Who Should Go Home From Detention? The Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Probation Officers’ Recommendations to the Court

Abstract

Racial and ethnic disparities permeate juvenile justice outcomes. Yet, little is known about the decision-making processes that inform these outcomes, including the often-hidden recommendations probation officers make to the court regarding youth confinement. Using data from a juvenile court in a southwest city, we examine how mental health concerns, alleged gang affiliation, family challenges, and perceived dangerousness inform probation officers’ recommendations to the court and how these vary by youths’ race and ethnicity. We find that youth with these factors are more likely to be recommended for detention/commitment and residential treatment than be recommended for release to the home. Findings also show that the effect of these factors vary across youths’ race and ethnicity. The implications for policy and practice are discussed.

Keywords

juvenile court detention race disparities probation officers

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albonetti

C. A.

(1991). An integration of theories to explain judicial discretion. Social Problems, 38(2), 247–266.

Alvarez

Bachman

R. D.

(1996). American Indians and sentencing disparity: An Arizona test. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24(6), 549–561.

American Civil Liberties Union. (n.d.). America’s addiction to juvenile incarceration: State by State. Author. https://www.aclu.org/issues/juvenile-justice/youth-incarceration/americas-addiction-juvenile-incarceration-state-state

Annie E. Casey Foundation. (2019). Youth incarceration in the United States. Author. https://www.aecf.org/resources/youth-incarceration-in-the-united-states#findings-and-stats

Armstrong

G. S.

Rodriguez

(2005). Effects of individual and contextual characteristics on preadjudication detention of juvenile delinquents. Justice Quarterly, 22(4), 521–539.

Bishop

D. M.

Frazier

C. E.

(1996). Race effects in juvenile justice decision-making: Findings of a statewide analysis. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 86(2), 392.

Bishop

D. M.

Leiber

(2011). Race, ethnicity, and juvenile justice: Racial and ethnic differences in delinquency and justice system responses. In Bishop

Feld

(Eds.), Juvenile justice (pp. 445–484). Oxford University Press.

Black

Downie

(2010). Watch your language: A review of the use of stigmatizing language by Canadian judges. Journal of Ethics in Mental Health, 5, 1–8.

Bridges

G. S.

Steen

(1998). Racial disparities in official assessments of juvenile offenders: Attributional stereotypes as mediating mechanisms. American Sociological Review, 63, 554–570.

10.

Bushway

S. D.

Piehl

A. M.

(2001). Judging judicial discretion: Legal factors and racial discrimination in sentencing. Law and Society Review, 35(4), 733–764.

11.

Campbell

M. A.

Schmidt

(2000). Comparison of mental health and legal factors in the disposition outcome of young offenders. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 27(6), 688–715.

12.

Cappon

Vander Laenen

(2013). Mental health in juvenile judges’ decision-making: Review of literature. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 36(1), 65–72.

13.

Caudill

J. W.

Morris

R. G.

Sayed

S. E.

Yun

DeLisi

(2013). Pathways through the juvenile justice system: Predictors of formal disposition. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 11(3), 183–195.

14.

Caudill

J. W.

Trulson

C. R.

Marquart

J. W.

DeLisi

(2017). On gang affiliation, gang databases, and prosecutorial outcomes. Crime & Delinquency, 63(2), 210–229.

15.

Cauffman

Piquero

A. R.

Kimonis

Steinberg

Chassin

Fagan

(2007). Legal, individual, and environmental predictors of court disposition in a sample of serious adolescent offenders. Law and human behavior, 31(6), 519–535.

16.

Dierkhising

C. B.

Lane

Natsuaki

M. N.

(2014). Victims behind bars: A preliminary study of abuse during juvenile incarceration and post-release social and emotional functioning. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 20(2), 181.

17.

Feld

(1999). Bad kids: Race and the transformation of the juvenile court. Oxford University Press.

18.

Freiburger

T. L.

Hilinski

C. M.

(2011). Probation officers’ recommendations and final sentencing outcomes. Journal of Crime and Justice, 34(1), 45–61.

19.

Gaarder

Rodriguez

Zatz

M. S.

(2004). Criers, liars, and manipulators: Probation officers’ views of girls. Justice Quarterly, 21(3), 547–578.

20.

Gale-Bentz

Goldstein

N. E.

Cole

L. M.

Durham

(2019). Impact of community-based provider reports on juvenile probation officers’ recommendations: Effects of positive and negative framing on decision making. Law and Human Behavior, 43(2), 193.

21.

Galvin

M. A.

Ulmer

J. T.

(2021). Expanding our understanding of focal concerns: Alternative sentences, race, and “salvageability”. Justice Quarterly, 39(6), 1332–1353.

22.

Garcia-Leys

Brown

(2019). Analysis of the attorney general’s annual report on calgang for 2018. Urban Peace Institute.

23.

