What Happens to Potential Discouraged? Masculinity Norms and the Contrasting Institutional and Labor Market Experiences of Less Affluent Black and White Men
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online January, 2007
What Happens to Potential Discouraged? Masculinity Norms and the Contrasting Institutional and Labor Market Experiences of Less Affluent Black and White Men
Though less affluent black and white boys and men adhere to similar gendered norms and aspirations and begin with similar labor market potential, they are often sorted into very different and unequal educational and labor market trajectories. Using national-level descriptive data and key qualitative studies of institutional processes, this article contrasts less affluent black and white men’s educational, labor market, and criminal justice system experiences and elucidates the processes of differentiation that reproduce those unequal patterns. In each institutional arena, less affluent black males pay a disproportionate price for enacting masculinity norms in comparison to white males. White boys and men are also presented with more desirable labor market options (and second-chance opportunities when they need help) that are denied their black male counterparts. This article suggests that only a complex strategy, which requires less affluent black men to resist more constructively while citizen groups hold institutions more publicly accountable, can enhance the labor market trajectories of black men.
Ainsworth, J. W. , and V. J. Roscigno . 2005. Stratification, school-work linkages and vocational education . Social Forces84 (1): 257-284 .
2.
Albertson, B. , and M. Harris-Lacewell . 2005. Good times? Understanding African American misperceptions of racial economic fortunes . Journal of Black Studies35 (5): 650-683 .
3.
Allard, P. , and M. Mauer . 2000. Regaining the vote: An assessment of activity relating to felon disenfranchisement laws. January. The Sentencing Project. www.sentencingproject.org.
4.
Alperstein, J. F.2005. Commentary on girls, boys, test scores and more. Teachers College Record, May 16. http:/www.tcrecord.org, ID number: 11874 (accessed October 10, 2006).
5.
Anderson, E.1990. Streetwise: Race, class, change in an urban community. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
6.
Anyon, J.2005. Radical possibilities: Public policy, urban education, and a new social movement. New York: Routledge .
7.
Barlow, A. L.2005. Globalization, racism, and the expansion of the American penal system. In African Americans in the U.S. economy, ed. C. A. Conrad , J. Whitehead , P. Mason , and J. Stewart , 223-231. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
8.
Barnett, R. C. , and C. Rivers . 2006. “Boy” crisis in education is nothing but hype. Women's eNews, March 15. http://www.womensenews.org/article.cfm/dyn/aid/2671 (accessed October 2, 2006).
9.
Blauner, R.1969. Internal colonialism and ghetto revolt . Social Problems16 (2): 393-408 .
10.
Blauner, R.1972. Racial oppression in America. New York: Harper & Row .
11.
Bobo, L. D. , and M. P. Massagli . 2001. Stereotyping and urban inequality. In Urban inequality: Evidence from four cities, ed. A. O'Connor , C. Tilly , and L. Bobo , 89-162. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
12.
Bound, J. , and R. Freeman . 1992. What went wrong? The erosion of the relative earnings and employment of young black men in the 1980s . Quarterly Journal of Economics107 (1): 201-232 .
13.
Braddock, J. H. , and J. McPartland . 1987. How minorities continue to be excluded from equal employment opportunities: Research on labor market and institutional opportunities . Journal of Social Issues43 (1): 5-39 .
14.
Bridges, G. S. , and S. Steen . 1998. Racial disparities in official assessments of juvenile offenders: Attributional stereotypes as mediating mechanis . American Sociological Review63 (4): 554-570 .
15.
Brodkin, K.2000. How Jews became white folks: And what that says about race in America. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press .
16.
Brooks, D.2006. The gender gap in schools. New York Times, May 23.
17.
Cain, G.1986. The economic analysis of labor market discrimination: A survey. In Handbook of labor economics, vol. 1, ed. O. Aschenfelter and R. Layard . Amsterdam: Elsevier Press .
18.
Carter, P. L.2005. Keepin' it real: School success beyond black and white. New York: Oxford University Press .
19.
Chandra, A.2000. Labor-market dropouts and the racial wage gap: 1940-1990 . American Economic Review90 (2): 333-338 .
20.
Cherry, R.2001. Who gets the good jobs? Combating race and gender disparities. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press .
