Islamically modified cognitive behavioral therapy: Enhancing outcomes by increasing the cultural congruence of cognitive behavioral therapy self-statements

Abstract

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is one of the most widely used and effective therapeutic modalities. When utilized with devout Muslims, however, outcomes may be enhanced by modifying traditional CBT self-statements to reflect Islamic values. Toward this end, the values that inform the Western counseling project are discussed. Areas of differing value emphasis are noted between Islam and traditional CBT. The process of constructing Islamically modified statements is illustrated, and it is proposed that this culturally congruent modality may engender (1) faster recovery, (2) better treatment compliance, (3) lower rates of relapse, and (4) reduced treatment disparities. The article concludes by providing suggestions to assist social workers implement Islamically modified CBT statements in a manner that maximizes the potential to achieve these salutary outcomes.

Keywords

CBT Islam Islamically Muslims social work

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is one of the most effective therapeutic modalities (Keith, 2013; Tolin, 2010). It has been used to successfully address a variety of problems (Chambless and Ollendick, 2001). Due to its perceived utility in clinical settings, its importance is predicted to increase in the future (Dobson, 2010).

Modifying CBT protocols so that they resonate with a given population’s cultural values can enhance effectiveness (Rathod et al., 2010). As Western societies have become more culturally diverse, it is increasingly recognized that therapeutic procedures should be adapted so they are consistent with clients’ value systems (Sue and Sue, 2013). Modifying therapeutic strategies so they are congruent with clients’ understandings of reality is an essential prerequisite for effective service provision (Wolf, 1978).

Social workers serve individuals from diverse cultural backgrounds. Muslims may increasingly come to the attention of social workers in light of the heightened climate of Islamophobia (Amri and Bemak, 2012). Islamophobia refers to ‘either outright anti-Muslim bigotry due to religious intolerance or racism and xenophobia toward people from the Middle East, North Africa, and South Asia who are Muslim or who have a “Muslim-like” appearance’ (Husain, 2015: n.p.). Muslims have become targets of physical and emotional violence following the 9/11 attacks (Peek, 2011). Muslims may increasingly find themselves in need of social work services to mitigate the deleterious impact of Islamophobic victimization. To best serve this population, social workers should deliver services in a manner that reflects the values, traditions, and belief systems of Islam.

Muslims represent one culturally distinct group that is rapidly increasing in size in many nations around the world (Hedayat-Diba, 2014). Islam provides adherents with a unique value system (Halstead, 2007). To be effective with Muslims, counselors must use therapeutic strategies that are consistent with Islamic values (Graham et al., 2010). As is the case with other culturally distinct populations, modifying Western therapeutic strategies can enhance their effectiveness with Muslims (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010). Increasing the cultural congruence of CBT self-statements with Islamic values can enhance therapeutic outcomes, a process that begins with understanding the values that inform CBT and other therapeutic modalities that comprise the Western counseling project (Hodge and Nadir, 2008).

The Western counseling project

The Western counseling project – like other human constructions – is informed by a particular set of values (Inayat, 2000; Kuhn, 1970). Certain anthropological assumptions regarding human functioning are implicitly affirmed in Western therapeutic models (Smither and Khorsandi, 2009). As a value-informed enterprise, the Western therapeutic project affirms certain norms regarding human existence, relational dynamics, and healthy functioning.

It is important to acknowledge that many factors contributed to the emergence of the present-day Western counseling project. Among these various factors, however, the European movement commonly referred to as the ‘Enlightenment’ played an instrumental role (Gellner, 1992; Jafari, 1993). The Enlightenment posited a distinct set of assumptions about the nature of human existence. In turn, these values informed the construction of the Western therapeutic enterprise.

The period of enlightenment marked a rupture between the systems of thought in the ancient world and modern thought (Sternhell, 2010). Enlightenment thinkers exchanged religious systems of meaning-making for rationalism and faith in scientism (Park, 2003). Indeed, this attempt to marginalize previously accepted beliefs in the supernatural influenced Freud’s essay on what he referred to as the ‘uncanny’ (Park, 2003). In this essay, Freud attempted to reaffirm the existence of the supernatural from a scientific perspective (Park, 2003). As such, his psychodynamic concept of the uncanny represents a merger of pre-enlightenment mysticism and the new age empiricism (Park, 2003). However, consistent with enlightenment philosophers, Freud rejected religion as a ‘mass delusion’ (Abu-Raya, 2014: 332). As such, he conceptualized his psychoanalytic theories, from which modern psychology is based, within a secular framework (Abu-Raya, 2014) with strong ties to enlightenment thought (Park, 2003).

A central assumption of the Enlightenment narrative is the notion that humans are autonomous individuals who are able to objectively discern material reality apart from any type of metaphysical revelation (Lyotard, 1984 [1979]). In the Enlightenment story, authority stemming from transcendent spiritual sources is largely displaced and relocated in the individual (Smith, 2003). In essence, the individual human being is seen as an island of autonomous authority in a naturalistic world (Skinner, 2010). The transcendent is de-centered and the individual is prioritized (Jafari, 1993).

In turn, the values of individualism and secularism have informed the Western counseling narrative (Jafari, 1993). Individualistically based concepts animate Western therapeutic discourse. Concepts such as independence, self-actualization, self-expression, and explicit communication styles that clearly express individual opinion are widely privileged in Western therapeutic discourse (Al-Abdul-Jabbar and Al-Issa, 2000; Smither and Khorsandi, 2009).

