Abstract
In this article, we compare extreme order statistics through vector majorization arising from heterogeneous Poisson and geometric random variables. These comparisons are carried out with respect to usual stochastic ordering.
Keywords
Introduction
The notion of stochastic order based on majorization (see Marshall et al. Maol) deals with the diversity of the components of a vector in
The field of univariate discrete distributions has been investigated by the researchers extensively in the past seven decades (see Johnson et al. [12] ). Discrete probability distributions and their applications are common in statistics and related disciplines such as reliability, economics, engineering, insurance, business and management, hydrology, epidemiology, and others. Many well-known discrete distributions, such as binomial, Poisson, negative binomial are studied vastly in the literature.
In particular, Poisson distribution is one of the most powerful distributions used in practice for modelling count data. The Poisson distribution is specified by a single parameter which defines both the mean and the variance of the distribution. This characteristic of Poisson distribution makes it an excellent choice for modelling over-dispersed data. For instance, the number of customer service calls per hour is an important metric for assessing the adequacy of customer service staffing in a customer care; the number of losses or claims that occur each year in an insurance firm helps reviewing and evaluating business insurance coverage; number of defects per metre is an essential quality performance indicator in a production line; patient footfall in an out patient department (OPD) of a hospital is an important metric for resource utilization and capacity planning. Poisson distribution can be the best choice for modelling each of the instances as mentioned above.
On the other hand, the geometric distribution is usually employed to model the number of failures in a sequence of independent and identically distributed Bernoulli trials before the first success occurs. Besides its theoretical flavour, geometric distribution has been proved of substantial interest in numerous practical applications, namely quality control, reliability, psychology, finance, ecology and others. Moreover, the distribution is extensively used in the literature to model discrete failure time. For instance, geometric distribution is appropriate when (i) a piece of equipment operates in cycles and the number of cycles prior to failure is observed; (ii) failures occur only due to incoming shocks and number of rounds fired until failure becomes more crucial than age at failure; (iii) a device is monitored only once per time period (e.g., an hour, a day) and the observation is the number of time periods successfully completed prior to failure of the device.
The number of articles on discrete order statistics is considerably smaller than on continuous case. For a discussion of order statistics from discrete distributions one can refer to Nagaraja [24] , Arnold et al. [1] and Dembiska. [8] Moreover, a handful number of articles have studied the heterogeneous effect on the distribution properties of discrete order statistics (see Davies and Dembiska [7] and Xu and Hu [30] ). Moreover, comparison of order statistics for heterogenous discrete distributions based on vector majorization has been rarely studied in the literature. The only article by Chen et al. [4] compares the order statistics stochastically from heterogeneous negative binomial random variables. Current work is an attempt to derive some results on ordering properties of extremes for heterogeneous and independent Poisson and geometric random variables and such exercise is motivated by the following examples.
Example 1: As mentioned earlier, Poisson distribution is a popular choice for describing number of insurance claims received by an insurance firm per unit time. Suppose there are two competing insurance firms selling
Example 2: Use of geometric distribution in the current set-up may be perceived from a reliability example. Suppose there are two systems consisting of
The rest of this article is organized as follows. In Section 2, we have given the required definitions and some useful lemmas that are used throughout the article. Results concerning stochastic comparison of the minimum and maximum order statistics for Poisson and geometric are derived in Section 3. Section 4 concludes the article. Throughout the article, the word increasing (resp. decreasing) and non-decreasing (resp. non-increasing) are used interchangeably, and
Preliminaries
Let
In order to compare
in usual stochastic (st) order, denoted as hazard rate (hr) order, denoted as reversed hazard rate (rhr) order, denoted as
It is well known that the results on different stochastic orders can be established using majorization order(s). Let
or equivalently,
Let us introduce the following lemma which will be used in the next section to prove the results.
for all where
Main Results
Some results on the comparison of minimum and maximum order statistics are derived in this section. In the first subsection, extreme order statistics from heterogeneous Poisson random variables are compared while in the second subsection, results are derived when each random variable follows geometric distribution.
Poisson Distribution
Let
and cumulative distribution function (CDF)
Let
and
The following lemma will be used to prove the next theorem.
is increasing in
So, if
then
and
given that
Let,
Differentiating
So, for
Thus, if for
proving the result.
Now the question arises: whether the result of the above theorem can be upgraded to reversed hazard rate ordering or not. Next counter-example shows that this is not possible.
Let, for
Differentiating the above expression with respect to
So, for
Now, it can be noted that, for
So, taking
Now, as for
then
which gives
So, from (3.1), it can be written that
proving the result.
Next one counter-example is given to show that the above theorem cannot be improved further to hazard rate ordering.
Geometric Distribution
Let
Now, if
Let,
The following theorem shows that under certain condition
Let,
Differentiating the above equation with respect to
So, for
So, for
proving the result.
Although there exists stochastic ordering between
Concluding Remarks
In this article, stochastic properties of extreme order statistics arising from independent and heterogeneous Poisson and geometric random variables are investigated using vector majorization of the distribution parameters. It is proved that if the vectors of means of two heterogeneous Poisson distributions are in majorization order, largest (smallest) order statistic of one system is stochastically larger (smaller) than the other system. Further, it is proved that if one set of vectors of failure probabilities from heterogeneous geometric distribution majorizes another, reliability of the parallel system formed by the former will always dominate that formed by the latter. On the other hand, hazard rate ordering is proved to exist between two series systems comprising of independent and heterogeneous geometric components under certain ordering conditions on the respective failure probabilities. As a scope for future research, it will be interesting to study the ordering properties of the extreme statistics of Poisson and geometric distributions under dependent set-up.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship and/or publication of this article.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
Funding
The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship and/or publication of this article.
