Gender Differences in the Reporting of Vocal Fatigue in Teachers as Quantified by the Vocal Fatigue Index

Abstract

Objectives:

Occupational voice users report higher instances of vocal health problems. Women, who are more likely than men to report voice problems, are the largest members of some occupational voice users, such as teachers. While a common complaint among this population is vocal fatigue, it has been difficult to quantify. Therefore, the goal of this study is to quantify vocal fatigue generally in school teachers and investigate any related gender differences.

Methods:

Six hundred forty (518 female, 122 male) teachers were surveyed using an online questionnaire consisting in part of the Vocal Fatigue Index (VFI), an index specifically designed to quantify vocal fatigue.

Results:

Compared to vocally healthy adults, the teachers surveyed were 3 times as likely to report vocal tiredness or vocal avoidance and over 3 times as likely to report physical voice discomfort. Additionally, female teachers were more likely to have scores approaching those with dysphonia.

Conclusions:

The VFI quantified elevated levels of vocal fatigue in teachers, with a significant prevalence of symptoms reported among females compared to males. Further, because the VFI indicated elevated complaints (between normal and dysphonic) in a population likely to be elevated, the VFI might be used to identify early indications of voice problems and/or track recovery.

Keywords

vocal fatigue voice disorders voice recovery occupational voice use

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Titze

Lemke

Montequin

. Populations in the U.S. workforce who rely on voice as a primary tool of trade: a preliminary report. J Voice. 1997;11(3):254-259.

Heidel

Torgerson

. Vocal problems among aerobic instructors and aerobic participants. J Commun Disord. 1993;26(3):179-191.

McHenry

Carlson

. The vocal health of auctioneers. Logoped Phoniatr Vocol. 2004;29(1):41-47.

Verdolini

Branski

Rosen

Hebra

. Shifts in biochemical markers associated with wound healing in laryngeal secretions following phonotrauma: a preliminary study. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2003;112(12):1021-1025.

Cantor Cutiva

Burdorf

. Medical costs and productivity costs related to voice symptoms in colombian teachers. J Voice. 2015;29(6):776.e15-776.e22.

Roy

Merrill

Gray

Smith

. Voice disorders in the general population: prevalence, risk factors, and occupational impact. Laryngoscope. 2005;115(11):1988-1995.

Ruotsalainen

Sellman

Lehto

Verbeek

. Systematic review of the treatment of functional dysphonia and prevention of voice disorders. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2008;138(5):557-565.

Welham

Maclagan

. Vocal fatigue: current knowledge and future directions. J Voice. 2003;17(1):21-30.

Bottalico

Graetzer

Hunter

. Effects of speech style, room acoustics, and vocal fatigue on vocal effort. J Acoust Soc Am. 2016;139(5):2870-2879.

10.

Williams

NR.

Occupational voice disorders due to workplace exposure to irritants—a review of the literature. Occup Med. 2002;52(2):99-101.

11.

Gaskill

O’Brien

Tinter

. the effect of voice amplification on occupational vocal dose in elementary school teachers. J Voice. 2012;26(5):667.e19-667.e27.

12.

Hunter

Titze

. Quantifying vocal fatigue recovery: dynamic vocal recovery trajectories after a vocal loading exercise. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2009;118(6):449-460.

13.

Sliwinska-Kowalska

Niebudek-Bogusz

Fiszer

et al . The prevalence and risk factors for occupational voice disorders in teachers. Folia Phoniatr Logop. 2006;58(2):85-101.

14.

Smith

Kirchner

Taylor

Hoffman

Lemke

. Voice problems among teachers: differences by gender and teaching characteristics. J Voice. 1998;12(3):328-334.

15.

Hunter

Tanner

Smith

. Gender differences affecting vocal health of women in vocally demanding careers. Logoped Phoniatr Vocol. 2011;36(3-4):128-136.

16.

Hammond

Gray

Butler

. Age-and gender-related collagen distribution in human vocal folds. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2000;109(10):913-920.

17.

