A growing number of economists blame the length and severity of the Great Depression on factors that rigidified wage rates, raised production costs, and interfered with the market allocation of labor. The target of their critique is President Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal labor program, which they portray as creating a series of large negative supply shocks through encouragement of unions, minimum wages, unemployment insurance, and other anticompetitive industrial relations practices. The author uses a combination of institutiognal and Keynesian theory to present the other side of the story. Drawing principally from the works of J. R. Commons and J. M. Keynes, he develops both a spending and a productivity rationale for stable wages during the Great Depression and demonstrates that the New Deal's interventionist labor program was on balance necessary and beneficial. He also highlights the neglected macro-economic dimension of industrial relations theory and policy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdelsteinRichard. 1991. “The nation as an economic unit”: Keynes, Roosevelt, and the managerial ideal. Journal of American History78(1): 160–87.
2.
AkerlofGeorgeYellenJanet. 1990. The fair wage-effort hypothesis and unemployment. Quarterly Journal of Economics105(May):255–84.
3.
AltmanMorris. 2004. Why unemployment insurance might not only be good for the soul, it might also be good for the economy. Review of Social Economy62(4): 517–41.
4.
AtkinsonGlenOlesonTheodoreJr.1998. Commons and Keynes: Their assault on laissez-faire. Journal of Economic Issues32(December):1019–30.
5.
BalderstonCanby. 1935. Executive Guidance of Industrial Relations. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
6.
BaliscianoMarcia. 1998. Hope for America: American notions of economic planning between pluralism and neoclassicism, 1930–1950. In MorganMaryRutherfordMalcolm (Eds.), From Interwar Pluralism to Postwar Neoclassicism, pp. 153–78. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
7.
BarberWilliam. 1985. From New Era to New Deal: Herbert Hoover, the Economists, and American Economic Policy, 1921–1933. New York: Cambridge University Press.
8.
BernankeBen. 2000. Essays on the Great Depression. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
9.
BernsteinIrving. 1960. The Lean Years: A History of the American Worker, 1920–1933. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
10.
BernsteinIrving. 1970. The Turbulent Years: A History of the American Worker, 1933–1941. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
11.
BewleyTruman. 1999. Why Wages Don't Fall During a Recession. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
12.
BrodyDavid. 1980. Workers in Industrial America: Essays on the Twentieth Century Struggle. New York: Oxford University Press.
13.
CalomirisCharles. 2007. A raw deal: Reconsidering the Great Depression. Foreign Affairs86(5): 141–46.
14.
ChariV.KehoePatrickMcGrattanEllen. 2003. Accounting for the Great Depression. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review27(2): 2–8.
15.
ColeHaroldOhanianLee. 2011. Stimulus and the depression: The untold story. Wall Street Journal (September 26).
16.
CommonsJohn. 1909. American shoemakers, 1648–1895. Quarterly Journal of Economics24(4): 39–83.
17.
CommonsJohn. 1911. Unions and Efficiency. American Economic Review1(3): 463–72.
18.
CommonsJohn. 1919. Industrial Goodwill. New York: McGraw-Hill.
19.
CommonsJohn. 1921. Industrial relations. In CommonsJ. (Ed.), Trade Unionism and Labor Problems, 2nd series, pp. 1–16. Boston: Ginn (reprinted by Augustus Kelly, 1967).
20.
CommonsJohn. 1923a. Unemployment prevention and insurance. In EdieL. (Ed.), Big Business: Economic Power in a Free Society, pp. 164–205. New York: Macmillan.
21.
CommonsJohn. 1923b. Hobson's “Economics of Unemployment.”American Economic Review13(4): 638–47.
22.
CommonsJohn. 1923c. Wage theories and wage policies. American Economic Review13(1): 110–17.
23.
CommonsJohn. 1924. The Legal Foundations of Capitalism. New York: Macmillan.
24.
CommonsJohn. 1934. Institutional Economics: Its Place in Political Economy. New York: Macmillan.
25.
CommonsJohn. 1950. The Economics of Collective Action. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
26.
CowdrickEdward. 1930. Dulling the ax of dismissal. Nation's Business (October 1930): 47–49, 212–13.
27.
CraypoCharles. 1997. Alternative perspectives on the purpose and effects of labor standards legislation. In KaufmanBruce (Ed.), Government Regulation of the Employment Relationship, pp. 221–51. Madison, WI: Industrial Relations Research Association.
28.
CrottyJames. 1990. Keynes on stages of development of the capitalist economy: The institutional foundation of Keynes' methodology. Journal of Economic Issues24(3): 761–80.
29.
DavidsonPaul. 2007. John Maynard Keynes. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
30.
DavisJ. Ronnie. 1971. The New Economics and the Old Economists. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press.
