Microplastic research is an emerging field. Consistent accurate identification of microplastic polymer composition is vital for understanding the effect of microplastic pollution in the environment. Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy is becoming commonplace for identifying microplastics. Conventional spectral identification is based on library searching, a process that utilizes a search algorithm against digital databases containing single spectra of pristine reference plastics. Several conditions on environmental microplastic particles such as weathering, additives, and residues cause spectral alterations relative to pristine reference library spectra. Thus, library searching is vulnerable to misidentification of microplastic samples. While a classification process (classifier) based on a collection of spectra can alleviate misidentification problems, optimization of each classifier (tuning parameter) is required. Additionally, erratic results relative to the particular optimized tuning parameter can occur when microplastic samples originate from new environmental or biological conditions than those defining the class. Presented in this study is a process that utilizes spectroscopic measurements in a hybrid fusion algorithm that depending on the user preference, simultaneously combines high-level fusion with low- and mid-level fusion based on an ensemble of non-optimized classifiers to assign microplastic samples into specific plastic categories (classes). The approach is demonstrated with 17 classifiers using FT-IR for binary classification of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) and high-density polyethylene (HDPE) microplastic samples from environmental sources. Other microplastic types are evaluated for non-class PET and HDPE membership. Results show that high accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity are obtained thereby reducing the risk of misidentifying microplastics.
ShimW.J.HongS.H.EoS.E.“Identification Methods in Microplastic Analysis: A Review”. Anal. Methods. 2017, 9(9): 1384–1391.
2.
HaleR.C.“Analytical Challenges Associated with the Determination of Microplastics in the Environment”. Anal. Methods. 2017, 9(9): 1326–1327.
3.
LenzR.EndersK.StedmonC.A., et al.“A Critical Assessment of Visual Identification of Marine Microplastic using Raman Spectroscopy for Analysis Improvement”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2015, 100(1): 82–91.
4.
BaldwinA.K.CorsiS.R.MasonS.A.“Plastic Debris in 29 Great Lakes Tributaries: Relations to Watershed Attributes and Hydrology”. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2016, 50(19): 10377–10385.
5.
KappK.J.YeatmanE.“Microplastic Hotspots in the Snake and Lower Columbia Rivers: A Journey from the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem to the Pacific Ocean”. Environ Pollut. 2018, 241: 1082–1090.
6.
JiangC.YinL.LiZ., et al.“Microplastic Pollution in the Rivers of the Tibet Plateau”. Environ Pollut. 2019, 249: 91–98.
7.
EriksenM.LebretonL.C.M.CarsonH.S., et al.“Plastic Pollution in the World’s Oceans: More than 5 Trillion Plastic Pieces Weighing Over 250,000 Tons Afloat at Sea”. PLoS One. 2014, 9(12): doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0111913.
8.
WagnerJ.WangZ.-M.GhosalS., et al.“Novel Method for the Extraction and Identification of Microplastics in Ocean Trawl and Fish Gut Matrices”. Anal. Methods. 2017, 9(9): 1479–1490.
9.
JungM.R.HorgenF.D.OrskiS.V., et al.“Validation of ATR FT-IR to Identify Polymers of Plastic Marine Debris, Including Those Ingested by Marine Organisms”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2018, 127: 704–716.
10.
WebbH.K.ArnottJ.CrawfordR.J., et al.“Plastic Degradation and Its Environmental Implications with Special Reference to Poly(ethylene Terephthalate)”. Polymers. 2012, 5(1): 1–18.
11.
RochmanC.M.BrowneM.A.HalpernB.S., et al.“Classify Plastic Waste as Hazardous”. Nature. 2013, 494(7436): 169–171.
12.
GregoryM.R.“Environmental Implications of Plastic Debris in Marine Settings—Entanglement, Ingestion, Smothering, Hangers-On, Hitch-Hiking and Alien Invasions”. Philos. Trans. Royal Soc. B. 2009, 364(1526): 2013–2025.
13.
BrowneM.A.DissanayakeA.GallowayT.S., et al.“Ingested Microscopic Plastic Translocates to the Circulatory System of the Mussel, Mytilus edulis (L.)”. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2008, 42(13): 5026–5031.
14.
