Clientelism has predominantly been represented in the literature as an expression of backwardness and corruption with little attention being paid to the question of how clientelism has changed over the years. In contrast, this paper examines the particulars of state intervention in the agrarian economy with respect to clientelism and exposes the illogicality of contrasting patron-client relationships with citizenship. The historical focus is on the ways in which, in the course of post-dictatorship consolidation in rural Greece throughout the 1980s, the transformation of traditional brokerage-based clientelism into the bureaucratic clientelism of the political parties actually enhanced the institutions and practices of ‘rural citizenship’. Comparative qualitative research on the driving force of agrarian change shows how Thessalian villagers made the transition from being socially excluded subjects to socially included clients in two lowland village communities and the role played by a dynamic state bureaucracy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BakerT. and NelsonR.E., (2005), ‘Creating Something from Nothing: Resource Construction through Entrepreneurial Bricolage’, Administrative Science Quarterly, 50: 329–366.
2.
BanfieldE., (1958), The Moral Basis of a Backward Society, New York: Free Press.
3.
BikaZ., (2012), ‘Entrepreneurial Sons, Patriarchy and the Colonels' Experiment in Thessaly, Rural Greece’, Entrepreneurship and Regional Development.
4.
BikaZ., (2007), ‘A Survey of Academic Approaches to Agrarian Transformation in Post-War Greece’, Journal of Peasant Studies, 34: 69–90.
5.
BoissevainJ., (1968), ‘The Place of Non-Groups in the Social Sciences’, Man, 3: 542–556.
6.
BrennerR., (1976), ‘Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe’, Past and Present, 70: 30–74.
7.
BromleyS., (1991), ‘The Politics of Postmodernism’, Capital and Class, 15: 129–150.
8.
ButtelF., (2001), ‘Some Reflections on Late Twentieth Century Agrarian Political Economy’, Sociologia Ruralis, 41: 165–181.
9.
CampbellJ.K., (1964), Honour, Family and Patronage: Study of Institutions and Moral Values in a Greek Mountain Community, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.
CloggR., (1992), A Concise History of Greece, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
DahrendorfR., (1974), ‘Citizenship and Beyond: The Social Dynamics of an Idea’, Social Research, 41: 673–701.
12.
DaggerR., (1981), ‘Metropolis, Memory, and Citizenship’, American Journal of Political Science, 25: 715–737.
13.
DamianakosS., (1997), ‘The Ongoing Quest for a Model of Greek Agriculture’, Sociologia Ruralis, 37: 190–208.
14.
DaoutopoulosG.A., (1991), ‘Community Development in Greece’, Community Development Journal, 26: 131–138.
15.
EvansP., (1995), Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation, Princeton-NJ: Princeton University Press.
16.
EvansP., (1996), ‘Government Action, Social Capital and Development: Reviewing the Evidence on Synergy’, World Development, 24: 1119–1132.
17.
EvansP. and RauchJ.E., (1999), ‘Bureaucracy and Growth: A Cross-National Analysis of the Effects of “Weberian” State Structures on Economic Growth’, American Sociological Review, 64: 748–765.
18.
GlennE., (2000), ‘Citizenship and Inequality: Historical and Global Perspectives’, Social Problems, 47: 1–20.
19.
GouldR.V., (1996), ‘Patron-Client Ties, State Centralization, and the Whisky Rebellion’, American Journal of Sociology, 102: 400–429.
20.
GoussiosD., (1995), ‘The European and local context of Greek family farming’, Sociologia Ruralis, 35: 322–334.
21.
GreenS., (2008), ‘Eating money and clogging things up: Paradoxes of elite mediation in Epirus, North-western Greece’, The Sociological Review, 56 (S1): 260–282.
22.
HeldD., (2004), ‘Democratic Accountability and Political Effectiveness from a Cosmopolitan Perspective’, Government and Opposition, 39: 364–391.
23.
HerzfeldM., (2003), ‘Localism and the Logic of Nationalistic Folklore: Cretan Reflections’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 45: 281–310.
24.
HungHo-Fung., (2008), ‘Agricultural Revolution and Elite Reproduction in Qing China: The Transition to Capitalism Debate Revisited’, American Sociological Review, 73: 569–588.
25.
KarampeliasG., (1989), State and Society in ‘Metapolitefsi’ (1974–1988), Athens: EXANTAS.
26.
KasimisC. and PapadopoulosA., (1997), ‘Family Farming and Capitalist Development in Greek Agriculture: A Critical Review of the Literature’, Sociologia Ruralis, 37: 209–227.
27.
KaufmanR., (1974), ‘The Patron-Client Concept and Macro-Politics: Prospects and Problems’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 16: 284–308.
28.
LazarS., (2004), ‘Personalistic Politics, Clientelism and Citizenship: Local Elections in El Alto, Bolivia’, Bulletin of Latin American Research, 23: 228–243.
29.
LemarchandR. and LeggK., (1972), ‘Political Clientelism and Development’, Comparative Politics, 4: 149–178.
30.
ListerR., (1998), ‘Citizen in action: Citizenship and community development in a Northern Ireland context’, Community Development Journal, 33: 226–235.
31.
LouloudisL. and MaraveyasN., (1997), ‘Farmers and Agricultural Policy in Greece since the Accession to the European Union’, Sociologia Ruralis, 37: 270–286.