Leanderson

Sundberg

. Breathing for singing. J Voice. 1988;2(1):2-12.

18.

Wadnerkar

Cowell

Whiteside

. Speech across the menstrual cycle: a replication and extension study. Neurosci Lett. 2006;408(1):21-24.

19.

Hunter

Titze

. Variations in intensity, fundamental frequency, and voicing for teachers in occupational versus nonoccupational settings. J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2010;53(4):862-875.

20.

Dietrich

Verdolini Abbott

Gartner-Schmidt

Rosen

. The frequency of perceived stress, anxiety, and depression in patients with common pathologies affecting voice. J Voice. 2008;22(4):472-488.

21.

Roy

Bless

Heisey

. Personality and voice disorders: a superfactor trait analysis. J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2000;43(3):749-768.

22.

Jacobson

Johnson

Grywalski

et al . The voice handicap index (VHI) development and validation. Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 1997;6(3):66-70.

23.

Hogikyan

Sethuraman

. Validation of an instrument to measure voice-related quality of life (V-RQOL). J Voice. 1999;13(4):557-569.

24.

Nanjundeswaran

Jacobson

Gartner-Schmidt

Verdolini Abbott

. Vocal Fatigue Index (VFI): development and validation. J Voice. 2015;29(4):433-440.

25.

Banks

RE.

Understanding vocal fatigue and grade level demand as quantified by the Vocal Fatigue Index (VFI). Michigan State University, Thesis, 2015. https://etd.lib.msu.edu/islandora/object/etd%3A2440/datastream/OBJ/download/Understanding_Vocal_Fatigue_and_Grade_Level_Demand_as_Quantified_by_the_Vocal_Fatigue_Index__VFI_.pdf. Accessed January 18, 2017.

26.

Goldring

Taie

Riddles

. Teacher attrition and mobility: results from the 2012-13 Teacher Follow-Up Survey. First look. NCES 2014-077. http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED546773. Accessed February 24, 2017.

27.

Rhemtulla

Brosseau-Liard

PÉ

Savalei

. When can categorical variables be treated as continuous? A comparison of robust continuous and categorical SEM estimation methods under suboptimal conditions. Psychol Methods. 2012;17(3):354-373.

28.

Westfall

PH.

Kurtosis as peakedness, 1905-2014. R.I.P. Am Stat. 2014;68(3):191-195.

29.

Bottalico

Speech adjustments for room acoustics and their effects on vocal effort. J Voice. 2017;31(3):392.e1-392.e12.

30.

Hunter

Bottalico

Graetzer

et al . Teachers and teaching: speech production accommodations due to changes in the acoustic environment. Energy Procedia. 2015;78:3102-3107.

31.

Arendt-Nielsen

Bajaj

Drewes

. Visceral pain: gender differences in response to experimental and clinical pain. Eur J Pain. 2004;8(5):465-472.

32.

Chesterton

Barlas

Foster

Baxter

Wright

. Gender differences in pressure pain threshold in healthy humans. Pain. 2003;101(3):259-266.

33.

Ellermeier

Westphal

. Gender differences in pain ratings and pupil reactions to painful pressure stimuli. Pain. 1995;61(3):435-439.

34.

Thomason

Williams

Hardman

. Sex and sex hormones mediate wound healing. In: Klein

Roberts

, eds. Sex and Gender Differences in Infection and Treatments for Infectious Diseases. New York: Springer International Publishing; 2015:31-48.

35.

Butler

Hammond

Gray

. Gender-related differences of hyaluronic acid distribution in the human vocal fold. Laryngoscope. 2001;111(5):907-911.

36.

Thibeault

Rousseau

Welham

Hirano

Bless

. Hyaluronan levels in acute vocal fold scar. Laryngoscope. 2004;114(4):760-764.

37.

Ward

Thibeault

Gray

. Hyaluronic Acid. J Voice. 2002;16(3):303-309.

38.

Wilhelm

Parker

Geerligs

Wedgwood

. Women and depression: a 30 year learning curve. Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2008;42(1):3-12.