Likewise, secularism is assumed to be normative and reflective of mental wellness. Secular values and perspectives are privileged in Western therapeutic discourse, often at the expense of spiritual alternatives (Woodhead, 2008). Leading theorists in the construction of the Western counseling project – including Freud (1966), Fromm (1950), and Ellis (1980) – posited that devout theistic spirituality was associated with psychopathology. In turn, this assumption was eventually reflected in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Third Edition, Revised (Larson et al., 1993), despite empirical evidence indicating that devout spirituality is associated with mental health, rather than mental illness (Koenig et al., 2012). Literature in the helping professions frequently frames Islamic and other theistic perspectives negatively (Cnaan et al., 1999; Hodge et al., 2006). For example, a content analysis of widely used Medline database revealed that the surveyed literature implicitly indicated that being an observant Muslim poses health risks, Muslims are adversely affected by tradition, and correspondingly, they should reject Islamic tradition and adopt the secular Enlightenment values of modernity (Laird et al., 2007).

In addition to pathologizing Islam, the biomedical basis in which practitioners make clinical decisions may conflict with the metaphysical complaints of Muslim patients, leading to culturally incongruent services. According to Islamic folklore, demonic spirits such as Jinn may possess an individual and cause illness and misfortune (Lim et al., 2015). Jinn are believed to have greater power than humans but less power than angels (Al-Krenawi and Graham, 1999). A review of the literature found 47 documented cases of jinn complaints among patients, including a range of somatic and psychiatric symptoms. In all, 66 percent of these cases led to a biomedical diagnosis, ignoring the causal explanation reported by the patients and their family (Lim et al., 2015). Other metaphysical causes of symptomatology among Islamic adherents may include ‘consequences for past sins, being cursed by the evil eye (envious individuals who cast a hexing glance at the subject) or separation from the divine’ (Keshavarzi and Haque, 2013: 233). Overlooking these cultural expressions of distress at the least may lead to feelings of incongruence with services among Islamic adherents or at the worst, the misdiagnosis of psychosis.

The inclusion of Albert Ellis in the above list of theorists who helped construct the Western counseling project is particularly noteworthy. Ellis is perhaps the most influential founder of contemporary CBT (Beck, 1976; Ellis, 1962). Ellis (1980, 2000) is also a committed atheist. As noted above, Ellis (1980) has posited that devout religious belief fosters psychopathology. Although Ellis (1996, 2000) has subsequently modified his theoretical perspective in light of the empirical research on spirituality and mental health, the self-statements central to the cognitive restructuring process reflect Enlightenment-derived assumptions that are reflective of Ellis’ atheistic belief system.

The following self-statement is representative of those constructed by Ellis (2000).

Basic to CBT is the notion that harmful schema are replaced with salutary self-statements (Hamdan, 2008). The goal of the subsequent self-statement is to enhance a client’s ability to tolerate frustration:

Nothing is terrible or awful, only at worst highly inconvenient. I can stand serious frustrations and adversity, even though I never have to like them. (Ellis, 2000: 32)

This self-statement reflects Enlightenment-based assumptions about human functioning. It is both individualistic and secular in nature. As the use of the word ‘I’ suggests, the individual serves as the change engine. The statement contains no reference to family, community, or the transcendent. Ultimate authority is vested in an autonomous, individual self. While these suppositions may be consistent with individuals who affirm Enlightenment values, they are often incongruent with Muslims who derive their values from Islamic discourse (Hodge, 2008).

Islamic values

Familiarity with the Islamic teachings and beliefs that shape and inform Islamic values is imperative for practitioners. Husain and Ross-Sheriff (2011) provide an overview of the Islamic worldview, the tenets of Islam, and the core values and the implications for social work practice. Islam is a way of life offering guidance for both the public and private domains of the lives of Muslims and has perceived relevance for all times. Islam teaches that Allah created all of creation to worship Him. This duty to worship Allah is central to the lives of Muslims. A part of worshipping Allah is to exist on earth as the stewards of Allah and to ‘struggle in life to uphold righteous speech and conduct’ (p. 14). Together, the teachings of Allah, the five pillars of Islam, and the six articles of faith are the foundational principles of Islamic ontology, ‘which sustains and perpetuates their belief in Allah’ (Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011: 16).

In the same way that certain values are embedded in the Enlightenment narrative, the Islamic narrative also tends to affirm certain values (Hussain, 2009). Islam provides adherents with a different understanding of the human story, a different suppositional framework for understanding reality (Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011). As such, it affirms different norms regarding human existence, relationships, and functioning (Weatherhead and Daiches, 2010).

In some cases, values widely affirmed within the Islamic narrative are also commonly affirmed in the Enlightenment narrative. In other cases, they differ or even conflict. For example, instead of individualism and secularism, Islam emphasizes community and spirituality (Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011). Likewise, compared to values such as independence, self-actualization, self-expression, and explicit communication styles that express individual opinion, Islam tends to affirm interdependence, community-actualization, self-control, and implicit communication styles that safeguard others’ opinions (Williams, 2005).

Due to the difference in values, some practicing Muslims may be uncomfortable with the use of traditional CBT self-statements (Rathod et al., 2010). For example, some clients might feel uncomfortable with the concept of the individual self as the locus of authority. As implied above, many Muslims would look to their families, the Islamic community, and, especially, to Allah. Self-actualization is not typically viewed as the pathway to mental health in Islam (Smither and Khorsandi, 2009). Rather, surrender of the self to Allah is assumed to foster wellness (Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011). A devout Muslim’s personal narrative is grounded in Allah rather than an autonomous self (Hamdan, 2008).

It should be noted that the importance of salutary cognitive schema is not in question. Both Enlightenment and Islamic narratives affirm the importance of the cognitive restructuring process. Like most other faith traditions, Islam holds that healthy cogitation plays a critical role in mental health (Richards and Bergin, 2014; Van Hook et al., 2001). Agreement exists that mental schema play an important role in fostering wellness.