32.
LukesS., (1977), ‘Power and Structure’, Essays in Social Theory, LukesS. (ed.), London: The Macmillan Press Ltd: 3–99. Cb to check page nos
33.
LyrintzisC., (1987), ‘The power of populism: The Greek case’, European Journal of Political Research, 15: 667–686.
34.
LyrintzisC., (1984), ‘Political Parties in Post-Junta Greece: A Case of ‘Bureaucratic Clientelism?’, West European Politics, 7: 99–118.
35.
MarantzidisN. and MavrommatisG., (1999), ‘Political Clientelism and Social Exclusion’, International Sociology, 14: 443–456.
36.
MaraveyasN., (1992), Agricultural Policy and Economic Development in Greece, Athens: NEA SINORA-LIBANI.
37.
MarsdenT., (1992), ‘Exploring a Rural Sociology for the Fordist Transition: Incorporating Social Relations into Economic Restructuring’, Sociologia Ruralis, 32: 209–230.
38.
MarshallT.H. and BottomoreT., (1950), Citizenship and Social Class, 2nd edition, London: Pluto Press.
39.
MattinaC., (2007), ‘Changes in Clientelism and Urban Government: A Comparative Case Study of Naples and Marseilles’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 31: 73–90.
40.
MooreB.Jr., (1966), Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
41.
MouzelisN., (1976), ‘Capitalism and Dictatorship in Post-war Greece’, New Left Review, 96: 57–80.
42.
MouzelisN., (1978), ‘Class and Clientelistic Politics: The case of Greece’, The Sociological Review, 26: 471–497.
43.
NarotzkyS., (2007), ‘The Project in the Model: Reciprocity, Social Capital, and the Politics of Ethnographic Realism’, Current Anthropology, 48: 403–424.
44.
NisbetR., (1974), ‘Citizenship: Two Traditions’, Social Research, 41: 612–637.
45.
PantazopoulosA., (2001), For the People and the Nation: the Time of Andreas Papandreou 1965–1989, Athens: POLIS.
46.
PapadopoulosA.G. and LiarikosC., (2007), ‘Dissecting changing rural development policy networks: The case of Greece’, Environment and Planning C, 25: 291–313.
47.
ParkerG. and RavenscroftN., (2001), ‘Land, Rights and the Gift: The Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000 and the Negotiation of Citizenship’, Sociologia Ruralis, 41: 381–398.
48.
PollisA., (1987), ‘The State, the Law and Human Rights in Modern Greece’, Human Rights Quarterly, 9: 587–614.
49.
PortisE.B., (1986), ‘Citizenship and Personal Identity’, Cambridge: Polity, 18: 457–472.
50.
PridhamG., (1990), Securing Democracy: Political Parties and Democratic Consolidation in Southern Europe, London: Routledge.
51.
RobertsB., (1995), The Making of Citizens: Cities of Peasants Revisited, London: Arnold.
52.
SayerA., (2001), ‘For a Critical Cultural Political Economy’, Antipode, 33: 687–708.
53.
SayerA., (2000), Realism and Social Science, London: Sage.
54.
SchneiderJ. and SchneiderP., (2005), ‘Mafia, Antimafia, and the Plural Cultures of Sicily’, Current Anthropology, 46: 501–520.
55.
SchneiderA. and Zuniga-HamlinR., (2005), ‘A Strategic Approach to Rights: Lessons from Clientelism in Rural Peru’, Development Policy Review, 23: 567–584.
56.
ScottJ., (1977), ‘Protest and Profanation: Agrarian Revolt and the Little Tradition’, Theory and Society, 4: 1–38.
57.
ScottJ., (1985), ‘Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance’, Haven: Yale University Press.
58.
SoifferS. and HoweG., (1982), ‘Patrons, Clients and the Articulation of Modes of Production: An Examination of the Penetration of Capitalism into Peripheral Agriculture in Northeastern Brazil’, Journal of Peasant Studies, 9: 176–206.
59.
SomersM.R., (1993), ‘Citizenship and the Place of the Public Sphere: Law, Community, and Political Culture in the Transition to Democracy’, American Sociological Review, 58: 587–620.
60.
SotiropoulosD., (1994), ‘Bureaucrats and politicians: A case study of the determinants of perceptions of conflict and patronage in the Greek bureaucracy under PASOK rule, 1981–1989’, British Journal of Sociology, 45: 349–365.
61.
SpourdalakisM., (1988), The Rise of the Greek Socialist Party, London and New York: Routledge.
62.
TurnerB., (1990), ‘Outline of a Theory of Citizenship’, Sociology, 24: 189–217.
63.
TurnerB., (2001), ‘The erosion of citizenship’, British Journal of Sociology, 52: 189–209.
64.
VergopoulosK., (1978), ‘Capitalism and Peasant Productivity’, Journal of Peasant Studies, 5: 446–465.
65.
WilliamsA., (1984), Southern Europe Transformed: Political and Economic Change in Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain, London: Harper and Row Publishers.
66.
WolfE., (1969), Peasant Wars of the Twentieth Century, New York: Harper and Row.
67.
YannopoulosG., (1972), ‘Workers and Peasants under the Military Dictatorship’, Greece under Military Rule, CloggR. and YannopoulosG. (eds), London: Secker and Warburg: 109–127.
