Studies of migration industries have demonstrated the critical role that border-spanning businesses play in international mobility. To date, most research has focused on meso-level entrepreneurial initiatives that operate in a legal gray area under a state that provides an environment for their growth or decline. Extending this work, the present article advances a taxonomy of the ways states partner with migration industries based on the nature of their relationship (formal or informal) and the type of actor involved (for-profit or non-profit). The analysis focuses on low-paid temporary migrant work programs — schemes that require substantial state involvement to function — and examines cases from the East Asian democracies with strong economies that have become net importers of migrants: Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea. The conclusion, incorporating cases beyond Asia, explicates the properties and limits of each arrangement based on the degree of formality and importance of profit.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbellaM.1992 “Contemporary Labor Migration from Asia: Policies and Perspectives of Sending Countries.” In International Migration Systems: A Global Approach, edited by KritzM.LimL. L.ZlotnikH., 263–278. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
2.
AguniasD. R.2010Migration’s Middlemen: Regulating Recruitment Agencies in the Philippines-United Arab Emirates Corridor. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.
3.
AkashiJ.2010Nyūkoku Kanri Seisaku: “1990nen Taisei” no Seiritsu to Tenkai. Kyoto: Nakanishiya Shuppan.
4.
Amnesty International2009Disposable Labor: Rights of Migrant Workers in South Korea. London: Amnesty International Limited.
5.
Amnesty International2014Bitter Harvest: Exploitation and Forced Labor of Migrant Agricultural Workers in South Korea. London: Amnesty International Limited.
6.
BaconC.2005The Evolution of Immigration Detention in the UK: The Involvement of Private Prison Companies. Refugee Studies Center Working Paper No. 27. Oxford Department of International Development: Refugee Studies Center.
7.
BelangerD.UenoK.HongK. T.OchiaiE.2011 “From Foreign Trainees to Unauthorized Workers: Vietnamese Migrant Workers in Japan.” Asian Pacific Migration Journal20(1):31–51.
8.
BessireD.2005 “Transparency: A Two-Way Mirror?” International Journal of Social Economics32(5):424–38.
9.
BustamanteJ.2011 “Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants: Annex.” Human Rights Council, Seventeenth Session. United Nations General Assembly.
10.
CalavitaK.1992Inside the State: The Bracero Program, Immigration, and the INS. New York: Routledge.
11.
ChanR.1999 “Taiwan’s Policy Toward Foreign Workers.” Journal of Contemporary Asia28(3):383–400.
12.
ChávezS.2009 “The Sonoran Desert’s Domestic Bracero Program: Institutional Actors and the Creation of Labor Migration Streams.” International Migration50(2):20–40.
13.
ChiavacciD.2011Japans neue Immigrationspolitik: Ostasiatisches Umfeld, ideelle Diversität und institutionelle Fragmentierung. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
Council of Labor Affairs2014Report on the Protection of the Rights of Foreign Workers in Taiwan. Taipei: Cross-Border Workforce Management Division.
16.
CrushJ.TshiterekeC.2001 “Contesting Migrancy: The Foreign Labor Debate in Post-1994 South Africa.” Africa Today48(3):49–70.
17.
Daily Yomiuri Newspaper2006 “Training Entity Held Strings for Trainee Visas.” November 8.
18.
DOS (US Department of State)2007Trafficking in Persons Report. Washington DC: US Department of State.
19.
DOS (US Department of State)2014Trafficking in Persons Report. Washington DC: US Department of State.
20.
DunleavyP.1991Democracy, Bureaucracy, and Public Choice: Economic Explanations in Political Science. New York: Prentice Hall.
21.
EisenhardtK.1989 “Agency Theory: An Assessment and Review.” The Academy of Management Review14(1):54–74.
22.
FaistT.2000Volume and Dynamics of International Migration and Transnational Social Spaces. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
23.
FinkleA.2005 “Relying on Information Acquired by a Principal.” International Journal of Industrial Organization23(4):263–78.
24.
FitzGeraldD.2008A Nation of Emigrants: How Mexico Manages Its Migration. Berkeley: University of California Press.
25.
FrimanH. R.2011 “The Illegal ‘Migration Industry’.” In Migration in the Global Political Economy, edited by PhillipsN., 83–99. London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
26.
Gaikokujin Kenshūseikenri Nettowaaku, ed. 2006a Gaikokujin Kenshūsei Jikyū 300 En no Rōdōsha, volume 2. Tokyo: Akashi Shoten.
27.
