This article examines the global forces that are responsible for the transformation of the meaning and practice of UNHCR's humanitarianism, and asks whether a transformation that enables the organization to become more deeply involved in the internal affairs of states is welcome or worrisome. I open by reviewing the changing relationship between multilateralism, sovereignty, and humanitarianism, and link that conceptual discussion to the international refugee regime. I then argue that the combination of state pressures and the normative principle of popular sovereignty enabled a more political and pragmatic UNHCR to widen its activities under the humanitarian banner and to become more deeply involved in the circumstances in the refugee-producing country. This expanding humanitarian umbrella, I suggest, might be a stealth agent for a policy of containment and a threat to refugee rights. This possibility is suggested by recent debates over the category of internally displaced peoples; the decided preference for repatriation; and UNHCR's involvement in reintegration activities. These developments generate the worrisome possibility that a more pragmatic UNHCR is potentially (though unwittingly) implicated in a system of containment. I conclude by reflecting on UNHCR's role in global politics and the dangers of a sovereignty-led humanitarianism.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Amnesty International1997“In Search of Safety: The Forcibly Displaced and Human Rights in Africa,”AI Index: AFR. January 5.
2.
Anonymous1997“The UNHCR Note on International Protection You Won't See,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 9(2): 267–273.
3.
BarberoJ.1993“Refugee Protection during Conflict: A New Conventional Wisdom,”Refuge, 12(8): 7–12.
4.
BarkinJ. S.1998“The Evolution of the Constitution of Sovereignty and the Emergence of Human Rights Norms,”Millennium, 27(2): 229–252.
5.
BarnettM.2000“UNHCR and Involuntary Repatriation: Environmental Developments, the Repatriation Culture, and the Rohingya Refugees.” Paper delivered at the International Studies Association annual meetings, Los Angeles, March 16–20.
6.
BarnettM.1995“The New U.N. Politics of Peace: From Juridical Sovereignty to Empirical Sovereignty,”Global Governance, 1(1): 79–97. Winter.
7.
BarnettM., and FinnemoreM.1999“The Politics, Power, and Pathologies of International Organizations,”International Organization, 53(4): 699–732. Fall.
8.
BarutciskiM.1998“Involuntary Repatriation when Refugee Protection Is No Longer Necessary,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 10: 236–255.
9.
BarutciskiM.1996“The Reinforcement of Non-Admission Policies and the Subversion of UNHCR: Displacement and Internal Assistance in Bosnia-Herzegovina,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 8(1): 49–110. January/April.
10.
BascomJ.1994“The Dynamics of Refugee Repatriation: The Case of Eritreans in Eastern Sudan.” In Population Migration and the Changing World Order. Ed. GouldW., and FindleyA.New York: John Wiley and Sons.
11.
BoliJ., and ThomasG.1999“INGOs and the Organization of World Culture.” In Constructing World Culture. Ed. BoliJ., and ThomasG.Stanford: Stanford University Press. Pp. 13–49
12.
Boutros-GhaliB.1995“Democracy: A Newly Recognized Imperative,”Global Governance, 1(1): 312. Winter.
13.
BullH.1977Anarchical Society.New York: Columbia University Press.
14.
ChimniB. S.1999“From Resettlement to Repatriation: Towards a Critical History of Durable Solutions to Refugee Problems,”New Issues in Refugee Research. Working Paper No. 2. Geneva: UNHCR.
15.
ChimniB. S.1998“The Geopolitics of Refugee Studies: A View from the South,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 11(4): 350–374.
16.
ChimniB. S.1993“The Meaning of Words and the Role of UNHCR in Voluntary Repatriation,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 5(3): 442–460.
17.
ChimniB. S.1991“Perspectives on Voluntary Repatriation: A Critical Note,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 3(3): 541–546.
18.
CohenR., and DengF.1998Masses in Flight.Washington, DC: Brookings Press.
19.
ColesG.1989“Approaching the Refugee Problem Today.” In The Question of Refugees and International Relations. Ed. LoescherG., and MonahanL.New York: Oxford University Press. Pp. 373–410
20.
ColesG.1985Voluntary Repatriation.Geneva: UNHCR.
21.
CrispJ. F.1984a “The Politics of Repatriation: Ethiopian Refugees in Djibouti,”Review of African Political Economy, 30: 73–82.
22.
CrispJ. F.1984b “Voluntary Repatriation Programs for African Refugees: A Critical Assessment,”Refugee Issues, 1(2): 23.
23.
CrispJ., and MooneyE.1999“Report on the Workshop on Internal Displacement in Africa, Addis Ababa, October 19–20, 1998,”International Migration Review, 33(2): 468–483.
24.
CunliffeS. A., and PughM.1999“UNHCR as Leader in Humanitarianism: A Triumph of Politics over Law?” In Refugee Rights and Realities: Evolving International Concepts and Regimes. Ed. NicholsonF., and TwomeyP.New York: Cambridge University Press.
25.
CunyF., and SteinB.1989“Prospects for and Promotion of Spontaneous Repatriation.” In The Question of Refugees and International Relations. Ed. LoescherG., and MonahanL.New York: Oxford University Press. Pp. 293–312
26.