BrandonJ.GoldsteinM.OhmanM.D.“Long-term Aging and Degradation of Microplastic Particles: Comparing in Situ Oceanic and Experimental Weathering Patterns”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2016, 110(1): 299–308.
15.
LusherA.McHughM.ThompsonR.“Occurrence of Microplastics in the Gastrointestinal Tract of Pelagic and Demersal Fish from the English Channel”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2013, 67(1–2): 94–99.
16.
FriesE.DekiffJ.H.WillmeyerJ., et al.“Identification of Polymer Types and Additives in Marine Microplastic Particles Using Pyrolysis-GC/MS and Scanning Electron Microscopy”. Environ. Sci.: Process. Impacts. 2013, 15(10): 1949.
17.
CauwenbergheL.V.VanreuselA.MeesJ., et al.“Microplastic Pollution in Deep-sea Sediments”. Environ Pollut. 2013, 182: 495–499.
18.
DekiffJ.H.RemyD.KlasmeierJ., et al.“Occurrence and Spatial Distribution of Microplastics in Sediments from Norderney”. Environ Pollut. 2014, 186: 248–256.
19.
NuelleM.-T.DekiffJ.H.RemyD., et al.“A New Analytical Approach for Monitoring Microplastics in Marine Sediments”. Environ Pollut. 2014, 184: 161–169.
20.
MarkwortL.KipB.“Micro-Raman Imaging of Heterogeneous Polymer Systems: General Applications and Limitations”. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 1996, 61(2): 231–254.
21.
HarrisonJ.P.OjedaJ.J.Romero-GonzálezM.E.“The Applicability of Reflectance Micro-Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy for the Detection of Synthetic Microplastics in Marine Sediments”. Sci. Total Environ. 2012, 416: 455–463.
22.
RennerG.SchmidtT.C.SchramJ.“A New Chemometric Approach for Automatic Identification of Microplastics from Environmental Compartments Based on FT-IR Spectroscopy”. Anal. Chem. 2017, 89(22): 12045–12053.
23.
Gryniewicz-RuzickaC.M.RodriguezJ.D.ArzhantsevS., et al.“Libraries, Classifiers, and Quantifiers: A Comparison of Chemometric Methods for the Analysis of Raman Spectra of Contaminated Pharmaceutical Materials”. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 2012, 61: 191–198.
24.
TangP.L.McCumskyR.RogersonM., et al.“Handheld FT-IR Spectroscopy for the Triage of Micro- and Meso-Sized Plastics in the Marine Environment Incorporating an Accelerated Weathering Study and an Aging Estimation”. Spectroscopy2019; 34(2): 54–60.
25.
GulmineJ.V.JanissekP.R.HeiseH.M., et al.“Degradation Profile of Polyethylene after Artificial Accelerated Weathering”. Polymer Degrad. Stability. 2003, 79: 385–397.
26.
AverettS.C.StanleyS.K.HansonJ.J., et al.“Surface Spectroscopic Signatures of Mechanical Deformation in High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE)”. Appl Spectrosc. 2018, 72(7): 1057–1068.
27.
HalleA.T.LadiratL.MartignacM., et al.“To What Extent are Microplastics from the Open Ocean Weathered?”. Environ Pollut2017; 227: 167–174.
28.
WoodallL.C.Sanchez-VidalA.CanalsM., et al.“The Deep Sea is a Major Sink for Microplastic Debris”. R. Soc. Open Sci2014; 1(4): 140317.
29.
LusherA.L.WeldenN.A.SobralP., et al.“Sampling, Isolating and Identifying Microplastics Ingested by Fish and Invertebrates”. Anal. Methods. 2017, 9(9): 1346–1360.
30.
RennerG.NellessenA.SchwiersA., et al.“Data Preprocessing & Evaluation used in the Microplastics Identification Process: A Critical Reviewand Practical Guide”. TrAC, Trends Anal. Chem. 2019, 111: 229–238.
31.
RennerG.SauerbierP.SchmidtT.C., et al.“Robust Automatic Identification of Microplastics in Environmental Samples Using FTIR Microscopy”. Anal. Chem. 2019, 91: 9656–9664.
32.
