A Renewed Social Democracy for an ‘Age of Internationalism’: An Interpretivist Account of New Labour's Foreign Policy

Abstract

This article employs an interpretive approach to explore New Labour's use of social scientific theories in developing its foreign policy. After situating New Labour in the broad tradition of social democracy, it outlines the beliefs that most social democrats shared about the values of internationalism, international community and moral leadership. Taking these concepts in turn, the article then considers how New Labour modified their content in response to issues raised by ‘New Times’. In so doing, it problematizes New Labour's responses by revealing that they drew on ideas taken from complex interdependence theory, communitarianism and democratic peace theory respectively. The article then examines how these theories, in conjunction with the reformulation of its foreign policy, influenced New Labour's transformation of the three values, before concluding with a brief examination of the dilemmas arising from this process.

Keywords

interpretivism New Labour foreign policy internationalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkins

(2011) Justifying New Labour Policy (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan).

Attlee

(1950) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 3 October.

Attlee

(1951) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 1 October.

BBC (2003) Clare Short interview, 10 March. Available online at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/2836925.stm

Bellamy

(2004) ‘Ethics and intervention: The “humanitarian exception” and the problem of abuse in the case of Iraq’, Journal of Peace Research, 41:2, 131–147.

Bevir

(2003) ‘Narrating the British state: An interpretive critique of New Labour's institutionalism’, Review of International Political Economy, 10:3, 455–480.

Bevir

(2005) New Labour: A Critique (London: Routledge).

Bevir

and Gains

(2011) ‘Ideas into policy: Governance and governmentality’, Policy & Politics, 39:4, 451–457.

Bevir

and O'Brien

(2001) ‘New Labour and the public sector in Britain’, Public Administration Review, 61, 535–547.

10.

Bevir

and Rhodes

R. A. W.

(2003) Interpreting British Governance (London: Routledge).

11.

Bevir

and Rhodes

R. A. W.

(2010) The State As Cultural Practice (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

12.

Blair

(1995) The Spectator Lecture, 22 March.

13.

Blair

(1996) Speech to the Keidanren, 5 January.

14.

Blair

(1998) The Third Way: New Politics for the New Century (London: Fabian Society).

15.

Blair

(1999) Doctrine of the International Community at the Economic Club, Chicago, 24 April.

16.

Blair

(2001) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 2 October.

17.

Blair

(2002a) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 1 October.

18.

Blair

(2002b) Speech at the George Bush Senior Presidential Library, 7 April.

19.

Blair

(2002c) Prime Minister's Iraq statement to Parliament, 24 September.

20.

Blair

(2003a) Prime Minister's statement opening Iraq debate, 18 March.

21.

Blair

(2003b) Speech to the Labour Party Spring Conference, 15 February.

22.

Blair

(2003c) Prime Minister's address to the Nation, 20 March.

23.

Blair

(2003d) Speech to the US Congress, 17 July.

24.

Blair

(2004) Prime Minister warns of continuing global terror threat, 5 March.

25.

Blair

(2010) A Journey (London: Hutchinson).

26.

Bluth

(2004) ‘The British road to war: Blair, Bush and the decision to invade Iraq’, International Affairs, 80, 871–892.

27.

Brivati

(2004) ‘Internationalism’, in Plant

Beech

and Hickson

(eds), The Struggle for Labour's Soul: Understanding Labour's Political Thought since 1945 (London: Routledge), 229–244.

28.

Brown

(1999) Speech to the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, 10 May.

29.

Brown

(2006) Speech to the United Nations Ambassadors, 20 April.

30.

Callaghan

(1977) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 4 October.

31.

Callaghan

(1980) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 30 September.

32.

Coates

and Krieger

(2004) Blair's War (Cambridge: Polity).

33.

Coates

Krieger

and Vickers

(2004) ‘New Labour: A Leading Force for Good in the World?’ in Coates

and Krieger

(eds), Blair's War (Cambridge: Polity), 9–21.

34.

Cook

(1997) Speech on the government's ethical foreign policy, 12 May.

35.

Daddow

(2009) ‘“Tony's war”? Blair, Kosovo and the interventionist impulse in British foreign policy’, International Affairs, 85:3, 547–560.

36.

Daddow

and Broad

(2010) ‘Half remembered quotations from mostly forgotten speeches: The limits of Labour's European discourse’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 12:2, 205–222.

37.

Driver

and Martell

(2006) New Labour (2nd edn.) (Cambridge: Polity Press).

38.

Dyson

S. B.

(2009) ‘What difference did he make? Tony Blair and British foreign policy from 1997–2007’, in Casey

(ed.), The Blair Legacy: Politics, Policy, Governance, and Foreign Affairs (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan), 235–246.

39.

Etzioni

(2006) ‘Sovereignty as responsibility’, Orbis, 50:1, 71–85.

40.

Fairclough

(2000) New Labour, New Language? (London: Routledge).

