African American (AA) teens endure disproportionately high rates of adolescent dating abuse (ADA). There is a limited understanding of the community–specific pathways that contribute to AA youth's higher risk. The purpose of this study is to investigate AA youths’ perspectives on the antecedents of ADA.
Methods:
Data were collected from interviews (n = 38) with AA teens. Thematic content analysis was employed to identify primary themes across the interviews. Analysis involved multiple rounds of iterative coding and the clustering of thematic constructs.
Results:
Interview participants described individual–level and intergenerational explanations of ADA. The majority of participants could not identify community–level factors.
Discussion and Implications:
Dating abuse perpetration and victimization were positioned as the product of personal deficits and exposure to abuse in individuals’ family environments. These findings underscore how structural and systemic determinants of dating abuse have not been translated to youth's meaning–making processes regarding abuse. Implications for diversifying the public discourse on dating abuse will be discussed, and consciousness–raising on the influence of upstream determinants of abuse will be presented.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmstadterAnanda B., ElwoodLisa S., BegleAngela M., GudmundsdottirBerglind, SmithDaniel W., ResnickHeidi S., and KilpatrickDean G.2011. “Predictors of Physical Assault Victimization: Findings from the National Survey of Adolescents.” Addictive Behaviors36(8):814–20.
2.
ArmsteadTheresa, RamboKirsten, KearnsMegan, JonesKathryn, DillsJenny, and BrownPamela. 2017. “CDC's DELTA FOCUS Program: Identifying Promising Primary Prevention Strategies for Intimate Partner Violence.” Journal of Women's Health26(1):9–12.
3.
ArriagaXimena B., and FosheeVangie A.2004. “Adolescent Dating Violence: Do Adolescents Follow in their Friends' or their Parents' Footsteps?” Journal of Interpersonal Violence19(2):162–84.
4.
BalesSusan N.2009. “The Trouble with Issues: The Case for Intentional Framing.” New Directions for Youth Development124:13–27.
5.
BanduraAlbert. 1977. Social Learning Theory. New York, NY: General Learning Press.
6.
Bent–GoodleyTricia B.2007. “Health Disparities and Violence Against Women.” Trauma, Violence, & Abuse8(2):90–104.
7.
BernsNancy. 2004. Framing the Victim: Domestic Violence, Media, and Social Problems. New York, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
8.
BlackBeverly M., ChidoLisa M., PrebleKathleen M., WeiszArlene N., YoonJina S., Delaney–BlackVirginia, KernsmithPoco D., and LewandowskiLinda. 2015. “Violence Exposure and Teen Dating Violence among African American Youth.” Journal of Interpesonal Violence30(12):2174–95.
9.
BlackDavid S., SussmanSteve, and UngerJennifer B.2010. “A Further Look at the Intergenerational Transmission of Violence: Witnessing Interparental Violence in Emerging Adulthood.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence25(6):1022–42.
10.
BonomiAmy E., ThompsonRobert S., AndersonMelissa, ReidRobert J., CarrellDavid, DimerJane A., and RivaraFrederick P.2006. “Intimate Partner Violence and Women's Physical, Mental and Social Functioning.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine93(7):1098–7.
11.
BraunVirgina and ClarkeVictoria. 2006. “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in Psychology3:77–101.
12.
BrushLisa D.2011. Poverty, Battered Women, and Work in U.S. Public Policy. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
13.
CannonElizabeth A., BonomiAmy E., AndersonMelissa L., and RivaraFrederick P., 2009. “The Intergenerational Transmission of Witnessing Intimate Partner Violence.” Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine163(8):706–8.
14.
CapaldiDeborah M., DishionThomas J., StoolmillerMike, and YoergerKaren. 2001. “Aggression Toward Female Partners by At–Risk Young Men: The Contribution of Male Adolescent Friendships.” Developmental Psychology37(1):61–73.
15.
Carbone–LopezKristin, KruttschnittCandace, and MacmillanRoss. 2006. “Patterns of Intimate Partner Violence and Their Associations with Physical Health, Psychological Distress, and Substance Abuse.” Public Health Reports121(4):382–92.
16.
