Scale Effects in the Response and Failure of Fiber Reinforced Composite Laminates Loaded in Tension and in Flexure

Abstract

The feasibility of using scale model testing for predicting the full-scale behavior of flat composite coupons loaded in tension and beam-columns loaded in flexure is examined. Classical laws of similitude are applied to fabricate and test replica model specimens to identify scaling effects in the load response, strength, and mode of failure. Experiments were performed on graphite-epoxy composite specimens having different laminate stacking sequences and a range of scaled sizes. From the experiments it was deduced that the elastic response of scaled composite specimens was independent of size. However, a significant scale effect in strength was observed. In addition, a transition in failure mode was observed among scaled specimens of certain laminate stacking se quences. A Weibull statistical model and a fracture mechanics based model were applied to predict the strength scale effect since standard failure criteria cannot account for the in fluence of absolute specimen size on strength.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Kellas, S. and J. Morton. 1990. "Strength Scaling in Fiber Composites," NASA CR 4335.

Jackson, K.E. 1990. "Scaling Effects in the Static and Dynamic Response of Graphite-Epoxy Beam-Columns," NASA TM 102697.

Davies, I.L. 1982. "Studies of the Response of Reinforced Concrete Structures to Short Duration Dynamic Loads," Design for Dynamic Loading, The Use of Model Analysis, G. S. T. Armer and F. K. Garas, eds. , London: Construction Press.

Murayama, Y. and S. Noda. 1983. "Study on Small Scale Model Tests for Reinforced Concrete Structures-Small Scale Model Tests by Using 3 MM Diameter Deformed Re-Bars," Kajima Institute of Construction Technology , Tokyo.

Pletta, D.H. and D. Frederick. 1954. "Model Analysis of a Skewed Rigid Frame Bridge and Slab," Journal of the American Concrete Institute, 26(3):217-230.

Pletta, D.H. and D. Frederick. 1953. "Experimental Analysis," Proceedings ASCE. 79(224).

Haritos, G.K. , J.W. Hager , A.K. Amos , M.J. Salkind and A.S.D. Wang. 1987. "Mesomechanics : The Microstructure-Mechanics Connection," AIAA Paper 87-0726, A Collection of Technical Papers Part 1, 28th Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference, pp. 812-818.

Booth, E. , D. Collier and J. Miles. 1983. "Impact Scalability of Plated Steel Structures," Structural Crashworthiness , Jones and Wierzbicki, eds., London: Butterworths, pp. 136-174.

Duffey, T.A. 1971. "Scaling Laws for Fuel Capsules Subjected to Blast, Impact, and Thermal Loading," Proceedings of the 1971 Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference, Boston, Mass. , pp. 775-786.

10.

Jones, N. 1984. "Scaling of Inelastic Structures Loaded Dynamically," Structural Impact and Crashworthiness , Vol. I, Keynote Lectures, Davies, ed., London: Elsevier Applied Science Publishers , pp. 46-71.

11.

Atkins, A.G. and R.M. Caddell. 1974. "The Laws of Similitude and Crack Propagation," International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 16:541-548.

12.

Gustafson, A.J. , G.S. Ng and G.T. Singley. 1982. "Impact Behavior of Fibrous Composites and Metal Substructures," USAAVRADCOM TR-82-D-31.

13.

McCullers, L.A. and J.D. Naberhaus. 1973. "Automated Structural Design and Analysis of Advanced Composite Wing Models," Computers and Structures, 3:925-937.

14.

Verderaime, V.S. 1985. "Scaling Phenomena of Graphite-Epoxy Wound Cases," Proceedings of the Seventh Conference on Fibrous Composites in Structural Design, AFWAL-TR-85-3094.

15.

Fairfull, A.H. 1986. "Scaling Effects in the Energy Absorption of Axially Crushed Composite Tubes," Ph.D. dissertation, University of Liverpool.

16.

Morton, J. 1988. "Scaling of Impact-Loaded Carbon-Fiber Composites," AIAA Journal, 26(8):989-994.

17.

Qian, Y. , S.R. Swanson , R.J. Nuismer and R.B. Bucinell. 1990. "An Experimental Study of Scaling Rules for Impact Damage in Fiber Composites," Journal of Composite Materials, 24(5):559-570.

