Effects of Online–Offline Service Integration on e‐Healthcare Providers: A Quasi‐Natural Experiment

Abstract

E‐healthcare platforms start to integrate medical services across online and offline channels, where providers can perform online consultations, schedule patients’ offline visits, synchronize relevant medical records, and finally, answer online inquiries regarding follow‐up and recovery anytime and anywhere within one operations management function (i.e., online–offline service integration). In this study, we seek to quantify the effects of online–offline service integration on the e‐healthcare providers’ demand and reputational outcomes, noting that it is not altogether clear how the service integration function will affect the providers who adopt such a function in e‐healthcare platforms. Leveraging a quasi‐natural experiment on an e‐healthcare platform, we conducted difference‐in‐differences analyses in tandem with a variety of matching strategies, including propensity score matching and look‐ahead propensity score matching. Furthermore, we explored the moderating roles of provider‐specific characteristics. Our results reveal a set of robust and interesting findings: (i) e‐healthcare providers, on average, experience increases in online demand and decreases in offline demand post online–offline service integration; (ii) the service integration function also improves the professional reputation of participating providers; (iii) the impact of channel integration on the outcomes is weaker for providers with lower (vs. higher) professional titles; and (iv) the providers who specialize in treating chronic (vs. acute) diseases experience greater increases in online demand and reputational outcomes, yet insignificant changes in offline demand. This work contributes to related prior literatures on healthcare operations management, e‐healthcare, and online–offline channel integration, offering design implications for the service operations of e‐healthcare platforms.

Keywords

online–offline service integration healthcare operations management e‐healthcare difference‐in‐differences look‐ahead propensity score matching

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agarwal

Gao

DesRoches

Jha

A. K.

. 2010. Research commentary—The digital transformation of healthcare: Current status and the road ahead. Inform. Syst. Res. 21(4): 796–809.

Angrist

J. D.

Pischke

J. S.

. 2008. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist's Companion. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.

Angst

C. M.

Devaraj

Queenan

C. C.

Greenwood

. 2011. Performance effects related to the sequence of integration of healthcare technologies. Prod. Oper. Manag. 20(3): 319–333.

Avery

Steenburgh

T. J.

Deighton

Caravella

. 2012. Adding bricks to clicks: Predicting the patterns of cross‐channel elasticities over time. J. Marketing 76(3): 96–111.

Ayabakan

Bardhan

Zheng

Kirksey

. 2017. The impact of health information sharing on duplicate testing. MIS Quarterly 41(4): 1083–1104.

Johansson

W. C.

. 2008. An exploratory study of the impact of e‐service process on online customer satisfaction. Prod. Oper. Manag. 17(1): 107–119.

Ball

M. J.

Lillis

. 2001. E‐health: Transforming the physician/patient relationship. Int. J. Med. Informatics 61(1): 1–10.

Banerjee

A. V.

1992. A simple model of herd behavior. Q. J. Econ. 107(3): 797–817.

Bapna

Ramaprasad

Umyarov

. 2016. Monetizing freemium communities: Does paying for premium increase social engagement? MIS Quarterly 42(3): 719–735.

10.

Barney

1991. Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. J. Manage. 17(1): 99–120.

11.

Bavafa

Hitt

L. M.

Terwiesch

. 2018. The impact of e‐visits on visit frequencies and patient health: Evidence from primary care. Manage. Sci. 64(12): 5461–5480.

12.

Beck

Rygl

. 2015. Categorization of multiple channel retailing in multi‐, cross‐, and omni‐channel retailing for retailers and retailing. J. Retail. Consum. Serv. 27: 170–178.

13.

Bell

D. R.

Gallino

Moreno

. 2018. Offline showrooms in omnichannel retail: Demand and operational benefits. Management Sci. 64(4): 1629–1651.

14.

Bergmo

T. S.

Kummervold

P. E.

Gammon

Dahl

L. B.

. 2005. Electronic patient–physician communication: Will it offset office visits and telephone consultations in primary care? Int. J. Med. Informatics 74(9): 705–710.

