Does low–level policing increase during gentrification? If so, are police responding to increased crime, increased demand by new residents, or are they attempting to “clean up” neighborhoods marked for economic redevelopment? To address these questions, I construct a longitudinal dataset of New York City neighborhoods from 2009 to 2015. I compile data on neighborhoods’ demographics, street stops, low–level arrests, crimes, 311 calls to the police, and—using a novel measure—property values. Maps, spatiotemporal modeling, and fixed effects regressions compare changes in stops and low–level arrests to changes in several measures of gentrification. I find, on average, calls to the police increased after a neighborhood's middle–class population grew. Calls did not translate into more stops or low–level arrests, however. Net of crime and spatial autocorrelation, police made more order–maintenance and proactive arrests following real estate market growth, suggesting development–directed policing. Property value growth in wealthy and already gentrified neighborhoods was not associated with an increase in arrests, underscoring policing's role in early–stage urban “renewal.” The article includes an analysis of three sources of property value data.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ACLU Illinois. 2014. “Newly Released Data Shows City Continues to Deny Equitable Police Services to South and West Side Neighborhoods.” ACLU, New York, NY.
BakerAl. 2016. “New York Police Still Struggle to Follow Street–Stop Rules, Report Finds.” The New York Times, February 16.
4.
BeckBrenden. 2017. “Broken Windows in the Cul–de–Sac? Race/Ethnicity and Quality–of–Life Policing in the Changing Suburbs.” Crime & Delinquency65:270–92.
5.
BeckBrenden, and GoldsteinAdam. 2017. “Governing Through Police? Housing Market Reliance, Welfare Retrenchment, and Police Budgeting in an Era of Declining Crime.” Social Forces96(3):1183–210.
6.
BeckettKatherine, and HerbertSteve. 2009. Banished: The New Social Control in Urban America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
7.
BergMark T., and LauritsenJanet L.2016. “Telling a Similar Story Twice? NCVS/UCR Convergence in Serious Violent Crime Rates in Rural, Suburban, and Urban Places (1973–2010).” Journal of Quantitative Criminology32(1):61–87.
8.
BillinghamChase M.2017. “Waiting for Bobos: Displacement and Impeded Gentrification in a Midwestern City.” City & Community16(2):145–68.
9.
BillinghamChase M., and KimelbergShelley McDonough. 2013. “Middle–Class Parents, Urban Schooling, and the Shift from Consumption to Production of Urban Space.” Sociological Forum28(1):85–108.
10.
BoggessLyndsay N., and HippJohn R.2014. “The Spatial Dimensions of Gentrification and the Consequences for Neighborhood Crime.” Justice Quarterly33(4):584–613.
11.
BragaAnthony A., WelshBrandon C., and SchnellCory. 2015. “Can Policing Disorder Reduce Crime? A Systematic Review and Meta–analysis.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency52(4):567–88.
12.
ChappellAllison T., MacDonaldJohn M., and ManzPatrick W.2006 “The Organizational Determinants of Police Arrest Decisions.” Crime & Delinquency52(2):287–306.
13.
ChauhanPreeti, TomascakShannon, CuevasCelina, HoodQuinn, and LuOlive. 2017. Trends in Arrests for Misdemeanor Charges in New York City, 1993–2016. Misdemeanor Justice Project. New York, NY: John Jay College of Criminal Justice.
14.
EngelRobin, and CohenDerek M.2014. “Racial Profiling.” In The Oxford Handbook of Police and Policing, edited by ReisigMichael D. and KaneRobert J.Oxford: Oxford University Press. Accessed June 30, 2019.
15.
FaganJeffrey, and MacDonaldJohn. 2012. “Policing, Crime and Legitimacy in New York and Los Angeles: The Social and Political Contexts of Two Historic Crime Declines.” Public Law & Legal Theory Working Paper Group. New York, NY: Columbia Law School.
16.
FaganJeffrey, GellerAmanda, DaviesGarth, and WestValerie. 2010. “Street Stops and Broken Windows Revisited.” Pp. 309–48 in Race, Ethnicity, and Policing, edited by RiceS.K. and WhiteM.D.New York, NY: New York University Press.
17.
FreemanLance. 2005. “Displacement or Succession? Residential Mobility in Gentrifying Neighborhoods.” Urban Affairs Review40(4):463–91.
18.
FreemanLance. 2006. There Goes the Hood: Views of Gentrification from the Ground Up. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
19.
Furman Center, NYU. 2016. Focus on Gentrification. New York, NY: Furman Center for Real Estate and Urban Policy, NYU School of Law and Wagner School of Public Service.
20.