In short, it is not the cognitive restructuring process that conflicts with the Islamic narrative; rather, it is the value system conveyed through the restructuring process (Hamdan, 2008). The key issue is the value system reflected in CBT self-statements (Rathod et al., 2010). Thus, it is possible to enhance the cultural congruence of the modality by modifying the self-statements to reflect Islamic values.

Constructing Islamically modified statements

The process of constructing Islamically modified CBT statements can be understood as a three-step process (Hodge, 2008). This process can be summarized as (1) unpacking the European Enlightenment values in CBT self-statements that are used to convey the underlying therapeutic concept, (2) evaluating the basic concept to ensure its congruence with the Islamic values affirmed by the client, and (3) repackaging the concept in Islamic values that resonates with the client’s value system. This process is illustrated using the above-mentioned self-statement designed to enhance toleration of frustration: ‘Nothing is terrible or awful, only at worst highly inconvenient. I can stand serious frustrations and adversity, even though I never have to like them’ (Ellis, 2000: 32).

Identify key therapeutic precepts

The first step is to separate the Enlightenment values from the underlying therapeutic concept that is posited to promote wellness (Hodge and Nadir, 2008). In other words, the essential theoretical precept (or precepts) that promotes mental health must be identified. This step entails identifying the fundamental therapeutic ideas the vocabulary is designed to convey.

In terms of the present example, the underlying therapeutic concept might be understood as the notion that frustrating events and circumstances are not horrendous but a normal part of existence. While difficult situations may not be pleasant, they are not necessarily catastrophic. Such situations are not ‘the end of the world’.

Ensure value congruence

Once the underlying concept(s) has been identified, it is possible to proceed to the next step: assessing the therapeutic concept’s degree of value congruence with Islam (Hodge and Nadir, 2008). Indicators of mental health and/or pathology are not universal (Gilligan, 1993; Richards and Davison, 1992). As noted in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (American Psychiatric Association, 2013), indicators can vary from culture to culture. Concepts that promote wellness within secular Enlightenment cultures may not foster wellness in Islamic cultures (Hussain, 2009).

In the case of the present example, the concept is congruent with the Islamic narrative (Hodge and Nadir, 2008). The notion that difficult situations are neither pleasant nor overwhelming is consistent with Islamic assumptions about human existence. Indeed, the Islamic narrative directly affirms the notion that Muslims will encounter difficult situations, but promises adherents that their circumstances can be overcome (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010).

Repackage the therapeutic concept

After identifying the therapeutic concept, and ensuring the concept is consistent with Islamic values, the concept must be formatted into an Islamically congruent CBT statement (Hodge and Nadir, 2008). In other words, the precept must be repacked in terminology drawn from the Muslim client’s Islamic narrative so that the statement is, at a minimum, consistent with the client’s value system. The following statement illustrates one way in which the therapeutic concept discussed above might be articulated so as to increase its degree of cultural congruence with Islamic values:

Misfortunes and blessings are from Allah. Misfortunes are not terrible or awful, but rather a test. Although adversities may be unpleasant, we can withstand them. Allah tells us that He will not test us beyond what we can bear. By reminding ourselves of Allah’s goodness, and engaging in regular dua (informal prayer), we can cope with life’s challenges. (Hodge and Nadir, 2008: 37)

This infusion of Islamic concepts provides an important new rationale for dealing with frustrating situations. Specifically, the Islamic statement posits that the difficult circumstances represent a test divinely ordered by Allah. In addition, the statement incorporates a crucial Islamic teaching – that the difficulty will not exceed a person’s ability to handle the situation. In other words, the client has Allah’s promise that perseverance – although challenging – is possible and that the faithful Muslim will prevail. This teaching can engender hope in the midst of adverse circumstances. Finally, the statement reminds Muslims to utilize the Islamic practice of prayer as a way to deal with life’s challenges, implicitly reminding clients that Allah in His goodness will help them cope with difficulties.

When modified in this manner, a limited but growing body of research suggests that such Islamic statements can help empower Muslims overcome a variety of problems.

Research on CBT modified with tenets from Islam and traditions

Although comparatively little research has been conducted with Muslims, a small body of research exists on the effectiveness of Islamically modified CBT (Koenig and Shohaib, 2014). Five studies have been conducted with relatively devout Muslims in Malaysia by two research teams. These studies explored outcomes with clients wrestling with anxiety disorders (Azhar et al., 1994; Razali et al., 2002), depression (Azhar and Varma, 1995b; Razali et al., 1998), and bereavement (Azhar and Varma, 1995a). A sixth study was conducted with Muslims wrestling with schizophrenia in Saudi Arabia (Wahass and Kent, 1997).

This general approach of adapting CBT self-statements to be congruent with clients’ spiritual narratives has also been used with a number of other cultural groups (Hook et al., 2010). For example, CBT modified with Taoistic precepts has been used with clients wrestling with neurosis (Xiao et al., 1998). Beliefs drawn from the Latter Day Saint (LDS) tradition have been used to treat perfectionism (Richards et al., 1993). A generic spirituality has been used to help clients cope with stress (Nohr, 2000), depression (D’Souza et al., 2002, 2003), and bipolar disorder (D’Souza et al., 2003). CBT modified with Christian beliefs has been used to address compulsive disorder (Gangdev, 1998) and, most notably, depression (Hawkins et al., 1999; Johnson et al., 1994; Pecheur and Edwards, 1984; Propst et al., 1992).

In light of the limited research on CBT that has been modified to incorporate beliefs and practices drawn from clients’ spiritual narratives, it is difficult to draw definitive conclusions (Tan, 2013). The present research does, however, raise the possibility of improved outcomes (Hook et al., 2010). More specifically, the research on CBT that has been modified with tenets from Islam and other spiritual traditions suggests that this modality may enhance a number of outcomes.

