Assessment of Fiber Contribution to Friction Material Performance Using Grey Relational Analysis (GRA)

Abstract

Design of friction material composition is a multicriteria optimization problem. The role of fibers in controlling tribo-performance, in particular, is multifunctional. The present article deals with the assessment of fiber contribution to the performance of friction materials based on various possible combinations of organic fibers (Aramid and PAN) and rock fibers (basalt and lapinus). The performance of the materials is evaluated on a Krauss friction tester. The various performance criteria selected for the analysis are friction fade, friction recovery, performance friction, difference between the maxima and the minima in the coefficient of friction, temperature rise of the disc, and wear. The criteria are normalized to conform to the smaller-the-better performance norm correspondingly to their respective performance defining attributes (PDAs). The degree of influence that the fiber combination factors exert on the overall performance is studied by investigating the geometrical correlation between them using grey relational analyzing (GRA). By analyzing the grey relational grade matrix, the most influential fiber combinations with regard to an objective property can be picked. The influence of the individual PDAs on the overall performance is studied. This is based on the correlation between the fiber combinations and their corresponding PDAs. Further, the GRA has enabled to speculate the performance of grey friction materials (based on fiber combinations, which are not evaluated within the context of the present article) in compliance with the existing set of incomplete data.

Keywords

friction material non-asbestos brake-pad materials fiber-reinforced phenolic composites grey relational analysis fade and recovery performance optimization

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Orthwein, W.C. (1986). Clutches and Brakes - Design and Selection, pp. 1-14, Marcel Dekker Inc., New York .

Bark, L.S. , Moran, D. and Percival, S.J. (1979). Inorganic and Organic Changes during Friction Material Performance , Wear, 53: 107-113 .

Bijwe, J. (1997). Composites as Friction Materials - Recent Developments in Non-asbestos Fibre Reinforced Friction Materials - A Review , Polym. Compos., 18(3): 378-396 .

Gopal, P. , Dharani, L.R. and Blum, F.D. (1994). Fade and Wear Characteristics of a Glass Fibre Reinforced Phenolic Friction Material , Wear, 174(1-2): 119-127 .

Evans, R.E. and Trainor, J.A. (1990). Acrylic Fibres in Non-asbestos Friction Materials , In: Proceedings of the Eighth Annual Brake Colloquium, Atlantic City, NJ, October 15-17, pp. 1-15 .

Nicholson, G. (1995). Facts About Friction, P & W Price Enterprises Inc., Gedoran America Ltd, Winchester, VA, USA .

Elzey, D.M. , Vancheeswaran, R. , Myers, S. and McLellan, R. (2000). Multi-criteria Optimization in the Design of Composites for Friction Applications , In: Proceedings of the International Conference on Brakes 2000, Automotive Braking-Technologies for the 21st Century, Leeds, UK, July 11-12, pp. 197-205 .

Satapathy, B.K. and Bijwe, J. (2004). Performance of Friction Materials based on Variation in Nature of Organic Fibres Part II . Optimisation by Balancing and Ranking using Multiple Criteria Decision Model (MCDM), Wear, 257(5-6): 585-589 .

Satapathy, B.K. and Bijwe, J. Fade and Recovery Behaviour of Non-asbestos Organic (NAO) Composite Friction Materials based on Combinations of Rock Fibres and Organic Fibres , J. Reinforced Plast. and Compos., 24(6): 563-577 .

10.

Satapathy, B.K. and Bijwe, J. (2004). Performance of Friction Materials based on Variation in Nature of Organic Fibres Part I . Fade and Recovery Behaviour, Wear, 257(5-6): 573-584 .

11.

Crosa, G. and Baumvol, I.J.R. (1993). Tribology of Composites used as Friction Materials, In: Friedrich, K. (ed.), Advances in Composite Tribology, Composite Material Series 8, Chapter 16, Elsevier, Amsterdam .

12.

Deng, J. (1989). Introduction to Grey System Theory , The Journal of Grey System, 1(1): 1-24 .

13.

Fu, C. , Zheng, J. , Zhao, J. and Xu, W. (2001). Application of Grey Relational Analysis for Corrosion Failure of Oil Tubes , Corrosion Science, 43(5): 881-889 .

14.

Fung, C.P. (2003). Manufacturing Process Optimization for Wear Property of Fibre-reinforced Polybutylene Terepthalate Composites with Grey Relational Analysis , Wear, 254(3-4): 298-306 .

15.

Zhang, H. , Li, Z. and Chen, Z. (2003). Application of Grey Modelling Method to Fitting and Forecasting Wear Trend of Marine Diesel Engines , Tribol. Int., 36(10): 753-756 .

16.

Tzeng, G.H. and Tsaur, S.H. (1994). The Multiple Criteria Evaluation of Grey Relational Model , The Journal of Grey System, 6(2): 87-108 .

17.

Tzeng, G.H. , Chang, J.R. , Lin, J.D. and Hung, C.T. (2002). Non-additive Grey Relation Model for the Evaluation of Flexible Pavement Condition , Int. J. of Fuzzy Systems, 4(2): 715-723 .

18.

Wen, K.L. and Wu, J.H. (1996). On Identification Coefficient and Relational Grade , The Journal of Grey System, 8(1): 11-18 .

19.

Kinkaid, N.M. , Oreilly, O.M. and Papadoupoulos, P. (2003). Review-Automotive Disc Brake Squeal , J. of Sound and Vibration, 267: 105-166 .