CaseyErin, and LindhorstTaryn. 2009. “Toward a Multi–level Ecological Approach to the Primary Prevention of Sexual Assault.” Trauma, Violence & Abuse10(2):91–114.
ChangLing–Yin, FosheeVangie A., McNaughton–ReyesH. Luz, EnnettSusan T., and HalpernCarolyn. 2015. “Direct and Indirect Effects of Neighborhood Characteristics on the Perpetration of Dating Violence Across Adolescence.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence44(3):727–44.
19.
CokerAnn L., ClearEmily R., GarciaLissandra S., AsaoluIbitola, Cook–CraigPatricia G., BrancatoCandace J., WilliamsCorrine M., BushHeather, and FisherBonnie S.2014. “Dating Violence Victimization and Perpetration Rates Among High School Students.” Violence Against Women20(10):1220–38.
20.
EastPatricia L., ChienNina C., AdamsJoyce, HokodaAudrey, and MaierAshley. 2010. “Links Between Sisters' Sexual and Dating Victimization: The Roles of Neighborhood Crime and Parental Controls.” Journal of Family Psychology24(6):698–708.
21.
EdwardsKatie M., BanyardVictoria L., MoschellaElizabeth A., and SeaveyKatherine M.2016. Rural Young Adults’ Lay Theories of Intimate Partner Violence: A Qualitative Examination. American Journal of Community Psychology58(3/4):434–45
22.
EdwardsKatie M., MattinglyMarybeth, DixonKristiana J., and BanyardVictoria L.2014. “Community Matters: Intimate Partner Violence Among Rural Young Adults.” American Journal of Community Psychology53(1–2):198–207.
23.
EhrensaftMiriam K., CohenPatricia, BrownJocelyn, SmailesElizabeth, ChenHenian, JohnsonJeffrey G.2003. “Intergenerational Transmission of Partner Violence: A 20 year Prospective Study.” Journal of Counseling and Clinical Psychology71(4):741–53.
24.
ElliotJane. 2005. Using Narrative in Social Research. Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches. London: Sage Publications.
25.
Exner–CortensDeinera, EckenrodeJohn, and RothmanEmily. 2013. “Longitudinal Associations Between Teen Dating Violence Victimization and Adverse Health Outcomes.” Pediatrics13(1):71–78.
26.
FleckmanJulia M., TaylorCatherine A., StorerHeather L., AndrinopoulosKatherine, WeilLindsey E., Rubin–MillerLily, and TheallKatherine P.2018. “Breaking the Mold: Socio–ecologic Factors to Influence the Development of Non–harsh Parenting Strategies to Reduce Risk for Child Physical Abuse.” Children Youth Services Review94:274–83.
27.
FloodMichael, and PeaseBob. 2009. Factors Influencing Attitudes to Violence Against Women. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse10(2):125–42.
28.
FreirePaulo. 1999. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. London, UK: Bloomsbury.
29.
GagneMarie–Hélène, LavoieFrancine, and HebertMartine. 2004. “Exploration of Interrelations of Different Experiences of Violence in the Lives of Young Quebec Girls.” Revue de Psychoeducation33(1):41–60.
30.
GillumTameka L.2009. “Improving Services to African American Survivors of IPV.” Violence Against Women”15(1):57–80.
31.
GraffunderCorinne M., ClineRebecca, and LaneKaren G.2011. “Primary Prevention.” Pp. 209–26 in Sourcebook on Violence Against Women, edited by RenzettiClaire M., EdlesonJeffrey L., and BergenRaquel K.Thousand, Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
32.
HeiseLori L.1998. “Violence against women: An Integrated, Ecological Framework.” Violence Against Women4(3):262–90.
33.
HelmSusana, BakerCharlene K., BerlinJeffrey, and KimuraShaye (2017). Getting In, Being in, Staying in, and Getting Out: Adolescents’ Descriptions of Dating and Dating Violence. Youth & Society49(3):318–40.
34.
HenryRacine R. and ZeytinogluSenem. 2012. “African Americans and Teen Dating Violence.” The American Journal of Family Therapy40:20–32.
35.
HsiehHsiu–Fang and ShannonSarah E.2005. “Three Approaches to Qualitative Content Analysis.” Qualitative Health Research15(9):1277–88.
