Impact of universal healthcare on patient choice and quality of care

Abstract

This paper examines the role of universal healthcare on patient choice and quality of care. Lack of health insurance is a leading contributor to emergency department (ED) visits from the uninsured. Using a natural experiment from Massachusetts, we follow previously uninsured individuals over time—both before and after the implementation of universal healthcare—to study the effects of insurance availability on their healthcare seeking behavior. We find that the availability of health insurance has a significant impact on the type of healthcare sought by the previously uninsured. Specifically, individuals are less likely to continue visiting the ED and instead more likely to choose hospital inpatient and outpatient services. We find that frequent fliers and patients with chronic conditions, who are both known to account for a substantial share of healthcare costs, exhibit heterogeneity in this behavior. Finally, we examine the effect of the policy on quality of care, as measured by short‐term ED revisits. Although the overall revisit rates remain unchanged, frequent ED users and chronic patients experience a decline in short‐term ED revisits. With key features of the Affordable Care Act being frequently criticized for repeal, understanding how these changes influence patient choice and quality of care is significantly policy relevant.

Keywords

emergency department hospitals patient choice quality of care universal healthcare

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

E. W.

Sullivan

M. W.

(1993). The antecedents and consequences of customer satisfaction for firms. Marketing Science, 12(2), 125–143.

Ang

Kwasnick

Bayati

Plambeck

E. L.

Aratow

(2015). Accurate emergency department wait time prediction. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 18(1), 141–156.

Angrist

Pischke

J.‐S.

(2009). Mostly harmless econometrics. Princeton University.

Antwi

Y. A.

Moriya

A. S.

Simon

Sommers

B. D.

(2015). Changes in emergency department use among young adults after the patient protection and Affordable Care Act's dependent coverage provision. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 65(6), 664–672.

Batt

R. J.

Terwiesch

(2015). Waiting patiently: An empirical study of queue abandonment in an emergency department. Management Science, 61(1), 39–59.

Bawa

(1990). Modeling inertia and variety seeking tendencies in brand choice behavior. Marketing Science, 9(3), 263–278.

Billings

Parikh

Mijanovich

(2000). Emergency department use in New York City: A substitute for primary care? Issue Brief (Commonwealth Fund), (433), 1–5.

Blundell

Browning

Meghir

(1994). Consumer demand and the life‐cycle allocation of household expenditures. The Review of Economic Studies, 61(1), 57–80.

Bodenheimer

Wagner

E. H.

Grumbach

(2002). Improving primary care for patients with chronic illness: The chronic care model, part 2. JAMA, 288(15), 1909–1914.

10.

Bolton

R. N.

(1998). A dynamic model of the duration of the customer's relationship with a continuous service provider: The role of satisfaction. Marketing Science, 17(1), 45–65.

11.

Card

Dobkin

Maestas

(2008). The impact of nearly universal insurance coverage on health care utilization: Evidence from Medicare. American Economic Review, 98(5), 2242–2258.

12.

Charlson

M. E.

Pompei

Ales

K. L.

MacKenzie

C. R.

(1987). A new method of classifying prognostic comorbidity in longitudinal studies: development and validation. Journal of chronic diseases, 40(5), 373–383.

13.

Chen

Scheffler

Chandra

(2011). Perspective: Massachusetts' health care reform and emergency department utilization. New England Journal of Medicine, 365, e25.

14.

Chintagunta

P. K.

(1998). Inertia and variety seeking in a model of brand‐purchase timing. Marketing Science, 17(3), 253–270.

15.

Coleman

Austin

B. T.

Brach

Wagner

E. H.

(2009). Evidence on the chronic care model in the new millennium. Health Affairs, 28(1), 75–85.

16.

Currie

Gruber

(1996). Health insurance eligibility, utilization of medical care, and child health. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 111(2), 431–466.

17.

Dresden

S. M.

Powell

E. S.

Kang

McHugh

Cooper

A. J.

Feinglass

(2017). Increased emergency department use in Illinois after implementation of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 69(2), 172–180.

18.

Felt‐Lisk

, Mc Hugh

Howell

(2002). Monitoring local safety‐net providers: Do they have adequate capacity? Health Affairs, 21(5), 277–283.

19.

Finkelstein

A. N.

Taubman

S. L.

Allen

H. L.

Wright

B. J.

Baicker

(2016). Effect of Medicaid coverage on ED use—Further evidence from Oregon's experiment. New England Journal of Medicine, 375(16), 1505–1507.

20.

Fuda

K. K.

Immekus

(2006). Frequent users of Massachusetts emergency departments: A statewide analysis. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 48(1), 16–e1.

21.

Gans

(2002). Customer loyalty and supplier quality competition. Management Science, 48(2), 207–221.

22.

Gaynor

Propper

Seiler

(2016). Free to choose? Reform, choice, and consideration sets in the English National Health Service. American Economic Review, 106(11), 3521–57.

23.

Ghosh

Simon

(2015). The effect of Medicaid on adult hospitalizations: Evidence from Tennessee's Medicaid contraction. [Technical report], National Bureau of Economic Research.

24.

Goldfarb

Tucker

C. E.

(2011). Privacy regulation and online advertising. Management Science, 57(1), 57–71.

25.

Gotanda

Kominski

Tsugawa

(2019). Association between the ACA Medicaid expansions and primary care and emergency department use during the first 3 years. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 35(3), 711–718.

26.