18.

Weibull, W. 1951. "A Statistical Distribution Function of Wide Applicability," Journal of Applied Mechanics , 18:293-297.

19.

Zweben, C. 1981. "The Effect of Stress Nonuniformity and Size on the Strength of Composite Materials," Composites Technology Review , 3(1):23-26.

20.

Bullock, R.E. 1974. "Strength Ratios of Composite Materials in Flexure and Tension," Journal of Composite Materials, 8:200-206.

21.

Wang, A.S.D. , R.W. Tung and B.A. Sanders. 1980. "Size Effect on Strength and Fatigue of a Short Fiber Composite Material," Emerging Technologies in Aerospace Structures, Design, Structural Dynamics and Materials , ASME, pp. 37-52.

22.

Chou, P.C. and R. Croman. 1979. "Scale Effect in Fatigue of Composite Materials," Journal of Composite Materials , 13(July):178-194.

23.

Wisnom, M.R. 1991. "Relationship between Strength Variability and Size Effect in Unidirectional Carbon Fiber/Epoxy," Composites , 22(1):47-51.

24.

Carpinteri, A. and P. Bocca. 1987. "Transferability of Small Specimen Data to Full-Size Structural Components," Composite Material Response: Constitutive Relations and Damage Mechanisms, G. C. Sih, G. F. Smith, I. H. Marshall and J. J. Wu, eds., London : Elsevier Applied Science.

25.

Baker, W.E. , P.S. Westine and F.T. Dodge. 1973. Similarity Methods in Engineering Dynamics , Rochelle Park, N.J.: Hayden Book Company.

26.

Langhaar, H.L. 1951. Dimensional Analysis and Theory of Models, New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.

27.

Derian, E.J. and M.W. Hyer. 1986. "Large Deformation Dynamic Bending of Composite Beams," NASA Contractor Report 4006.

28.

Sensmeier, M.D. , O.H. Griffin and E.R. Johnson. 1988. "Static and Dynamic Large Deflection Flexural Response of Graphite-Epoxy Beams," NASA CR 4118.

29.

Morton, J. , H. Ho , M.Y. Tsai and G.L. Farley. 1992. "An Evaluation of the Iosipescu Specimen for Composite Materials Shear Property Measurement," Journal of Composite Materials, 26(5):708-750.

30.

Whitney, J.M. , C.E. Browning and A. Mair. 1974. "Analysis of the Flexure Test for Laminated Composite Materials," Composite Materials: Testing and Design (Third Conference), ASTM STP 546, American Society for Testing and Materials, pp. 30-45.

31.

Parvizi, A. , K.W. Garrett and J.E. Bailey. 1978. "Constrained Cracking in Glass Fibre-Reinforced Epoxy Cross-Ply Laminates," Journal of Materials Science, 13:195-201.

32.

Crossman, F.W. and A.S.D. Wang. 1982. "The Dependence of Transverse Cracking and Delamination on Ply Thickness in Graphite/Epoxy Laminates," Damage in Composite Materials, ASTM STP 775, K. L. Reifsnider, ed., American Society for Testing and Materials, pp. 118-139.

33.

Flaggs, D.L. and M.H. Kural. 1982. "Experimental Determination of the In Situ Transverse Lamina Strength in Graphite/Epoxy Laminates," Journal of Composite Materials, 16:103-116.

34.

Crossman, F.W. , W.J. Warren and A.S.D. Wang. 1983. "Influence of Ply Thickness on Damage Accumulation and Final Fracture," Advances in Aerospace Structures, Materials, and Dynamics: A Symposium on Composites , ASME Publication AD-06, pp. 215-226.

35.

Wang, A.S.D. , P.C. Chou and S.C. Lei. 1983. "A Stochastic Model for the Growth of Matrix Cracks in Composite Laminates," Advances in Aerospace Structures, Materials, and Dynamics: A Symposium on Composites, ASME Publication AD-06, pp. 7-16.

36.

Laws, N. and G.J. Dvorak. 1988. "Progressive Transverse Cracking in Composite Laminates," Journal of Composite Materials , 22:900-916.