Post-occupancy evaluation (POE) is defined as examination of the effectiveness for human users of occupied, designed environments. POEs generally focus on a single type of designed setting, tend to describe rather than manipulate, and are usually aimed at application. Within this wide focus, POEs vary considerably, and three conceptual dimensions-generality, breadth of focus, and applicability-are useful in cataloguing them. These dimensions are described and their implications for POE sponsorship and methods are discussed. Suggestions are proposed for future developments of the field.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALTMAN, I. (1975) The Environment and Social Behavior. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
2.
American Institute of Architects Research Corporation (1977) Post-Occupancy Evaluation: Final Report on an Interagency Project. Washington, DC: Author.
3.
BECHTEL, R. B. and R. K. SRIVASTAVA (1978) "Post occupancy evaluation of housing." Report submitted to the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
4.
BECKER, F. D. (1975) "Design for living: the residents' view of multi-family housing." Final report submitted to the New York State Urban Development Corporation Department of Design and Environmental Analysis, College of Human Ecology, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.
5.
BRILL, M. (1974) "Evaluating buildings on a performance basis" in J. Langet al. (eds.) Designing for Human Behavior. Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross.
6.
BROOKES, M. and A. KAPLAN (1972) "Office environments: space planning and effective behavior."Human Facto?-s14: 373-391.
7.
CARSON, D. H. , F. CARSON, S. T. MARGULIS, and R. WEHRLI (1980) "Post-occupancy evaluation: a practical strategy for obtaining control groups."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
8.
CONWAY, D. , J. ZEISEL, P. WELCH, P. CLAYTON, and P. HEINIG (1977) Radiation Therapy Facilities: Social and Behavioral Issues for Design. Bethesda, MD: National Institutes of Health.
9.
COOK, T. and D. CAMPBELL (1979) Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis for Field Settings. Skokie, IL: Rand McNally.
10.
COOPER, C. C. (1975) Easter Hill Village. New York: Free Press.
11.
DEVLIN, A. S. (1980) "Housing for the elderly: cognitive considerations."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
12.
FARBSTEIN, J. (1979) Personal communication (September).
13.
FARRENKOPF, T. and V. ROTH (1980) "The university faculty office as an environment."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
14.
FRANCESCATO, G. , S. WEIDEMANN, J. R. ANDERSON, and R. CHENOWETH (1979) Resident Satisfaction in HUD Assisted Housing: Design and Management Factors. Washington, DC: Department of Housing and Urban Development.
15.
FRIEDMANN, A. , C. ZIMRING, and E. ZUBE (1978) Environmental Design Evaluation. New York: Plenum.
16.
GUTMAN, R. and B. WESTERGAARD (1 974) "Building evaluation, user satisfaction and design," in J. Langet al. (eds.) Designing for Human Behavior. Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross.
17.
HOWELL, S. and G. EPP (1978) Private Space: Habitability of Apartments for the Elderly. Cambridge, MA: MIT Department of Architecture.
18.
HOWELL, S. , J. E. REIZENSTEIN, and C. ALBRIGHT (1976) Shared Spaces in Housing for the Elderly. Cambridge, MA: MIT Department of Architecture.
19.
KANTROWITZ, M. and R. NORDHAUS (1980) "The impact of post-occupancy evaluation research: a case study."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
20.
KAPLAN, R. (1980) "Citizen participation in the design and evaluation of a park."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
21.
KEYS, C. R. and R. E. WENER (1980) "Organizational intervention issues: a fourphase approach to post-occupancy evaluation."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
22.
KNIGHT, R. C. and D. E. CAMPBELL (1980) "Environmental evaluation research: evaluator roles and inherent social commitments."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
23.
KNIGHT, R. C. , W. H. WEITZER, and C. M. ZIMRING (1978) Opportunity for Control and the Built Environment: The ELEMR Project. Amherst, MA: The Environmental Institute, Univ. of Massachusetts.
24.