CuttsM.1998“Politics and Humanitarianism,”Refugee Survey Quarterly, 17(1): 1–15.
27.
DacylJ.1996“Sovereignty Versus Human Rights: From Past Discourses to Contemporary Dilemmas,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 9(2): 136–165.
28.
DemuszK.1998“From Relief to Development: Negotiating the Continuum on the Thai-Burmese Border,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 11(3): 231–249.
29.
DengF.1995“Dealing with the Displaced: A Challenge to the International Community,”Global Governance, 1. Winter.
30.
de WallA.1998Famine Crimes.Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
31.
DoyleM.1986“Liberalism and World Politics,”American Political Science Review, 80: 1151–1169.
32.
FellerE.1990UNHCR and the International Protection of Refugees – Current Problems and Future Prospects,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 2: 335–346. September.
33.
FranckT.1992“The Emerging Right to Democratic Governance,”American Journal of International Law, 86(1): 46–91. January.
34.
FrelickB.1993“Preventing Refugee Flows: Protection or Peril,”World Refugee Survey. Pp. 5–13.
35.
FrelickB.1990“The Right to Return,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 2: 442–448.
36.
GilbertG.1998“Rights, Legitimate Expectations, Needs, and Responsibilities: UNHCR and the New World Order,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 10(3): 349–388.
37.
Goodwin-GillG.1999“Refugee Identity and Protections Fading Prospect.” In Refugee Rights and Realities: Evolving International Concepts and Regimes. Ed. NicholsonF., and TwomeyP.New York: Cambridge University Press. Pp. 220–252
38.
Goodwin-GillG.1996The Refugee in International Law, 2nd Edition.New York: Oxford University Press.
39.
GordenkerL.1981“Organizational Expansion and Limits in International Services for Refugees,”International Migration Review, 15(1): 74–87.
40.
Harrell-BondB.1989“Repatriation: Under What Conditions Is it the Most Desirable Solution for Refugees?”African Studies Review, 32: 41–69.
41.
HathawayJ.1997“The Meaning of Repatriation,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 9(4): 551–558.
42.
HathawayJ.1991“Reconceiving Refugee Law as Human Rights Protection,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 4(2): 113–131.
43.
HolbornL.1975Refugees: Problem of Our Time: The Work of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, 2 volumes. Metuchen, NJ: Scarecrow Press.
44.
Human Rights Watch1997Uncertain Refugee: International Failures to Protect Refugees, 9: 1. April.
45.
Human Rights Watch1996“Burma: The Rohingyan Muslims Ending a Cycle of Violence?” 8: 0. September.
46.
Human Rights Watch/Asia and Refugees International1997“Rohingya Refugees in Bangladesh: The Search for a Lasting Solution,” 9: 7. August.
47.
JacksonR.1993“The Weight of Ideas in Decolonization: Normative Change in International Relations.” In Ideas and Foreign Policy: Belief, Institutions, and Political Change. Ed. GoldsteinJ., and KeohaneR.Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Pp. 111–138
48.
JacobsenH.1962“The United Nations and Colonialism: A Tentative Appraisal,”International Organization, 1: 37–56. Winter.
49.
JonesD.1991Code of Peace: Ethics and Security in the World of the Warlord States.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
50.
KennedyD.1986“International Refugee Protection,”Human Rights Quarterly, 8: 1–69.
51.
KourulaP.1998Broadening the Edges: Refugee Definition and International Protection Revisited.The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
52.
LandgrenK.1998“The Future of Refugee Protection,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 11(4): 416–432.
53.
Lawyers Committee for Human Rights (LCHR)1991UNHCR at 40: Refugee Protection at the Crossroads.New York: LCHR.
54.
LoescherG.1994“The United Nations, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, and the Global Refugee Problem.” In U.S. Policy and the Future of the United Nations. Ed. CoateR.New York: Twentieth Century Fund.
55.
LoescherG.1989“Introduction: Refugee Issues in International Relations.” In Refugees and International Relations. Ed. LoescherG., and MonahanL.New York: Oxford University Press. Pp. 1–33
56.
LoescherG., and MonahanL., eds. 1989The Question of Refugees and International Relations.New York: Oxford University Press.
57.
MalkkiL.1995“Refugees and Exile: From “Refugee Studies” to the National Order of Things,”Annual Review of Anthropology, 24: 495–523.
58.
MarenM.1997The Road to Hell.New York: Free Press.
59.
McRaeJ.1999“Aiding Peace … and War: UNHCR, Returnee Reintegration, and the Relief-Development Debate,”New Issues in Refugee Research, Working Paper No. 14. Geneva: Center for Documentation and Research, UNHCR.
60.
MSF/Holland1997“Better off in Burma? The Plight of the Burmese Rohingyas.” November.
61.
MSF/Holland1995a “MSF's Concerns on the Repatriation of Rohingyan Refugees from Bangladesh to Burma.” May 1.
62.
MSF/Holland1995b “Awareness Survey of Rohingyan Refugee Camps,” March 15.
