The military influence on engineering education in Britain and India,1848

Abstract

The original colleges for military engineers—the Royal Military Academy (RMA) Woolwich and the East India Company (EIC) Seminary at Addiscombe—were the only outlet for a curriculum based on the theory and practice of engineering taught within an academically orientated institution in Britain during the nineteenth century. Overall, engineering in Britain was taught through work-related traditional apprenticeship systems that focused on the ‘practical man’ concept, supported from 1853 onwards with funding based on a payments-by-results system administered by the Department of Science and Art. This trend continued despite the introduction of modest engineering faculties within the British university system. In India, matters were different: there were four colleges of civil engineering, the oldest, Thomason College, having been founded in 1847. Their role was to provide civil engineers for the Indian Public Works Department. Both in Britain and in India, the administration and management of science, technical and engineering education was undertaken by officers from the Royal Engineers and the Indian Army equivalent, (commonly referred to as sapper officers). This trend in civil/military relationships continued with the establishment of the Royal Indian Engineering College (also known as Cooper’s Hill College) in 1870, specifically to train civil engineers in England for duties with the Indian Public Works Department. The comparisons between engineering education in Britain and India during the nineteenth century are stark. The role of the military in the development of engineering education both in Britain and India was crucial. The Indian Public Works Department, although technically a civilian organisation, relied on military engineers during its life until 1947. An examination of the topic from both the British and Indian perspective gives an insight not only into comparative engineering education but also into the civil/military relationships that existed in Britain and India during the latter half of the nineteenth century.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

HMSO Minutes of Evidence of the Committee of Inquiry into the RIEC, (Cd 2056) 1904.

Cameron Taylor, A. General Sir Alex Taylor GCB: His Times, His Friends, and His Work, London , 1913.

Cameron, J.G. The Royal Indian Engineering College Cooper’s Hill 1871–1906, London , 1960.

Calcutta Review,‘ Report of the Commissioners of Inquiry into Indian Accounts’, Gazette of India Extraordinary , 25 October, Vol. XL, 1864, pp. 419–51 .

Chesney, G. ‘ Economics of the Public Works Department, India ’, Calcutta Review, Vol. 64, 1859, pp. 344–79 .

The Nature and Status of Education and Status of Civil Engineers in the United Kingdom and in Foreign Countries, Report, 1870, pp. viii–xi.

ICE Proceedings 1902–03, Vol. 151, pp. 422–23, Obituary of Rai Madhub Chunder Roy Bahadoor.

Engineering, 3 April 1907, p. 9.

The National Archives Kew, London.

10.

Records of the Royal Military Academy, 1742–1892.

11.

Bailey, F. ‘ The Indian Forestry School ’, The Royal Engineers Journal, 2 November 1885.

12.

His Majesty’s Stationery Office (HMSO), (Cd 2056), 1904, East India [Royal Indian Engineering College (RIEC)], Minutes of Evidence taken before the Committee into the expediency of maintaining the Royal Indian Engineering College and other matters.

13.

The Royal Engineers Journal, 2 July 1894, obituary of General Robert Maclagan RE .

14.

The Royal Engineers Journal, June 1912, Memoir of General Sir Alexander Taylor GCB RE (Bengal ), pp. 401–14 .

15.

Sandes, Lt Col E.W.C. ‘ The Thomason College, Roorkee ’, The Royal Engineers Journal, Vol. XXXIX, 1925, pp. 540–48 .

16.

Argles, M. South Kensington to Robbins, London , 1964.

17.

Armytage, W.H.G. Four Hundred Years of English Education, Cambridge , 1965.

18.

Barnett, C. The Audit of War, London , 1990.

19.

Black, J. ‘ A More Vigorous Prosecution of Public Works: The Reforms of the Indian Public Works Department ’, Accounting History NS, Vol. 6> (2), 2001, pp. 91–119 .

20.

Brock, M.G. ‘A Plastic Structure’, in M.G. Brock and M.C. Curthoys , eds, The History of Oxford University, Vol. VII, Nineteenth Century Oxford, Part 2, Oxford , 2000, pp. 3–66.

21.

Buchanan, R.A. ‘Engineers and Government’, in R. MacLeod , ed., Government and Expertise, Specialists, Administrators and Professionals, 1860–1919, London , 2003, pp. 41–58.

22.

Coleman, D.C. ‘ Gentlemen and Players ’, Economic History Review, XXIV,second series 26, 1973, pp. 92–116 .

23.

Cuddy, B.P. and Mansell, T. ‘ Engineers for India: The Royal Indian Engineering College at Cooper’s Hill ’, History of Education Journal, Vol. 23 (1), 1994, pp. 107–23 .

24.

Farrington, A.J. Records of the East India College, Haileybury and Other Institutions, London , 1976.

25.

Foden, F.E. ‘ Popular Science Examinations of the Nineteenth Century ’, Journal of the Royal Institute of Chemistry, Vol. 87, January, 1963, pp. 6–9 .

26.

Gay, H. The History of Imperial College London 1907–2007, London , 2007.

27.

Howarth, J. ‘Oxford for the Arts: The Natural Sciences, 1880–1914’, in M.G. Brock and M.C. Curthoys , eds, The History of the University of Oxford, Vol II, Nineteenth Century Oxford, Part 2, Oxford , 2000a, pp. 457–97.

28.

Howarth, J. ‘The Self Governing University 1882–1914’, in M.G. Brock and M.C. Curthoys , eds, The History of the University of Oxford, Vol. II, Nineteenth Century Oxford, Part 2, Oxford 2000b, pp. 599–643.

29.

Mital, K. The History of Thomason College of India, Roorkee , 1986.

30.

Percival Spear, T.G. A History of India Vol. 2 From the Sixteenth Century to the Twentieth Century, London , 1990.

31.

Pollard, S. The Genesis of Modern Management, London , 1966.

32.

Richards, S. ‘ The South-Eastern Agricultural College and Public Support for Technical Education, 1894–1914 ’, Agricultural History Review, 36 (II), 1979, pp. 172–87 .

33.

Rothblatt, S. The Revolution of the Dons: Cambridge and Society in Victorian England, Cambridge , 1981.

34.

Sharp, P.R. ‘ The Entry of County Councils into English Educational Administration, 1889 ’, Journal of Educational Administration and History, Vol. 1, 1968, pp. 14–22 .

35.

Sharp, P.R. ‘ Whisky Money and the Development of Technical and Secondary Education in the 1890s ’, Journal of Educational Administration and History, Vol. 4, 1971, pp. 31–36 .

36.

Symonds, R. ‘Oxford and Empire’, in M.G. Brock and M.C. Curthoys , eds, The History of Oxford University, Vol. VII, Nineteenth Century Oxford, Part 2, Oxford, 2000, pp. 698–761.

37.

Walker, E.G. William Cawthorne Unwin, London , 1938.

38.

Wells, H.G. An Experiment in Autobiography, Vol. 1, London , 1934.

The military influence on engineering education in Britain and India,1848–1906

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References