Goldman

Rodriguez

(2022). The State as the “ultimate parent”: The implications of family for racial and ethnic disparities in the juvenile justice system. Race and Justice, 12(4), 714–735.

24.

Guevara

Boyd

L. M.

Taylor

A. P.

Brown

R. A.

(2011). Racial disparities in juvenile court outcomes: A test of the liberation hypothesis. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 9(3), 200–217.

25.

Haney-López

(2000). Institutional racism: Judicial conduct and a new theory of racial discrimination. Yale Law Journal, 109, 1717–1884.

26.

Harris

(2009). Attributions and institutional processing: How focal concerns guide decision-making in the juvenile court. Race and Social Problems, 1, 243–256.

27.

Holman

Ziedenberg

(2007). The dangers of detention: The impact of incarcerating youth in detention and other secure facilities. Justice Policy Institute, Annie E. Casey Foundation. Retrieved August, 16, 2011.

28.

Johnson

B. D.

Betsinger

(2009). Punishing the “model minority”: Asian-American criminal sentencing outcomes in federal district courts. Criminology, 47(4), 1045–1090.

29.

Johnson

(2022). Gang databases: Race and the constitutional failures of contemporary gang policing in New York City. St. John’s Law Review, 94(4), 11.

30.

Kazdin

A. E.

(2000). Adolescent development, mental disorders, and decision making of delinquent youths. In Grisso

Schwartz

(Eds.), Youth on trial (pp. 33–65). University of Chicago Press.

31.

Kennedy

(2009). Gangs and public policy: Constructing and deconstructing gang databases. Criminology & Public Policy, 8, 711–716.

32.

Kutateladze

B. L.

Andiloro

N. R.

Johnson

B. D.

Spohn

C. C.

(2014). Cumulative disadvantage: Examining racial and ethnic disparity in prosecution and sentencing. Criminology, 52(3), 514–551.

33.

Leiber

M. J.

(2003). The context of juvenile justice decision-making: When race matters. State University of New York-Albany.

34.

Leiber

M. J.

Beaudry-Cyr

Peck

J. H.

Mack

K. Y.

(2018). Sentencing recommendations by probation officers and judges: An examination of adult offenders across gender. Women & Criminal Justice, 28(2), 100–124.

35.

Leiber

M. J.

Johnson

J. D.

(2008). Being young and black: What are their effects on juvenile justice decision making? Crime & Delinquency, 54(4), 560–581.

36.

Leiber

M. J.

Mack

K. Y.

(2003). The individual and joint effects of race, gender, and family status on juvenile justice decision-making. Journal of Research in Crime and delinquency, 40(1), 34–70.

37.

Leiber

M. J.

Reitzel

Mack

(2011). Probation officer recommendations for sentencing relative to judicial practice: The implications for African Americans. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 22(3), 301–329.

38.

Lowery

P. G.

Burrow

J. D.

Kaminski

R. J.

(2018). A multilevel test of the racial threat hypothesis in one state’s juvenile court. Crime & Delinquency, 64(1), 53–87.

39.

Lyons

J. S.

Royce Baerger

Quigley

Erlich

Griffin

(2001). Mental health service needs of juvenile offenders: A comparison of detention, incarceration, and treatment settings. Children’s Services: Social Policy, Research, and Practice, 4, 69–85.

40.

Mears

D. P.

Cochran

J. C.

Stults

B. J.

Greenman

S. J.

Bhati

A. S.

Greenwald

M. A.

(2014). The “true” juvenile offender: Age effects and juvenile court sanctioning. Criminology, 52(2), 169–194.

41.

Miethe

T. D.

McCorkle

R. C.

(1997). Gang membership and criminal processing: A test of the “master status” concept. Justice Quarterly, 14(3), 407–427.

42.

Morrow

W. J.

Dario

L. M.

Rodriguez

(2015). Examining the prevalence of a ‘youth discount’ in the juvenile justice system. Journal of Crime and Justice, 38(4), 473–490.

43.

Oglesby-Neal

Peterson

(2021). Influence of race in the deep end of the juvenile justice system. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 19(2), 186–205.

44.

Paternoster

Brame

Mazerolle

Piquero

(1998). Using the correct statistical test for the equality of regression coefficients. Criminology, 36(4), 859–866.

45.

Pescosolido

B. A.

Fettes

D. L.

Martin

J. K.

Monahan

McLeod

J. D.

(2007). Perceived dangerousness of children with mental health problems and support for coerced treatment. Psychiatric Services, 58(5), 619–625.

46.

Pilnik

Schwartz

K. L.

Feierman

Sorenson

(2019). Transforming justice: Bringing Pennsylvania’s young people safely home from juvenile justice placements. Juvenile Law Center.

47.

Pullmann

M. D.

Heflinger

C. A.

(2009). Community determinants of substance abuse treatment referrals from juvenile courts: Do rural youths have equal access? Journal of Child & Adolescent Substance Abuse, 18(4), 359–378.

