This article analyses the changing political significance of UK balance of payments assessment in the post-war era, seeking to explain its disappearance as a policy issue today. We demonstrate the historically contingent nature of balance of payments performance assessment by comparing its shifting, conjunctural, constructions, rooted in underlying political economic assumptions, across four periods in the 20th and 21st centuries. We argue that the political salience of UK balance of payments assessment is contingent upon structural changes (both ideational and material) within the global political economy and domestic politics. Changes in the prevailing policy paradigm through which balance of payments was interpreted (for example from ‘embedded liberalism’ to neo-liberalism), and redefinitions of balance of payments assessment techniques, both of which happened on numerous occasions in the post-war world, had the effect of reshaping the nature of the external international political economic constraints to which UK governments were subjected.
AbdelalR.BlythM. and ParsonsC. (forthcoming) ‘Constructing the international economy’, in AbdelalR.BlythM. and ParsonsC. (eds), Constructing the International Economy (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
2.
BlockF. (1977) The Origins of International Economic Disorder: A Study of US International Monetary Policy from World War Two to the Present (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press).
3.
BlockF. (2001) ‘Introduction' to Polanyi, Karl, The Great Transformation: The Political and Economic Origins of Our Time (Boston: Beacon Press), xviii–xxxviii.
4.
BlythM. (1997) ‘“Any more bright ideas?” The ideational turn of comparative political economy’, Comparative Politics, 29:2, 229–250.
5.
BlythM. (2002) Great Transformations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
6.
BrittanS. (1970) The Price of Economic Freedom (Basingstoke: Macmillan).
7.
BuiterW. (1980) ‘The Macroeconomics of Dr. Pangloss: A critical survey of the new classical macroeconomics’, Economic Journal, 90:357, 34–50.
8.
BurnhamP. (2003) Remaking the Postwar World Economy (Basingstoke: Palgrave).
9.
BurnsT. (1996) Managing the National Economy, Treasury Occasional Paper No. 5 (London: Treasury).
10.
CairncrossA. (1986) Years of Recovery: British Economic Policy, 1945–1951 (London: Methuen).
11.
CampbellJ. (2001) ‘Institutional analysis and the Role of Ideas in Political Economy’, in CampbellJ. and PedersenO. (eds), The Rise of Neoliberalism and Institutional Analysis (Princeton: Princeton University Press), 159–190.
12.
CliftB. and TomlinsonJ. (2007) ‘Credible Keynesianism?: New Labour macroeconomic policy and the political economy of coarse tuning’, British Journal of Political Science, 37:1, 47–69.
13.
ConanA. R. (1961) The Rationale of the Sterling Area (London: Macmillan).
14.
CongdonT. (1982) Monetary Control in Britain (London: Macmillan).
15.
CouttsK. and GodleyW. (1992) ‘Does Britain's balance of payments matter any more?’, in MichieJ. (ed.), The Economic Legacy 1979–1992 (London: Academic Press), 60–67.
16.
CoxR. (1987) Power, Production and World Order (New York: Columbia University Press).
17.
De VriesM. G. (1987) Balance of Payments Adjustment 1945 to 1986: The IMF Experience (Washington, DC: IMF).
18.
DysonK. (2000) ‘EMU as Europeanization: Convergence, Diversity and Contingency’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 38:4, 645–666.
19.
EatwellJ. (1982) Whatever Happened to Britain? (London: BBC Books).
20.
EatwellJ. (1995) ‘The international origins of unemployment’, in MichieJ. and Grieve SmithJ. (eds), Managing The Global Economy (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 271–286.
21.
EatwellJ. and TaylorL. (2000) Global Finance at Risk: The Case for International Regulation (Cambridge: Polity).
22.
EichengreenB. (1996) Globalizing Capital (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
23.
FootM. (1972) ‘The balance of payments in the inter-war period’, Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, 12, 345–363.
24.
FriedmanM. (1953) ‘The case for flexible rates’, in FriedmanM. (ed.), Essays in Positive Economics (Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press), 157–203.
25.
GambleA. (1984) ‘Stabilization policy and adversary politics’, in GambleA. and WalklandS. A. (eds), The British Party System and Economic Policy 1945–1983 (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 40–91.
26.
GambleA. (1986) ‘The Political Economy of Freedom’, in LevitasR. (ed.), The Ideology of the New Right (Cambridge: Polity), 25–54.
27.
GermainR. (1997) The International Organisation of Credit (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
28.
HallP. (1993) ‘Policy paradigms, social learning and the state’, Comparative Politics, 25:3, 275–296.
29.
HayC. (2004) ‘The normalizing role of rationalist assumptions in the institutional embedding of neo-liberalism’, Economy and Society, 33:4, 500–527.
30.
HazelwoodA. (1962) ‘The export and import of capital’, in WorswickG. D. N. and AdyP. H. (eds), The British Economy in the Nineteen Fifties (Oxford: Clarendon), 173–204.
31.
HirschF. (1965) The Pound Sterling: A Polemic (London: Penguin).
32.
HMSO (1986) Pink Book (London: HMSO).