Gaikokujin Kenshūseikenri Nettowaaku, ed. 2006b Gaikokujin Kenshūsei Jikyū 300 En no Rōdōsha, volume 1. Tokyo: Akashi Shoten.
28.
GalarzaErnesto1964Merchants of Labor: The Mexican Bracero Story. Santa Barbara, NC: McNally and Loftin.
29.
Gammeltoft-HansenT.Nyberg SørensenN., eds. 2013The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration. London: Routledge.
30.
GarapichM.2008 “The Migration Industry and Civil Society: Polish Immigrants in the United Kingdom Before and After EU Enlargement.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies34(5):735–52.
31.
GossJ.LindquistB.1995 “Conceptualizing International Labor Migration: A Structuration Perspective.” International Migration Review29(2):317–51.
32.
GriffithD.2006American Guestworkers: Jamaicans and Mexicans in the U.S. Labor Market. University Park: Penn State Press.
33.
HawkinsD.LakeD.NielsonD.TierneyM.2006 “Delegation Under Anarchy: States, International Organizations, and Principal-Agent Theory.” In Delegation and Agency in International Organizations, edited by HawkinsD.LakeD.NielsonD.TierneyM., 3–38. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
34.
HayakawaC.2008 “Gaikokujin Kenshū Ginō/Jisshū Seidō ni okeru Rōdōhō no Teikyō Mondai.” Nihon Rōdōhō Gakushi112:73–81.
35.
HennebryJ.2008 “Bienvenidos a Canadá? Globalization and the Migration Industry Surrounding Temporary Agricultural Migration in Canada.” Canadian Studies in Population35(2):339–56.
36.
Hernández-LeónR.2005The Migration Industry in the Mexico-US Migratory System. California Center for Population Research, Online Working Paper Series (CCPR-049-05). Los Angeles: California Center for Population Research.
37.
Hernández-LeónR.2008Metropolitan Migrants: The Migration of Urban Mexicans to the United States. Berkeley: University of California Press.
38.
Hernández-LeónR.2013 “Conceptualizing the Migration Industry.” In The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration, edited by Gammeltoft-HansenT.Nyberg SørensenN., 24–44. London: Routledge.
39.
HugoG.StahlC.2004 “Labor Export Strategies in Asia.” In International Migration: Prospects and Policies in a Global Market, edited by MasseyD.TaylorJ. E., 174–200. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
40.
KajitaT.2002 “Nihon no Gaikokujin Rōdōsha Seisaku.” In Kokusaika Suru Nihon Shakai, edited by KajitaT.MiyajimaT., 15–44. Tokyo: Tokyo University Press.
41.
Kantō Bengoshikai Rengōkai1990Gaikokujin Rōdōsha no Jūrō to Jinken. Tokyo: Akashi.
42.
KempA.RaijmanR.2014 “Bringing in State Regulations, Private Brokers, and Local Employers: A Meso-Level Analysis of Labor Trafficking in Israel.” International Migration Review48(3):604–42.
43.
KiewietR.McCubbinsM.1991The Logic of Delegation: Congressional Parties and the Appropriations Process. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
44.
KimJ.2003 “Insurgency and Advocacy: Unauthorized Foreign Workers and Civil Society in South Korea.” Asian and Pacific Migration Journal12(3):237–69.
45.
KimJ.2005 “State, Civil Society and International Norms: Expanding the Political and Labor Rights of Foreigners in South Korea.” Asian and Pacific Migration Journal14(4):383–418.
46.
KimN. H.-J.2008 “Korean Immigration Policy Changes and the Political Liberals’ Dilemma.” International Migration Review43(2):576–96.
47.
KimD.2011 “From Foreign Trainees to Unauthorized Workers: NGOs and the Enactment of the Employment Permit System.” Asian and Pacific Migration Journal20(1):55–78.
KongD.YoonK.SoyungY.2010 “The Social Dimensions of Immigration in Korea.” Journal of Contemporary Asia40(2):252–74.
50.
KrissmanF.2000 “Immigrant Labor Recruitment: U.S. Agribusiness and Undocumented Migration from Mexico.” In Immigration Research for a New Century, edited by FonerN.RumbautR.GoldS., 227–300. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
51.
KuY.-l.2013 “A Distorted Semi-Liberal Market of Migrant Workers in Taiwan.” Taiwan Human Rights Journal2(2):93–112.
52.
KurematsuS.2010Hanhinkonde Tsunagarō: Kokkyō wo Koeta Nakamatachi. Kyoto: Kamogawa Shuppan.
53.