Potentially enhanced outcomes

Islamically modified CBT may enhance four outcomes when used with Muslims who are spiritually motivated (Azhar and Varma, 2000; D’Souza and Rodrigo, 2004; Propst, 1996). These four outcomes can be summarized as follows: faster recovery, enhanced treatment compliance, lower levels of relapse, and reduced treatment disparities. Although interrelated in nature, each outcome is discussed separately below.

Faster recovery

Adapting interventions so that they resonate with clients’ Islamic belief system may enhance motivation to change (Beitel et al., 2007; Margolin et al., 2006). Although decisions to seek assistance are often multifaceted, help is often sought when problems become unmanageable (Cohen et al., 2007). Thus, clients are often motivated to change by their inability to manage their lives in a satisfactory manner. In addition to this motivation, the use of Islamic themes provides a further ‘motivational language’ that can be used to encourage the implementation of CBT self-statements (Propst, 1996: 400). Creating statements that incorporate Islamic precepts can tap devout Muslims’ spiritual motivation, as illustrated by the above Islamic statement regarding frustration (Hamdan, 2008).

Since Islamically modified CBT taps two ‘motivational engines’, faster recovery may result (Hodge, 2008; Koenig et al., 1996). Harnessing both secular and spiritual motivations may speed recovery by heightening clients’ desire to address the problem (Azhar and Varma, 2000; D’Souza and Rodrigo, 2004; Propst et al., 1992). Greater client ‘buy-in’ may result, in tandem with greater buy-in among members of a client’s family and community (Al-Abdul-Jabbar and Al-Issa, 2000; Al-Radi and Mahdy, 1994; Banawi and Stockton, 1993; Nadir and Dziegielewski, 2001).

Enhanced treatment compliance

Treatment adherence may be increased by adapting CBT statements so that they better reflect Muslims’ spiritual values (Beitel et al., 2007; Margolin et al., 2006). For instance, framing treatment as a form of spiritual practice can help mitigate the stigma often associated with seeking therapeutic help and even elicit support from clients’ religious communities (Azhar and Varma, 2000; Weatherhead and Daiches, 2010). Support from one’s community can enhance one’s desire to comply with the implementation of the therapeutic protocols. The family and community ‘buy-in’ mentioned above support compliance with the treatment since therapeutic compliance is also viewed as compliance with the community’s spiritual beliefs and practices.

Lower levels of relapse

As success is achieved in counseling, relapse is a common problem (Piderman et al., 2007). As the problems that caused the original decision to seek treatment become more manageable over time, the impetus to continue implementing traditional CBT self-statements can dissipate. Conversely, if the statements are constructed in a manner that reflects Islamic precepts, spiritually motivated Muslims are likely to continue to implement the protocols (D’Souza and Rodrigo, 2004; Hamdan, 2008). A felt spiritual rationale continues to exist when the felt secular rationale is no longer operative (Beitel et al., 2007; Margolin et al., 2006). In turn, the implementation of such spiritually based interventions may result in lower levels of relapse (Elsheikh, 2008; Jarusiewicz, 2000; Lau and Segal, 2007; Sterling et al., 2007; Taub et al., 1994).

Reduced treatment disparities

Finally, the use of Islamically modified CBT may engage Muslims who would otherwise fail to receive help. Many Muslims are hesitant to access mental health professionals due to concerns that their Islamic values will not be respected by Western-trained therapists who are often assumed to be guided by Enlightenment values (Hedayat-Diba, 2014; Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011). By constructing CBT statements that incorporate Islamic values, therapists implicitly communicate respect for clients’ values. Treatment disparities can be reduced as previously un-served Muslims receive counseling services (Azhar and Varma, 2000; Bowen et al., 2006).

It is important to emphasize that all four of these outcomes will not necessarily be experienced by every client. Rather, they represent potential outcomes that some spiritually engaged Muslims may experience. The following suggestions are provided to assist helping professionals implement Islamically modified CBT statements in a manner that maximizes the potential to achieve positive outcomes.

Implementing Islamically modified CBT statements in practice

When interacting with clients, it is important to note the diversity that exists among self-identified Muslims (Springer et al., 2009). In addition to a substantial number of native-born converts, the Islamic community in North America alone comprises Muslims from over 80 nations (Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011). Just as no single Enlightenment narrative exists, no single Islamic narrative exists. Rather, many individual Islamic narratives exist, each shaped by an individual’s culture of origin, race, ethnicity, spirituality, gender, and other contextual factors such as the degree of acculturation with the dominant secular culture (Ross-Sheriff, 2001; Smith, 1999).

Accordingly, it is critical to work within the parameters of the client’s value system (Hodge and Bushfield, 2006). Since no two Muslims have exactly the same value system, it is important to understand, and work within, the confines of each client’s personal Islamic narrative. Administering a spiritual assessment can be helpful in mapping the unique terrain of an individual’s personal value system (Canda and Furman, 2010). Given the variety of assessment models that exist, an assessment approach can be selected that provides the best culture fit with each client’s needs, desires, and values.

As is the case with traditional CBT self-statements, there is no single correct method of phrasing Islamic statements (Hamdan, 2008). Therapeutic concepts that incorporate Islamic values may be expressed in numerous phrasings. Statements that resonate with one Muslim may not resonate with another or even be consistent with the values of another client.