31.
DerberMilton. 1970. The American Idea of Industrial Democracy. Champaign-Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
32.
DessingMaryke. 2002. Labor supply, the family and poverty: The S-shaped labor supply curve. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization49(4): 433–58.
33.
DillardDudley. 1946. The pragmatic basis of Keynes's political economy. Journal of Economic History6(November):121–52.
34.
DillardDudley. 1983. Economics of John Maynard Keynes: The Theory of a Monetary Economy. Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group.
35.
DouglasPaul. 1928. The modern technique of mass production and its relation to wages. Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science, Vol. 12 (1926–28): 663–88.
36.
DouglasPaul. 1939. The effect of wage increases upon employment. American Economic Review29(1): 138–57.
37.
EggertssonGauti. 2008. Great expectations and the end of the depression. American Economic Review98(4): 1476–1516.
38.
EichengreenBarry. 2007. Barry Eichengreen. In ParkerRandall (Ed.), The Economics of the Great Depression, pp. 138–54. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
39.
EliotThomas. 1992. Recollections of the New Deal: When the People Mattered. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
40.
EmersonHarrington. 1922. Wages. Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering (August 30): 400–403.
41.
FarGrant. 1959. The Origins of Recent Labor Policy. Boulder, CO: University of Colorado Press.
42.
FusfeldDaniel. 1956. The Economic Thought of Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Origins of the New Deal. New York: Columbia University Press.
43.
GallowayLowell. 2010. Unions, the high-wage doctrine, and employment. Cato Journal30(1): 197–213.
44.
GlickmanLawrence. 1997. A Living Wage: American Workers and the Making of Consumer Society. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
45.
GordonColin. 1994. New Deals: Business, Labor, and Politics in America, 1920–1935. New York: Cambridge University Press.
46.
GraebnerWilliam. 1980. A History of Retirement: The Meaning and Function of an American Institution. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
47.
GroshenEricaSchweitzerMark. 1997. Macro- and microeconomic consequences of wage rigidity. In LewinD.MitchellD.ZaidiM. (Eds.), The Human Resource Management Handbook, Part 1, pp. 217–49. Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
48.
HamermeshDaniel. 1993. Labor Demand. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
49.
HanesChristopherJamesJohn. 2003. Wage adjustments under low inflation: Evidence from U.S. History. American Economic Review93(4): 1414–23.
50.
HansenAlvin. 1923. The outlook for wages and employment. American Economic Review13(1): 27–44.
51.
HicksClarence. 1941. My Life in Industrial Relations. New York: Harper & Bros.
52.
HimmelbergRobert. 2001. The Great Depression and New Deal. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
53.
JacobySanford. 1985. Employing Bureaucracy: Managers, Unions, and the Transformation of Work in American Industry, 1900–1945. New York: Columbia University Press.
54.
JacobySanford. 1997. Modern Manors: Welfare Capitalism Since the New Deal. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
55.
JohnsonGeorge. 1921. What I've learned about business since 1920. System15(6): 679–83, 728–30.
56.
KatesSteven. 1998. Say's Law and the Keynesian Revolution. Northampton, MA: Elgar.
57.
KatesSteven. 2008. A letter from Keynes to Harlan McCracken dated 31st August 1933: Why the standard story on the origins of the General Theory needs to be rewritten. History of Economics Review47(Winter):39–53.
58.
KaufmanBruce. 1996. Why the Wagner Act? Reestablishing contact with its original purpose. In LewinD.KaufmanB.SockellD. (Eds.), Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations, Vol. 7, pp. 15–68. Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
59.
KaufmanBruce. 2000. The case for the company union. Labor History41(3): 321–50.
60.
KaufmanBruce. 2003a. Industrial Relations Counselors, Inc.: Its history and significance. In KaufmanBruceBeaumontRichardHelfgottRoy (Eds.), Industrial Relations to Human Resources and Beyond: The Evolving Process of Employee Relations Management, pp. 31–112. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
61.
KaufmanBruce. 2003b. The quest for cooperation and unity of interest in industry. In KaufmanBruceBeaumontRichardHelfgottRoy (Eds.), Industrial Relations to Human Resources and Beyond: The Evolving Process of Employee Relations Management, pp. 115–46. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
62.
KaufmanBruce. 2003c. John R. Commons and the Wisconsin school on industrial relations strategy and policy. Industrial and Labor Relations Review57(1): 3–30.
63.
KaufmanBruce. 2004. The Global Evolution of Industrial Relations: Events, Ideas and the IIRA. Geneva: International Labour Organization.
64.
KaufmanBruce. 2008. Managing the Human Factor: The Early Years of Human Resource Management in American Industry. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
65.