15.

Bernell

Howard

S. W.

. 2016. Use your words carefully: What is a chronic disease? Front. Public Health 4: 159.

16.

Berry

L. L.

Bolton

R. N.

Bridges

C. H.

Meyer

Parasuraman

Seiders

. 2010. Opportunities for innovation in the delivery of interactive retail services. J. Interact. Mark. 24(2): 155–167.

17.

Brandeau

M. L.

Sainfort

Pierskalla

W. P.

. (Eds.). 2004. Operations research and health care: A handbook of methods and applications (Vol. 70). Springer Science+Business Media, Berlin, Germany.

18.

Burke

Kraut

R. E.

. 2014. Growing closer on Facebook: Changes in tie strength through social network site use. In Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (ACM SIGCHI), Toronto, ON, Canada. 4187–4196.

19.

Cao

. 2015. The impact of cross‐channel integration on retailers’ sales growth. J. Retail. 91(2): 198–216.

20.

Cenfetelli

R. T.

Benbasat

Al‐Natour

. 2008. Addressing the what and how of online services: Positioning supporting‐services functionality and service quality for business‐to‐consumer success. Inform. Syst. Res. 19(2): 161–181.

21.

Chang

Y. W.

Hsu

P. Y.

Wang

Chang

P. Y.

. 2019. Integration of online and offline health services: The role of doctor‐patient online interaction. Patient Educ. Couns. 102(10): 1905–1910.

22.

Chen

R. R.

Robinson

L. W.

. 2014. Sequencing and scheduling appointments with potential call‐in patients. Prod. Oper. Manag. 23(9): 1522–1538.

23.

Chung

J. E.

2013. Social interaction in online support groups: Preference for online social interaction over offline social interaction. Comput. Hum. Behav. 29(4): 1408–1414.

24.

Cline

R. J.

Haynes

K. M.

. 2001. Consumer health information seeking on the Internet: The state of the art. Health Educ. Res. 16(6): 671–692.

25.

Dahlöf

2010. Cardiovascular disease risk factors: Epidemiology and risk assessment. Am. J. Cardiol. 105(1): 3A–9A.

26.

Das

Faxvaag

Svanæs

. 2015. The impact of an eHealth portal on health care professionals’ interaction with patients: Qualitative study. J. Med. Internet Res. 17(11): e267.

27.

Detz

López

Sarkar

. 2013. Long‐term doctor‐patient relationships: Patient perspective from online reviews. J. Med. Internet Res. 15(7): e131.

28.

Diamant

Milner

Quereshy

. 2018. Dynamic patient scheduling for multi‐appointment health care programs. Prod. Oper. Manag. 27(1): 58–79.

29.

Dong

Gardner

. 2020. An interactive web‐based dashboard to track COVID‐19 in real time. Lancet. Infect. Dis 20(5): 533–534.

30.

Gallino

Moreno

. 2014. Integration of online and offline channels in retail: The impact of sharing reliable inventory availability information. Management Sci. 60(6): 1434–1451.

31.

Gardner

J. W.

Boyer

K. K.

Gray

J. V.

. 2015. Operational and strategic information processing: Complementing healthcare IT infrastructure. J. Oper. Manag. 33: 123–139.

32.

Geyskens

Gielens

Dekimpe

M. G.

. 2002. The market valuation of Internet channel additions. J. Mark. 66(2): 102–119.

33.

Goh

J. M.

Gao

Agarwal

. 2016. The creation of social value: Can an online health community reduce rural‐urban health disparities? MIS Quarterly 40(1): 247–263.

34.

Griffiths

Lindenmeyer

Powell

Lowe

Thorogood

. 2006. Why are health care interventions delivered over the internet? A systematic review of the published literature. J. Med. Internet Res. 8(2): e10.

35.

Guha

Kumar

. 2018. Emergence of big data research in operations management, information systems, and healthcare: Past contributions and future roadmap. Prod. Oper. Manag. 27(9): 1724–1735.

36.

