Social Capital and Livelihoods in Johannesburg: Differential Advantages and Unexpected Outcomes among Foreign-Born Migrants,Internal Migrants,and Long-Term South African Residents 1
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online March, 2014
Social Capital and Livelihoods in Johannesburg: Differential Advantages and Unexpected Outcomes among Foreign-Born Migrants,Internal Migrants,and Long-Term South African Residents 1
Foreign-born migrants – a group rarely compared with both internal migrants and long-term residents – are often positioned as the most disadvantaged South African urban population. We use data from a 2008 cross-sectional household survey conducted in Johannesburg to compare a contextually relevant measure of social capital and livelihood advantages between foreign-born migrants, internal migrants, and long-term South African residents. Our findings are counterintuitive and emphasize the need to explore the heterogeneity of urban migrant populations, and the mechanisms in which they better their lives, by showing that (1) foreign-born migrants have better urban livelihood outcomes, and (2) indicators of social capital are not necessarily associated with improved livelihood outcomes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
KerrA., and WittenbergM.2013“Sampling Methodology and Field Work Changes in the October Household Surveys and Labour Force Surveys.” A Southern Africa Labour and Development Research Unit Working Paper Number 101. Cape Town: SALDRU, University of Cape Town.
2.
VeareyJ.2013“Sampling in an Urban Environment: Overcoming Complexities and Capturing Differences.”Journal of Refugee Studies26(1): 155–162.
3.
AdlerP. S., and KwonS.-W.2002“Social Capital: Prospects for a New Concept.”Academy of Management Review27(1): 17–40.
4.
AmitR.2010“Lost in the Vortex: Irregularities in the Detention and Deportation of Non-Nationals in South Africa.” Forced Migration Studies Programme Report. University of the Witwatersrand.
5.
BeallJ.CrankshawO., and ParnellS.2000“Local Government, Poverty Reduction, and Inequality in Johannesburg.”Environment and Urbanization12(1): 107–121.
6.
BooysenF.2008“Using an Asset Index to Assess Trends in Poverty in Seven Sub-Saharan African Countries.”World Development36(6): 1113–1130.
7.
BorjasG. J.1989“Economic Theory and International Migration.”International Migration Review23(3): 457–485.
8.
BorjasG. J.1995“The Economic Benefits from Migration.”Journal of Economic Perspectives9(2): 3–22.
9.
BourdieuP.1986“The Forms of Capital.” In Handbook of Theory Research for the Sociology of Education. Ed. RichardsonJ. E.London: Greenwood Press, Pp. 47–58.
10.
BrowningC. R.FeinbergS. L., and DietzR. D.2004“The Paradox of Social Organization: Networks, Collective Efficacy, and Violent Crime in Urban Neighborhoods.”Social Forces83(2): 503–534.
11.
BurtR.1992Structural Holes: The Social Structure of Competition.Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
12.
BurtR.2001“Structural Holes Versus Network Closure as Social Capital.” In Social Capital: Theory and Research. Ed. LinN.CookK., and BurtR.New York: Aldine de Gruyter, Pp. 31–56.
13.
ColemanJ. S.1988“Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.”American Journal of Sociology94: S95–S120.
14.
ComaroffJ. L.1998“Reflections on the Colonial State, in South Africa and Elsewhere: Factions, Fragments, Facts, and Fiction.”Social Identities4(3): 321–361.
15.
CrankshawO., and WhiteC.1995“Racial Desegregation and Inner City Decay in Johannesburg.”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research19(4): 622–638.
16.
CrulM., and DoomernikJ.2003“The Turkish and Moroccan Second Generation in the Netherlands: Divergent Trends between and Polarization within the Two Groups.”International Migration Review37(4): 1039–1064.
17.
CrushJ.2008The Perfect Storm: The Realities of Xenophobia in Contemporary South Africa.Cape Town: Southern African Migration Programme (SAMP).
18.
De JongG. F., and MadambaA. B.2001“A Double Disadvantage? Minority Group, Immigrant Status, and Underemployment in the United States.”Social Science Quarterly82(1): 117–130.
19.
FafchampsM., and MintenB.2002“Returns to Social Network Capital among Traders.”Oxford Economic Papers54(2): 173–206.
20.