KaufmanBruce. 2010a. The theoretical foundation of industrial relations and its implications for labor economics and human resource management. Industrial and Labor Relations Review64(1): 817–51.
66.
KaufmanBruce. 2010b. Hired Hands or Human Resources? Case Studies of Human Resource Programs and Practices in Early American Industry. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
67.
KaufmanBruce. 2010c. Institutional economics and the minimum wage: Broadening the theoretical and policy debate. Industrial and Labor Relations Review63(3): 427–53.
68.
KerrClark. 1988. The neoclassical revisionists in labor economics (1940–1960)—R.I.P. In KaufmanBruce E. (Ed.), How Labor Markets Work. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
69.
KeynesJohn. 1936. The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money. London: Harcourt Brace.
70.
KingWilliam. 1918. Industry and Humanity. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
71.
KochanThomasKatzHarryMcKersieRobert. 1986. The Transformation of American Industrial Relations. New York: Basic Books.
KuhnRick. 1988. Labour movement economic thought in the 1930s: Underconsumptionism and Keynesian economics. Australian Economic History Review28(2): 53–74.
74.
LauckW. Jett. 1929. The New Industrial Revolution and Wages. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.
75.
LavoieMarc. 1992. Foundations of Post-Keynesian Economic Analysis. Northampton, MA: Elgar.
76.
LawlerEdward. 1992. The Ultimate Advantage: Creating the High-Involvement Organization. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
77.
LeeFrederickSamuelsWarren. 1992. The Heterodox Economics of Gardiner C. Means: A Collection. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
78.
LeisersonWilliam. 1938. Right and Wrong in Labor Relations. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
79.
LevendisJohn. 2007. The fallacy of wage cuts and Keynes' involuntary unemployment. Journal of the History of Economic Thought29(3): 309–29.
80.
LewisohnSamDraperErnestCommonsJohnLescohierDon. 1925. Can Business Prevent Unemployment?New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
81.
LinderMarc. 1989. The minimum wage as industrial policy: A forgotten role. Journal of Legislation16(1) 151–71.
82.
LucasRobertRappingLeonard. 1969. Real wages, employment, and inflation. Journal of Political Economy77(June):721–54.
83.
LutzMark. 1999. Economics for the Common Good: Two Centuries of Social Economic Thought in the Humanistic Tradition. New York: Routledge.
84.
MacKenzieDouglas. 2010. Industrial employment and the policies of Herbert C. Hoover. Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics13(3): 101–19.
85.
MadsenJakob. 2004. Price and wage stickiness during the Great Depression. European Review of Economic History8(3): 263–95.
86.
McCrackenHarlan. 1933. Value Theory and Business Cycles. New York: Falcon Press.
87.
MeyerStephen. 1981. The Five Dollar Day: Labor, Management, and Social Control in the Ford Motor Company, 1908–1921. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
88.
MillerGary. 1991. Managerial Dilemmas: The Political Economy of Hierarchy. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
89.
MilnowAlex. 1992. The evolution of J. M. Keynes' wage and employment theory, 1920–1946. History of Economics Review17(Winter):47–78.
90.
MitchellDaniel. 1984. Inflation, unemployment, and the Wagner Act: A critical reappraisal. Stanford Law Review38(April):1065–95.
91.
MitchellDaniel. 1985. Wage flexibility then and now. Industrial Relations24(2): 266–79.
92.
MitchellDaniel. 1986. Wages and Keynes: Lessons from the past. Eastern Economic Journal12(3): 199–208.
93.
MitchellDaniel. 1993. Keynesianism, old Keynesianism, and new Keynesian wage nominalism. Industrial Relations32(1): 1–29.
94.
MoggridgeDonald. 1982. The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, Vols. 20 and 21. London: Macmillan.
95.
MoriguchiChiaki. 2005. Did American welfare capitalists breach their implicit contracts during the Great Depression? Preliminary findings from company-level data. Industrial and Labor Relations Review59(1): 51–81.
96.
MulliganCasey. 2010. Do jobless benefits discourage people from finding jobs?New York Times, March 17, Economix Blogs, New York Times. Accessed at http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com.
97.
NeumarkDavid. 2009. Delay the minimum wage hike. Wall Street Journal, June 12: A15.
98.
NevinsAllan. 1954. Ford: The Times, the Man, the Company. New York: Scribner's.
99.
O'BrienAnthony. 1989. A behavioral explanation for nominal wage rigidity during the Great Depression. Quarterly Journal of Economics104(4): 719–35.
100.
OhanianLee. 2009. What—or Who—Started the Great Depression?Journal of Economic Theory144(6): 2310–35.
101.
OzanneRobert. 1968. Wages in Theory and Practice: McCormick and International Harvester, 1860–1960. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
102.
ParkerRandall. 2007. The Economics of the Great Depression. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
103.