KurematsuS.2013 “Nyūkanhō Kaiseigo mo Burookaa ni yoru Fusei.” In Gaikokujin Jisshūsei: Sabetsu, Yokuatsu, Sakushu no Shisutemu, edited by JisshūseiGaikokujinI’inkaiHenshū, 127–135. Tokyo: Gakushū no Tomosha.
54.
KyleD.2003Transnational Peasants: Migrations, Networks, and Ethnicity in Andean Ecuador. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
55.
KyleD.KoslowskiR. (eds.) 2001Global Human Smuggling: Comparative Perspectives. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
56.
LanP.-C.2007 “Legal Servitude, Free Illegality: Migrant “Guest” Workers in Taiwan.” In Asian Diasporas: New Conceptions, New Frameworks, edited by ParrenasR.SiuL., 253–77. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
57.
LeeJ.2010 “Taiwan.” In Immigration Worldwide: Policies, Practices, and Trends, edited by SegalU.ElliotD.MayadasN., 335–53. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
58.
Lemberg-PedersonM.2013 “Private Security Companies and the European Borderscapes.” In The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration, edited by Gammeltoft-HansenT.Nyberg SørensenN., 152–72. London: Routledge.
59.
LimT.2003 “Racing from the Bottom in South Korea? The Nexus Between Civil Society and Transnational Migrations.” Asian Survey43(3):423–42.
60.
LindquistJ.2010 “The Indonesian Migration Industry.” Pacific Affairs83(1):115–32.
61.
Liu-FarrerG.2009 “Educationally Channeled International Labor Mobility: Contemporary Student Migration from China to Japan.” International Migration Review43(1):178–204.
62.
MacDermottT.OpeskinB.2010 “Regulating Pacific Seasonal Labour in Australia.” Pacific Affairs83(2):283–305.
63.
MartinP.1980Guestworker Programs: Lessons From Europe. Washington, DC: Bureau of International Labor Affairs, US Department of Labor.
64.
MasseyD.DurandJ.MaloneN.2002Beyond Smoke and Mirrors: Mexican Immigration in an Era of Economic Integration. New York: Russell Sage.
65.
MenzG.2011 “Neo-Liberalism, Privatization and the Outsourcing of Migration Management: A Five-Country Comparison.” Competition and Change15(2):116–35.
66.
MillyD.2014New Policies for New Residents: Immigrants, Advocacy, and Governance in Japan and Beyond. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
67.
Ministry of Employment and Labor2011Goyongheogaje Sihaeng Pyeongga mit Gaeseon Bangan. Seoul: Goyong Nodongbu (MOEL).
68.
Ministry of Justice2014Immigration Control Report. Tokyo: Immigration Bureau, Ministry of Justice.
69.
MoriyaT.FuK.2011 “Nihon ni okeru Gaikokujin Kensh?sei/Gin?jissh?sei Seid? ni Kansuru Kenky?.” Pp. 140–164 in Nihon no Gaikokujin Ryūgakusei/Rōdōsha to Koyō Mondai, edited by MoriyaT.Kyoto: Kōyō Shobō.
70.
NakagawaI.2003 “Gaikokuin Rōdōsha Ukeire Rongi ga Terashidasu Nihon no Kadai: 1980–1990 Nendai no Nihon Kokunai ni okeru Kenkyū Dōkō no Tokuchō.” Ohara Shakai Mondai Kenkyūjo Zasshi523:1–26.
OhJ.-E.KangD. K.ShinJ. J.LeeS.-l.LeeS. B.ChungK.2012 “Migration Profile of the Republic of Korea.” International Organization of Migration Research Report Series No. 2011-01. Seoul: IOM Migration Research and Training Center.
73.
OishiN.1995 “Training or Employment? Japanese Immigration Policy in Dilemma.” Asian and Pacific Migration Journal4(2–3):367–85.
74.
PollackM.2003The Engines of European Integration: Delegation, Agency, and Agenda Setting. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
75.
RahmanM. M.2011Recruitment of Labor Migrants for the Gulf States: The Bangladeshi Case. Working Paper No. 132. Singapore: Institute for South Asian Studies.
76.
RodriguezR.2010Migrants for Export: How the Philippine State Brokers Labor to the World. St. Paul, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
77.
SaltJ.SteinJ.1997 “Migration as a Business: The Case of Trafficking.” International Migration35:467–94.
78.
SeolD.-H.2004 “Migrant Workers in the Midst of Reforming Foreign Labor Policy in Korea.” In Xen: Migration, Labor and Identity, edited by MinY. S.de SouzaA., 26–30. Seoul: SSamzie Space.