Guo

Fang

Vogel

. 2017. How doctors gain social and economic returns in online health‐care communities: A professional capital perspective. J. Manage. Inform. Syst. 34(2): 487–519.

37.

Gupta

Koulamas

Kyparisis

G. J.

. 2009. E‐business: A review of research published in production and operations management (1992–2008). Prod. Oper. Manag. 18(6): 604–620.

38.

Helm

J. E.

Alaeddini

Stauffer

J. M.

Bretthauer

K. M.

Skolarus

T. A.

. 2016. Reducing hospital readmissions by integrating empirical prediction with resource optimization. Prod. Oper. Manag. 25(2): 233–257.

39.

Hewitt‐Taylor

Bond

C. S.

. 2012. What e‐patients want from the doctor‐patient relationship: Content analysis of posts on discussion boards. J. Med. Internet Res. 14(6): e155.

40.

Homburg

Vollmayr

Hahn

. 2014. Firm value creation through major channel expansions: Evidence from an event study in the United States, Germany, and China. J. Mark. 78(3): 38–61.

41.

Hong

Pavlou

P. A.

. 2014. Product fit uncertainty in online markets: Nature, effects, and antecedents. Inform. Syst. Res. 25(2): 328–344.

42.

Bell

R. A.

Kravitz

R. L.

Orrange

. 2012. The prepared patient: Information seeking of online support group members before their medical appointments. J. Health Commun. 17(8): 960–978.

43.

Huang

Hong

Burtch

. 2017. Social network integration and user content generation: Evidence from natural experiments. MIS Quarterly 41(4): 1035–1058.

44.

Ishfaq

Defee

C. C.

Gibson

B. J.

Raja

. 2016. Realignment of the physical distribution process in omni‐channel fulfillment. Int. J. Phys. Distr. Logist. Manag. 46(6): 543–561.

45.

Janakiraman

Park

Demirezen

Kumar

2017. The effects of health information exchange access on healthcare quality and efficiency: An empirical investigation. Available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2915190 (accessed date Dec 2, 2020).

46.

Kagashe

Yan

Suheryani

. 2017. Enhancing seasonal influenza surveillance: Topic analysis of widely used medicinal drugs using Twitter data. J. Med. Internet Res. 19(9): e315.

47.

Khurana

Qiu

Kumar

. 2019. When a doctor knows, it shows: An empirical analysis of doctors’ responses in a Q&A Forum of an online healthcare portal. Inform. Syst. Res. 30(3): 872–891.

48.

Kim

S. M.

J. Y.

. 2011. Health information acquisition online and its influence on intention to visit a medical institution offline. Inform. Res. 16(4): 16–24.

49.

Kohli

Tan

S.‐S.‐L.

. 2016. Electronic health records: How can IS researchers contribute to transforming healthcare? MIS Quarterly 40(3): 553–573.

50.

Kollmann

Kuckertz

Kayser

. 2012. Cannibalization or synergy? Consumers' channel selection in online–offline multichannel systems. J. Retail. Consum. Serv. 19(2): 186–194.

51.

Kuang

Huang

Hong

Yan

. 2019. Spillover effects of financial incentives on non‐incentivized user engagement: Evidence from an online knowledge exchange platform. J. Manage. Inform. Syst. 36(1): 289–320.

52.

Kulp

S. C.

Lee

H. L.

Ofek

. 2004. Manufacturer benefits from information integration with retail customers. Management Sci. 50(4): 431–444.

53.

Kumar

Mehra

Kumar

. 2019. Why do stores drive online sales? Evidence of underlying mechanisms from a multichannel retailer. Inform. Syst. Res. 30(1): 319–338.

54.

Kumar

Qiu

Kumar

. 2018b. Exit, voice, and response on digital platforms: An empirical investigation of online management response strategies. Inform. Syst. Res. 29(4): 849–870.

55.

Kumar

Mookerjee

Shubham

. 2018a. Research in operations management and information systems interface. Prod. Oper. Manag. 27(11): 1893–1905.

56.

Lechner

2011. The estimation of causal effects by difference‐in‐difference methods. Found. Trends Econ. 4(3): 165–224.

57.