21.
Cole, J. B. , and B. Guy-Sheftall . 2003. Gender talk: The struggle for women's equality in African American communities. New York: Ballantine .
22.
Comer, J. P. , N. M. Haynes , E. T. Joyner , and M. Ben-Avie . 1996. Rallying the whole village: The Comer process for reforming education. New York: Teachers College Press .
23.
Conley, D.1999. Being black, living in the red: Race, wealth, and social policy in America. Berkeley: University of California Press .
24.
Conlin, M.2003. The new gender gap. Business Week Online, May 23. http://businessweek.com/magazine/content/03_21/b3834001_mz001.htm (accessed October 2, 2006).
25.
Connell, R. W.1995. Masculinities. Berkeley: University of California Press .
26.
Cross, W. E. , and P. Fhagen-Smith . 2001. Patterns of African American identity development: A life span perspective. In New perspective on racial identity development: A theoretical and practical anthology, ed. C. L. Wijeyesinghe and B. W. Jackson III. New York: New York University Press .
27.
Delpit, L.1988. The silenced dialogue: Power and pedagogy in educating other people's children . Harvard Educational Review68 (3): 280-298 .
28.
Donaldson, M.1993. What is hegemonic masculinity?Theory and Society22 (5): 643-657 .
29.
Duster, T.1995. Postindustrialization and youth unemployment: African Americans as a harbingers. In Poverty, inequality, and the future of social policy: Western states in the new world order, ed. K. McFate , R. Lawson , and W. J. Wilson , 461-488. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
30.
Dyson, M. E.2005. Is Bill Cosby right? Or has the black middle class lost its mind?New York: Basic Books .
31.
England, P. , K. Christopher , and L. L. Reid . 1999. Gender, race, ethnicity, and wages. In Latinas and African American women at work, ed. I. Browne . New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
32.
Falcon, L. M. , and E. Melendez . 2001. Racial and ethnic differences in job searching in urban centers. In Urban inequality: Evidence from four cities, ed. A. O'Connor , C. Tilly , and L. Bobo , 341-371. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
33.
Farkas, G. , and K. Vicknair . 1996. Appropriate tests of racial wage discrimination require controls for cognitive skill: Comment on Cancio, Evans, and Maume . American Sociological Review61: 557-560 .
34.
Ferguson, A. A.2000. Bad boys: Public schools in the making of black masculinity. Ann Arbor: Michigan University Press .
35.
Fine, M. , and L. Weiss . 1998. The unknown city: Lives of poor and working-class young adults. Boston: Beacon .
36.
Fordham, S. , and J. Ogbu . 1986. Black students' school success: Coping with the burden of acting white . Urban Review18 (3): 176-206 .
37.
Freeman, R.1991. Employment and earnings of disadvantaged young men in a labor shortage economy. In The urban underclass, ed. C. Jencks and P. Peterson . Washington, DC: Brookings Institution .
38.
Freeman, R. B. , and D. A. Wise . 1982. The youth labor market problem: Its nature, causes and consequences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
39.
Glasgow, D.1980. The black underclass: poverty, unemployment, and entrapment of ghetto youth. New York: Vintage .
40.
Greene, J. P. , and M. A. Winters . 2006. Public school graduation rates in the United States. Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, Civic Report no. 31. http:/www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_31.htm (accessed October 2, 2006).
41.
Guglielmo, T. A.2003. Rethinking whiteness historiography: The case of Italians in Chicago, 1890-1945. In White out: The continuing significance of racism, ed. A. W. Doane and E. Bonilla-Silva , 49-62. New York: Routledge .
42.
Guinier, L. , and G. Torres . 2002. The miner's canary: Enlisting race, resisting power, transforming democracy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
43.
Gurian, M. , and K. Stevens . 2005. What is happening with boys in school?Teachers College Record, May 2. http://wwwtcrecord.org, ID number: 11854 (accessed October 2, 2006).
44.
Hale, J. E.2001. Learning while black: Creating educational excellence for African American children. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press .
45.
Hamilton, D.2006. The racial composition of American jobs. In The state of black America 2006. New York: National Urban League .
46.
Hawkins, D.1996. Gender gap: Black females outpace male counterparts at three degree levels . Black Issues in Higher Education13: 20-22 .
