘Resilience Thinking Meets Social Theory Situating Social Change in Socio-ecological Systems (SES) Research’, Progress in Human Geography 36(4), pp. 475–489.

29.

Coward

(2006), ‘Against Anthropocentrism: The Destruction of the Built Environment as a Distinct Form of Political Violence’, Review of International Studies 32, pp. 419–437.

30.

Davoudi

(2012), ‘Resilience: A Bridging Concept or a Dead End?’, Planning Theory & Practice 13(2), pp. 299–307.

31.

De Goede

Randalls

(2009), ‘Precaution, Preemption: Arts and Technologies of the Actionable Future’, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 27(5), pp. 859–878.

32.

Dean

(1999), Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society, London: Sage.

33.

Edwards

(2009), Resilient Nation, London: Demos.

34.

Ericson

Haggerty

(1997), Policing the Risk Society, Oxford: Clarendon.

35.

Foucault

(1977), Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, London: Penguin.

36.

Foucault

(2007), Security, Territory, Population, Basingstoke: Palgrave.

37.

Godschalk

D.R.

(2003), ‘Urban Hazard Mitigation: Creating Resilient Cities’, Natural Hazards Review 4(3), pp. 136–143.

38.

Goldstein

(ed.) (2012), Collaborative Resilience: Moving through Crisis to Opportunity, London: MIT Press.

39.

Goodwin

(2012), ‘Why We Should Reject “Nudge”’, Politics 32(2), pp. 85–92.

40.

Graham

(2001), ‘In a Moment: On Glocal Mobilities and the Terrorized City’, City 5(3), pp. 411–415.

41.

Graham

(2004), Cities, War and Terrorism: Towards an Urban Geopolitics, Oxford: Blackwell.

42.

Graham

(2006), ‘Cities and the “War on Terror”’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 30(2), pp. 255–276.

43.

HM Government (2006), Countering International Terrorism: The United Kingdom's Strategy, CM 688, London: HM Government.

44.

HM Government (2010a), Working Together to Protect Crowded Places, London: TSO.

45.

HM Government (2010b), Crowded Places: The Planning System and Counterterrorism, London: TSO.

46.

HM Government (2010c), Decentralisation and the Localism Bill: An Essential Guide, London: TSO.

47.

Home Office (2004), Preparing for Emergencies: What You Need to Know, London: TSO.

48.

Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) (2009), Shared Responsibilities: A National Security Strategy for the United Kingdom, IPPR Commission on National Security in the 21st Century, London: IPPR.

49.

Institution of Civil Engineers (2009), State of the Nation Report: Defending Critical Infrastructure, London: ICE.

50.

Isin

E.F.

(2004), ‘The Neurotic Citizen’, Citizenship Studies 8(3), pp. 217–235.

51.

Jones

Pykett

Whitehead

(2011), ‘Governing Temptation: Changing Behaviour in an Age of Libertarian Paternalism’, Progress in Human Geography 35(4), pp. 83–501.

52.

Leichenko

(2011), ‘Climate Change and Urban Resilience’, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 3(3), pp. 164–168.

53.

Lentzos

Rose

(2009), ‘Governing Insecurity: Contingency Planning, Protection, Resilience’, Economy & Society 38(2), pp. 230–254.

54.

Little

(2002), ‘Controlling Cascading Failure: Understanding the Vulnerabilities of Interconnected Infrastructures’, Journal of Urban Technology 9–10, pp. 109–123.

55.

Little

(2004), ‘A Socio-technical Systems Approach to Understanding and Enhancing the Reliability of Interdependent Infrastructure Systems’, International Journal of Emergency Management 2(1–2), pp. 98–110.

56.

Martin

(2012), ‘Regional Economic Resilience, Hysteresis and Recessionary Shocks’, Journal of Economic Geography 12(1), pp. 1–32.

57.

Newman

Beatley

Boyer

(2009), Resilient Cities: Responding to Peak Oil and Climate Change, London: Island Press.

58.

O'Brien

Read

(2005), ‘The Future of UK Emergency Management: New Wine, Old Skin?’, Disaster Prevention and Management 14(3), pp. 353–361.

59.

O' Malley

(2010), ‘Resilient Subjects: Uncertainty, Warfare and Liberalism’, Economy and Society 39(4), pp. 488–509.

60.

Porter

Davoudi

(2012), ‘The Politics of Resilience for Planning: A Cautionary Note’, Planning Theory & Practice 13(2), pp. 329–333.

61.

Raco

Street

(2011), ‘Resilience Planning, Economic Change and the Politics of Post-Recession Development in London and Hong Kong’, Urban Studies 49(5), pp. 1065–1087.

62.

Reid

(2012), ‘The Disastrous and Debased Subject of Resilience’, Development Dialogues 58, pp. 67–81.

63.

Rogers

C.D.F.

Bouch

C.J.

Williams

Barber

A.R.G.

Baker

C.J.

Bryson

J.R.

Chapman

D.N.

Chapman

Coaffee

Jefferson

Quinn

A.D.

(2011), ‘Resistance and Resilience: Paradigms for Critical Local’, Proceedings of the Institute of Civil Engineers: Mechanical Engineering 165(2), pp. 73–83.

64.

Rose

(2000), ‘Government and Control’, British Journal of Criminology 40(2), pp. 321–339.

65.

Security Service (MI5) (2006), Protecting against Terrorism, London: TSO.

66.

Shaw

(2012), ‘“Reframing” Resilience: Challenges for Planning Theory and Practice’, Planning Theory & Practice 13(2), pp. 308–312.

67.

Simpson

Stoffregen

(2011), ‘The Urban Dream vs the Urban Myth’, Crisis Response Journal 6(4), pp. 8–9.

68.

Thaler

Sunstein

(2008), Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth and Happiness, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

69.

United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction (2012), How to Make Cities More Resilient: A Handbook for Local Government, Geneva: UNISDR.

70.

Walker

Broderick

(2006), The Civil Contingencies Act 2004: Risk Resilience, and the Law in the United Kingdom, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

71.

Walker

Burningham

(2011), ‘Flood Risk Vulnerability and Environmental Justice: Evidence and Evaluation in the UK Context’, Critical Social Policy 31(2), pp. 216–240.

72.

Walker

Cooper

(2011), ‘Genealogies of Resilience: From Systems Ecology to the Political Economy of Crisis Adaptation’, Security Dialogue 42(2), pp. 143–160.

73.

Weizman

(2004), ‘Strategic Points, Flexible Lines, Tense Surfaces, and Political Volumes: Ariel Sharon and the Geometry of Occupation’ in Graham

(ed.), Cities, War, and Terrorism: Towards an Urban Geopolitics, Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 172–191.

74.

Wilkinson

(2011), ‘Social-Ecological Resilience: Insights and Issues for Planning Theory’, Planning Theory 11(2), pp. 148–169.

75.

The Young Foundation (2010), The State of Happiness: Can Public Policy Shape People's Wellbeing and Resilience?, London: The Young Foundation.

76.

Zolli

Healy

(2012), Resilience: Why Things Bounce Back, London: Headline.