Benton

W. C.

. 2006. Hospital technology and nurse staffing management decisions. J. Oper. Manag. 24(5): 676–691.

58.

Liu

2016. Optimal choice for appointment scheduling window under patient no‐show behavior. Prod. Oper. Manag. 25(1): 128–142.

59.

Liu

Guo

Vogel

2014. Doctor's effort influence on online reputation and popularity. Zheng

Zeng

Chen

Zhang

Xing

Neill

D. B.

(eds). International Conference for Smart Health (ICSH) 2014, Springer‐Verlag, Berlin, Berlin, 111–126.

60.

Liu

Guo

. 2016. The impact of individual and organizational reputation on physicians’ appointments online. Int. J. Electron. Commer. 20(4): 551–577.

61.

Liu

Helm

J. E.

Lavieri

M. S.

Skolarus

T. A.

. 2018. Missed opportunities in preventing hospital readmissions: Redesigning post‐discharge checkup policies. Prod. Oper. Manag. 27(12): 2226–2250.

62.

Lorig

K. R.

Sobel

D. S.

Stewart

A. L.

Brown

B. W.

Bandura

Ritter

Gonzalez

V. M.

Laurent

D. D.

Holman

H. R.

. 1999. Evidence suggesting that a chronic disease self‐management program can improve health status while reducing hospitalization: A randomized trial. Med. Care 37(1): 5–14.

63.

Maloney‐Krichmar

Preece

. 2005. A multilevel analysis of sociability, usability, and community dynamics in an online health community. ACM Trans. Comput.‐Hum. Interact. (TOCHI) 12(2): 201–232.

64.

Marshall

Vasilakis

El‐Darzi

. 2005. Length of stay‐based patient flow models: Recent developments and future directions. Health Care Manage. Sci. 8(3): 213–220.

65.

Mehra

Kumar

Raju

J. S.

. 2018. Competitive strategies for brick‐and‐mortar stores to counter “showrooming”. Management Sci. 64(7): 3076–3090.

66.

Nault

B. R.

Rahman

M. S.

. 2019. Proximity to a traditional physical store: The effects of mitigating online disutility costs. Prod. Oper. Manag. 28(4): 1033–1051.

67.

Norris

S. L.

Glasgow

R. E.

Engelgau

M. M.

Os'Connor

P. J.

McCulloch

. 2003. Chronic disease management. Dis. Manage. Health Outcomes 11(8): 477–488.

68.

2012. The characteristics and motivations of health answerers for sharing information, knowledge, and experiences in online environments. J. Am. Soc. Inform. Sci. Technol. 63(3): 543–557.

69.

Osadchiy

. 2017. Are patients patient? The role of time to appointment in patient flow. Prod. Oper. Manag. 26(3): 469–490.

70.

Proserpio

Zervas

. 2017. Online reputation management: Estimating the impact of management responses on consumer reviews. Mark. Sci. 36(5): 645–665.

71.

Qian

Guo

Lindsey

. 2017. Comparison of subsidy schemes for reducing waiting times in healthcare systems. Prod. Oper. Manag. 26(11): 2033–2049.

72.

Safadi

Faraj

. 2011. IT in healthcare: an integrative study of organizational change. In AMCIS Proceedings. Link: http://aisel.aisnet.org/amcis2011_submissions/21 (accessed date Jan 19, 2021).

73.

Santana

Lausen

Bujnowska‐Fedak

Chronaki

Kummervold

P. E.

Rasmussen

Sorensen

. 2010. Online communication between doctors and patients in Europe: Status and perspectives. J. Med. Internet Res. 12(2): e20.

74.

Segars

A. H.

Grover

. 1993. Re‐examining perceived ease of use and usefulness: A confirmatory factor analysis. MIS Quarterly 17(4): 517–525.

75.

Stone

Hobbs

Khaleeli

. 2002. Multichannel customer management: The benefits and challenges. J. Database Mark. Cust. Strategy Manag. 10(1): 39–52.

76.