47.
Holzer, H. J.1996. What employers want: Job prospects for less educated workers. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
48.
Holzer, H. , and S. Danziger . 2001. Are jobs available for disadvantaged workers in urban areas? In Urban inequality: Evidence from four cities, ed. A. O'Connor , C. Tilly , and L. Bobo . New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
49.
Holzer, H. J. , and K. R. Ihlanfelt . 1998. Customer discrimination and employment outcomes for minority workers . Quarterly Journal of Economics133 (3): 835-867 .
50.
Holzer, H. J. , P. Offner , and E. Sorenson . 2005. What explains the continuing decline in labor force activity among young black men?Labor History46 (1): 37-55 .
51.
Holzer, H. J. , S. Raphael , and M. A. Stoll . 2004. Will employers hire former offenders? Employer preferences, background checks, and their determinants. In Imprisoning America: The social effects of mass incarceration, ed. M. Pattillo , D. Weiman , and B. Western , 205-246. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
52.
Holzman, M.2006. Public education and black male students: The 2006 state report card. Schott Educational Equity Index. Cambridge, MA: The Schott Foundation for Public Education .
53.
Hughes, L.1951. Montage of a dream deferred. New York: Henry Holt .
54.
Hull, J.1994. Do teachers punish according to race?Time, April 4, pp. 30-31.
55.
Jencks, C. , and M. Phillips . 1998. The black-white test score gap. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press .
56.
Johnston, R. C. , and D. Viadero . 2000. Unmet promise: Raising minority achievement. Education Week, March 15, pp. 18-21.
57.
Kelly, R. D. G.1994. Race rebels: Culture, politics, and the black working class. New York: Free Press .
58.
Kerner Commission . 1968. Report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office .
59.
Klinkner, P. A. , and R. M. Smith . 1999. The unsteady march: The rise and decline of racial equality in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
60.
Kunjufu, J.1986. Motivating and preparing black youth for success. Chicago: African American Images .
61.
Lamont, M.2000. The dignity of working men: Morality and the boundaries of race, class, and immigration. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
62.
Legal Action Center . 2004. After prison: Roadblocks to reentry: A report on state legal barriers facing people with criminal records. A Report by the Legal Action Center. http://www.lac.org/lac/upload/lacreport/LAC_PrintReport.pdf.
63.
Lewin, T.1998. American colleges begin to ask, where have all the men gone?New York Times, December 6, p. A1-A1.
64.
Lopez, N.2003. Hopeful girls, troubled boys: Race and gender disparity in urban education. New York: Routledge .
65.
MacLeod, J.1995. Ain't no makin’ it: Leveled aspirations and attainment in a low income neighborhood. San Francisco: Westview .
66.
Mac an Ghaill, M.1994. The making of men: Masculinities, sexualities, and schooling. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press .
67.
Majors, R. , and J. M. Billson . 1992. Cool pose: The dilemmas of black manhood in America. New York: Lexington Books .
68.
Manza, J. , and C. Uggen . 2006. Locked out: Felony disenfranchisement and American democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
69.
Martino, W.2000. Mucking around in class, giving crap, and acting cool: Adolescent boys enacting masculinities at school . Canadian Journal of Education25 (2): 102-112 .
70.
Mason, P.2004. Understanding recent empirical evidence on race and labor market outcomes in the USA . Review of Social Economy58 (3): 319-338 .
71.
Mason, P.2005. Persistent racial discrimination in the labor market. In African Americans in the U.S. economy, ed. C. A. Conrad , J. Whitehead , P. Mason , and J. Stewart , 141-150. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
72.
Mauer, M.1997. Intended and unintended consequences: State racial disparities in imprisonment. The Sentencing Project. www.sentencingproject.org.
73.
McElroy, S. W.2005. Race and gender differences in the U.S. labor market: The impact of education attainment. In African Americans in the U.S. economy, ed. C. A. Conrad , J. Whitehead , P. Mason , and J. Stewart , 133-140. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
74.
Miller, J.1997. Search and destroy: African American males in the criminal justice system. New York: Cambridge University Press .
75.
Mills, M. , and B. Lingard . 1997. Masculinity politics, myths, and boys' schooling: A review essay . British Journal of Educational Studies45 (3): 276-292 .