Green

L. V.

(2012). Om forum: The vital role of operations analysis in improving healthcare delivery. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 14(4), 488–494.

27.

Heckman

(1974). Life cycle consumption and labor supply: An explanation of the relationship between income and consumption over the life cycle. The American Economic Review, 64(1), 188–194.

28.

Hoffman

Rice

Sung

H.‐Y.

(1996). Persons with chronic conditions: Their prevalence and costs. JAMA, 276(18), 1473–1479.

29.

Hunt

K. A.

Weber

E. J.

Showstack

J. A.

Colby

D. C.

Callaham

M. L.

(2006). Characteristics of frequent users of emergency departments. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 48(1), 1–8.

30.

Institute of Medicine (2006). Hospital‐based emergency care: At the breaking point. [Technical report], Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

31.

Jeuland

A. P.

(1979). Brand choice inertia as one aspect of the notion of brand loyalty. Management Science, 25(7), 671–682.

32.

Joy

Clement

Sisti

(2016). The ethics of behavioral health information technology: Frequent flyer icons and implicit bias. JAMA, 316(15), 1539–1540.

33.

D. S.

(2013). Does multitasking improve performance? Evidence from the emergency department. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 16(2), 168–183.

34.

Kellermann

A. L.

(2006). Crisis in the emergency department. New England Journal of Medicine, 355(13), 1300–1303.

35.

Kim

H.‐W.

Kankanhalli

(2009). Investigating user resistance to information systems implementation: A status quo bias perspective. MIS Quarterly, 33(3), 567–582.

36.

Klein

E. Y.

Levin

Toerper

M. F.

Makowsky

M. D.

Cole

Kelen

G. D.

(2017). The effect of Medicaid expansion on utilization in Maryland emergency departments. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 70(5), 607–614.

37.

Kolstad

J. T.

Kowalski

A. E.

(2012). The impact of health care reform on hospital and preventive care: Evidence from Massachusetts. Journal of Public Economics, 96(11), 909–929.

38.

LaCalle

Rabin

(2010). Frequent users of emergency departments: The myths, the data, and the policy implications. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 56(1), 42–48.

39.

Lemon

K. N.

White

T. B.

Winer

R. S.

(2002). Dynamic customer relationship management: Incorporating future considerations into the service retention decision. Journal of Marketing, 66(1), 1–14.

40.

Long

S. K.

Masi

P. B.

(2009). Access and affordability: An update on health reform in Massachusetts, fall 2008: Access, affordability, and coverage have improved since 2006, but rising health costs have eroded some gains in affordability of care. Health Affairs, 28(Suppl1), w578–w587.

41.

Musalem

Olivares

Schilkrut

(2013). Measuring the effect of queues on customer purchases. Management Science, 59(8), 1743–1763.

42.

Maister

D. H.

(1984). The psychology of waiting lines. Harvard Business School.

43.

Miller

(2012). The effect of insurance on emergency room visits: An analysis of the 2006 Massachusetts health reform. Journal of Public Economics, 96(11), 893–908.

44.

Nikpay

Freedman

Levy

Buchmueller

(2017). Effect of the Affordable Care Act Medicaid expansion on emergency department visits: Evidence from state‐level emergency department databases. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 70(2), 215–225.

45.

Png

I. P.

Reitman

(1994). Service time competition. The Rand Journal of Economics, 25(4), 619–634.

46.

Polites

G. L.

Karahanna

(2012). Shackled to the status quo: The inhibiting effects of incumbent system habit, switching costs, and inertia on new system acceptance. MIS Quarterly, 36(1), 21–42.

47.

Rust

R. T.

Zahorik

A. J.

Keiningham

T. L.

(1995). Return on quality (ROQ): Making service quality financially accountable. The Journal of Marketing, 59(2), 58–70.

48.

Seetharaman

Chintagunta

(1998). A model of inertia and variety‐seeking with marketing variables. International Journal of Research in Marketing, 15(1), 1–17.

49.

Smulowitz

P. B.

O'Malley

Yang

Landon

B. E.

(2014). Increased use of the emergency department after health care reform in Massachusetts. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 64(2), 107–115.

50.

Sommers

B. D.

Blendon

R. J.

Orav

E. J.

Epstein

A. M.

(2016). Changes in utilization and health among low‐income adults after medicaid expansion or expanded private insurance. JAMA Internal Medicine, 176(10), 1501–1509.

51.

Song

Tucker

A. L.

Murrell

K. L.

(2015). The diseconomies of queue pooling: An empirical investigation of emergency department length of stay. Management Science, 61(12), 3032–3053.

52.

Zenios

(2004). Patient choice in kidney allocation: The role of the queueing discipline. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 6(4), 280–301.

53.

Uscher‐Pines

Pines

Kellermann

Gillen

Mehrotra

(2013). Deciding to visit the emergency department for non‐urgent conditions: A systematic review of the literature. The American Journal of Managed Care, 19(1), 47.

54.

Werner

R. M.

Canamucio

Marcus

S. C.

Terwiesch

(2014). Primary care access and emergency room use among older veterans. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 29(2), 689–694.

55.

Woolhandler

Campbell

Himmelstein

D. U.

(2003). Costs of health care administration in the United States and Canada. New England Journal of Medicine, 349(8), 768–775.

56.

Chan

C. W.

(2016). Using future information to reduce waiting times in the emergency department via diversion. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 18(3), 314–331.