36.
JewkesRachel, MorrelRobert, HearnJeff, LundqvistEmma, BlackbeardDavid, LindeggerGraham, QualeMichael, SikweyiyaYandisa, and GottzenLucas. 2015. “Hegemonic Masculinity: Combining Theory and Practice in Gender Interventions.” Culture, Health, & Sexuality16(7):96–111.
37.
JohnsonRenee M., ParkerElizabeth M., RinehartJenny, NailJennifer, and RothmanEmily R.2015. “Neighborhood Factors and Dating Violence Among Youth: A Systematic Review.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine49(3):458–66.
38.
LongmoreMonica A., ManningWendy D., GiordanoPeggy C., and CoppJennifer E.2014. “Intimate Partner Victimization, Poor Relationship Quality, and Depressive Symptoms During Young Adulthood.” Social Science Research48:77–89.
39.
MbilinyiLyungai F., Logan–GreenePatricia B., NeighborsClayton, WalkerDenise D., RoffmanRoger A., and ZegreeJoan. 2012. “Childhood Domestic Violence Exposure among a Community Sample of Adult Perpetrators: What Mediates the Connection?.” Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma21(2):171–87.
40.
McMahonSarah and BanyardVictoria L.2012. “When can I help? A Conceptual Framework for the Prevention of Sexual Violence Through Bystander Intervention.” Trauma, Violence & Abuse13(1):3–14.
41.
MorseJanice. 2015. “Critical Analysis of Strategies for Determining Rigor in Qualitative Inquiry.” Qualitative Health Research25(9):1212–22.
42.
MulfordCarrie F. and Blachman–DemnerDara R.2013. “Teen Dating Violence: Building a Research Program through Collaborative Insights.” Violence Against Women19(6):756–70.
43.
NaborsErin L., DietzTracy L., and JasinskiJana L.2006. “Domestic Violence Beliefs and Perceptions Among College Students.” Violence and Victims, 21(6):779–95.
44.
NoonanRita, and CharlesDyanna. 2009. “Developing Teen Dating Violence Prevention Strategies: Formative Research with Middle School Youth.” Violence Against Women15(9):1087–105.
45.
O'KeefeMaura, and TreisterLaura. 1998. “Victims of Dating Violence Among High School Students: Are the Predictors Different for Males and Females?” Violence Against Women4(2):195–223.
46.
PhelanJo C., LinkBruce G., and TehranifarParisa. 2010. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Health Inequalities: Theory, Evidence, and Policy Implications.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51:S28–40.
47.
Prothrow–StithDeborah, & DavisRachael A.2010. “A Public Health Approach to Preventing Violence.” Pp. 323–50 in Prevention is Primary, edited by CohenLarry, ChavezVivian, and CheminiSena. San Francisco, CA: Jossey–Bass.
48.
ReevesPatricia M. and OrpinasPamela. 2012. “Dating Norms and Dating Violence Among Ninth Graders in Northeast Georgia: Reports from Student Surveys and Focus Groups.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence27(9):1677–98.
49.
RennerLynette M., and SlackKristen S.2006. “Intimate Partner Violence and Child Maltreatment: Understanding Intra–and intergenerational Connections.” Child Abuse & Neglect30(6):599–617.
50.
RothmanEmily F., Bair–MerrittMegan H., and TharpAndra T.2015. “Beyond the Individual Level: Novel Approaches and Considerations for Multilevel Adolescent Dating Violence Prevention.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine49(3):445–7.
51.
RothmanEmily F., JohnsonRenee M., YoungRobin, WeinbergRobin J., AzraelDeborah, and MolnarBeth E.2011. “Neighborhood–level Factors Associated with Physical Dating Violence Perpetration: Results of a Representative Survey Conducted in Boston, MA.” Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine88(2):201–13.
52.
RothmanEmily F., StuartGregory L., WinterMichael, WangNa, BowenDeborah J. and BernsteinJudith. 2012. “Youth Alcohol Use and Dating Abuse victimization and Perpetration: A Test of the Relationships at the Daily Level in a Sample of Pediatric Emergency Department Patients Who Use Alcohol.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence29(14):2959–79.