Consequently, helping professionals should work with clients to co-construct interventions that resonate with each client’s values (Azhar and Varma, 2000; Beck et al., 2004). Building upon the knowledge obtained during the spiritual assessment, therapists might facilitate this process by asking questions designed to help clients articulate relevant aspects of their value system (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010). As pertinent Islamic beliefs and practices are identified, helping professionals can interface their own understanding of therapeutically relevant concepts into the discussion (Hodge and Nadir, 2008). Tentative hypotheses regarding Islamic statements can be suggested based upon clients’ articulation. In turn, clients are encouraged to accept, reject, or modify the tentative working statements.

Accordingly, the actual construction process is fluid and interactive. Although the construction of the Islamic CBT statements was presented above as a sequential process for pedagogical purposes, in practice the construction process is more circular than linear. The therapist and the client engage in a dialectic conversation in which therapeutic hypotheses are offered, rejected, developed, and refined until both parties eventually converge on mutually agreed statements (Azhar and Varma, 2000).

Toward this end, therapists might familiarize themselves with the basic tenets of Islam and cultural norms among Muslims they commonly encounter in practice settings (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010; Nadir and Dziegielewski, 2001). By developing a working understanding of basic Islamic values, they are better positioned to construct potentially relevant interventions (Hamdan, 2008). In other words, such knowledge helps therapists collaborate with clients by enhancing their ability to suggest potentially relevant Islamic CBT statements.

Developing collaborative relationships with local religious and community leaders can also be helpful (Husain and Ross-Sheriff, 2011). A local Imam may be able to assist therapists identify therapeutic concepts that are consistent with Islam. In addition, they can also help therapists convey such concepts in spiritually precise language that can help engage clients along with members of their families and communities. Similarly, when questions arise about the nature of clients’ Islamic beliefs and practices, collaboration with an Imam can be helpful in distinguishing between healthy and unhealthy beliefs and practices (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010). While religion is typically a source of comfort, it can also be a source of distress (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010). In the latter, an individual may express conflict and/or doubt in Allah, faith, or religious relationships (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010; Khan et al., 2011). Because of the centrality of religion to the lives of Muslims, negative religious coping may be more predictive of negative outcomes than among members of other groups (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010). Furthermore, stigma and social isolation may mediate the relationship as religious doubts in Islamic culture may be less socially acceptable than in other cultures (Abu Raiya and Pargament, 2010: 186).

When problems arise that require additional information, Imams can be valuable partners in constructing interventions that respect and reflect Muslims’ cultural values. Accordingly, practitioners might seek to establish working relationships with Imams in their catchment areas.

Readers interested in further information on constructing Islamically modified CBT statements may find the following sources helpful. Hamdan (2008) delineates a number of therapeutically beneficial statements that reflect core Islamic beliefs. Hodge and Nadir (2008) illustrate the modification process by taking a number of statements drawn from Beck and Ellis’ work and adapting them to incorporate Islamic values. Finally, Nielsen (2004) provides a well-documented case study that illustrates a non-Muslim therapist – trained in Ellis’ perspective – co-constructing interventions with a Muslim client.

Conclusion

Therapists are increasingly likely to encounter Muslims in practice settings as this population continues to grow in Western nations (Crabtree et al., 2008; Hedayat-Diba, 2014). To work effectively with clients who adhere to an Islamic value system, it is necessary to ensure that the modalities used in clinical settings reflect Islamic values (Weatherhead and Daiches, 2010). As Graham et al. (2010) observe, therapists must reformate their interventions so that they reflect Islamic values to be effective with Muslim clients.

CBT is particularly effective (Tolin, 2010), has been used with a wide array of problems (Dobson, 2010), and can be readily adapted to incorporate Islamic values. As such, Islamically modified CBT might be considered a first-line therapeutic option when working with spiritually engaged Muslims. Islamically modified CBT may lead to faster recovery, better treatment compliance, lower rates of relapse, and reduced treatment disparities. Accordingly, social work practitioners may wish to familiarize themselves with this modality.

Footnotes

Funding

The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Author biographies

David R Hodge is Professor at the School of Social Work, Arizona State University, and Senior Nonresident Fellow, Program for Research on Religion and Urban Civil Society, University of Pennsylvania.

Altaf Husain is Associate Professor at the School of Social Work, Howard University.

References

Abu-Raiya

(2014) ‘Western Psychology and Muslim Psychology in Dialogue: Comparisons Between a Qura’nic Theory of Personality and Freud’s and Jung’s Ideas’, Journal of Religion and Health 53(2): 326–338.

Abu Raiya

Pargament

K.I.

(2010) ‘Religiously Integrated Psychotherapy with Muslim Clients: From Research to Practice’, Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 41(2): 181–8.

Al-Abdul-Jabbar

Al-Issa

(2000) ‘Psychotherapy in Islamic Society’, in Al-Issa

(ed.) Al-Junun: Mental Illness in the Islamic World, pp. 277–93. Madison, CT: International Universities Press.

Al-Krenawi

Graham

J.R.

(1999) ‘Social Work and Koranic Mental Health Healers’, International Social Work 42(1): 53–65.

Al-Radi

Mahdy

M.A.

(1994) ‘Group Therapy: An Islamic Approach’, Integrative Psychiatry 10(3): 106–9.

American Psychiatric Association (2013) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edn. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.

Amri

Bemak

(2013) ‘Mental Health Help-Seeking Behaviors of Muslim Immigrants in the United States: Overcoming Social Stigma and Cultural Mistrust’, Journal of Muslim Mental Health 7(1): 43–63.

Azhar

M.Z.

Varma

S.L.

(1995a) ‘Religious Psychotherapy as Management of Bereavement’, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 91(4): 233–5.

Azhar

M.Z.

Varma

S.L.

(1995b) ‘Religious Psychotherapy in Depressive Patients’, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 63(3/4): 165–8.

10.

Azhar

M.Z.

Varma

S.L.