GastonShytierra. 2018. “Enforcing Race: A Neighborhood–Level Explanation of Black–White Differences in Drug Arrests.” Crime & Delinquency65(4):499–526.
21.
GellerAmanda, FaganJeffrey, TylerTom, and LinkBruce G.2014. “Aggressive Policing and the Mental Health of Young Urban Men.” American Journal of Public Health104(12):2321–27.
22.
GelmanAndrew, FaganJeffrey, and KissAlex. 2007. “An Analysis of the New York City Police Department's “Stop–and–Frisk” Policy in the Context of Claims of Racial Bias.” Journal of the American Statistical Association102(479):813–23.
23.
GoelSharad, RaoJustin M., and ShroffRavi. 2016. “Precinct or Prejudice? Understanding Racial Disparities in New York City's Stop–and–Frisk Policy.” The Annals of Applied Statistics10(1):365–94.
24.
GreenbergDavid. 2013. “Studying New York City's Crime Decline: Methodological Issues.” Justice Quarterly31(1):154–88.
25.
GreerWilliam R.1985. “The Fortunes of the Lower East Side Are Rising.” The New York Times, August 4.
26.
HerbertSteve. 2009. Citizens, Cops, and Power: Recognizing the Limits of Community. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
27.
HowellBabe. 2009. Broken Lives from Broken Windows: The Hidden Costs of Aggressive Order–Maintenance Policing. New York University Review of Law & Social Change33:271–329.
28.
HwangJackelyn. 2016. “While Some Things Change, Some Things Stay the Same: Reflections on the Study of Gentrification.” City & Community15(3):226–30.
29.
HwangJackelyn, and LinJeffrey. 2016. “What Have We Learned About the Causes of Recent Gentrification?” Cityscape18(3):9–26.
30.
HwangJackelyn, and SampsonRobert J.2014. “Divergent Pathways of Gentrification: Racial Inequality and the Social Order of Renewal in Chicago Neighborhoods.” American Sociological Review79(4):726–51.
31.
JashnaniGaurav, BustamantePriscilla, and StoudtBrett G.2017. “Dispossession by Accumulation: The Impacts of Discretionary Arrests in New York City.” Race and Justice. https://doi.org/10.1177/2153368717742476.
32.
KreagerDerek A., LyonsChristopher J., and HaysZachary R.2011. “Urban Revitalization and Seattle Crime, 1982–2000.” Social Problems58(4):615–39.
33.
LandisJohn D.2016. “Tracking and Explaining Neighborhood Socioeconomic Change in US Metropolitan Areas between 1990 and 2010.” Housing Policy Debate26(1):2–52.
34.
LaniyonuAyobami. 2017. “Coffee Shops and Street Stops: Policing Practices in Gentrifying Neighborhoods.” Urban Affairs Review54(5):898–930.
35.
LauritsenJanet L., RezeyMaribeth L., and HeimerKaren. 2016. “When Choice of Data Matters: Analyses of US Crime Trends, 1973–2012.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology32(3):335–55.
36.
LegewieJoscha, and FaganJeffrey. 2018. “Aggressive Policing and the Educational Performance of Minority Youth.” American Sociological Review84:220–47.
37.
LegewieJoscha, and SchaefferMerlin. 2016. “Contested Boundaries: Explaining Where Ethnoracial Diversity Provokes Neighborhood Conflict.” American Journal of Sociology122(1):125–61.
38.
LenehanRose. 2017. “What Stop & Frisk Really Means: Discrimination and Use of Force.” Prison Policy Initiative, August 17.
39.
LermanAmy E., and WeaverVesla M.2014. Arresting Citizenship: The Democratic Consequences of American Crime Control. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
40.
LibermanAkiva M., KirkDavid S., and KimKideuk. 2014. “Labeling Effects of First Juvenile Arrests: Secondary Deviance and Secondary Sanctioning.” Criminology52(3):345–70.
41.
LoganJohn R., and MolotchHarvey. 1987. Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
42.
LoganJohn R., XuZengwang, and StultsBrian. 2014. “Interpolating US Decennial Census Tract Data from as Early as 1970 to 2010: A Longitudinal Tract Database” The Professional Geographer66(3):412–20.
43.
LyonsTara, KrüsiAndrea, PierreLeslie, SmallWill, and ShannonKate. 2017. “The Impact of Construction and Gentrification on an Outdoor Trans Sex Work Environment: Violence, Displacement and Policing.” Sexualities20(8):881–903.
44.
MacDonaldJohn, FaganJeffrey, and GellerAmanda. 2016. “The Effects of Local Police Surges on Crime and Arrests in New York City.” PLOS One11(6):e0157223.
45.
