Motivation for weight-loss diets: A clustering,longitudinal field study using self-esteem and self-determination theory perspectives

Abstract

Background Gradual elevation of body weight leads numerous individuals to dieting and weight loss behaviours. Nevertheless, the prevalence of obesity continues to rise in industrialised countries. The examination of the motivational determinants of dietary modification (‘dieting’) in order to identify clusters of individuals in the first 6 months of their effort to control body weight was the aim of the current study. The theories of self-determination and self-esteem formation guided our analysis.

Methods A longitudinal study was conducted with three data collection points (N₁=256; N₂=135; N₃=75). Data were responses on the Treatment Self Regulation Questionnaire, Social Physique Anxiety Scale, Physical Self-Description Questionnaire, Kaiser Physical Activity Survey Questionnaire, and items assessing expectations of achievement and self-confidence.

Results Cluster analyses provided stable and validated cluster profiles for all data sets. In the 1st and 2nd data sets, results revealed three groups of dieters labelled as ‘media victims’, ‘try to feel nice’ and ‘older and experienced’. For the 3rd data set, results supported a 4-group solution (‘less adaptive profile’, ‘second successful dieters’, ‘successful dieters’, and ‘unsuccessful dieters’). The need for autonomous versus controlling dieting reasons based on Self-Determination Theory, along with the need for an alternative paradigm in weight management, are proposed. Conclusions Psychological theories of self-determination and self-esteem provide important ways of understanding and identifying adaptive and less adaptive weight control strategies.

Keywords

motivation self-determination cluster analysis self-esteem physical activity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Miller WC . Fitness and fatness in relation to health: Implications for a paradigm shift . Journal of Social Issues, 1999: 55(2): 207-219 .

Polivy J , Herman CB . Dieting and its relation to eating disorders. In: KD Brownell , CG Fairburn (Eds), Eating Disorders and Obesity: A Comprehensive Handbook (pp.83-86). New York: The Guilford Press , 1995.

Garner DM , Wooley SC . Confronting the failure of behavioural and dietary treatments for obesity . Clinical Psychology Review, 1991: 11: 729-780 .

Goldstein DJ . Beneficial effects of modest weight loss . International Journal of Obesity, 1992: 16: 397-415 .

National Task Force on the Prevention and Treatment of Obesity . Weight cycling . Journal of the American Medical Association, 1994: 272: 1196-1202 .

Devlin MJ , Yanovski SZ , Wilson GT . Obesity: What mental health professionals need to know . American Journal of Psychiatry, 2000: 157(6): 854-866 .

Deci EL , Ryan RM . Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior. New York: Plenum Press , 1985.

Ryan RM , Deci EL . Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development and well-being . American Psychologist, 2000: 55(1): 68-78 .

Deci EL , Ryan RM . The support of autonomy and the control of behavior . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1987: 53: 1024-1037 .

10.

Strong KG , Huon GF . Motivational processes and the persistence of weight-loss dieting . British Journal of Health Psychology, 1999: 4: 151-163 .

11.

Williams GC , Grow VM , Freedman ZR , Ryan RM , Deci EL . Motivational predictors of weight loss and weight-loss maintenance . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996: 70(1): 115-126 .

12.

Vallerand RJ . Toward a hierarchical model of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. In: MP Zanna (Ed), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 29 (pp.271-360). New York: Academic Press , 1997.

13.

Marlatt GA . Relapse: A cognitive-behavioral therapy. In: KD Brownell , CG Fairburn (Eds), Eating Disorders and Obesity: A Comprehensive Handbook (pp.541-546). New York: The Guilford Press , 1995.

14.

Vitousek KB . Cognitive-behavioral therapy for anorexia nervosa. In: KD Brownell , CG Fairburn (Eds), Eating Disorders and Obesity: A Comprehensive Handbook (pp.324-329). New York: The Guilford Press , 1995.

15.

Deci EL , Flaste R . Why We Do What We Do: Understanding Self-motivation. New York: Grosset-Putman , 1995.

16.

Ravussin E . Energy expenditure and body weight. In: KD Brownell , CG Fairburn (Eds), Eating Disorders and Obesity: A Comprehensive Handbook (pp.32-37). New York: The Guilford Press , 1995.

17.

Blair SN . Measurement of physical activity. In: KD Brownell , CG Fairburn (Eds), Eating Disorders and Obesity: A Comprehensive Handbook (pp.111-116). New York: The Guilford Press , 1995.

18.

Bouchard C , Despres JP , Tremblay A . Exercise and obesity . Obesity Research, 1993: 1: 133-147 .

19.

Grundy SM , Blackburn G , Higgins M , Lauer R , Perri MG , Ryan D . Physical activity in the prevention and treatment of obesity and its comorbidities . Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 1999: 31(11): S502-S508 .

20.

Crocker J , Major B , Steele C . Social stigma. In: DT Gilbert , ST Fiske , L Gardner (Eds), The Handbook of Social Psychology, Vol. 2, 4th Edition (pp.504-553). New York: McGraw-Hill , 1998.