FilmerD., and PritchettL. H.2001“Estimating Wealth Effects without Expenditure Data – or Tears: An Application to Educational Enrollments in States of India.”Demography38(1): 115–132.
21.
FriedbergR. M., and HuntJ.1995“The Impact of Immigrants on Host Country Wages, Employment and Growth.”Journal of Economic Perspectives9(2): 23–44.
22.
GansH.1992“Second-Generation Decline: Scenarios for the Economic and Ethnic Futures of the Post-1965 American Immigrants.”Ethnic and Racial Studies15(2): 173–190.
23.
GinsburgC.NorrisS. A.RichterL. M., and CoplanD. B.2009“Patterns of Residential Mobility Amongst Children in Greater Johannesburg–Soweto, South Africa: Observations from the Birth to Twenty Cohort.”Urban Forum20(4): 397–413.
24.
GlaeserE. L.LaibsonD. I.ScheinkmanJ. A., and SoutterC. L.2000“Measuring Trust.”The Quarterly Journal of Economics115(3): 811–846.
25.
GranovetterM.1973“The Strength of Weak Ties.”American Journal of Sociology78(6): 1360–1380.
26.
GrootaertC., and NarayanD.2004“Local Institutions, Poverty and Household Welfare in Bolivia.”World Development32(7): 1179–1198.
27.
de HaasH.2010“The Internal Dynamics of Migration Processes: A Theoretical Inquiry.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies36(10): 1587–1617.
28.
HargreavesJ. R.2007“Assessing Household Wealth in Health Studies in Developing Countries: A Comparison of Participatory Wealth Ranking and Survey Techniques from Rural South Africa.”Emerging Themes in Epidemiology4: 4.
29.
Hondagneu-SoteloP.2001Doméstica: Immigrant Workers Cleaning and Caring in the Shadows of Affluence.Los Angeles: University of California Press.
30.
IcelandJ., and ScopillitiM.2008“Immigrant Residential Segregation in US Metropolitan Areas, 1990–2000.”Demography45(1): 79–94.
31.
JamesD.1997“Anthropology, History, and the Making of Past and Place.”African Studies56(2): 115–136.
32.
JhaS.RaoV., and WoolcockM.2007“Governance in the Gullies: Democratic Responsiveness and Leadership in Delhi's Slums.”World Development35(2): 230–246.
33.
KasinitzP.MollenkopfJ. H.WatersM. C., and HoldawayJ.2008Inheriting the City: The Children of Immigrants Come of Age.New York: Russell Sage.
34.
KolenikovS., and AngelesG.2009“Socioeconomic Status Measurement with Discrete Proxy Variables: Is Principal Component Analysis a Reliable Answer?”Review of Income and Wealth55(1): 128–165.
35.
KrishnaA.2012Active Social Capital: Tracing the Roots of Development and Democracy.New York: Columbia University Press.
36.
LandauL. B.2005“Urbanisation, Nativism, and the Rule of Law in South Africa's ‘Forbidden’ Cities.”Third World Quarterly26(7): 1115–1134.
37.
LandauL. B.2009“Living Within and Beyond Johannesburg: Exclusion, Religion, and Emerging Forms of Being.”African Studies68(2): 197–214.
38.
LandauL. B.2011Exorcising the Demons Within: Xenophobia, Violence and Statecraft in Contemporary South Africa.Tokyo, New York, and Paris: United Nations University Press.
39.
LandauL. B., and FreemantleI.2010“Tactical Cosmopolitanism and Idioms of Belonging: Insertion and Self-Exclusion in Johannesburg.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies36(3): 375–390.
40.
LandauL. B., and GindreyV.2008“Migration and Population Trends in Gauteng Province 1996–2055.” Migration Studies Working Paper 42, Forced Migration Studies Programme, Johannesburg.
41.
LangG.2005“The Difference Between Wages and Wage Potentials: Earnings Disadvantages of Immigrants in Germany.”Journal of Economic Inequality3: 21–42.
42.
LinN.1999a “Social Networks and Status Attainment.”Annual Review of Sociology25: 467–487.
43.
LinN.1999b “Building a Network Theory of Social Capital.”Connections22(1): 28–51.
44.