P. Ribeiro-Claro, M.M. Nolasco, C. Araújo. “Characterization of Microplastics by Raman Spectroscopy”. Compr. Anal. Chem. 2017. 75: 119–151.
33.
KieferJ.“The Danger of Relying on Database Spectra”. Appl. Spectrosc. 2018, 72(8): 1272–1276.
34.
GuoS.HeinkeR.StöckelS., et al.“Towards an Improvement of Model Transferability for Raman Spectroscopy in Biological Applications”. Vib. Spectrosc. 2017, 91: 111–118.
35.
CandolfiA.MassartD.L.“Model Updating for the Identification of NIR Spectra from a Pharmaceutical Excipient”. Appl. Spectrosc. 2000, 54(1): 48–53.
36.
MylesA.J.ZimmermanT.A.BrownS.D.“Transfer of Multivariate Classification Models Between Laboratory and Process Near-Infrared Spectrometers for the Discrimination of Green Arabica and Robusta Coffee Beans”. Appl. Spectrosc. 2006, 60(10): 1198–1203.
37.
B.K. Lavine, W.S. Rayens. “Classification: Basic Concepts”. In: S.D Brown, R Tauler, B. Walczak, editors. Comprehensive Chemometrics: Chemical and Biochemical Data Analysis. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier, 2009. Pp. 508–510.
38.
ScottD.M.WaterlandR.L.“Identification of Plastic Waste using Spectroscopy and Neural Networks”. Polym. Eng. Sci. 1995, 35(12): 1011–1015.
39.
TachwaliY.Al-AssafY.Al-AliA.“Automatic Multistage Classification System for Plastic Bottles Recycling”. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2007, 52(2): 266–285.
ÖzkanK.ErginS.IşıkŞ., et al.“A New Classification Scheme of Plastic Wastes Based upon Recycling Labels”. Waste Manage. (Oxford). 2015, 35: 29–35.
42.
B.K. Chabuka, J.H. Kalivas. “Raman Spectroscopy and Fusion Classification to Identify Plastic Recyclables Targeting Microplastics”. In: Idaho Conference on Undergraduate Research, Boise, Idaho: 2018. https://scholarworks.boisestate.edu/icur/2018/Poster_Session/24/ [accessed Apr 22 2020].
43.
SerrantiS.PalmieriR.BonifaziG., et al.“Characterization of Microplastic Litter from Oceans by an Innovative Approach Based on Hyperspectral Imaging”. Waste Manage. (Oxford). 2018, 76: 117–125.
44.
PaulA.WanderL.BeckerR., et al.“High-Throughput NIR Spectroscopic (NIRS) Detection of Microplastics in Soil”. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 2018, 26(8): 7364–7374.
45.
ShanJ.ZhaoJ.LiuL., et al.“A Novel Way to Rapidly Monitor Microplastics in Soil by Hyperspectral Imaging Technology and Chemometrics”. Environ Pollut. 2018, 238: 121–129.
46.
HalsteadJ.E.SmithJ.A.CarterE.A., et al.“Assessment Tools for Microplastics and Natural Fibers Ingested by Fish in an Urbanised Estuary”. Env. Pollution. 2018, 234: 552–561.
47.
PaulA.WanderL.BeckerR., et al.“High-throughput NIR Spectroscopic (NIRS) Detection of Microplastics in Soil”. Env. Sci. Pollution Res. 2019, 26: 7364–7374.
48.
Comnea-StancuI.R.WielandK.RamerG., et al.“On the Identification of Rayon/Viscose as a Major Fraction of Microplastics in the Marine Environment: Discrimination Between Natural and Manmade Cellulosic Fibers Using Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy”. Appl. Spectrosc2017; 71(5): 939–950.
49.
MecozziM.PietrolettiM.MonakhovaY.B.“FTIR Spectroscopy Supported by Statistical Techniques for the Structural Characterization of Plastic Debris in the Marine Environment: Application to Monitoring Studies”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2016, 106: 155–161.
50.
HoT.K.HullJ.SrihariS.“Decision Combination in Multiple Classifier Systems”. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence. 1994, 16(1): 66–75.
SteinmetzV.SévilaF.Bellon-MaurelV.“A Methodology for Sensor Fusion Design: Application to Fruit Quality Assessment”. J. Agric. Eng. Res. 1999, 74(1): 21–31.
