We compared the outcomes of cartilage tympanoplasty in nonsmokers and smokers.
Methods:
We performed a retrospective chart review of patients who underwent cartilage tympanoplasty in a tertiary academic medical center from 1991 to 2010. There were 129 operations in 118 patients; 84 operations were performed in nonsmokers and 45 operations were performed in smokers. The primary outcome measure was the tympanic membrane graft take rate at the interval and most recent follow-up visits. Secondary measures included recurrence, the need for revision surgery, and hearing outcomes.
Results:
Nonsmokers and smokers had comparable long-term rates of intact eardrums (90.6% versus 92.9%; p = 0.99). There was a trend toward a higher rate of recurrent or persistent disease requiring further operation for smokers (13.3% versus 4.7%; p = 0.09). Both groups had improvement in pure tone averages (12.1 dB in nonsmokers and 12.8 dB in smokers) and air-bone gaps (9.6 dB in nonsmokers and 5.1 dB in smokers), although the rates were not statistically significantly different from each other. The rates of success of cartilage tympanoplasty in smokers appear superior to previously published rates of noncartilage tympanoplasty.
Conclusions:
Cartilage tympanoplasty has success rates and postoperative audiological measures that are comparable between smokers and nonsmokers. In smokers, cartilage grafting is superior to noncartilage grafting and is recommended for any patient who smokes and is undergoing tympanoplasty.
WullsteinH. Technic and early results of tympanoplasty. Monatsschr Ohrenheilkd Laryngorhinol1953;87:308–11.
2.
ZoellnerF. Operations for the improvement of the hearing. Triangle1960;4:126–31.
3.
GlasscockMEIIIJacksonCGNissenAJSchwaberMK. Postauricular undersurface tympanic membrane grafting: A follow-up report. Laryngoscope1982;92:718–27.
4.
HalikJJSmythGD. Long-term results of tympanic membrane repair. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1988;98:162–9.
5.
CampbellEE. Homograft tympanoplasty: A long-term review of 477 ears. Am J Otol1990;11:66–70.
6.
SheltonCSheehyJL. Tympanoplasty: Review of 400 staged cases. Laryngoscope1990;100:679–81.
7.
FukuchiICerchiariDPGarciaERezendeCERapoportPB. Tympanoplasty: Surgical results and a comparison of the factors that may interfere in their success. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol2006;72:267–71.
8.
BecvarovskiZKartushJM. Smoking and tympanoplasty: Implications for prognosis and the Middle Ear Risk Index (MERI). Laryngoscope2001;111:1806–11.
9.
KaylieDMBennettMLDavisBJacksonCG. Effects of smoking on otologic surgery outcomes. Laryngoscope2009;119:1384–90.
10.
UguzMZOnalKKazikdasKCOnalA. The influence of smoking on success of tympanoplasty measured by serum cotinine analysis. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol2008;265:513–6.
11.
CantrellRW. Myringoplasty failure related to smoking: A preliminary report. Otolaryngol Clin North Am1970;3:141–5.
12.
OnalKUguzMZKazikdasKCGursoySTGokceH. A multivariate analysis of otological, surgical and patient-related factors in determining success in myringoplasty. Clin Otolaryngol2005;30:115–20.
13.
PichardoH MolinaEnríquezB García. Smoking effects on tympanoplasty: Surgical results. An Orl Mex2009;54:45–50.
14.
GarrettBEDubeSRTrosclairACaraballoRSPechacekTF; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Cigarette smoking — United States, 1965–2008. MMWR Surveill Summ2011;60 (suppl):109–13.
15.
The Surgeon General's 1990 report on the health benefits of smoking cessation. Executive summary. MMWR Recomm Rep1990;39:i–xv,1–12.
16.
FureySASchaanningJSpoontSBirkheadNC. The comparative effects on circulation of smoking tobacco and lettuce leaf cigarettes. Angiology1967;18:218–23.
17.
KruegerJKRohrichRJ. Clearing the smoke: The scientific rationale for tobacco abstention with plastic surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg2001;108:1063–77.
18.
EtzelRAPattishallENHaleyNJFletcherRHHendersonFW. Passive smoking and middle ear effusion among children in day care. Pediatrics1992;90:228–32.
19.
Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium guidelines for the diagnosis and evaluation of therapy in Menière's disease. American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Foundation, Inc. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1995;113:181–5.
20.
AidonisIRobertsonTCSismanisA. Cartilage shield tympanoplasty: A reliable technique. Otol Neurotol2005;26:838–41.
21.