LochnerK. A.KawachiI.BrennanR. T., and BukaS. L.2003“Social Capital and Neighborhood Mortality Rates in Chicago.”Social Science & Medicine56(8): 1797–1805.
45.
MadhavanS., and LandauL. B.2011“Bridges to Nowhere: Hosts, Migrants, and the Chimera of Social Capital in Three African Cities.”Population and Development Review37(3): 473–497.
46.
MarkidesK. S., and CoreilJ.1986“The Health of Hispanics in the Southwestern United States: An Epidemiological Paradox.”Public Health Reports101(3): 253–265.
47.
MarkidesK. S.CoreilJ., and EschbachK.2005“Aging, Migration, and Mortality: Current Status of Research on the Hispanic Paradox.”Journal of Gerontology60B(Special Issue II): 68–75.
48.
MasseyD. S.1990“Social Structure, Household Strategies, and the Cumulative Causation of Migration.”Population Index56(1): 3–26.
49.
MasseyD. S., and EspinosaK. E.1997“What's Driving Mexico-US Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical, and Policy Analysis.”American Journal of Sociology102(4): 939–999.
50.
MasseyD. S.AlarconR.DurandJ., and GonzalesH.1987Return to Aztlan: The Social Process of International Migration from Western Mexico.Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
51.
MasseyD. S.1998Worlds in Motion, Understanding International Migration at the End of the Millenium.Oxford: Clarendon Press.
52.
McDonaldJ. T., and KennedyS.2004“Insights Into the ‘Healthy Immigrant Effect’: Health Status and Health Service Use of Immigrants to Canada.”Social Science & Medicine59(8): 1613–1627.
53.
MisagoJ.-P.LandauL. B., and MonsonT.2009Towards Tolerance, Law and Dignity: Addressing Violence against Foreign Nationals in South Africa.Pretoria: IOM.
54.
MorrisA.1999“Tenant-Landlord Relations, the Anti-apartheid Struggle and Physical Decline in Hillbrow, an Inner-city Neighbourhood in Johannesburg.”Urban Studies36(3): 509–526.
55.
MunshiK.2003“Networks in the Modern Economy: Mexican Migrants in the US Labor Market.”Quarterly Journal of Economics118(2): 549–598.
56.
NarayanD., and PritchettL.1999“Cents and Sociability: Household Income and Social Capital in Rural Tanzania.”Economic Development and Cultural Change47(4): 871–897.
57.
NarayanD., and PritchettL., and KapoorS.2009Moving out of Poverty: Success from the Bottom Up.Washington, DC: World Bank and Palgrave MacMillan.
58.
NarayanD., and PritchettL.2000Voices of the Poor: Can Anyone Hear Us?New York: Oxford University Press.
59.
NeocosmosM.2010From ‘Foreign Natives’ to ‘Native Foreigners’: Explaining Xenophobia in Post-apartheid South Africa: Citizenship and Nationalism, Identity and Politics.Senegal: CODESRIA.
60.
OosthuizenM., and NaidooP.2004“Internal Migration to the Gauteng Province.” Working Paper, Development Policy Research Unit, University of Cape Town.
61.
PalloniA.2001“Social Capital and International Migration: A Test Using Information on Family Networks.”American Journal of Sociology106(5): 1262–1298.
62.
PerlmanJ. E.1976The Myth of Marginality: Urban Poverty and Politics in Rio de Janeiro.Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
63.
PhilipsJ. A., and MasseyD. S.2000“Engines of Immigration: Stocks of Human and Social Capital in Mexico.”Social Science Quarterly81(1): 33–48.
64.
PolzerT., and IgglesdenV.2009“Humanitarian Assistance to Internally Displaced Persons in South Africa: Lessons Learned Following Attacks on Foreign Nationals in May 2008.” Report, Forced Migration Studies Programme, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg.
65.
PortesA.1998“Social Capital: Its Origins and Applications in Modern Sociology.”Annual Review of Sociology24: 1–24.
66.
PoselD., and CasaleD.2006“Internal Labor Migration and Household Poverty in Post-Apartheid South Africa.” In Poverty and Policy in Post-Apartheid South Africa. Eds. BhoratH., and KanburR.Cape Town: Human Sciences Research Council Press. Pp. 351–365.
67.
PutnamR.1993Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy.Princeton: Princeton University Press.
68.