53.
AnttiH.BollardM.E.EbbelsT., et al.“Batch Statistical Processing of 1H NMR-Derived Urinary Spectral Data”. J. Chemom. 2002, 16(8–10): 461–468.
54.
AzmiJ.GriffinJ.L.AnttiH., et al.“Metabolic Trajectory Characterisation of Xenobiotic-Induced Hepatotoxic Lesions using Statistical Batch Processing of NMR Data”. Analyst. 2002, 127(2): 271–276.
55.
LiC.HeinemannP.SherryR.“Neural Network and Bayesian Network Fusion Models to Fuse Electronic Nose and Surface Acoustic Wave Sensor Data for Apple Defect Detection”. Sens. Actuators B. 2007, 125(1): 301–310.
56.
WoldS.KettanehN.TjessemK.“Hierarchical Multiblock PLS and PC Models for Easier Model Interpretation and as an Alternative to Variable Selection”. J. Chemom. 1996, 10(5–6): 463–482.
57.
ErikssonL.AnttiH.GottfriesJ., et al.“Using Chemometrics for Navigating in the Large Data Sets of Genomics, Proteomics, and Metabonomics (gpm)”. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 2004, 380(3): 419–429.
58.
BorràsE.FerréJ.BoquéR., et al.“Data fusion Methodologies for Food and Beverage Authentication and Quality Assessment – A Review”. Anal. Chim. Acta. 2015, 891: 1–14.
59.
ScavinoE.WahabD.A.HussainA., et al.“Application of Automated Image Analysis to the Identification and Extraction of Recyclable Plastic Bottles”. J. Zhejiang Univ. Sci. A. 2009, 10(6): 794–799.
60.
BrownfieldB.LemosT.KalivasJ.H.“Consensus Classification Using Non-Optimized Classifiers”. Anal. Chem. 2018, 90(7): 4429–4437.
61.
BrownfieldB.KalivasJ.H.“Consensus Outlier Detection Using Sum of Ranking Differences of Common and New Outlier Measures Without Tuning Parameter Selections”. Anal. Chem. 2017, 89: 5067–5094.
62.
BrownfieldB.KalivasJ.H.“Correction to Consensus Outlier Detection Using Sum of Ranking Differences of Common and New Outlier Measures Without Tuning Parameter Selections”. Anal. Chem. 2017, 89(17): 9609–9609.
63.
StokesT.D.FoteiniM.BrownfieldB., et al.“Feasibility Assessment of Synchronous Fluorescence Spectral Fusion by Application to Argan Oil for Adulteration Analysis”. Appl. Spectrosc. 2018, 72(3): 432–441.
64.
J.H. Kalivas. “Data Fusion of Nonoptimized Models: Applications to Outlier Detection, Classification, and Image Library Searching”. In: M Cocchi, editor. Data Fusion Methodology and Applications. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2019. Chap. 12, Pp. 345–370.
LoudermilkJ.B.HimmelsbachD.S.BartonF.E.II, et al.“Novel Search Algorithms for a Mid-Infrared Spectral Library of Cotton Contaminants”. Appl. Spectrosc. 2008, 62(6): 661–670.
GrenetI.MerloK.CometJ.P., et al.“Stacked Generalization with Applicability Domain Outperforms Simple QSAR in in Vitro Toxicological Data”. J. Chem. Info. Mod. 2019, 59: 1486–1496.
TosinM.WeberM.SiottoM., et al.“Laboratory Test Methods to Determine the Degradation of Plastics in Marine Environmental Conditions”. Front. Microbiol. 2012, 3(325): 1–9.
71.
PrimpkeS.LorenzC.Rascher-FriesenhausenR., et al.“An Automated Approach for Microplastics Analysis Using Focal Plane Array (FPA) FTIR Microscopy and Image Analysis”. Anal. Methods. 2017, 9(9): 1499–1511.
72.
GeorgouliK.OsorioM.T.RinconJ.M.D., et al.“Data Augmentation in Food Science: Synthesising Spectroscopic Data of Vegetable Oils for Performance Enhancement”. J. Chemom. 2018, 32(6): e3004.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