79.
SeolD.-H.2012 “The Citizenship of Foreign Workers in South Korea.” Citizenship Studies16 (1):119-33.
80.
SeolD. H.SkrentnyJ.2004 “South Korea: Importing Undocumented Workers.” In Controlling Migration: A Global Perspective, edited by CorneliusW.TsudaT.MartinP.HollifieldJ.. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
81.
ShimadaH.1994Japan’s “Guest Workers”: Issues and Public Policies. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.
82.
SpaanE.1994 “Taikongs and Calos: The Role of Middlemen and Brokers in Javanese International Migration.” The International Migration Review28(1):93–113.
83.
SpaanE.HillmanF.2013 “Migration Trajectories and the Migration Industry: Theoretical Reflections and Empirical Examples from Asia.” In The Migration Industry, edited by Gammeltoft-HansenT.Nyberg SørensenN., 64–86. London: Routledge.
84.
SpenerD.2009 “Some critical reflections on the migration industry concept.” Paper presented at the Migration in the Pacific Rim Workshop, University of California, Los Angeles, CA. May 29.
85.
SurakK.2013 “Guestwork: A Taxonomy.” New Left Review84:84–102.
86.
TajimaJ.2010Kokusai Ijū no Shakaigaku: Higashi Ajia no Guroobaruka wo Kangaeru. Tokyo: Akashi.
87.
TengY. M.2014 “Singapore’s System for Managing Foreign Manpower.” In Managing International Migration for Development in East Asia, edited by AdamsR. H.AhsanA., 220–40. Washington, DC: World Bank Group.
88.
TierneyR.2007 “The Guest Labor System in Taiwan: Labor Market Considerations, Wage Injustices, and the Politics of Foreign Labor Brokerage.” Critical Asian Studies39(2):205–28.
89.
Trujillo-PagánN.2014 “Emphasizing the ‘Complex’ in the ‘Immigration Industrial Complex.” Critical Sociology40(1):29–46.
90.
TsayC.-l.1992 “Clandestine Labor Migration to Taiwan.” Asian and Pacific Migration Journal1(3–4):637–65.
91.
TsengY.-f.WangH.-z.2013 “Governing Migrant Workers at a Distance: Managing the Temporary Status of Guestworkers in Taiwan.” International Migration51(4):1–28.
92.
UemotoT.2009 “Gaikokujin Kenshūsei no Seibōryoku Higai Saiban no Tenmatsu.” In Gaikokujin Kenshūsei Jikyū 300 En no Rōdōsha, Volume 2, edited by Gaikokujin Kenshūseikenri Nettowaaku, 124–36. Tokyo: Akashi Shoten.
93.
US Department of State2014Trafficking in Persons Report. Washington DC: US Department of State.
94.
VaronaR.2013License to Exploit: A Report on the Recruitment Practices and Problems Experienced by Filipino Domestic Workers in Hong Kong. Quezon City, Philippines: Alliance of Progressive Labor.
WangH.-z.BélangerD.2011 “Exploitative Recruitment Processes and Working Conditions of Vietnamese Migrant Workers in Taiwan.” In Labor in Vietnam, edited by ChanA., 309–34. Singapore: ISEAS.
97.
WatanabeH.2010 “Concerning Revisions in the Foreign Trainee and Technical Intern System.” Japan Labor Review7(3):43–67.
98.
WeingastB. R.MoranM.1983 “Bureaucratic Discretion or Congressional Control? Regulatory Policymaking by the Federal Trade Commission.” Journal of Political Economy91(5):765–800.
99.
YamadaM.2010 “Current Issues on Foreign Workers in Japan.” Japan Labor Review7(3):1–18.
100.
YasudaK.2013 “Gaikokujin Jisshūseidō no Jitai to Kaisei Nyūhōgo no Genjō wo Kokuhatsu Suru.” In Gaikokujin Jisshūsei: Sabetsu, Yokuatsu, Sakushu no Shisutemu, edited by Henshū I’inkaiGaikokujin Jisshūsei, 24–63. Tokyo: Gakushū no Tomosha.
101.
YooK.-S.2003Korea. OECD Country Report. Paris: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
102.
YoonI.-J.2009A Comparative Analysis of Immigration Policy in South Korea and Taiwan. Asiatic Research Institute Working Paper Series No. 3. Seoul: Korea University.
103.
ZolbergA.2006A Nation by Design: Immigration Policy in the Fashioning of America. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
