Analytical/Experimental Evaluation of Hybrid Commingled Carbon/Glass/Epoxy Thick-Section Composites under Compression

Abstract

This paper outlines a current effort at improving the compressive strength of carbon fiber reinforced composites (CFRC) by using a hybrid carbon/glass commingling concept. Prior investigations into the hydrostatic strength of thick-section carbon fiber reinforced composite cylinders resulted in failures which were significantly lower (50 to 70% of design pressure) than anticipated. The formation and propagation of fiber kink bands at the microscopic level, triggered by the fiber misalignment defects formed during the manufacturing process, leading to a shear crippling failure at the macroscopic level is the dominant compressive failure mode in the presence of fiber misalignment or waviness. It is theorized that one way to improve compressive strength is through the use of a commingled (at the tow level) hybrid fiber system. A novel fracture mechanics based concept for commingling a small percentage of glass with carbon fibers to suppress compressive failures due to inelastic micro-buckling of fibers and kink band propagation is developed. A Griffith type fracture criterion for a mode II crack growth, based on the principle of energy balance, is introduced to derive the hitherto unknown concept of kink toughness (i.e., resistance to kink band propagation), and to determine the required glass-carbon ratio for possible enhancement of toughness against the kink band propagation. The width of a kink band normalized with respect to a characteristic length scale, such as thickness of a matrix impregnated fiber tow can be used as a practical measure for kink toughness. Preliminary experimental data suggest enhancement of the compressive and flexural strengths of the composite material even with a small percentage (15%) of glass fibers in commingled hybrid composites. Most significantly, inspection of the failed compression test coupons clearly demonstrates that introduction of this small percentage of glass fibers is effective in changing the failure mode away from the catastrophic kink band failure mode. Furthermore, it may be noted that the flexural hybrid commingled glass/carbon/epoxy composite specimens have failed in tension, which is in sharp contrast to what has been observed in their baseline carbon/epoxy counterparts.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Garala, H. J. 1986. "Structural Evaluation of Externally Pressurized, 4-Inch Diameter, Graphite-Composite Cylinder," DTRC Report 86-071, December.

2. Garala, H. J. 1989. "Structural Evaluation of 8-Inch Diameter Graphite-Epoxy Composite Cylinders Subjected to External Hydrostatic Compressive Loading," DTRC Report 89/016, September.

3. Garala, H. J. and R. A. Chaudhuri . 1993. "Structural Evaluation of Advanced Composite Thick-Section Cylinders under Biaxial Compression," Mechanics of Thick Composites, AMD-Vol. 162, Y. Rajapakse , ed., pp. 227-236.

4. Chaudhuri, R. A. 1991. "Prediction of the Compressive Strength of Thick-Section Advanced Composite Laminates, J. Composite Materials, 25:1244-1276.

5. Abdallah, M. G. , H. E. Gascoigne , D. S. Cairnes and K. B. Patton . 1990. "Measurement of Deformation in Thick Composite Rings Subjected to External Pressure," presented at SEM's spring Conference on Experimental Mechanics and Manufacturer's Exhibit, Albuquerque, NM, June.

6. Hahn, H. T. and M. M. Sohi . 1986. "Buckling of a Fiber Bundle Embedded in Epoxy," Composites Science and Technology, 27:25-41.

7. Chaplin, C. R. 1977. "Compressive Fracture in Unidirectional Glass-Reinforced Plastics," Journal of Material Science, 12:347-352.

8. Knauss, W. G. , J. Starnes and E. Henneke . 1978. "The Compressive Failure of Gr/Epoxy Plates with Circular Holes," NASA CR 157115, N778-24295.

9. Starnes, J. and J. G. Williams . 1982. "Failure Characteristics of Gr/Epoxy Structural Components Loaded in Compression," NASA TM 84552.

10.

10. Waas, A. M. , C. D. Babcock and W. G. Knauss . 1990. "An Experimental Study of Compression Failure of Fibrous Laminated Composites in the Presence of Stress Gradients," International Journal of Solids and Structures, 26:1071-1098.

11.

11. Weaver, C. W. and J. G. Williams . 1975. "Deformation of a Carbon-Epoxy Composite under Hydrostatic Pressure," Journal of Material Science, 10:1323-1333.

12.

12. Hann, H. T. and J. G. Williams . 1986. "Compressive Failure Mechanisms in Unidirectional Composites," ASTM STP 893, pp. 115-139.

13.

13. Shuart, M. J. 1985. "Short-Wavelength Buckling and Shear Failures for Compression-Loaded Composite Laminate," NASA TM 87640.

14.

14. Schutheisz, C. R. and A. M. Waas . "Compressive Failure of Composites, Part I: Testing and Micromechanical Theories," Progress in Aerospace Sciences (to be published).

15.

15. Post, D. , F. L. Dai , Y. Guo and P. Ifju . 1989. "Interlaminar Shear Moduli of Cross-Ply Laminates: An Experimental Analysis," J. Composite Materials, 23:264-279.

16.

16. Garala, H. J. and R. A. Chaudhuri . 1992. "Hybrid Composites," presented at the ONR Annual Review Conference, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, June 29-July 1.

17.

17. Chaudhuri, R. A. and Garala, H. J. 1992. "On Deformation and Failure Behavior of Thick Advanced Composites under Compression," presented at ICTAM, Haifa, (abstract published, Paper #984), August 22-28.

18.

18. Garala, H. J. , W. Phyllaier and R. A. Chaudhuri . 1992. "Structural Response of Glass-Graphite Composite Cylinders Subjected to External Hydrostatic Pressure," presented at the Seventeenth Annual Mechanics of Composites Review, Materials Directorate of the Wright Laboratory, Dayton, OH, November.

19.

19. Chaudhuri, R. A. , M. Xie and H. J. Garala . "Stress Singularity Due to Kink Band Weakening a Unidirectional Composite under Compression," J. Composite Materials (to be published).

20.

20. Hyer, M. W. , L. C. Maas and H. P. Fuchs . 1988. "The Role of Layer Waviness on Influencing the Stress State in Composite Cylinders Subjected to External Hydrostatic Loading," Mechanics of Composite Materials, AMD-Vol. 92, pp. 175-184.

21.

21. Agrawala, B. B. and L. J. Broutman . 1980. Analysis and Performance of Fiber Composite. Wiley-in-Science Publisher, NY.

22.

22. Gipple, K. 1990. "A Comparison of Compression Response of Thick (6.35 mm) and Thin (1.60 mm) Dry and Moisture Saturated AS4/3501-6 Laminates," DTRC-SME-90/74, October.

23.

23. Toland, R. H. 1972. "Failure Modes in Impact Loaded Composite Materials," paper presented at Failure Modes in Composites Symposium, AIME Spring Meeting, May.