Forty patients with clinically and electromyographically proven carpal tun nel syndrome were examined for the frequency of concomitantly occurring Ray naud's phenomenon. The angiologic work-up was based on a detailed vascular history and examination, Doppler sonography to determine systolic digital ar tery pressures before and after exposure to the cold (10 ° C for one minute), and thermoplate tests for recording heat convection of the hands at normal room temperature and measuring rewarming time after standardized cold exposure. Only 10% of the patients were found to have manifest Raynaud's phenomenon. The incidence was thus the same as in the general population. In addition, Ray naud's phenomenon and the carpal tunnel syndrome were poorly correlated with respect to their preliminary symptom appearances.
Consequently, the carpal tunnel syndrome can no longer be regarded as a disease underlying Raynaud's phenomenon.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bollinger A., Butti P.: Primäres und sekundäres Raynaud-Syndrom. Schweiz Med Wochenschr106:415, 1976.
2.
Bollinger A.: Pathophysiologie des Raynaud-Phänomens. Dtsch Med Wochenschr107:1699, 1982.
3.
Heidrich H.: Primäres und sekundäres Raynaud-Syndrom: Definition, Ätiologie, Pathophysiologie, Klinik und Therapie. DtschMed J23:375, 1972.
4.
Benini A., Schlumpf M.: Das Karpaltunnelsyndrom. Med Wochenschr30:199, 1976.
5.
Mummenthaler M., Schliack H.: Läsionen peripherer Nerven, 3. AuflStuttgart: Thieme, 1977, p 233.
6.
Heidrich H.: Etiological aspects of Raynaud's syndrome. In: Raynaud's Phenomenon , ed. by Heidrich H. Oeynhausen: TM-Verlag1975, p 185.
7.
Heidrich H.: Raynaud-Phänomen. Herz und Gefäβe4:21, 1984.
8.
Garland H., Bradshaw Jpp, Clark Jmp: Compression of median nerve in carpal tunnel and its relation to acroparaesthesis . Br Med J1:730, 1957.
9.
Benini A.: Karpaltunnelsyndrom und vasomotorische Handstörung. Akt Neurol1:219, 1974.
10.
Chiche P., Dreyfus P.: Les acrosyncopes carpiennes, etude de 14 cas d'acrosyncope digitales associees a des signes d'atteinte du nerf median au poignet. Soc Med Hop Paris116:913, 1965.
11.
Linscheid RL , Peterson Lfa, Juergens JL: Carpal tunnel syndrome associated with vasospasm . J Bone Joint Surg49A: 1141, 1967.
12.
Neundörfer B., Dietrich B., Braun B.: Raynaud-Phänomen beim Carpaltunnelsyndrom . Wien Med Wochenschr89:131, 1977.
13.
Rageot E., Maigne R., Nataf J.: Les troubles dits sympatiques du membre superieur, phenomene de Raynaud et algo-neurodystrophies reflexes: leur rapport avec le syndrome du canal carpien . Angeiologie20:359, 1968.
14.
Treves R., Arnaud IP, Benabbon M., et al: Ulceration digital au cours d'un syndrome du canal carpien avec syndrom de Raynaud. Rev Rhum Mal Osteoartic47:578, 1980.
15.
Heidrich H. : Raynaud-Phänomen: Überfällige Begriffsenti wirrung. Münch Med Wochenschr121:403, 1979.
16.
Tanzer RC: The carpal tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint Surg41A:626, 1959.
17.
Kulbertus H. , Bandinet V., Couignon P.: Phenomenes de Raynaud et syndrome du canal carpien. Rev MedLiege21:319, 1966.
18.
Phalen G.: The carpal tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint Surg48:211, 1966.
19.
Rageot E., Maigne R., Nataf J.: Guerison d'un syndrome de Raynaud au stade de gangrene par une intervention portant sur le canal carpien. Couer Med int12:317, 1973.
20.
Kölbel R., Heidrich H.: Orthopedic presentation of Raynaud's phenomenon. In: Raynaud's Phenomenon, ed. by Heidrich H. Oeynhausen : TM-Verlag, 1979, p 207.
21.
Porter JM, Snider RL, Bardana EJ, et al: The diagnosis and treatment of Raynaud's phenomenon. Surgery77:11, 1975.
22.
Schwarz A., Keller F., Seyfert S., et al: Das Karpaltunnelsyndrom: eine Spätkomplikation bei chronischer Hämodialyse. Dtsch Med Wochenschr109:285, 1984.
23.
Gottwald W.: Incidence of Raynaud's syndrome in neuropsychiatric diseases. In: Raynaud's Phenomenon, ed. by Heidrich H. Oeynhausen : TM-Verlag, 1979, p 185.
24.
O'Reilly Mjg, Talpos G., Roberts VC, et al: The value of Doppler ultrasound in Raynaud's Phenomenon. In: Raynaud's Phenomenon, ed. by Heidrich H.Oeynhausen: TM-Verlag, 1979, p 291.
25.
Bollinger A. : Kritische Sichtung verschiedener Verfahren zur frühzeitigen Erfassung peripherer arterieller Gefäβveränderungen. VASA4:327, 1975.
26.
Sunderland S.: The nerve lesions in the carpal tunnel syndrome . J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry39:285, 1976.
27.
Bollinger A. , Schlumpf M.: Finger blood flow in healthy subjects of different sex and age and in patients with Raynaud's disease. Acta Chir Scand465 (suppl): 42, 1976.
28.
Nothnagel H. : Zur Lehre von den vasomotorischen Neurosen . Dtsch Arch Klin Med2:173, 1867.
29.
Kendall D.: Aetiology, diagnosis and treatment of paraesthesia in the hands. Br Med J1633, 1960.
30.
Langeron P. : Les syndromes vasculaires du membre superieur . J des sciences med de Lille89:471, 1971.
31.
Hutchinson J.: Inherited liability to Raynaud's phenomenon with great proneness to chillblain-gradual increase of liability to paroxysmal local asphyzis-acrosphalelus with scleroderma-cheeks affected. Arch Surg4:312, 1898.
