We report a study of 3- to 5-year-olds who performed a magnitude-comparison task. Stimuli were a series of pairs of arrays that sometimes differed in numerosity, and the children were asked to point to the more numerous array in each pair. The proportion of accurate responses was above chance for all age groups. However, error patterns were consistent with analog models of magnitude representation. Errors varied systematically with the ratio of stimulus pairs. Items with a 2:3 ratio were harder than items with a 1:2 ratio. Performance on posttests of verbal counting ability was variable, but did not predict performance on the numerical discrimination task. We argue that neither verbal counting nor nonnumerical perceptual strategies can explain these results. This study supports the hypothesis that adults and children share preverbal, analog representations of magnitude.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AntellS.E.KeatingD.P.
(1983).
Perception of numerical invariance in neonates.
Child Development,
54, 695–701.
2.
BertelliR.JoanniE.MartlewM.
(1998).
Relationship between children's counting ability and their ability to reason about number.
European Journal of Psychology of Education,
13, 371–384.
3.
Bijeljac-BabicR.BertonciniJ.MehlerJ.
(1993).
How do 4-day-old infants categorize multisyllabic utterances?Developmental Psychology,
29, 711–721.
4.
BloomP.WynnK.
(1997).
Linguistic cues in the acquisition of number words.
Journal of Child Language,
24, 511–533.
5.
BrannonE.M.TerraceH.S.
(1998).
Ordering of the numerosities 1 to 9 by monkeys.
Science,
282, 746–749.
6.
BroadbentH.A.ChurchR.M.MeckW.H.RatikinB.C.
(1993).
Quantitative relationships between timing and counting. In
BoysenS.T.CapaldiJ. (Eds.),
The development of numerical competence: Animal and human models (pp. 171–187).
Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
7.
CanfieldR.L.SmithE.G.
(1996).
Number-based expectations and sequential enumeration by 5-month-old infants.
Developmental Psychology,
32, 269–279.
8.
CareyS.
(1998).
Knowledge of number: Its evolution and ontogeny.
Science,
282, 641–642.
9.
DehaeneS.
(1992).
Varieties of numerical abilities.
Cognition,
44, 1–42.
10.
FusonK.C.
(1988).
Children's counting and concepts of number.
New York: Springer Verlag.
11.
GallistelC.R.
(1990).
The organization of learning.
Cambridge, MA: Bradford Books/MIT Press.
12.
GallistelC.R.GelmanR.
(1992).
Preverbal and verbal counting and computation.
Cognition,
44, 43–74.
13.
GelmanR.
(1972).
The nature and development of early number concepts.
Advances in Child Development and Behavior,
7, 115–167.
14.
GelmanR.
(1993).
A rational-constructivist account of early learning about numbers and objects. In
MedinD.L. (Ed.),
The psychology of learning and motivation (pp. 61–96).
San Diego: Academic Press.
15.
GelmanR.GallistelC.R.
(1978).
The child's understanding of number.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
16.
MeckW.H.ChurchR.M.
(1983).
A mode control model of counting and timing processes.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes,
9, 320–334.
17.
MehlerJ.BeverT.G.
(1967).
Cognitive capacity of very young children.
Science,
158, 141–142.
18.
MillerK.F.
(1989).
Measurement as a tool for thought: The role of measuring procedures in children's understanding of quantitative invariance.
Developmental Psychology,
25, 589–600.
19.
MixK.S.HuttenlocherJ.LevinS.C.
(1996).
Do preschool children recognize auditory-visual numerical correspondences?Child Development,
67, 1592–1608.
20.
MoyerR.S.LandauerT.K.
(1967).
Time required for judgements of numerical inequality.
Nature,
215, 1519–1520.
21.
PiagetJ.
(1965).
The child's conception of number.
New York: W.W. Norton. (Original work published 1941)
22.
PlattJ.R.JohnsonD.M.
(1971).
Localization of position within a homogeneous behavior chain: Effects of error contingencies.
Learning & Motivation,
2, 386–414.
SieglerR.S.
(1981).
Developmental sequences within and between concepts.
Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development,
46(2, Serial No. 189).
27.
SojaN.N.CareyS.SpelkeE.S.
(1991).
Ontological categories guide young children's inductions of word meaning: Object terms and substance terms.
Cognition,
38, 179–211.
28.
StarkeyP.CooperR.G.
(1980).
Perception of numbers by human infants.
Science,
210, 1033–1035.
29.
StarkeyP.CooperR.G.
(1995).
The development of subitizing in young children.
British Journal of Developmental Psychology,
13, 399–420.
30.
StraussM.S.CurtisL.E.
(1981).
Infant perception of numerosity.
Child Development,
52, 1146–1152.
31.
TempleE.PoerM.
(1998).
Brain mechanisms of quantity are similar in 5-year-olds and adults.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA,
95, 7836–7841.
32.
WhalenJ.GallistelC.R.GelmanR.
(1999).
Nonverbal counting in humans: The psychophysics of number representation.
Psychological Science,
10, 130–137.
33.
WynnK.
(1990).
Children's understanding of counting.
Cognition,
36, 155–193.
34.
WynnK.
(1992).
Children's acquisition of the number words and the counting system.
Cognitive Psychology,
24, 220–251.
35.
WynnK.
(1996).
Infants' individuation and enumeration of actions.
Psychological Science,
7, 164–169.
36.
WynnK.ChiangW.-C.
(1998).
Infants' representation and tracking of objects: Implications from collections. Manuscript submitted for publication.