(2000) ‘Mental Illness and Its Treatment in Malaysia’, in Al-Issa

(ed.) Al-Junun: Mental Illness in the Islamic World, pp. 163–85. Madison, CT: International Universities Press.

11.

Azhar

M.Z.

Varma

S.L.

Dharap

A.S.

(1994) ‘Religious Psychotherapy in Anxiety Disorder Patients’, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 90(1): 1–3.

12.

Banawi

Stockton

(1993) ‘Islamic Values Relevant to Group Work, with Practical Applications for the Group Leader’, The Journal for Specialists in Group Work 18(3): 151–60.

13.

Beck

A.T.

(1976) Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorders. New York: International Universities Press.

14.

Beck

A.T.

Freeman

Davis

D.D.

(2004) Cognitive Therapy of Personality Disorders, 2nd edn. New York: Guilford Press.

15.

Beitel

Genova

Schuman-Olivier

Arnold

Avants

S.K.

Margolin

(2007) ‘Reflections by Inner-City Drug Users on a Buddhist-Based Spirituality-Focused Therapy: A Qualitative Study’, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 77(1): 1–9.

16.

Bowen

Witkiewitz

Dillworth

T.M.

Blume

A.W.

Chawla

Simpson

T.L.

Ostafin

B.D.

Larimer

M.E.

Blume

A.W.

Parks

G.A.

Marlatt

G.A.

(2006) ‘Mindfulness Meditation and Substance Use in an Incarcerated Population’, Psychology of Addictive Behaviors 20(3): 343–7.

17.

Canda

E.R.

Furman

L.D.

(2010) Spiritual Diversity in Social Work Practice: The Heart of Helping. New York: Oxford University Press.

18.

Chambless

D.L.

Ollendick

T.H.

(2001) ‘Empirically Supported Psychological Interventions: Controversies and Evidence’, Annual Review of Psychology 52: 685–716.

19.

Cnaan

R.A.

Wineburg

R.J.

Boddie

S.C.

(1999) The Newer Deal: Social Work and Religion in Partnership. New York: Columbia University Press.

20.

Cohen

Feinn

Arias

Kranzler

H.R.

(2007) ‘Alcohol Treatment Utilization: Findings from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions’, Drug and Alcohol Dependence 86: 214–21.

21.

Crabtree

S.A.

Husain

Spalek

(2008) Islam and Social Work: Debating Values, Transforming Practice. Bristol: Policy Press.

22.

Dobson

K.S.

(2010) Handbook of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapies, 3rd edn. New York: Guilford Press.

23.

D’Souza

Rodrigo

Keks

Tonso

Tabone

(2003) ‘An Open Randomized Control Study of an Add on Spiritually Augmented Cognitive Behavior Therapy in Patients with Depression and Hopelessness’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 37(S1): A6.

24.

D’Souza

Rich

Diamond

Godfery

Gleeson

(2002) ‘An Open Randomized Control Trial of a Spiritually Augmented Cognitive Behavior Therapy in Patients with Depression and Hopelessness’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 36(6): A9.

25.

D’Souza

R.F.

Rodrigo

(2004) ‘Spiritually Augmented Cognitive Behavioral Therapy’, Australian Psychiatry 12(2): 148–52.

26.

Ellis

(1962) Reason and Emotion in Psychotherapy. New York: Lyle Stuart.

27.

Ellis

(1980) ‘Psychotherapy and Atheistic Values: A Response to A.E. Bergin’s ‘Psychotherapy and Religious Values’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 48(5): 635–9.

28.

Ellis

(1996) Better, Deeper, and More Enduring Brief Therapy: The Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy Approach. New York: Brunner/Mazel Publishers.

29.

Ellis

(2000) ‘Can Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy be Effectively Used with People Who Have Devout Beliefs in God and Religion? Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 31(1): 29–33.

30.

Elsheikh

S.E.

(2008) ‘Factors Affecting Long-Term Abstinence from Substance Use’, International Journal of Mental Health Addiction 6: 306–15.

31.

Freud

(1966) Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis (trans. Strachey

). New York: W.W. Norton.

32.

Fromm

(1950) Psychoanalysis and Religion. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

33.

Gangdev

P.S.

(1998) ‘Faith-Assisted Cognitive Therapy of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 32: 575–8.

34.

Gellner

(1992) Postmodernism, Reason and Religion. New York: Routledge.

35.

Gilligan

(1993) In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

36.

Graham

J.R.

Bradshaw

Trew

J.L.

(2010) ‘Cultural Considerations for Social Service Agencies Working with Muslim Clients’, Social Work 55(4): 337–46.

37.

Halstead

J.M.

(2007) ‘Islamic Values: A Distinctive Framework for Moral Education? Journal of Moral Education 36(3): 283–96.

38.

Hamdan

(2008) ‘Cognitive Restructuring: An Islamic Perspective’, Journal of Muslim Mental Health 3(1): 99–116.

39.

Hawkins

R.S.

Tan

S.-Y.

Turk

A.A.

(1999) ‘Secular Versus Christian Inpatient Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Programs: Impact on Depression and Spiritual Well-Being’, Journal of Psychology and Theology 274(4): 309–18.

40.

Hedayat-Diba

(2014) ‘Psychotherapy with Muslims’, in Richards

P.S.

Bergin

A.E.

(eds) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Religious Diversity, 2nd edn, pp. 287–317. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

41.

Hodge

D.R.

(2008) ‘Constructing Spiritually Modified Interventions: Cognitive Therapy with Diverse Populations’, International Social Work 51(2): 178–92.

42.

Hodge

D.R.

Nadir

(2008) ‘Moving toward Culturally Competent Practice with Muslims: Modifying Cognitive Therapy with Islamic Tenets’, Social Work 53(1): 31–41.