LinYCWangWHWengHHLinYC. Predictors of surgical and hearing long-term results for inlay cartilage tympanoplasty. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2011;137:215–9.
22.
AgiusAMWakeMPahorALSmallmanLA. Smoking and middle ear ciliary beat frequency in otitis media with effusion. Acta Otolaryngol1995;115:44–9.
23.
LeeIWGohEKRohHJLeeCHChungBJChonKM. Histologic changes in the eustachian tube mucosa of rats after short-term exposure to cigarette smoke. Otol Neurotol2006;27:433–40.
24.
HeeJGuillermR. Discussion on smoke and mucociliary transport. Eur J Respir DisSuppl1985;139:86–8.
25.
VastagEMatthysHKöhlerDGronbeckLDaikelerG. Mucociliary clearance and airways obstruction in smokers, ex-smokers and normal subjects who never smoked. Eur J Respir DisSuppl1985;139:93–100.
26.
BriggsRDWrightSTCordesSCalhounKH. Smoking in chronic rhinosinusitis: A predictor of poor long-term outcome after endoscopic sinus surgery. Laryngoscope2004;114:126–8.
27.
DornhofferJ. Cartilage tympanoplasty: Indications, techniques, and outcomes in a 1,000-patient series. Laryngoscope2003;113:1844–56.
28.
DuckertLGMüllerJMakielskiKHHelmsJ. Composite autograft “shield” reconstruction of remnant tympanic membranes. Am J Otol1995;16:21–6.
29.
MilewskiC. Composite graft tympanoplasty in the treatment of ears with advanced middle ear pathology. Laryngoscope1993;103:1352–6.
30.
GerberMJMasonJCLambertPR. Hearing results after primary cartilage tympanoplasty. Laryngoscope2000;110:1994–9.
31.
KyrodimosESismanisASantosD. Type III cartilage “shield” tympanoplasty: An effective procedure for hearing improvement. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg2007;136:982–5.
SmythGDKerrAG. Cartilage homografts. Experimental and clinical aspects. Acta Otorhinolaryngol Belg1970;24:53–9.
34.
SchuknechtHFShiSR. Surgical pathology of middle ear implants. Laryngoscope1985;95:249–58.
35.
SteinbachEPusalkarA. Long-term histological fate of cartilage in ossicular reconstruction. J Laryngol Otol1981;95:1031–9.
36.
NakanishiNOkamotoMNakamuraKSuzukiKTataraK. Cigarette smoking and risk for hearing impairment: A longitudinal study in Japanese male office workers. J Occup Environ Med2000;42:1045–9.
37.
CruickshanksKJKleinRKleinBEWileyTLNondahlDMTweedTS. Cigarette smoking and hearing loss: The epidemiology of hearing loss study. JAMA1998;279:1715–9.
38.
AgrawalYPlatzEANiparkoJK. Risk factors for hearing loss in US adults: Data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 1999 to 2002. Otol Neurotol2009;30:139–45.
39.
FerriteSSantanaV. Joint effects of smoking, noise exposure and age on hearing loss. Occup Med (Lond)2005;55:48–53.
40.
FerrucciLGuralnikJMPenninxBWLeveilleS. Cigarette smoke exposure and hearing loss. JAMA1998;280:963–4.
41.
GopinathBFloodVMMcMahonCMBurlutskyGSmithWMitchellP. The effects of smoking and alcohol consumption on age-related hearing loss: The Blue Mountains Hearing Study. Ear Hear2010;31:277–82.
42.
GierekTSlaska-KasperaAMajzelKKlimczak-GołabL. Results of myringoplasty and type I tympanoplasty with the use of fascia, cartilage and perichondrium grafts [in Polish]. Otolaryngol Pol2004;58:529–33.
43.
AndersonJCayé-ThomasenPTosM. A comparison of cartilage palisades and fascia in tympanoplasty after surgery for sinus or tensa retraction cholesteatoma in children. Otol Neurotol2004;25:856–63.
44.
DornhofferJL. Hearing results with cartilage tympanoplasty. Laryngoscope1997;107:1094–9.
45.
CouloignerVBaculardFEl BakkouriW. Inlay butterfly cartilage tympanoplasty in children. Otol Neurotol2005;26:247–51.
46.
YungM. Cartilage tympanoplasty: Literature review. J Laryngol Otol2008;122:663–72.
47.
OhlinPLundhBWestlingH. Carbon monoxide blood levels and reported cessation of smoking. Psychopharmacology (Berl)1976;49:263–5.
48.
DornhofferJ. Cartilage tympanoplasty: Indications, techniques, and outcomes in a 1,000-patient series. Laryngoscope2003;113:1844–56.
