Evaluation of the Texas Correctional Substance Abuse Treatment Initiative: The Impact of Policy Research

Abstract

An evaluation of the first Texas correctional therapeutic community substance abuse program indicated that recidivism was significantly reduced for offenders completing treatment. However, a large number of offenders did not complete treatment and those persons had recidivism rates comparable to those not participating. Rapid expansion of these programs caused problems associated with client selection, program consistency, and retention in treatment. Research showed that the operational “nuts and bolts” were not in place to effectively expand these programs from 5,000 beds to the originally planned 14,000 beds. Based on these findings, the Texas Legislature decided against expansion.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Condelli, Ward S. and George DeLeon . 1993. “Fixed and Dynamic Predictors of Client Retention in Therapeutic Communities.” Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 10:11-16.

Criminal Justice Policy Council . 1993. Estimating Cost-Effectiveness of the In-Prison Therapeutic Community Program. Unpublished report, State of Texas, Austin, Texas.

Criminal Justice Policy Council . 1994. Projected Demand for Substance Abuse Felony Punishment Facility Beds. Austin, TX: State of Texas.

DeLeon, George . 1993. “Technical Assistance Report to the Commission on Alcohol and Drug Abuse.” New York, October.

DeLeon, George and Nancy Jainchill . 1986. “Circumstances, Motivation, Readiness, and Stability as Correlates of Treatment Tenure.” Journal of Psychoactive Drugs 18:203-208.

Fabelo, Tony . 1994. “Sentencing Reform in Texas: Can Criminal Justice Research Inform Public Policy?” Crime & Delinquency 40:282-294.

Hubbard, Robert L. , Mary Ellen Marsden , J. Valley Rachal , Henrick J. Harwood , Elizabeth R. Cavanaugh , and Harold M. Ginzburg . 1989. Drug Abuse Treatment: A National Study of Effectiveness. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.

Judicial Advisory Council . 1995. Resolution to the Criminal Justice Policy Council Supporting the Expansion of SAFP. Austin, TX: Community Justice Assistance Division, Texas Department of Criminal Justice.

Martin, Steve S. 1992. “Strategies for Implementing TC's in Prison Settings: What Has Been Learned from Recent Research.” Paper presented at the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences meeting, Pittsburgh, March.

10.

Shapiro, Steve . 1989. Treatment Options for Drug-Dependent Offenders: A Policy Overview. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Assistance.

11.

Simpson, D. Dwayne and George W. Joe . 1993. “Motivation as a Predictor of Early Drop-out from Drug Abuse Treatment.” Psychotherapy 30:357-368.

12.

Texas Commission on Alcohol and Drug Abuse . 1990. Substance Abuse Among Texas Department of Corrections Inmates, 1988. Austin, TX: State of Texas.

13.

U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice . 1992. Drug Use Forecasting: 1992 Annual Report Drugs and Crimes in America's Cities. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

14.

Wexler, Harry K. , Gregory Falkin , and Douglas Lipton . 1990. “Outcome Evaluation of a Prison Therapeutic Community for Substance Abuse Treatment.” Criminal Justice and Behavior 17:71-92.

15.

White, Jerry . 1993. “Inmates Given Tools to Rebuild Their Lives.” Austin American-Statesman, November 21, Section A, p.1.