43.

Hodge

D.R.

Bushfield

(2006) ‘Developing Spiritual Competence in Practice’, Journal of Ethnic and Cultural Diversity in Social Work 15(3/4): 101–27.

44.

Hodge

D.R.

Baughman

L.M.

Cummings

J.A.

(2006) ‘Moving toward Spiritual Competency: Deconstructing Religious Stereotypes and Spiritual Prejudices in Social Work Literature’, Journal of Social Service Research 32(4): 211–32.

45.

Hook

J.N.

Worthington

E.L.

Davis

D.E.

Jennings

D.J.

Gartner

A.L.

Hook

J.P.

(2010) ‘Empirically Supported Religious and Spiritual Therapies’, Journal of Clinical Psychology 66(1): 46–72.

46.

Husain

(2015) ‘Islamophobia’, in Franklin

(ed.) Encyclopedia of Social Work. Available online at: http://socialwork.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199975839.001.0001/acrefore-9780199975839-e-964?rskey=l1xJTI&result=1

47.

Husain

Ross-Sheriff

(2011) ‘Cultural Competence with Muslim Americans’, in Lum

(ed.) Culturally Competent Practice: A Framework for Understanding Diverse Groups and Justice Issues, 4th edn, pp. 358–89. Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole.

48.

Hussain

(2009) ‘The Mental Health of Muslims in Britain’, International Journal of Mental Health 38(2): 21–36.

49.

Inayat

(2000) ‘The Relationship between Integrative and Islamic Counseling’, Counseling Psychology Quarterly 14(4): 381–6.

50.

Jafari

M.F.

(1993) ‘Counseling Values and Objectives: A Comparison of Western and Islamic Perspectives’, The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 10(3): 326–39.

51.

Jarusiewicz

(2000) ‘Spirituality and Addiction: Relationship to Recovery and Relapse’, Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly 18(4): 99–109.

52.

Johnson

W.B.

Devries

Ridley

C.R.

Pettorini

Peterson

D.R.

(1994) ‘The Comparative Efficacy of Christian and Secular Rational-Emotive Therapy with Christian Clients’, Journal of Psychology and Theology 22(2): 130–40.

53.

Keith

(2013) Tackling Health Anxiety: A CBT Handbook. London: RCPsych Publications.

54.

Keshavarzi

Haque

(2013) ‘Outlining a Psychotherapy Model for Enhancing Muslim Mental Health within an Islamic Context’, International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 23(3): 230–49.

55.

Khan

Z.H.

Watson

P.J.

Chen

(2011) ‘Differentiating Religious Coping from Islamic Identification in Patient and Non-Patient Pakistani Muslims’, Mental Health, Religion & Culture 14(10): 1049–1062.

56.

Koenig

H.G.

Shohaib

S.A.

(2014) ‘Religion and Negative Emotions in Muslims’, in Koenig

H.G.

Shohaib

S.A.

(eds) Health and Well-Being in Islamic Societies: Background, Research, and Applications, pp. 125–65. New York: Springer.

57.

Koenig

H.G.

King

Carson

V.B.

(2012) Handbook of Religion and Health, 2nd edn. New York: Oxford University Press.

58.

Koenig

H.G.

Larson

D.B.

Matthews

D.A.

(1996) ‘Religion and Psychotherapy with Older Adults’, Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 29(2): 155–84.

59.

Kuhn

T.S.

(1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd edn. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago.

60.

Laird

L.D.

Marrais

J. D.

Barnes

L.L.

(2007) ‘Portraying Islam and Muslims in MEDLINE: A Content Analysis’, Social Science & Medicine 65: 2425–39.

61.

Larson

D.B.

Thielman

M.A.

Greenwold

Lyons

S.G.

Post

K.A.

Sherrill

K.A.

Wood

G.G.

Larson

S.S.

(1993) ‘Religious Content in the DSM-III–R Glossary of Technical Terms’, American Journal of Psychiatry 150(12): 1884–5.

62.

Lau

M.A.

Segal

Z.V.

(2007) ‘Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy as a Relapse Prevention Approach to Depression’, in Witkiewitz

K.A.

Marlatt

G.A.

(eds) Therapist’s Guide to Evidence-Based Relapse Prevention, pp. 73–90. Burlington, MA: Elsevier.

63.

Lim

Hoek

H.W.

Blom

J.D.

(2015) ‘The Attribution of Psychotic Symptoms to Jinn in Islamic Patients’, Transcultural Psychiatry 52(1): 18–32.

64.

Lyotard

J.-F.

(1984 [1979]) The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (trans. Bennington

Massumi

). Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

65.

Margolin

Beitel

Schuman-Olivier

Avants

S.K.

(2006) ‘A Controlled Study of a Spiritually-Focused Intervention for Increasing Motivation for HIV Prevention among Drug Users’, AIDS Education and Prevention 18(4): 311–22.

66.

Nadir

Dziegielewski

S.F.

(2001) ‘Islam’, in Van Hook

Hugen

Aguilar

(eds) Spirituality within Religious Traditions in Social Work Practice, pp. 146–66. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.

67.

Nielsen

S.L.

(2004) ‘A Mormon Rational Emotive Behavior Therapist Attempts Qur’anic Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy’, in Richards

P.S.

Bergin

A.E.

(eds) Casebook for a Spiritual Strategy in Counseling and Psychotherapy, pp. 213–30. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

68.

Nohr

R.W.

(2000) ‘Outcome Effects of Receiving a Spiritually-Informed vs. a Standard Cognitive Behavioral Stress-Management Workshop’, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, Marquette University, Milwaukee, WI.

69.