48.

Rodriguez

(2010). The cumulative effect of race and ethnicity in juvenile court outcomes and why preadjudication detention matters. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 47(3), 391–413.

49.

Rodriguez

(2013). Concentrated disadvantage and the incarceration of youth: Examining how context affects juvenile justice. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 50(2), 189–215.

50.

Rodriguez

Smith

Zatz

M. S.

(2009). “Youth is enmeshed in a highly dysfunctional family system”: Exploring the relationship among dysfunctional families, parental incarceration, and juvenile court decision making. Criminology, 47(1), 177–208.

51.

Rodriguez

Webb

V. J.

(2007). Probation violations, revocations, and imprisonment: The decisions of probation officers, prosecutors, and judges pre-and post-mandatory drug treatment. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 18(1), 3–30.

52.

Rovner

(2021). Racial disparities in youth incarceration persists. The Sentencing Project.

53.

Schlesinger

(2005). Racial and ethnic disparity in pretrial criminal processing. Justice Quarterly, 22(2), 170–192.

54.

Schwalbe

C. S.

Hatcher

S. S.

Maschi

(2009). The effects of treatment needs and prior social services use on juvenile court decision making. Social Work Research, 33, 31–40.

55.

Shelden

R. G.

Snodgrass

(1992). Comparing gang and non-gang offenders: Some tentative findings. Gang Journal, 1(1), 73–86.

56.

Shook

J. J.

Goodkind

S. A.

(2009). Racial disproportionality in juvenile justice: The interaction of race and geography in pretrial detention for violent and serious offenses. Race and Social Problems, 1(4), 257–266.

57.

Shufelt

J. L.

Cocozza

J. J.

(2006). Youth with mental health disorders in the juvenile justice system: Results from a multi-state prevalence study (pp. 1–6). National Center for Mental Health and Juvenile Justice.

58.

Spinney

Yeide

Feyerherm

Cohen

Stephenson

Thomas

(2016). Racial disparities in referrals to mental health and substance abuse services from the juvenile justice system: A review of the literature. Journal of Crime and Justice, 39(1), 153–173.

59.

Spohn

Holleran

(2000). The imprisonment penalty paid by young, unemployed black and Hispanic male offenders. Criminology, 38(1), 281–306.

60.

Steffensmeier

Painter-Davis

Ulmer

(2017). Intersectionality of race, ethnicity, gender, and age on criminal punishment. Sociological Perspectives, 60(4), 810–833.

61.

Steffensmeier

Ulmer

Kramer

(1998). The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology, 36(4), 763–798.

62.

Torbet

P. M.

(1996). Juvenile probation: The workhorse of the juvenile justice system. US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

63.

Tracy

P. E.

(2002). Decision making and juvenile justice: An analysis of bias in case processing. Praeger.

64.

Trejos-Castillo

Lopoo

Dwivedi

(2020). Learned helplessness, criminalization, and victimization in vulnerable youth. The Square-One Project.

65.

Ulmer

Painter-Davis

Tinik

(2016). Disproportional imprisonment of Black and Hispanic males: Sentencing discretion, processing outcomes, and policy structures. Justice Quarterly, 33(4), 642–681.

66.

Walker

D. A.

Cesar

G. T.

(2020). Examining the “gang penalty” in the juvenile justice system: A focal concerns perspective. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 18, 315–336.

67.

Ward

G. K.

(2012). The Black child-savers. University of Chicago Press.

68.

Ward

G. K.

Kupchik

(2010). What drives juvenile probation officers? Relating organizational contexts, status characteristics, and personal convictions to treatment and punishment orientations. Crime & Delinquency, 56(1), 35–69.

69.

Wasserman

G. A.

McReynolds

L. S.

Schwalbe

C. S.

Keating

J. M.

Jones

S. A.

(2010). Psychiatric disorder, comorbidity, and suicidal behavior in juvenile justice youth. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 37(12), 1361–1376.

70.

White

(2016). Incarcerating youth with mental health problems: A focus on the intersection f race, ethnicity, and mental illness. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 14(4), 426–447.

71.

Wilmot

K. A.

Delone

M. A.

(2010). Sentencing of Native Americans: A multistage analysis under the Minnesota sentencing guidelines. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 8(3), 151–180.

72.

Wooldredge

(2007). Neighborhood effects on felony sentencing. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 44(2), 238–263.

73.

Wooldredge

Frank

Goulette

(2017). Ecological contributors to disparities in bond amounts and pretrial detention. Crime & Delinquency, 63(13), 1682–1711.

74.

Zane

S. N.

Welsh

B. C.

Mears

D. P.

Zimmerman

G. M.

(2021). Pathways through juvenile justice: A system-level assessment of cumulative disadvantage in the processing of juvenile offenders. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 38, 483–514.