41.

Foot

(1982) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 28 September.

42.

Gamble

and Wright

(2004) ‘The fallout from Iraq’, Political Quarterly, 75:3, 209–212.

43.

Gearty

(2003) ‘How did Blair get here?’, London Review of Books, 20 February 25:4, pp. 7–8.

44.

Giddens

(1990) The Consequences of Modernity (Cambridge: Polity Press).

45.

Giddens

(1998) The Third Way: The Renewal of Social Democracy (Cambridge: Polity Press).

46.

Goes

(2004) ‘The Third Way and the politics of community’, in Hale

Leggett

and Martell

(eds), The Third Way and beyond: Criticisms, Futures, Alternatives (Manchester: Manchester University Press), 108–127.

47.

HC Deb (2002–03) 401, col. 902.

48.

Held

McGrew

Goldblatt

and Perraton

(1999) Global Transformations: Politics, Economics and Culture (Cambridge: Polity Press).

49.

Hirst

and Thompson

(1996) Globalisation in Question: The International Economy and the Possibilities of Governance (Cambridge: Polity Press).

50.

Hoggett

(2005) ‘Iraq: Blair's mission impossible’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 7:3, 418–428.

51.

Hughes

and Smith

(1998) ‘New Labour—New Europe?’, International Affairs, 74:1, 93–103.

52.

Ish-Shalom

(2007–08) ‘“The civilization of clashes”: Misapplying the democratic peace in the Middle East’, Political Science Quarterly, 122:4, 533–554.

53.

Kettell

(2006) Dirty Politics: New Labour, British Democracy and the Invasion of Iraq (London: Zed Books).

54.

Kinnock

(1985) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 1 October.

55.

Labour Party (1987) General Election Manifesto. Available online at: http://www.labour-party.org.uk/manifestos/1987/1987-labour-manifesto.shtml

56.

Labour Party (1997) General Election Manifesto. Available online at: http://www.labour-party.org.uk/manifestos/1997/1997-labour-manifesto.shtml

57.

Lawson

(2002) The New Agenda for International Relations: From Polarization to Globalization in World Politics? (Cambridge: Polity Press).

58.

Layne

(1994) ‘Kant or cant: The myth of the democratic peace’, International Security, 19:2, 5–49.

59.

Manning

(2007) ‘Development’, in Seldon

(ed.), Blair's Britain 1999–2007 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 551–571.

60.

McGrew

(2004) ‘Globalisation’, in Plant

Beech

and Hickson

(eds), The Struggle for Labour's Soul: Understanding Labour's Political Thought since 1945 (London: Routledge), 137–162.

61.

Nye

J. S.

(2004) Power in the Global Information Age: From Realism to Globalization (London: Routledge).

62.

Ohmae

(1991) The Borderless World: Power and Strategy in the Interlinked Economy (London: Fontana).

63.

Ohmae

(1995) ‘Putting global logic first’, Harvard Business Review, 73:1, 119–125.

64.

Porteous

(2005) ‘British government policy in sub-Saharan Africa under New Labour’, International Affairs, 81:2, 281–297.

65.

Rosato

(2003) ‘The flawed logic of democratic peace theory’, American Political Science Review, 97, 585–602.

66.

Rosen

(2005) Old Labour to New: The Dreams that Inspired, the Battles that Divided (London: Politico's Publishing).

67.

Rosenberg

(2000) ‘Just war and intervention: The challenge of the international for social and political theory’, Papers in Social Theory, 5, 2–20.

68.

Scholte

J. A.

(1993) International Relations of Social Change (Buckingham: Open University Press).

69.

Smith

(1992) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 29 September.

70.

Spiro

D. E.

(1994) ‘The insignificance of the liberal peace’, International Security, 19:2, 50–86.

71.

Straw

(2003) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 1 October.

72.

Straw

(2005) Speech to the Fabian Society, 10 March.

73.

Thorpe

(2008) A History of the British Labour Party (3rd edn.) (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan).

74.

Vickers

(2000) ‘Blair's Kosovo campaign: Political communications, the battle for public opinion and foreign policy’, Civil Wars, 3:1, 55–70.

75.

Vickers

(2004) The Labour Party and the World, Volume 1: The Evolution of Labour's Foreign Policy 1900–1951 (Manchester: Manchester University Press).

76.

Vine

(2009) Island of Shame: The Secret History of the U.S. Military Base on Diego Garcia (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).

77.

Wheeler

N. J.

and Dunne

(1998) ‘Good international citizenship: A third way for British foreign policy’, International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944–), 74:4, 847–870.

78.

Williams

P. D.

(2004) ‘Who's making UK foreign policy?’, International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944–), 80:5, 911–929.

79.

Wilson

(1964) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 12 December.

80.

Wilson

(1968) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 1 October.

81.

Wilson

(1970) Speech to the Labour Party Conference, 29 September.