MaharawalManissa M.2017. “Black Lives Matter, Gentrification and the Security State in the San Francisco Bay Area.” Anthropological Theory17(3):338–64.
46.
MooreMark H., and BragaAnthony. 2003. The Bottom Line of Policing: What Citizens Should Value (and Measure!) in Police Performance. Washington, DC: Police Executive Research Forum.
47.
MooreMark H., and PoethigMargaret. 1999. “The Police as an Agency of Municipal Government: Implications for Measuring Police Effectiveness.” Pp. 151–68 in Measuring What Matters: Proceedings from the Policing Research Institute Meetings, edited by LangworthyR. H. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice, U.S. Department of Justice.
48.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2017. Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime and Communities. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
OcejoRichard E.2014. Upscaling Downtown: From Bowery Saloons to Cocktail Bars in New York City. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
52.
PapachristosAndrew V., SmithChris M., SchererMary L., and FugieroMelissa A.2011. “More Coffee, Less Crime? The Relationship between Gentrification and Neighborhood Crime Rates in Chicago, 1991 to 2005.” City & Community10(3):215–40.
53.
ParekhTrushna. 2015. “‘They Want to Live in the Tremé, but They Want It for Their Ways of Living’: Gentrification and Neighborhood Practice in Tremé, New Orleans.”Urban Geography36(2):201–20.
54.
ParkerKaren F., and MaggardScott R.2005. “Structural Theories and Race–Specific Drug Arrests: What Structural Factors Account for the Rise in Race–Specific Drug Arrests Over Time?” Crime & Delinquency51(4):521–47.
55.
PetersMark G., and EurePhilip K.2016. “An Analysis of Quality–of–Life Summonses, Quality–of–Life Misdemeanor Arrests, and Felony Crime in New York City, 2010–2015.” New York, NY: New York City Department of Investigation Office of the Inspector General for the NYPD.
RaiCandice. 2011. “Positive Loitering and Public Goods: The Ambivalence of Civic Participation and Community Policing in the Neoliberal City.” Ethnography12(1):65–88.
58.
RolandiRobert. 2017. Personal phone communication with Robert Rolandi, City Assessor, New York City Department of Finance. September 13.
59.
RosenfeldRichard, and FornangoRobert. 2017. “The Relationship between Crime and Stop, Question, and Frisk Rates in New York City Neighborhoods.” Justice Quarterly34(6):931–51.
60.
SaundersPenelope, and KirbyJennifer. 2010. “Move Along: Community–Based Research into the Policing of Sex Work in Washington, DC.” Social Justice37(1):107–27.
61.
SharpElaine B.2013. “Politics, Economics, and Urban Policing: The postindustrial City Thesis and Rival Explanations of Heightened Order Maintenance Policing.” Urban Affairs Review50(3):340–65.
62.
SmithNeil. 1996. The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and the Revanchist City. Psychology Press.
63.
StoudtBrett G., FineMichelle, and FoxMadeline. 2011. Growing Up Policed in the Age of Aggressive Policing Policies. New York: John Jay College of Criminal Justice.
64.
StuartForrest. 2016. “From ‘Rabble Management’ to ‘Recovery Management’: Policing Homelessness in Marginal Urban Space.”Urban Studies51(9):1909–25.
65.
TimberlakeJeffrey M., and Johns–WolfeElaina. 2017. “Neighborhood Ethnoracial Composition and Gentrification in Chicago and New York, 1980 to 2010.” Urban Affairs Review53(2):236–72.
66.
TylerTom R.2005. “Policing in Black and White: Ethnic Group Differences in Trust and Confidence in the Police.” Police Quarterly8(3):322–42.
67.
VaiseyStephen, and MilesAndrew. 2017. “What You Canand Can—and Can't—Do with Three–Wave Panel Data.” Sociological Methods & Research46(1):44–67.
68.
VigdorJacob L.2002. “Does Gentrification Harm the Poor?” Brookings–Wharton Papers on Urban Affairs. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
WeisburdDavid, HinkleJoshua C., BragaAnthony A., and WooditchAlese. 2015. “Understanding the Mechanisms Underlying Broken Windows Policing: The need for Evaluation Evidence.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency52(4):589–608.
71.
WuYuning, SunIvan Y., and TriplettRuth A.2009. “Race, Class or Neighborhood Context: Which Matters More in Measuring Satisfaction with Police?” Justice Quarterly26(1):125–56.
72.
ZukinSharon, TrujilloValerie, FrasePeter, JacksonDanielle, RecuberTim, and WalkerAbraham. 2009. “New Retail Capital and Neighborhood Change: Boutiques and Gentrification in New York City.” City & Community8(1):47–64.
