Executives' and Academics' Perceptions on the Need for Instruction in Written Persuasion

Abstract

Picture a new hire. Sh's put in two weeks on her first job after raduation. In business college she wrote one sales letter, one collection letter, one favor request letter, and one job application letter—and another application when she graduated and applied for work. Her new boss says, "Write an inter-branch memo that'll speed up my counterpart in the Dayton office. We've called him and called him, but I'm getting the idea he doesn't believe what he doesn't see on paper. Dayton is holding up our Air Force contract on superwide radials. If they mess around much longer our competitor's going to get that business, but it'll be OUR fault, not theirs. Oh, and put my name on the memo, Don't get em mad, though. Here's the file. By three today, okay?"

A problem in persuasion. It isn't sales . Nor a favor request. Nora collection. Nor a job application—though she might get to write another of those if she doesn't solve problems like these effectively.

Do business communication classes prepare students adequately for tasks like these? According to a survey of communication executives and business communication teachers, probably not.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Flatley, Marie , "A Comparative Analysis of the Written Communication of Managers at Various Organization Levels in the Private Business Sector," The Journal of Business Communication, Vol. 19, No. 3, Summer 1982, pp. 35-49.

Dorrell, Jean and Betty Johnson , "A Comparative Analysis of Topics Covered in Twenty College-Level Textbooks ." The ABCA Bulletin, Vol. XLV, No. 3 (September 1982), pp. 11-16. The six books analyzed were: Murphy and Peck, 1980; Himstreet and Baty, 1984; Wilkinson et al., 1980; Sigband and Bateman, 1981; Lesikar. 1984; and Huseman et al., 1984. Analysis of the textbooks predated the questionnaire. Thus, in each case, the edition analyzed was the one available to the researcher in 1984. Several of the texts have since undergone revision.

Glassman, Myron , and E. Ann Farley , "AACSB Accredited Schools' Approach to Business Communication Classes ," The Journal of Business Communication, Vol. 16. No. 3 (Spring 1979 ), pp. 41-8.

Harris. Thomas E. Note. August 1985.

Harris, Thomas E. and T. Dean Thomlison , "Career-Bound Communication Education: A Needs Analysis," Central States Speech journal, Vol. XXXIV (Winter 1983), pp. 260-67.

Stine, Donna and Donald Skarzenski , "Priorities for the Business Communication Classroom: A Survey of Business and Academe," The Journal of Business Communication, Vol. 16, No. 3 (Spring 1979), pp. L5-30.

Storms, C. Gilbert , "What Business School Graduates Say About the Writing They Do at Work: Implications for the Business Communication Course, "The ABCA Bulletin, Vol. XLVI, No. 4 (December 1983), pp. 13-8.

Swenson, Dan II. "Relative Importance of Business Communication Skills for the Next Ten Years," The Jourml of Business Communication, Vol. 17, No. 2 (Winter 1980), pp. 41-9.