PerelmanMichael. 2007. The Confiscation of American Prosperity: From Right-Wing Extremism and Economic Ideology to the Next Great Depression. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
104.
PigouArthur. 1933. The Theory of Unemployment. London: Cass.
105.
PraschRobert. 2005. The social cost of labor. Journal of Economic Issues39(2): 1–7.
106.
PrescottEdward. 1999. Some observations on the Great Depression. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review23(1): 25–29.
107.
RaymondDaniel. 1930. Flight from high wages. Outlook and Independent, July 30: 498–500, 516–17.
108.
ReesAlbert. 1970. On equilibrium in labor markets. Journal of Political Economy78(2): 306–10.
109.
RiggiMarriana. 2010. Nominal and real wage rigidities in new Keynesian models: A critical survey. Journal of Economic Surveys24(3): 539–72.
110.
RomerChristina. 1993. The nation in depression. Journal of Economic Perspectives7(2): 19–39.
111.
RosenEliott. 1977. Hoover, Roosevelt, and the Brains Trust: From Depression to New Deal. New York: Columbia University Press.
112.
RosenofTheodore. 1975. Dogma, Depression, and the New Deal. Port Washington, NY: Kennikat Press.
113.
RosenofTheodore. 1983. Patterns of Political Economy in America: The Failure to Develop a Democratic Left Synthesis, 1933–1950. New York: Garland.
114.
RutherfordMalcolmDesrochesC. Tyler. 2008. The institutionalist reaction to Keynesian economics. Journal of the History of Economic Thought30(1): 29–48.
115.
SamuelsonPaul. 1946. Lord Keynes and The General Theory. Econometrica14(July): 187–200.
116.
SamuelsonPaul. 1948. Economics, An Introductory Analysis. New York: McGraw Hill.
117.
ShapiroCarlStiglitzJoseph. 1984. Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device. American Economic Review74(3): 433–44.
118.
ShidleNorman. 1920. How an effective employment department is being developed. Automotive Industries, August 19: 370–73.
119.
SismondiJ. C. L.1819 (1951). Nouveaux Principes d'Economie Politique, 3rd ed.Geneva:Jeheber.
120.
SkidelskyRobert. 1995. John Maynard Keynes: The Economist as Savior, 1920–37, Vol. 2. New York:Penguin.
121.
SkidelskyRobert. 2009. Keynes: Return of the Master. New York: Public Affairs.
122.
SlichterSumner. 1928. The secret of high wages. New Republic54(695): 183–85.
123.
SolowRobert. 1990. The Labor Market as a Social Institution. New York: Blackwell.
124.
StabileDonald. 1993. Activist Unionism: The Institutional Economics of Solomon Barkin. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
125.
StabileDonald. 2008. The Living Wage: Lessons from the History of Economic Thought. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
126.
StiglitzJoseph. 2010. Freefall: America, Free Markets and the Sinking of the World Economy. New York: W. W. Norton.
127.
StiglitzJoseph. 2012. The Price of Inequality: How Today's Divided Society Endangers Our Future. New York: W. W. Norton.
128.
TeminPeter. 2007. Peter Temin. In ParkerRandall (Ed.), The Economics of the Great Depression, pp. 29–51. Northampton, MA:Edward Elgar.
129.
ThorntonMark. 2010. Hoover, Bush, and the Great Depression. Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics13(3): 86–100.
130.
TipperHarry. 1922. Fundamental of labor question ignored. Automotive Industries, April 20: 878–79.
131.
TobinJames. 1975. Keynesian models of recession and depression. American Economic Review65(2): 195–202.
132.
VittozStanley. 1987. New Deal Labor Policy and the American Industrial Economy. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
133.
WaltonGaryRockoffHugh. 2005. History of the American Economy, 10th ed.Mason, OH:Southwestern-Thompson.
134.
WaltonRichard. 1986. From control to commitment in the workplace. Harvard Business Review63(2): 76–84.
135.
WanderseeWinifred. 1993. I'd rather pass a law than organize a union: Frances Perkins and the reformist approach to organized labor. Labor History34(1): 5–32.
136.
WhalenCharles. 1993. Saving capitalism by making it good: The monetary economics of John R. Commons. Journal of Economic Issues27(4): 1155–79.
137.
WhalenCharles. 2008a. Toward “wisely managed” capitalism: Post-Keynesian institutionalism and the creative state. Forum for Social Economics37(1): 43–60.
138.
WhalenCharles. 2008b. John R. Commons and John Maynard Keynes on economic history and policy: The 1920s and today. Journal of Economic Issues42(1): 225–42.
139.
WhalenCharles. 2011. Rethinking Economics: Analyzing Instability and Securing Prosperity after the Great Recession. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