21.

Fox KR . The physical self and processes in self-esteem development. In: KR Fox (Ed), The Physical Self: From Motivation to Well-being (pp.111-139). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics , 1997.

22.

Page A , Fox KR . Adolescent weight management and the physical self. In: KR Fox (Ed), The Physical Self: From Motivation to Well-being (pp.229-256). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics , 1997.

23.

Miller CT , Downey KT . A meta-analysis of heavyweight and self-esteem . Personality and Social Psychology Review, 1999: 3(1): 68-84 .

24.

Hart EA , Leary MR , Rejeski WJ . The measurement of social physique anxiety . Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1989: 11: 94-104 .

25.

Bain LL , Wilson T , Chaikind E . Participant perceptions of exercise programmes for overweight women . Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 1989: 60: 134-143 .

26.

McAuley E , Bane SM , Rudolph DL , Lox CL . Physique anxiety and exercise in middle-aged adults . Journal of Gerontology, 1995: 5: 229-235 .

27.

Treasure DC , Lox CL , Lawton BR . Determinants of physical activity in a sedentary, obese female population . Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1998: 20: 218, 224 .

28.

Vallerand RJ , Losier GF . An integrative analysis of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in sport . Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 1999: 11: 142-169 .

29.

Bouchard C , Bray GA . Introduction. In: C Bouchard , GA Bray (Eds), Regulation of Body Weight: Biological and Behavioral Mechanisms (pp.1-13). New York: Wiley , 1996.

30.

Garrow JS . Obesity. In: JS Garrow , WPT James , A Ralph (Eds), Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 10th Edition (pp.527-545). London: Churchill Livingstone Press , 2000.

31.

Declaration of Common Acceptance. Dietary Fat, Mediterranean Diet and Good Health for Life . International Congress for Mediterranean Diet 2000, Royal College of Physicians, London, UK, 2000.

32.

Ryan RM , Connell JP . Perceived locus of causality and internalisation: Examining reasons for acting in two domains . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1989: 57: 749-761 .

33.

Motl RW , Conroy DE . Validity and factorial invariance of the social physique anxiety scale . Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2000: 32(5): 1007-1017 .

34.

Marsh HW , Richards G , Johnson S , Roshe L , Tremayne P . Physical Self-Description Questionnaire: Psychometric properties and a multitrait-multimethod analysis of relations to existing instruments . Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1994: 16: 270-305 .

35.

Zahariadis P , Tsorbatzoudis H . A preliminary examination on high-school students self-concept. Exercise & Society , Journal of Sports Science, 2000: 25: 227 .

36.

Ainsworth BE , Sternfeld B , Richardson MT , Jackson K . Evaluation of the Kaiser Physical Activity Survey in women . Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2000: 32(7): 1327-1338 .

37.

Baecke JAH , Burema J , Fritjers JER . A short questionnaire for the measurement of habitual physical activity in epidemiological studies . American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1982: 36: 936-942 .

38.

Westerterp KR . Assessment of physical activity level in relation to obesity: Current evidence and research issues . Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 1999: 31(11): S547-S552 .

39.

Hair JF , Black WC . Cluster analysis. In: LG Grimm , PR Yarnold (Eds), Reading and Understanding More Multivariate Statistics (pp.147-205). New York: American Psychological Association , 2000.

40.

Aldenderfer MS , Blashfield RK . Cluster Analysis. Newbury Park, CA: Sage , 1984.

41.

Harter S . Historical roots of contemporary issues involving the self-concept. In: BA Bracken (Ed), Handbook of Self-Concept: Developmental, Social and Clinical Considerations (pp.1-37). New York: Wiley , 1996.

42.

Punj G , Stewart DW . Cluster analysis in marketing research: Review and suggestions for application . Journal of Marketing Research, 1983: 20: 134-148 .

43.

Sternfeld B , Ainsworth BE , Quesenberry CP Jr . Physical activity patterns in diverse population of women . Preventive Medicine, 1999: 28: 313-323 .

44.

Sonstroem RJ . The physical self-system: The mediator of exercise and self-esteem. In: KR Fox (Ed), The Physical Self: From Motivation to Well-being (pp.3-26). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics , 1997.

45.

Marsh HW . The measurement of physical self-concept: A construct validation approach. In: KR Fox (Ed), The Physical Self: From Motivation to Well-being (pp.27-58). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics , 1997.

46.

Davis C . Body image, exercise and eating behaviors. In: KR Fox (Ed), The Physical Self: From Motivation to Well-being (pp.143-174). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics , 1997.

47.

Jebb SA , Moore MS . Contribution of a sedentary lifestyle and inactivity to the etiology of overweight and obesity: Current evidence and research issues . Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 1999: 31(11): S534-S541 .

48.

Williamson DF , Madans J , Anda RF , Kleinman JC , Kahn HS , Byers T . Recreational physical activity and 10-year weight change in a US national cohort . International Journal of Obesity, 1993: 17: 279-286 .