Sun

Zhu

. 2011. Ad revenue and content commercialization: Evidence from blogs. Management Sci. 59(10): 2314–2331.

77.

Teece

D. J.

Pisano

Shuen

. 1997. Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strateg. Manage. J. 18(7): 509–533.

78.

Tian

Vakharia

A. J.

Tan

. 2018. Marketplace, reseller, or hybrid: Strategic analysis of an emerging E‐commerce model. Prod. Oper. Manag. 27(8): 1595–1610.

79.

Tice

J. A.

Miglioretti

D. L.

C. S.

Vachon

C. M.

Gard

C. C.

Kerlikowske

. 2015. Breast density and benign breast disease: Risk assessment to identify women at high risk of breast cancer. J. Clin. Oncol. 33(28): 3137.

80.

Tieu

Sarkar

Schillinger

Ralston

J. D.

Ratanawongsa

Pasick

Lyles

C. R.

. 2015. Barriers and facilitators to online portal use among patients and caregivers in a safety net health care system: A qualitative study. J. Med. Internet Res. 17(12): e275.

81.

Venkatesh

2000. Determinants of perceived ease of use: Integrating control, intrinsic motivation, and emotion into the technology acceptance model. Inform Syst. Res. 11(4): 342–365.

82.

Venkatesh

Zhang

Sykes

T. A.

. 2011. Doctors do too little technology: A longitudinal field study of an electronic healthcare system implementation. Inform. Syst. Res. 22(3): 523–546.

83.

Wagner

E. H.

1998. Chronic disease management: What will it take to improve care for chronic illness? Eff. Clin. Pract. 1(1): 2.

84.

Wang

Yan

Zhou

Guo

Heim

G. R.

. 2020. Understanding physicians’ online‐offline behavior dynamics: An empirical study. Inform. Syst. Res. 31(2): 537–555.

85.

Weiner

J. P.

Yeh

Blumenthal

. 2013. The impact of health information technology and E‐health on the future demand for physician services. Health Aff. 32(11): 1998–2004.

86.

Willis

Royne

M. B.

. 2017. Online health communities and chronic disease self‐management. Health Commun. 32(3): 269–278.

87.

Van Woensel

Roy

P. C.

Abidi

S. R.

Abidi

S. S. R.

. 2015. A mobile and intelligent patient diary for chronic disease self‐management. In MedInfo, 118–122.

88.

. 2017. Online written consultation, telephone consultation and offline appointment: An examination of the channel effect in online health communities. Int. J. Med. Inform. 107: 107–119.

89.

Xiang

Stanley

S. J.

. 2017. From online to offline: Exploring the role of e‐health consumption, patient involvement, and patient‐centered communication on perceptions of health care quality. Comput. Hum. Behav. 70: 446–452.

90.

Chan

Ghose

Han

S. P.

. 2016. Battle of the channels: The impact of tablets on digital commerce. Management Sci. 63(5): 1469–1492.

91.

Yan

Tan

. 2014. Feeling blue? go online: An empirical study of social support among patients. Information Systems Research 25(4): 690–709.

92.

Yan

Tan

Sun

S. X.

. 2019. Shared minds: How patients use collaborative information sharing via social media platforms. Prod. Oper. Manag. 28(1): 9–26.

93.

Yan

Wang

Chen

Zhang

. 2016. Knowledge sharing in online health communities: A social exchange theory perspective. Inform. Manag. 53(5): 643–653.

94.

Yaraghi

A. Y.

Sharman

Gopal

R. D.

Ramesh

. 2014. Health information exchange as a multisided platform: Adoption, usage, and practice involvement in service co‐production. Inform. Syst. Res. 26(1): 1–18.

95.

Mei

Q. Y.

Wang

Q. H.

2016. From offline to online: How health insurance policies drive the demand for online healthcare service? In Proceedings of the 20th Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems (PACIS) Chaiyi, Taiwan, June 27‐July 1. 1–13

96.

Zhang

2010. The sound of silence: Observational learning in the US kidney market. Mark. Sci. 29(2): 315–335.