53.
SaldañaJohnny M.2009. The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
54.
SchwartzSeth J., ZamboangaByron L., LuyckxKoen, MecaAlan, and RitchieRachel A.2013. “Identity in Emerging Adulthood Reviewing the Field and Looking Forward.” Emerging Adulthood1:96–113.
55.
SimonThomas R., MillerShari, Gorman–SmithDeborah, OrpinasPamela, and SullivanTerri. 2010. “Physical Dating Violence Norms and Behavior Among Sixth–grade Students From Four U.S. Sites.” The Journal of Early Adolescence30(3):395–409.
56.
SithSandra M., RosenKaren H., MiddletonKimberly A., BuschAmy L., LundebergKirsten, and CarltonRussel P.2000. “The Intergenerational Transmission of Spouse Abuse: A Meta–Analysis.” Journal of Marriage and Family62(3):640–54.
57.
Smith–DardenJoanne P., KernsmithPoco D., ReidyDennis E., and CortinaKai S.2017. “In Search of Modifiable Risk and Protective Factors for Teen Dating Violence.” Journal of Research on Adolescence27(2):423–35.
58.
SpencerGrace. 2014. “Young People and Health: Towards a New Conceptual Framework for Understanding Empowerment.” Health18(1):3–22.
59.
SpriggsAubrey, IannottiRobert, NanselTonja, and HaynieDenise L. (2007). “Bullying Involvement and Perceived Family, Peer, and School Relations: Commonalities and Differences Across Race/Ethnicity.” Journal of Adolescent Health41(3):283–93.
60.
SpriggsAubrey L., HalpernCarolyn T., and MartinSandra L.2009. “Continuity of Adolescent and Early Adult Partner Violence Victimization: Association with Witnessing Violent Crime in Adolescence.” Journal of Epidemiological Community Health63(9):741–8.
61.
StigeBrynjulf, MalterudKristi, and MidtgardenTorjus. 2009. “Toward an Agenda for Evaluation of Qualitative Research.” Qualitative Health Research19:1504–16.
62.
StorerHeather L.2017. ““A Year of Bad Choices:” A Postfeminist “Retelling” of Dating and Domestic violence.” Affilia: Journal of Women and Social Work32(3):292–307.
63.
StorerHeather L., CaseyErin, CarlsonJuliana, TolmanRichard, and EdlesonJeffrey. 2016. “Primary Prevention Is?: A Global Perspective on How Organizations Engaging Men in Preventing Gender-Based Violence Conceptualize and Operationalize Their Work.” Violence Against Women22(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/1077801215601247.
64.
StorerHeather L., and StrohlKatyayani. 2016. “A Primer for Preventing Teen Dating Violence? The Representation of Teen Dating Violence in Young Adult Literature and Its’ Implications for Prevention.” https://doi.org/10.1177/1077801216666725
65.
TaylorKatherine A., SullivanTerri N., and FarrellAlbert D.2015. Longitudinal Relationships Between Individual and Class Norms Supporting Dating Violence and Perpetration of Dating Violence. Journal of Youth & Adolescence44(3):745–60.
66.
VagiKevin J., RothmanEmily F., LatzmanNatasha E., TharpAndra Teten, HallDiane M., and BreidingMathew J.2013. “Beyond Correlates: A Review of Risk and Protective Factors for Adolescent Dating Violence Perpetration.” Journal of Youth & Adolescence42(4):633–49.
67.
VaterlausJ. Mitchell, TulaneSarah, BrandonPorter D., and BeckertTroy E.2018. “The Perceived Influence of Media and Technology on Adolescent Romantic Relationships.” Journal of Adolescent Research33(6):651–71.
68.
VezinaJohanne, & HerbertMartine. 2007. “Risk Factors for Victimization in Romantic Relationships of Young Women: A Review of Empirical and Implications for Prevention.” Trauma, Violence, & Abuse8(1):33–66.
69.
WalkerRebekah, WilliamsJoni S., and EgedeLeonard E.2016. “Impact of Race/Ethnicity and Social Determinants of Health on Diabetes Outcomes.” American Journal of Medical Science351(4):366–73.
