This paper explores the importance of occupational downgrading in explaining the pay gap of New Member States (NMS) immigrants to Ireland by taking advantage of two data sources, the Census and the Survey on Income and Living Conditions (SILC). The study identifies biases in the coverage of NMS immigrants in SILC that dampen their estimated earnings disadvantage. Corrections to population weights are suggested. These adjustments have a significant impact on results, increasing both the size of the wage penalty of NMS immigrants and the extent to which the pay gap can be explained by occupational downgrading. A replication of published results for the UK reveals similar patterns of penalties for NMS workers in both countries. Factors that may explain the concentration of NMS workers in low-skill/low-wage occupations are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BachanR., and SheehanM.2010“On the Labour Market Progress of Polish Accession Workers in South-East England.”International Migration49(2): 104–134.
2.
BarrellR.FitzGeraldJ., and RileyR.2010“EU Enlargement and Migrations: Assessing the Macroeconomic Impacts.”Journal of Common Market Studies48(2): 373–395.
3.
BarrettA.BerginA., and DuffyD.2006“The Labour Market Characteristics and Labour Market Impact of Immigrants in EU.”Economic and Social Review37(1): 1–26.
4.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD., and KellyE.2011“Estimating the Impact of Immigration on Wages in Ireland.”Economic and Social Review42(1): 1–26.
5.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD., and DuffyD.2008“Are Ireland's Immigrants Integrating into Its Labor Markets?”International Migration Review42(3): 597–619.
6.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD., and KellyE.2012“The Impact of Ireland's Recession on the Labour Market Outcomes of its Immigrants.”European Journal of Population28: 91–111.
7.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD., and McCarthyY.2007a “Immigrants in a Booming Economy: Analysing their Earnings and Welfare Dependence.”Labour21(4-5): 789–808.
8.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD., and McCarthyY.2007b “The Earnings of Immigrants in Ireland: Results from the 2005 EU Survey of Income and Living Conditions”. Quarterly Economic Commentary, Winter.
9.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD.McCarthyY.McGuinessS., and O'BrienM.2012“The Immigrants Earnings Disadvantage Across the Earnings and Skills Distribution: The Case of Immigrants from the EU's New Member States in EU.”British Journal of Industrial Relations50(3): 457–481.
10.
BarrettA.BerginA.DuffyD.McCarthyY., and O'ConnellP.2013“Immigrants and Employer-Provided Training.”Journal of Labor Research34(1): 52–78.
11.
BattuH.SeamanP., and ZenouY.2011“Job Contact Networks and the Ethnic Minorities.”Labour Economics18: 48–56.
12.
BorjasG.2013The Slowdown in the Economic Assimilation of Immigrants: Aging and Cohort Effects Revisited Again. NBER working paper series No. 19116. Cambridge, MA: NBER
13.
Central Statistical Office (CSO)2007Census 2006, Principal Socio-economic Results, Appendix 2.Dublin, Ireland: CSO.
14.
Central Statistical Office2009“Foreign Nationals: PPSN allocation and Employment, 2007”.Dublin, Ireland: CSO.
15.
Central Statistical Office (CSO)2012“Census 2011, Profile 6, Migration and Diversity”, the Stationery Office.Dublin, Ireland: CSO.
16.
Central Statistical Office (CSO)2013Foreign Nationals: PPSN Allocations, Employment and Social Welfare Activity, 2010–2011.Dublin, Ireland: CSO.
17.
CookJ.DwyerP., and WaiteL.2011“The Experiences of Accession 8 Migrants in England: Motivation, Work and Agency.”International Migration49(2): 54–79.
18.
DrinkwaterS.EadeJ., and GarapichM.2009“Poles Apart? EU Enlargement and the Labour Market Outcomes of Immigrants in the United Kingdom.”International Migration47(1): 161–190.
19.
DustmanC., and FabbriF.2003“Language Proficiency and Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK.”Economic Journal113: 695–717.
20.
FavellA.2008“The New Face of East-West migration in Europe.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies34(5): 701–716.
21.
FihelA.KaczmarczykP., and OkolskiM.2006Labour Mobility in the Enlarged European Union, International Migration from the EU8 Countries. Centre of Migration Research Working Papers 14/72. Warsaw: Faculty of Economic Sciences, Warsaw University.
22.
FrenchS.2012“Beyond ESOL? Assessing the Propensity of East European Migrant Workers to Undertake Further and Higher Education.”Research in Post-Compulsory Education17(1): 125–142.
23.
FriedbergR.2000“You Can't Take it with You? Immigration Assimilation and the Portability of Human Capital.”Journal of Labor Economics18(29): 221–251.
24.
KaczmarczykP., and OkolskiM.2008“Demographic and Labour Market Impacts of Migration on Poland.”Oxford Review of Economic Policy24(3) 599–624.
25.
KomitoL., and BatesJ.2009“Virtually Local: Social Media and Community Among Polish Nationals in Dublin.”Aslib Proceedings: New Information Perspectives61(3): 232–244.
26.
KringsT.2013“Polish Migration to Ireland: ‘Free Movers’ in the New European Mobility Space.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies39(1): 87–103.
27.
LongJ.S., and FreezeJ.2006Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables Using Stata, laded. Texas: Stata Press.
28.
McGinnityF.QuinnE.O'ConnellP., and DonnelyN.2011Annual Monitory Report on Integration 2010.Dublin: ESRI.
29.
Office for National Statistics (ONS).2013Economic and Social Characteristics of the Resident Population of England and Wales by Nationality and Country of Birth in 2011.
30.
O'ConnellP., and McGinnityF.2008Immigrants at Work, Ethnicity and Nationality in the Irish Labour Market, Dublin: Equality Research Series, ESRI.
31.
RileyR., and WealeM.2006“Commentary: Immigration and its Effects.”National Institute Economic Review198(4): 4–9.
32.
Skill and Labour Market Research Unit (SLMRU)2011National Skills Bulletin 2011.Dublin: Planning and Research Department, FAS.
33.
Skill and Labour Market Research Unit (SLMRU)2008National Skills Bulletin 2008.Dublin: Planning and Research Department, FAS.
34.
SportonD.2013“They Control My Life: The Role of Local Recruitment Agencies in East European Migration to the UK.”Population, Space and Place19: 443–458.
35.
SumptionM.2009Social Networks and Polish Immigration to the UK. Economics of Migration Working Paper 5. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
36.
TurnerT.2010“The Jobs Immigrants do: Issues of Displacement and Marginalisation in the Irish Labour Market.”Work, Employment and Society24(2): 318–336.
37.
VoitchovskyS.MaîtreB., and NolanB.2012“Wage Inequality in Ireland's “Celtic Tiger” Boom.”The Economic and Social Review43(1): 99–133.
38.
WalshF.2013“Labour Market Regulation and Migration in Ireland.”Economic and Social Review44(1): 82–102.
39.
WhiteA., and RyanL.2008“Polish “Temporary” Migration: The Formation of and Significance of Social Networks.”Europe-Asia Studies60(9): 1467–1502.
40.
WooldridgeJ.2012Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach, 5th ed., Mason, OH: South-Western.