76.
Mincy, R.1994. Nurturing young black males: Challenges to agencies, programs, and social policy. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press .
77.
Minnesota Department of Children, Families and Learning . 1996. Student suspension and expulsion: Report to the legislature. St. Paul: Minnesota Department of Children, Families and Learning .
78.
Mirza, H. S.1999. Review: Black masculinities and schools: A black feminist response . British Journal of Sociology of Education20 (1): 137-147 .
79.
Morrell, R.1998. Of boys and men: Masculinity and gender in Southern African studies . Journal of Southern African Studies24 (4): 605-630 .
80.
Morris, A. D.1984. The origins of the civil rights movement: Black communities organizing for change. New York: Free Press .
81.
Moss, P. , and C. Tilly . 1991. Why black men are doing worse in the labor market: A review of supply-side and demand-side explanations. Working Paper, Social Science Research Council, New York .
82.
Moss, P. , and C. Tilly . 1996. Soft skills and race: An investigation of black men's employment problems . Work & Occupations23 (3): 252-276 .
83.
Moss, P. , and C. Tilly . 2001a. Stories employers tell: Race, skill, and hiring in America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
84.
Moss, P. , and C. Tilly . 2001b. Why opportunity isn't knocking: Racial inequality and the demand for labor. In Urban inequality: Evidence from four cities, ed. A. O'Connor , C. Tilly , and L. Bobo , 444-495. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
85.
Oliver, M. L. , and T. M. Shapiro . 1997. Black wealth, white wealth: A new perspective on racial inequality. New York: Routledge .
86.
Newman, K.1999. No shame in my game: The working poor in the inner city. New York: Vintage .
87.
Pager, D.2003. The mark of a criminal record . American Journal of Sociology108: 937-975 .
88.
Pager, D. , and L. Quillian . 2005. Walking the talk? What employers say versus what they do . American Sociological Review70 (3): 355-380 .
89.
Pattillo, M. , D. Weiman , and B. Western , eds. 2004. Imprisoning America: The social effects of mass incarceration. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
90.
Patterson, O.1999. Rituals of blood: Consequences of slavery in two American centuries. Washington, DC: Counterpoint/Civitas .
91.
Patterson, O.2006. A poverty of the mind. New York Times, March 26.
92.
Perlmann, J.1988. Ethnic differences in schooling and social stratification among Irish, Italian, Jews and blacks in an American city, 1880-1935. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
93.
Petersilla, J.2003. When prisoners come home: Parole and prisoner reentry. New York: Oxford University Press .
94.
Pettit, B. , and B. Western . 2004. Mass imprisonment and the life course: Race and class inequality in U.S. incarceration . American Sociological Review69: 151-169 .
95.
Pinderhughes, D.2005. The renewal of the Voting Rights Act. In State of black America 2005. New York: National Urban League .
96.
Quadagno, J.1994. The color of welfare: How racism undermined the war on poverty. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
97.
Robinson, C. J.1997. Black movements in America. New York: Routledge .
98.
Roediger, D. R.2005. Working toward whiteness: How America's immigrants became white. New York: Basic Books .
99.
Rogers, J. , and R. Texeira . 2000. America's forgotten majority: Why the white working class still matters. New York: Basic Books .
100.
Roscigno, V. J. , D. Tomaskovic-Devey , and M. Crowley . 2006. Education and the inequalities of place . Social Forces84 (4): 2121-2145 .
101.
Rosenbaum, J.1984. Career mobility in a corporate hierarchy. New York: Academic Press .
102.
Royster, D. A.2003. Race and the invisible hand: How white networks exclude black men from blue-collar jobs. Berkeley: University of California Press .
103.
Rubinstein, G. , and D. Mukamal . 2002. Welfare and housing—Denial of benefits to drug offenders. In Invisible punishment: The collateral consequences of mass imprisonment, ed. M. Mauer and M. Chesney-Lind , 37-49. New York: New Press .
104.
Saint-Aubin, A. F.1994. Testeria: The dis-ease of black men in white supremacist, patriarchal culture . Callaloo17 (4): 1054-1073 .
105.