PutnamR. D.2000Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.New York: Simon & Schuster.
69.
SampsonR. J.MorenoffJ. D., and EarlsF.1999“Beyond Social Capital: Spatial Dynamics of Collective Efficacy for Children.”American Sociological Review64(5): 633–660.
70.
SchnepfS. V.2007“Immigrants’ Educational Disadvantage: An Examination Across Ten Countries and Three Surveys.”Journal of Population Economics20(3): 527–545.
71.
SegattiA.2011“Migration to South Africa: Regional Challenges versus National Instruments and Interests.” In Contemporary Migration to South Africa. A Regional Development Issue. Ed. SegattiA., and LandauL.Washington, DC: The World Bank and the Agence Francaise de Developpement, Pp. 9–29.
72.
SegattiA., and LandauL. B.2011“Appendix B. How Many Are They? Migration Data Collection Issues.” In Contemporary Migration to South Africa. A Regional Development Issue. Ed. SegattiA., and LandauL.Washington, DC: The World Bank and the Agence Francaise de Developpement. Pp. 145–150.
73.
SimonP.2003“France and the Unknown Second Generation: Preliminary Results on Social Mobility.”International Migration Review37(4): 1039–1064.
74.
Statistics South Africa2012Statistical Release: Census 2011.Pretoria, South Africa: Statistics South Africa.
75.
SteenkampC.2009“Xenophobia in South Africa: What Does it Say About Trust?”The Round Table98(403): 439–447.
76.
SzreterS., and WoolcockM.2004“Health by Association? Social Capital, Social Theory, and the Political Economy of Public Health.”International Journal of Epidemiology33(4): 650–667.
77.
United Nations Development Programme2013Human Development Report 2013.New York: United Nations Development Programme.
78.
VeareyJ.2011“Learning from HIV: Exploring Migration and Health in South Africa.”Global Public Health7(1): 58–70.
79.
VeareyJ.2013“Sampling in an Urban Environment: Overcoming Complexities and Capturing Differences.”Journal of Refugee Studies26(1): 155–162.
80.
VeareyJ.2010“Urban Health in Johannesburg: The Importance of Place in Understanding Intraurban Inequalities in a Context of Migration and HIV.”Health & Place16: 694–702.
81.
VeenstraG.2000“Social Capital, SES and Health: An Individual-Level Analysis.”Social Science & Medicine50(5): 619–629.
82.
VigneswaranD.2009“Residential Sampling and Johannesburg's Forced Migrants.”Journal of Refugee Studies22(4): 439–459.
83.
Von FrantziusI.2004“World Summit on Sustainable Development Johannesburg 2002: A Critical Analysis and Assessment of the Outcomes.”Environmental Politics13(2): 467–473.
84.
WacquantL. J. D.1998“Negative Social Capital: State Breakdown and Social Destitution in America's Urban Core.”Journal of Housing and the Built Environment13(1): 25–40.
85.
WatersM. C.1999Black Identities: West Indian Immigrant Dreams and American Realities.New York: Russell Sage.
86.
de WetT.PlagersonS.HarphamT., and MatheeA.2011“Poor Housing, Good Health: A Comparison of Formal and Informal Housing in Johannesburg, South Africa.”International Journal of Public Health56(6): 625–633.
87.
WhiteM., and LindstromD.2005“Internal Migration.” In Handbook of Population. Ed. PostonD. L., and MicklinM.New York: Springer, Pp. 311–345.
88.
WimmerA., and Click SchillerN.2003“Methodological Nationalism, the Social Sciences, and the Study of Migration: An Essay in Historical Epistemology.”International Migration Review37(3): 576–610.
89.
WoolcockM.1998“Social Capital and Economic Development: Toward a Theoretical Synthesis and Policy Framework.”Theory and Society27(2): 151–208.
90.
WoolcockM., and NarayanD.2000“Social Capital: Implications for Development Theory, Research, and Policy.”World Bank Research Observer15(2): 225–249.
ZengZ., and XieY.2004“Asian-Americans’ Earnings Disadvantage Reexamined: The Role of Place of Education.”American Journal of Sociology109(5): 1075–1108.
94.
ZhouM., and BankstonC. L.III1994“Social Capital and the Adaptation of the Second Generation.”International Migration Review28(4): 821–845.