Park

(2003) ‘Unheimlich Maneuvers: Enlightenment Dolls and Repetitions in Freud’, The Eighteenth Century 44(1): 45–68.

70.

Pecheur

D.R.

Edwards

K.J.

(1984) ‘A Comparison of Secular and Religious Versions of Cognitive Therapy with Depressed Christian College Students’, Journal of Psychology and Theology 12(1): 45–54.

71.

Peek

(2011) Behind the Backlash: Muslim Americans after 9/11. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

72.

Piderman

K.M.

Schneekloth

T.D.

Pankratz

S.P.

Maloney

S.D.

Altchuler

S.I.

(2007) ‘Spirituality in Alcoholics during Treatment’, The American Journal on Addiction 16(3): 232–7.

73.

Propst

L.R.

(1996) ‘Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy and the Religious Person’, in Shafranske

E.P.

(ed.) Religion and the Clinical Practice of Psychology, pp. 391–407. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

74.

Propst

L.R.

Ostrom

Watkins

Dean

Mashburn

(1992) ‘Comparative Efficacy of Religious and Nonreligious Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for the Treatment of Clinical Depression in Religious Individuals’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 60(1): 94–103.

75.

Rathod

Kingdon

Phiri

Gobbi

(2010) ‘Developing Culturally Sensitive Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Psychosis for Ethnic Minority Patients by Exploration and Incorporation of Service Users’ and Health Professionals’ Views and Opinions’, Behavioral and Cognitive Psychotherapy 38: 511–33.

76.

Razali

S.M.

Hasanah

C.I.

Aminah

Subramaniam

(1998) ‘Religious-Sociocultural Psychotherapy in Patients with Anxiety and Depression’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 32: 867–72.

77.

Razali

S.M.

Aminah

Khan

U.A.

(2002) ‘Religious-Cultural Psychotherapy in the Management of Anxiety Patients’, Transcultural Psychiatry 39(1): 130–6.

78.

Richards

P.S.

Bergin

A.E.

(2014) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Religious Diversity, 2nd edn. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

79.

Richards

P.S.

Davison

M.L.

(1992) ‘Religious Bias in Moral Development Research: A Psychometric Investigation’, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 31(4): 467–85.

80.

Richards

P.S.

Owen

Stein

(1993) ‘A Religiously Oriented Group Counseling Intervention for Self-Defeating Perfectionism: A Pilot Study’, Counseling and Values 37: 96–104.

81.

Ross-Sheriff

(2001) ‘Immigrant Muslim Women in the United States: Adaptation to American Society’, Journal of Social Work Research 2(2): 283–94.

82.

Skinner

(2010) ‘An Islamic Approach to Psychology and Mental Health’, Mental Health, Religion & Culture 13(6): 547–51.

83.

Smith

(2003) The Secular Revolution. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

84.

Smith

J.I.

(1999) Islam in America. New York: Columbia University Press.

85.

Smither

Khorsandi

(2009) ‘The Implicit Personality Theory of Islam’, Psychology of Religion and Spirituality 1(2): 81–96.

86.

Springer

P.R.

Abbott

D.A.

Reisbig

A.M.J.

(2009) ‘Therapy with Muslim Couples and Families: Basic Guidelines for Effective Practice’, The Family Journal: Counseling and Therapy for Couples and Families 17(3): 229–35.

87.

Sternhell

(2010) The Anti-Enlightenment Tradition. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

88.

Sterling

R.C.

Weinstein

Losardo

Raively

Hill

Petrone

Gottheil

(2007) ‘A Retrospective Case Control Study of Alcohol Relapse and Spiritual Growth’, The American Journal on Addiction 16: 56–61.

89.

Sue

D.W.

Sue

(2013) Counseling the Culturally Diverse: Theory and Practice. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

90.

Tan

S.-Y.

(2013) ‘Addressing Religion and Spirituality from a Cognitive-Behavioral Perspective’, in Pargament

K.I.

(ed.) APA Handbook of Psychology, Religion, and Spirituality: Vol. 2. An Applied Psychology Religion and Spirituality, pp. 169–87. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

91.

Taub

Steiner

S.S.

Weingarten

Walton

K.G.

(1994) ‘Effectiveness of Broad Spectrum Approaches to Relapse Prevention in Severe Alcoholism: A Long-Term, Randomized, Controlled Trial of Transcendental Meditation, EMG Biofeedback and Electronic Neurotherapy’, Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly 11(1–2): 187–220.

92.

Tolin

D.F.

(2010) ‘Is Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy More Effective Than Other Therapies? A Meta-Analytic Review’, Clinical Psychology Review 30: 710–20.

93.

Van Hook

Hugen

Aguilar

M.A.

(eds) (2001) Spirituality within Religious Traditions in Social Work Practice. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.

94.

Wahass

Kent

(1997) ‘The Modification of Psychological Interventions for Persistent Auditory Hallucinations to an Islamic Culture’, Behavioral and Cognitive Psychology 25: 351–64.

95.

Weatherhead

Daiches

(2010) ‘Muslim Views on Mental Health and Psychotherapy’, Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 83: 75–89.

96.

Williams

(2005) ‘Working with Muslims in Counselling: Identifying Sensitive Issues and Conflicting Philosophy’, International Journal for the Advancement of Counseling 27(1): 125–30.

97.

Wolf

(1978) ‘Social Validity: The Case for Subjective Measurement’, Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 11(2): 203–14.

98.

Woodhead

(2008) ‘Secular Privilege, Religious Disadvantage’, The British Journal of Sociology 59(1): 53–8.

99.

Xiao

Young

Zhang

(1998) ‘Taoistic Cognitive Psychotherapy for Neurotic Patients: A Preliminary Clinical Trial’, Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 52(Supp.): S238–41.