Shapiro, T.2004. The hidden cost of being African American: How wealth perpetuates inequality. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
106.
Shapiro, T. , and J. Kenty-Drane . 2005. The racial wealth gap. In African Americans in the U.S. economy, ed. C. A. Conrad , J. Whitehead , P. Mason , and J. Stewart , 175-184. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
107.
Smith, S. S.2005. Don't put my name on it: Social capital activation and job-finding assistance among the black urban poor . American Journal of Sociology111 (1): 1-57 .
108.
Sommers, C.2000. The war against boys: How misguided feminism is harming young men. New York: Simon & Schuster .
109.
Steinberg, S.1995. Turning back: The retreat from racial justice in American thought and policy. Boston: Beacon .
110.
Steinberg, S.2001. The ethnic myth: Race, ethnicity, and class in America. Boston: Beacon .
111.
Stoll. M.2005. The black youth employment problem revisited. In African Americans in the U.S. economy, ed. C. A. Conrad , J. Whitehead , P. Mason , and J. Stewart , 294-304. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .
112.
Sullivan, M.1989. Getting paid: Youth, crime and work in the inner city. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
113.
Thompson, G.2004. Through ebony eyes: What teachers need to know but are afraid to ask about African American students. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .
114.
Tonry, M.1996. Malign neglect: Race crime and punishment in America. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
115.
Travis, J.2005. But they all come back: Facing the challenges of prisoner reentry. New York: Urban Institute Press .
116.
Tushar, K.2005. Racial disparity in sentencing: A review of the literature. The Sentencing Project. www.sentencingproject.org.
117.
Uggen, C. , and J. Manza . 2002. Democratic contraction? The political consequences of felon disenfranchisement laws in the United States . American Sociological Review67: 777-803 .
118.
Uggen, C. , J. Manza , and M. Thompson . 2006. Citizenship, democracy, and the civic reintegration of criminal offenders . Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science605 (1): 281-310 .
119.
Wacquant, L.2001. Deadly symbiosis: When prison and ghetto meet and mesh . Punishment and Society3: 95-134 .
120.
Weaver-Hightower, M.2005. Dare the school build a new education for boys?Teachers College Record, February 14. http://www.tcrecord.org, ID number: 11743 (accessed October 10, 2006).
121.
Weiss, L.1990. Working class without work: High school students in a deindustrialized economy. New York: Routledge .
122.
Western, B.1998. Does criminal conviction affect employment?Princeton, NJ: Princeton University .
123.
Western, B.2006. Punishment and inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
124.
Western, B. , M. Kleykamp , and J. Rosenfeld . 2006. Did falling wages and employment increase U.S. imprisonment?Social Forces84 (4): 2291-2311 .
125.
Western, B. , and B. Pettit . 2005. Black-white wage inequality, employment rates, and incarceration . American Journal of Sociology111: 553-578 .
126.
Whitmire, R.2006. Boys and books: Boy trouble. The New Republic, January 18. http:/www.tnr.com/doc.mhtml?i=20060123&s=whitmire012306&c=2 (accessed October 2, 2006).
127.
Williams, J.2006. Enough: The phony leaders, dead-end movements, and culture of failure that are undermining black America—And what we can do about it. New York: Crown Books .
128.
Willis, P.1981. Learning to labor: How working class kids get working class jobs. New York: Columbia University Press .
129.
Wilson, F. D. , M. Tienda , and L. Wu . 1995. Race and unemployment: Labor market experiences of black and white men 1968-1988 . Work & Occupations22: 245-270 .
130.
Wilson, W. J.1987. The truly disadvantaged: The inner city, the underclass, and public policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
131.
Wilson, W. J.1996. When work disappears: The new world of the urban poor. New York: Knopf .
132.
Wright, C. , D. Weekes , A. McGlaughlin , and D. Webb . 1998. Masculinised discourses within education and the construction of black male identities amongst African Caribbean youth . British Journal of Sociology of Education19 (1): 75-87 .
133.
Yamagata, E. P. , and M. A. Jones . 2000. And justice for some: Differential treatment of minority youth in the justice system. Washington, DC: Building Blocks for Youth .
134.
Young, A.2003. The minds of marginalized black men: Making sense of mobility, opportunity and future life chances. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