33.
HuttonW. (1994) ‘Reviving Bretton Woods’, New Economy, 1:4, 207–212.
34.
IMF (1984) Exchange Rate Volatility and World Trade, Occasional Paper no. 28 (Washington: IMF).
35.
JamesH. (1996) International Monetary Co-operation since Bretton Woods (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
36.
JohnsonC. (1991) The Economy under Mrs Thatcher 1979–1990 (London: Penguin).
37.
KenenP. and EichengreenB. (1994) ‘Managing the World Ecn under the Bretton Woods System: an Overview’, in KenenP. (ed.), Managing the World Economy (Washington DC: Institute for International Economics), 3–57.
38.
KettellS. (2004) The Political Economy of Exchange Rate Policy-Making (Basingstoke: Palgrave).
39.
KeynesJ. M. (1964 [1936]) The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (London: Macmillan).
40.
KeynesJ. M. (1979 [1945]) Collected Writings (vol. 24) (Basingstoke: Macmillan).
41.
LawsonN. (1988) The State of the Market, Occasional Paper no. 80 (London: IEA).
42.
LindertP. (1969) Key Currencies and Gold 1900–1930 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
43.
Lord Radcliffe (1958) Report of the Committee on the Working of the Monetary System, Cmnd 827 (London: HMSO).
44.
McCombieJ. and ThirlwallT. (1992) ‘Comment: The re-emergence of the balance of payments constraint’, in MichieJ. (ed.), The Economic Legacy 1979–1992 (London: Academic Press), 66–74.
45.
McCombieJ. and ThirlwallA. (2004) Essays on Balance of Payments Constrained Growth (London: Routledge).
46.
MachlupF. (1964) International Payments, Debts, and Gold (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons).
47.
ManserW. A. P. (1971) Britain in Balance: The Myth of Failure (London: Penguin).
48.
MeadeJ. (1951) The Theory of International Economic Policy, Vol I., The Balance of Payments (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
49.
MiddletonR. (2002) ‘Struggling with the impossible: Sterling, the balance of payments and British economic policy, 1949–72’, in ArnonA. and YoungW. (eds), The Open Economy Macro-Model: Past, Present and Future (Boston, MA: Kluwer), 103–154.
50.
MosleyL. (2000) ‘Room to move: International financial markets and national welfare states’, International Organization, 54:4, 737–773.
51.
MosleyL. (2003) Global Capital and National Governments (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
52.
NickellS. (2002) ‘The assessment: The economic record of the Labour government since 1997’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 18:2, 107–119.
53.
PaishF. (1956) ‘Britain's Foreign Investments: the Post-War Record’, Lloyds Bank Review July.
54.
PolanyiK. (2001) The Great Transformation (Boston, MA: Beacon Press).
55.
RosamondB. (2002) ‘Imagining the European economy: “Competitiveness” and the social construction of “Europe” as an economic space’, New Political Economy, 7:2, 157–178.
56.
RuggieJ. (1982) ‘International regimes, transactions and change: Embedded liberalism in the post-war economic order’, International Organization, 36:2, 379–415.
57.
RuggieJ. (1998) Constructing the World Polity: Essays in International Institutionalization (London: Routledge).
58.
SayersR. (1976) The Bank of England 1891–1944 (vol. 1) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
59.
SchenkC. (1994) Britain and the Sterling Area (London: Routledge).
60.
SearleJ. (1995) The Construction of Social Reality (London: Penguin).
61.
ShonfieldA. (1958) British Economic Policy since the War (London: Penguin).
62.
SinclairT. (2005) The New Masters of Capital: American Bond Rating Agencies and the Politics of Creditworthiness (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press).
63.
SnowdenN. and MilnerC. (1992) ‘External imbalances and policy constraint in the 1990s’, in MilnerC. and SnowdenN. (eds), External Imbalance and Policy Constraints in the 1990s (Basingstoke: Macmillan), 1–11.
64.
StrangeS. (1971) Sterling and British Policy (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
65.
StrangeS. (1976) International Monetary Relations (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
66.
ThirlwallA. (1980) Balance-of-Payments Theory and the United Kingdom Experience (Basingstoke: Macmillan).
67.
ThirlwallA. and GibsonH. (1992) Balance-of-Payments Theory and the United Kingdom Experience (4th edn) (Basingstoke: Macmillan).
68.
ThompsonH. (forthcoming) ‘National economic policy’, in FlindersM.HayC.GambleA. and KennyM. (eds), The Oxford Handbook of British Politics (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
69.
TiratsooN. and TomlinsonJ. (1998) The Conservatives and Industrial Efficiency 1951–1964 (London: Routledge).
70.
TomlinsonJ. (1996) Democratic Socialism and Economic Policy: The Attlee Years 1945–1951 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
71.
Treasury (2007) Financial Statement and Budget Report (London: HMSO).
72.
ZisG. (2004) ‘The elusive case for flexible exchange rates’, in CatterallR. and AldcroftD. (eds), Exchange Rates and Economic Policy in the 20th Century (Aldershot: Ashgate), 254–295.