63.
MelanderG.1987“The Two Refugee Definitions,” Raoul Wallenberg Institute of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law, Report No. 4, Lund, Sweden.
64.
MertusJ.1998“The State and the Post-Cold War Refugee Regime: New Models, New Questions,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 10(3): 320–347.
65.
MooneyE.1999“In-Country Protection: Out of Bounds for UNHCR?” In Refugee Rights and Realities: Evolving International Concepts and Regimes. Ed. NicholsonF., and TwomeyP.New York: Cambridge University Press. Pp. 200–219
66.
MooreJ.1998Hard Choices: Moral Dilemmas in Humanitarian Intervention.Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
67.
MorrisN.1997“Protection Dilemmas and UNHCR's Response: A Personal View from within UNHCR,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 9(3): 492–499.
68.
MorrisN.1990“Refugees: Facing Crisis in the 1990s – A Personal View from within UNHCR,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 2: 38–57.
69.
NyersP.1999“Emergency or Emerging Identities? Refugees and Transformations in World Order,”Millennium, 28(1): 1–26.
70.
OgataS.1999a “Half a Century on the Humanitarian Frontlines.” Lecture delivered at Graduate Institute for International Studies, Geneva, November 25.
71.
OgataS.1999b “On the Humanitarian Frontlines: New Challenges to Refugee Work.” Lecture delivered at Harvard University, November 8.
72.
OgataS.1996“World Order, Internal Conflict, and Refugees.” Lecture delivered at Harvard University, October 28.
73.
PetrasekD.1999“Through Rose-Coloured Glasses: UNHCR's Role in Monitoring the Safety of the Rohningya Refugees Returning to Burma.” Unpublished paper.
74.
PittermanS.1985“International Responses to Refugee Situations: The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.” In Refugees in World Politics. Ed. FerrisE.Praeger Press. Pp. 43–81.
75.
ReiffD.1997“Charity on the Rampage,”Foreign Affairs, 76(1): 132–139. January/February.
76.
ReismanW. M.1990“Sovereignty and Human Rights in International Law,”American Journal of International Law, 84(4): 866–876.
77.
RoggeJ.1994“Repatriation of Refugees.” In When Refugees Go Home: African Experiences. Ed. AllenT., and MorsinkH.Geneva: UNRISD.
78.
RuggieJ., ed. 1993Multilateralism Matters.New York: Columbia University Press.
79.
SchnyderF.1965“Extracts from Lecturesat the Hagve Academy of International Law.” HCR/RS/32, October 26.
80.
SkranC.1992“The International Refugee Regime: The Historical and Contemporary Context of International Responses to Asylum Problems.” In Refugees: The Asylum Dilemma in the West. Ed. LoescherG.College Station: Pennsylvania State University Press. Pp. 8–34
81.
SteinB.1986“Durable Solutions for Developing Country Refugees,”International Migration Review, 20(2): 264–282.
82.
SteinB., and CunyF.1994“Refugee Repatriation during Conflict: Protection and Post-Return Assistance,”Development in Practice, 4: 1.
83.
SteinB., and CunyF.1993“Repatriation in a Civil War/Conflict Situation.” Paper presented at Roundtable Consultation on Voluntary Repatriation and UNHCR, Geneva, Switzerland. June 2–3.
84.
SteinB., and CunyF.1991“Repatriation Under Conflict,”World Refugee Survey.
85.
SuhrkeA.1998“Burden-Sharing during Refugee Emergencies: The Logic of Collective Versus National Action,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 11(4): 396–415.
86.
SztuckiJ.1989“The Conclusions on the International Protection of Refugees Adopted by the Executive Committee of the UNHCR Programme,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 1(3): 285–318.
87.
TakahashiS.1997The UNHCR Handbook on Voluntary Repatriation: The Emphasis of Return over Protection,”International Journal of Refugee Law, 9(4): 592–612.
88.
UNHCR1995State of the World's Refugees: In Search of Solutions.New York: Oxford University Press.
89.
U.S. Committee for Refugees1996“USCR Site Visit to Bangladesh, June 20-July 1.” Issue Brief.
90.
U.S. Committee for Refugees1995The Return of the Rohingyan Refugees to Burma: Voluntary Repatriation or Refoulement?Washington, DC: U.S. Committee on Refugees.
91.
WarnerD.1994“Voluntary Repatriation and the Meaning of Return to Home: A Critique of Liberal Mathematics,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 7(2/3): 160–174.
92.
WeinerM.1998“The Clash of Norms: Dilemmas in Refugee Policies,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 11(4): 433–453.
93.
WeissT., and PasicA.1996“Reinventing UNHCR: Enterprising Humanitarians in the Former Yugoslavia, 1991–95,”Global Governance, 3: 41–58.
94.
Working Group on International Refugee Policy1999“Report of the International Conference on the Protection Mandate of UNHCR,”Journal of Refugee Studies, 12(2): 202–217.
95.
ZieckM.1997UNHCR and Voluntary Repatriation of Refugees: A Legal Analysis.The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
