AN EVALUATION OF ORDER PICKING POLICIES FOR MAIL ORDER COMPANIES

Abstract

This paper is concerned with the problem of order picking in mail order companies. Order picking is the retrieval of items from their warehouse storage locations to satisfy customer orders. Five order picking policies, strict order, batch, sequential zone, batch zone, and wave, are evaluated using labor requirements, processing time, and customer service as performance measures. A simulation model was developed to investigate these picking policies in a mail order environment. Prior research has focused on the study of individual picking policies. This study extends the prior research by evaluating multiple picking policies under varying operating conditions. The results of the study seem to indicate that (1) wave picking and batch picking perform well across the range of operating conditions considered in this study, and (2) sequential zone and batch zone picking do not perform well, especially as the order volume increases. However, the benefits and drawbacks to each picking policy must be taken into account. The key to effective implementation of an order picking system is to match the firm's business strategy, capabilities, technology, and space requirements with an order picking policy that maximizes the benefits of order picking to the firm and its customers.

Keywords

ORDER PICKING AND FULFILLMENT WAREHOUSING MAIL ORDER SIMULATION

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ackerman

K. B.

(1990), Practical Handbook of Warehousing, VanNorstrand Reinhold, New York.

Armstrong

R. D.

Cook

W. D.

, and Saipe

A. L.

(1979), “Optimal Batching in a Semi‐Automated Order Picking System, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 30, 8, 711–720.

Barrett

B. G.

(1977), “A Further Digression on the Over‐Automated Warehouse: Some Evidence, Interfaces, 8, 1, 46–49.

Bartholdi

J. J.

and Eisenstein

D. D.

(1996), “Call Out the Bucket Brigade,” WERCsheet (A publication of the Warehousing Educational and Research Council).

Bassan

Roll

, and Rosenblatt

M. J.

(1980), “Internal Layout Design of a Warehouse, AIIE Transactions, 12, 4, 317–322.

Ben‐Mahmaud

(1987), The Effect of Warehouse Layout on Order Picking Efficiency, Unpublished M.S. thesis, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR.

Bozer

Y. A.

and Sharp

G. P.

(1985), “An Empirical Evaluation of a General Purpose Automated Order Accumulation and Sortation System used in Batch Picking, Material Flow, 2, 111–131.

Bozer

Y. A.

Quiroz

M. A.

, and Sharp

G. P.

(1988), “An Empirical Evaluation of Alternate Control Strategies for Automated Order Accumulation and Sortation Systems, Material Flow, 4, 265–282.

Coyle

J. J.

Bardi

E. J.

, and Langley

C. J.

(1996), The Management of Business Logistics, West, St. Paul, MN.

10.

Frazelle

E. H.

and Apple

J. M.

(1994), “Warehouse Operations” in The Distribution Management Handbook, Tompkins

J. A.

and Harmelink

D. A.

(eds.), McGraw‐Hill, New York, 22.1–22.36.

11.

Gibson

D. R.

and Sharp

G. P.

(1992), “Order Batching Procedures, European Journal of Operational Research, 58, 57–67.

12.

Gray

A. E.

Karmarkar

U. S.

, and Seidmann

(1992), “Design and Operation of an Order‐Consolidation Warehouse: Models and Application, European Journal of Operational Research, 58, 3–13.

13.

Huffman

J. R.

(1988), “Order‐Picking Systems” in The Warehouse Management Handbook, Tompkins

J. A.

and Smith

J. D.

(eds.), McGraw‐Hill, New York, 595–618.

14.

Johnson

M. E.

(1998), ‘The Impact of Sorting Strategies on Automated Sortation System Performance,’ IIE Transactions, 30, 67–77.

15.

Johnson

M. E.

and Lofgren

(1994), “Model Decomposition Speeds Distribution Center Design, Interfaces, 24, 5, 95–106.

16.

Law

A. M.

and Kelton

W. D.

(1991), Simulation Modeling and Analysis, McGraw‐Hill, New York.

17.

Napolitano

(1995), “Simulation and The Advanced Performance Warehouse,” WERCsheet (A publication of the Warehousing Educational and Research Council).

18.

Petersen

C. G.

(1997), “An Evaluation of Order Picking Routeing Policies, International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 17, 1, 1096–1111.

19.

Petersen

C. G.

and Schmenner

R. W.

(1999), “An Evaluation of Routing and Volume‐Based Storage Policies in an Order Picking Operation, Decision Sciences, 30, 2, 481–501.

20.

Rosenwein

M. B.

(1996), “A Comparison of Heuristics for the Problem of Batching Orders for Warehouse Selection, International Journal of Production Research, 34, 3, 657–664.

21.

Saccomano

(1996), “How to Pick Picking Technologies, Traffic World, 39–40.

22.

Sharp

G. P.

Choe

, and Yoon

C. S.

(1991), “Small Parts Order Picking: Analysis Framework and Selected Results” in Progress in Material Handling and Logistics, White

J. A.

and Pence

I. W.

(eds.), 2, Springer‐Verlag, Berlin, 317–341.

23.

Speaker

R. L.

(1975), “Bulk Order Picking, Industrial Engineering, 7, 12, 14–18.

24.

Yoon

C. S.

and Sharp

G. P.

(1996), “A Structured Procedure for Analysis and Design of Order Pick Systems, IIE Transactions, 28, 379–389.