MARCUS, C. C. (1978) "Evaluation: a tale of two spaces."AIA J. (August): 34.
25.
McCAIN, G. , V. C. COX, and P. B. PAULUS (1976) "The relationship between illness complaints and degree of crowding in a prison environment."Environment and Behavior8: 283-290.
26.
McLAUGHLIN, H. (1979) "Notes on research in practice."J. of Architectural Education: 32.
27.
MICHELSON, W. [ed.] (1975) Behavioral Research Methods in Environmental Design. Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross.
28.
MOORE, R. C. and H. WONG (1976) Curricularscapes. San Francisco: Chevron.
29.
MURTHA, M. (1979) Feasibility Study on Improving Access to Information about the Impact of the Built Environment on the Health and Lives of People: Final Report Submitted to the National Institutes for Mental Health. Washington, DC: Association for the Study of Man-Environment Relations.
30.
OSTRANDER, E. R. , assisted by B. R. CONNELL (1975) "Definition of linking experiments in post-construction evaluation."Cornell University, Ithaca; New York.
31.
OSTRANDER, E. R. and B. R. CONNELL (1976) "Maximizing cost-benefits of post-construction evaluation," in P. Suedfeld and J. Russell (eds.) The Behavioral Basis of Design, Book 1: Selected Papers. Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross.
32.
PAULUS, P. B. , A. B. ANNIS, and J. J. SETA (1976) "Density does affect task performance."Personality and Social Psychology, 34: 248-253.
33.
PAULUS, P. B. , V. C. COX, G. McCAIN, and J. CHANDLER (1975) "Some effects of crowding in a prison environment."Applied Social Psychology, 5: 86-91.
34.
REDE [Research and Design Institute] (1974) Butterfield Hall Evaluation Report. Providence, RI: Author.
35.
REIN, M. (1976) Social Science and Public Policy. New York: Penguin.
36.
REIZENSTEIN, J. E. (1980) "The importance of presentation format."Environment and Behavior12, 4.
37.
REIZENSTEIN, J. E. (1979) "Changing the definition of design decision-making as a way of increasing use of post-occupancy evaluation findings." Presented at the Tenth Annual Meeting of the Environmental Design Research Association, Buffalo, New York.
38.
REIZENSTEIN, J. E. (1975) "Linking social research and design."J. of Architectural Research4: 3.
39.
REIZENSTEIN, J. E. and W. McBRIDE (1977) Designing for Mentally Retarded People: A Social-Environmental Evaluation of New England Villages, Inc.Springfield, VA: National Technical Information Service. (PB291895)
40.
REIZENSTEIN, J. E. and E. R. OSTRANDER (forthcoming) "Design for independence: a condensed post-occupancy evaluation of housing for the severely disabled."Environment and Behavior.
41.
SNYDER, P. Z. , E. K. SADALLA, and D. STEA (1976) "Sociocultural modification and user needs in Navajo housing,"J. of Architectural Research5: 3.
42.
TOCH, H. (1969) Violent Men. Chicago: AVC.
43.
WEISMAN, J. (forthcoming) "Way-finding in the built environment: an evaluation of architectural legibility."Environment and Behavior.
44.
WENER, R. E. and R. V. OLSEN (1980) "Innovative correctional environments: a user assessment."Environment and Behavior.
45.
WINEMAN, J. (n.d.) Personal communication.
46.
ZEISEL, J. (1975) Sociology and Architectural Design. New York: Russell Sage.
47.
ZEISEL, J. and M. GRIFFIN (1975) Charlesview Housing: A Diagnostic Evaluation, Cambridge, MA: Architecture Research Office, Harvard Graduate School of Design.
48.
ZEISEL, J. , G. EPP, and S. DEMOS (1 977) Low Rise Housing for the Elderly. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
49.
ZUBE, E. , J. CRYSTAL, and J. PALMER (1976) Vistor Center Design Evaluation. Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts, Institute for Man and Environment.
